Lindsay Clancy and Abortion

So you fell for it.

The video creator jumped from linking understanding post-partum mental health with support for murdering children to their real message: "Feminism = bad" and you followed right along going right to the real message of the video.

It's a bit off topic, really, and I'm not the one to make arguments for or against feminism. Not my thing.
But I'm a sucker. (I like arguing things because it's the best way to learn. Sometimes I even argue the opposite view, because it's an even better way to learn.) Anyway....

Equality of what, exactly? Fighting for equality of opportunity is not fighting nature. But fighting for equality of outcome absolutely is. And a lot of feminists don't fight for equality of opportunity.
This is often thrown out in relation to any rights movement. But it's only a half truth at best.
It comes down to metrics.

Looking at outcomes is a way to evaluate opportunity. If barriers are removed and disparity persists, it could indicate additional barriers not noticed or addressed previously.

That said, some people do tend to skip the step where they identify barriers. Similarly, some will scream about "equality of opportunity instead of outcome," also without investigating if there are barriers. Different sides of the same coin.

"No woman should be authorized to stay at home and raise her children. Society should be totally different. Women should not have that choice, precisely because if there is such a choice, too many women will make that one." - Simone de Beauvoir
Yes, they quoted one feminist who died 20 years ago. I think what she was pretty stupid.

But I consider it insufficient evidence of the position mainstream feminists advocate. (The loudest and most radical are almost never the "mainstream.") I don't know much about her, but I think there is a radical faction on the feminist side that is the equivalent of the incels on the other. Neither are "mainstream," I hope.
Is this part wrong? If so, how and why?
So you want me to discredit a claim the video makes without support?
I'll give it just as much support.

Evolutionary traits may contribute to the characteristics of social orders. That does not mean that we "evolved into" those social orders. (Evolution doesn't have a "direction" or goal.) It means that environments pressures resulted in certain traits. Social orders are likely influenced by and result from those traits. Social orders may also artificially enforce those traits.

However, removing the pressures (including the artificial ones) that encourage those traits will result in a different distribution of traits over time.

Would it not just as legitimate to say that we have evolved into a new (feminist friendly?) social order as it is we evolved into the traditional social order? Therefore, feminism cannot be women fighting against nature, because this, too, is nature.

Modern society doesn't need to adhere to how we evolved, and I would argue in some cases we absolutely shouldn't. But we should be aware of those evolutionary effects, and try to account for them.
Absolutely. (However, I think you are giving a bit more respect to the evolutionary context than I think is warranted.)
That's why I support separate sports categories for male and female athletes.

Of course, I also recognize that in a few thousand years, they may no longer be relevant because removal of evolutionary pressures may equalize physical capabilities between the sexes. That day is not today.

The differences in mental capabilities, however, I believe to be almost entirely environmental rather than evolutionary.
That's a straw man. First off, being a mother is not incompatible with work or STEM. Second, there is such a thing as preference. Fewer women than men want to work in STEM. The ones who do want to and have the talent should be allowed to, absolutely, and I don't think the author is arguing otherwise. But there's no sense in pretending that there isn't a sex difference, or trying to force equality of outcome contrary to that difference in preference.
Ah, but WHY do fewer women want to work in STEM?

If it's because girls are not encouraged or held to different expectations, that's not biology, that's society. We can and should change that.
The author is suggesting that these differences are due to nature rather than nurture. I take the opposite view.

Is it a sex difference if we, expecting women to be housewives, and prepare them for life as a housewife? Or is it a social?
Is it a sex difference if we give boys Legos and erector sets and guide them towards shop class? Or is it social?

The question is who is making the choice? By example, toy selection, education guidance (Shop or home economics...yes, I'm old.) are we catering to their choices and sex differences, or are we teaching them to want what we assume they should want?
 
Ah, but WHY do fewer women want to work in STEM?

If it's because girls are not encouraged or held to different expectations, that's not biology, that's society. We can and should change that.
The author is suggesting that these differences are due to nature rather than nurture. I take the opposite view.

Is it a sex difference if we, expecting women to be housewives, and prepare them for life as a housewife? Or is it a social?
Is it a sex difference if we give boys Legos and erector sets and guide them towards shop class? Or is it social?

When women are free to choose, they more often choose social occupations, like nursing or teaching, than hard sciences, like engineering.


The question is who is making the choice? By example, toy selection, education guidance (Shop or home economics...yes, I'm old.) are we catering to their choices and sex differences, or are we teaching them to want what we assume they should want?

Sex differences in chimpanzees' use of sticks as play objects resemble those of children
 
Last edited:
Looking at outcomes is a way to evaluate opportunity. If barriers are removed and disparity persists, it could indicate additional barriers not noticed or addressed previously.
In principle, it could. But there is VERY strong evidence that in the case of sex representation in STEM fields, it doesn't.
That said, some people do tend to skip the step where they identify barriers.
Like how you skipped the step where you recognize preferences?
Yes, they quoted one feminist who died 20 years ago. I think what she was pretty stupid.
And yet, her ideas remain influential.
Would it not just as legitimate to say that we have evolved into a new (feminist friendly?) social order as it is we evolved into the traditional social order?
Only if they survive. Feminist societies are literally dying out.
Of course, I also recognize that in a few thousand years, they may no longer be relevant because removal of evolutionary pressures may equalize physical capabilities between the sexes.
In a few thousand years? Not a ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ chance. We aren't going to evolve out of the effects of testosterone that fast. And the mere removal of pressure (which hasn't happened yet) won't guarantee equalization of physical capability over any time scale at all.
Ah, but WHY do fewer women want to work in STEM?

If it's because girls are not encouraged or held to different expectations, that's not biology, that's society.
It's not. The most egalitarian societies have low women's participation in STEM fields. The societies with high women's participation in STEM fields are NOT egalitarian at all, and they tend to not be very free either.
 
Yes, your video is asking the same questions I am. Is it biology or society?
It's biology. Human sexual dimorphism is more than physical. That doesn't mean that a woman cannot be an engineer or that a man cannot be a nurse. But when society has gender equality, sex differences in preferences come out.
 
I agree it's interesting.
It's interesting in it's dishonesty and lack of logic.
Given the source, both general and on this forum, that's too be expected
I'm not going to analyze this deeply, (I did watch it all the way through. To my regret.), but I will point out a few things:
  • It starts with the assertion that feminists are "cheering" the children's deaths, which as far as I can tell, is a false statement. The video supports this by mischaracterizing what is meant when women say they feel sympathetic. What the women are referring to is postpartum depression. One can understand and be sympathetic to the situation that leads to someone committing a crime without condoning the crime.
  • Then it moves to bad analogies using go fund-me donation as a metric to support the previous point. A logical leap that ignores a number of reasons why someone might donate to her defense. The most obvious being sympathy for her mental health condition as a mitigating factor, as opposed to support for her crime. It's an extension of the same lie.
  • Next the video sets up a framework for the pro-choice argument leading to declaring that the mainstream position is "unconditional abortion until birth." I consider this to be a misrepresentation of the "mainstream" position. (Most pro-choice people are not supportive of elective late term abortion. But they also see those cases as medical decisions that should be made by the people involved and qualified: doctors and patients, not unqualified people: lawyers and politicians.)
  • This sets up the leap that kids are stressful after birth as well, so they must support "aborting" kids after birth as well. A position no one actually takes. (I suppose there are some people of both sexes out there who take it, but still....)
  • Next leap: the video asserts that liberal women don't want or value children or parenthood. I just have to look around at reality to see that this is false. This section is just stupid and not grounded in the real world.
  • Now we get to "biology." (I have a degree in biology. I have to put their use of the term in quotes because...it's not really biology now is it?) The point the video is really trying to make is this: Humans have biologically evolved to support a patriarchal society. Fighting for equality is fighting nature. It supports this with a really specious evocation of natural selection.
  • From there it moves further into incel territory. Basically, we are evolved for a patriarchal society. Feminists are rejecting the biological reality that their role is to be mothers and homemakers and that big things like work, math and science (STEM) are the role of men. (Looking around my professional colleagues, I can see that this is wrong.)

Throwing around terms like logic and science does not make your argument logical or scientific.
Yeah, it's a mix of horrific misogyny and anti-abortion propaganda
 
I don't have time for more than a quick response this morning.
This really isn't on topic for the thread anyway.

In principle, it could. But there is VERY strong evidence that in the case of sex representation in STEM fields, it doesn't.

Like how you skipped the step where you recognize preferences?
I'm not sure I would say there is "VERY" strong evidence. I did some superficial reading yesterday where they found that boys and girls learn math at similar rates, and with the same activity on MRIs. However, differentiation occurred later, which they hypothesized had to do with differing social expectations and such.

I did not skip or fail to recognize preferences. I was describing a metric and looking into why that metric showed a given result. Part of the "WHY" is preference. And the why of the preference.

Your hypothesis is that it's biological.
My hypothesis is that it's a combination of biological and sociological.
And yet, her ideas remain influential.
Is she? I'm not a scholar of feminism, and could really care less.
But does the mainstream feminist think that women should have choices forced upon them?

To be clear, I don't consider activists to be "mainstream." I expect activists to be more radical than the mainstream. (Or at least present themselves to be so to push the needle in the desired direction.) Showing me statements by activists doesn't qualify as an indication of mainstream to me.

Only if they survive. Feminist societies are literally dying out.
A species can evolve itself to extinction.

Also, I didn't say "feminist society." I said "feminist friendly."

Regardless, in what way are they "literally dying out?"
In a few thousand years? Not a ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ chance. We aren't going to evolve out of the effects of testosterone that fast. And the mere removal of pressure (which hasn't happened yet) won't guarantee equalization of physical capability over any time scale at all.
:rolleyes:That was not meant to be taken literally. The point is that things change over time. Also, technology has radically altered pressures. Completely? No.
It's not. The most egalitarian societies have low women's participation in STEM fields. The societies with high women's participation in STEM fields are NOT egalitarian at all, and they tend to not be very free either.
And it comes back to that question of "why?"
There are varying hypothesis for this. I know you have a preferred one.
Myself, I don't have a preferred hypothesis, but I suspect there are both biological factors and societal factors involved. Social conditioning is still a thing in egalitarian societies, even if unintended. But I'm not an activist invested in changing that. (I gave my daughter different toys than I give my grandson, and I don't feel particularly guilty about it.)

None of this has anything to do with the idea of feminism/pro-choice supporting child murder. (Does anyone remember the thread topic?)

Anyway, I'm busy the rest of the day, so don't expect any replies.
 
It's biology. Human sexual dimorphism is more than physical. That doesn't mean that a woman cannot be an engineer or that a man cannot be a nurse. But when society has gender equality, sex differences in preferences come out.
That's one hypothesis.
There are others.
 
I'm not sure I would say there is "VERY" strong evidence. I did some superficial reading yesterday where they found that boys and girls learn math at similar rates, and with the same activity on MRIs.
That has absolutely nothing to do with preferences.
Regardless, in what way are they "literally dying out?"
Demographic collapse. Below-replacement birth rates. Feminist societies aren't the only ones facing this problem, but they are still facing it.
Myself, I don't have a preferred hypothesis, but I suspect there are both biological factors and societal factors involved. Social conditioning is still a thing in egalitarian societies, even if unintended.
Sure. But social pressures are much less of a thing than in non-egalitarian societies. And yet, egalitarian societies show more sex-based differences, not less.
 
What trimester is this thread in?
Does it matter? It's a discussion, not a human life. On the one hand, you probably can't get it killed, but on the other hand, nobody will hold it against you if you just walk away and let it live or die without you.

Though I suppose... Is this a mental health issue? Should we kill the thread before someone suffers an emotional breakdown or psychotic episode? If the thread goes to nine pages, does that make it too well established to send it all to deep storage, and the poor mentally unwell must just learn to deal with it?

Maybe that's what happened on the Night of the Yellow Fever. A mod just snapped. "Aaah! I can't take it anymore! Time to hand out some yellow cards of mental health necessity!"
 
Last edited:
So when they hold 59& or more of the jobs, has biology ceased to have any effect? (And they will, the coming generations seem to be heading that way here; 54% of all science students in high school are girls.)

When my mother grew up, being a doctor was considered inaporopriate for girls - too bloody, not to mention difficult - but nursing was of course fine. Now 50% of all doctors worldwide are female. Did biology change?
 
So when they hold 59& or more of the jobs, has biology ceased to have any effect? (And they will, the coming generations seem to be heading that way here; 54% of all science students in high school are girls.)

When my mother grew up, being a doctor was considered inaporopriate for girls - too bloody, not to mention difficult - but nursing was of course fine. Now 50% of all doctors worldwide are female. Did biology change?
This thread is about abortions of mental health necessity, not abortions of career convenience. Lindsay Clancy didn't kill her kids because they were getting in the way of her STEM degree.
 
So when they hold 59& or more of the jobs, has biology ceased to have any effect? (And they will, the coming generations seem to be heading that way here; 54% of all science students in high school are girls.)

When my mother grew up, being a doctor was considered inaporopriate for girls - too bloody, not to mention difficult - but nursing was of course fine. Now 50% of all doctors worldwide are female. Did biology change?
It appears that biology biases women towards people-centric professions, and men torwards thing-centric professions. I find it very interesting that you're using doctors as your example, because it suggests to me that you aren't actually examining the issue objectively, you're just looking for a way to try to prove me wrong.

Being a doctor is a very people-centric profession. Mathematics, on the other hand, is a very thing-centric profession. Medicine being dominated by women doesn't in any way indicate that biology changed. Oh, and since it's possible to over-ride innate preferences through social factors, it's possible that mathematics could, in principle, become a female-dominated profession. It's a bad idea to do that, but it can be done.
 
But back before women became doctors, the arguments were the same as yours is now; it was against the nature of women.
The fact that people got it wrong before doesn't mean I'm wrong now.
STEM is a good example, from 14% in 1970, to 35 now. And girls in science programs in high school; 54% here.
High school doesn't mean ◊◊◊◊.
 
But back before women became doctors, the arguments were the same as yours is now; it was against the nature of women. STEM is a good example, from 14% in 1970, to 35 now. And girls in science programs in high school; 54% here.

But I won't belabour this thread drift any further.
Put it this way:

Lindsay Clancy killed her kids because having kids drove her insane.

If she'd killed one of her kids earlier, while it was still in her body and she was still in her right mind, would it have kept her sane and saved the lives of her other kid(s)?

Is the risk of infanticidal post-partum depression significant enough to greenlight abortion of an otherwise-healthy pregnancy, simply as a prophylactic against taking that life in a fit of madness later on?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom