Lindsay Clancy and Abortion

theprestige

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Aug 14, 2007
Messages
85,317
Location
The Antimemetics Division
Social issues because not the trial, the public response.

It seems to me that roughly 50% of Americans side with Lindsay Clancy. One thing this tells me is that roughly 50% of Americans favor extending abortions of medical necessity even as far as the seventeenth trimester. The medical necessity in this case being one of mental health.

In abortion terms, she had to attempt a "back-alley" disposal of an unwanted child that was causing her severe psychological trauma, because society insistent that she keep the child and suffer, and would not provide a safe, legal (and rare!) child-disposal option for her. And her situation was orders of magnitude worse than for a merely pregnant aborter. She had to suffer with multiple children for years, rather than with just one child for a matter of months.
 
Social issues because not the trial, the public response.

It seems to me that roughly 50% of Americans side with Lindsay Clancy. One thing this tells me is that roughly 50% of Americans favor extending abortions of medical necessity even as far as the seventeenth trimester. The medical necessity in this case being one of mental health.

In abortion terms, she had to attempt a "back-alley" disposal of an unwanted child that was causing her severe psychological trauma, because society insistent that she keep the child and suffer, and would not provide a safe, legal (and rare!) child-disposal option for her. And her situation was orders of magnitude worse than for a merely pregnant aborter. She had to suffer with multiple children for years, rather than with just one child for a matter of months.

Have you actually ever met anyone suffering a significant, severe psychotic state? ETA And by that I do mean one that will lead to someone killing another, no matter how close to them?
 
I'd like to see some evidence that 50% of Americans consider this to be an abortion.
 
Social issues because not the trial, the public response.

It seems to me that roughly 50% of Americans side with Lindsay Clancy. One thing this tells me is that roughly 50% of Americans favor extending abortions of medical necessity even as far as the seventeenth trimester. The medical necessity in this case being one of mental health.

In abortion terms, she had to attempt a "back-alley" disposal of an unwanted child that was causing her severe psychological trauma, because society insistent that she keep the child and suffer, and would not provide a safe, legal (and rare!) child-disposal option for her. And her situation was orders of magnitude worse than for a merely pregnant aborter. She had to suffer with multiple children for years, rather than with just one child for a matter of months.
Your thinking is based on "an eye for an eye" retribution.

There are multiple tragedies here. The mother's alleged post-partum psychosis, and the deaths of the children.

Sending the mother to jail would be another tragedy. But you want to do more harm by doing so?
 
Your thinking is based on "an eye for an eye" retribution.
No it is not. I am not interested in retribution here.

There are multiple tragedies here. The mother's alleged post-partum psychosis, and the deaths of the children.
The murders of the children. It's not like they died of natural causes, or out of some accident free from human agency.

Sending the mother to jail would be another tragedy. But you want to do more harm by doing so?
Again, this is not about the case, it's about the public response. I made that absolutely clear to you in the first line of my post. Why are you still this confused?
 
No it is not. I am not interested in retribution here.
Then why argue what you're arguing?
The murders of the children. It's not like they died of natural causes, or out of some accident free from human agency.
It's still a tragedy. And do you think the mother feels no regret?

Again, this is not about the case, it's about the public response. I made that absolutely clear to you in the first line of my post. Why are you still this confused?
The public response IS about the case. Why are you so confused?
 
Then why argue what you're arguing?
Because I want to. What have I said that leads you to the conclusion that it's about retribution?

It's still a tragedy.
It's just "deaths", though. It's not like they died of natural causes. It's not like they died of an unavoidable accident, after their mother did everything in her power to save their lives. It's not even like they died of an avoidable accident, and their mother was culpably negligent.

She murdered her children. That's the tragedy she has to live with.

And do you think the mother feels no regret?
That isn't a question I had even considered. Do you think I should have? What part of my position do you think I would change, or should change, with this question in mind?



That said, now that you have brought it to my attention: I think her feelings are probably very mixed right now. If autoethnography is permitted, I think she probably feels huge relief at having the kids taken care of (so to speak). I think she probably also feels a lot of guilt for feeling relieved. I think she probably feels some amount of regret about the way things played out, and maybe even her part in that. I think she probably feels genuine regret and sorrow over the loss of her children. I think she probably feels resentment towards her husband, maybe even hatred.

So that's the big stuff. Does it help you better understand my argument?


The public response IS about the case. Why are you so confused?
I'm not. This is not a thread about the charges, the sentence sought, the evidence, the witnesses, the opening and closing statements, the jury instructions, the ruling, or any other aspect of the trial process as such. This is a thread about public opinion about abortion policy, and how it correlates with public opinion about a sensational item in this week's news cycle.

There's a whole other thread in a whole other subforum, for the conversation you seem to want.
 
Social issues because not the trial, the public response.

It seems to me that roughly 50% of Americans side with Lindsay Clancy. One thing this tells me is that roughly 50% of Americans favor extending abortions of medical necessity even as far as the seventeenth trimester. The medical necessity in this case being one of mental health.

In abortion terms, she had to attempt a "back-alley" disposal of an unwanted child that was causing her severe psychological trauma, because society insistent that she keep the child and suffer, and would not provide a safe, legal (and rare!) child-disposal option for her. And her situation was orders of magnitude worse than for a merely pregnant aborter. She had to suffer with multiple children for years, rather than with just one child for a matter of months.
I haven't really been aware of this case, so I just read a bit about it. Perhaps you can provide a basis for linking someone's position to their opinion about abortion?

My take, after a superficial read, is not that people support her right to "abort" her children, but that they see post-partum depression as a real mental issue that is neglected. The kids were murdered. It's not a question of whether murdering kids is OK under any condition, but rather of the mental illness defense.

Which leads to three issues, really:
  1. Is mental illness a legitimate defense for murder? Precedent says yes, as it's been successfully argued many times in the past.
  2. Does it apply to this case? As I've said, I'm not that familiar with the case so I don't have a position. Also, you've said this isn't about the case.
  3. What do we do with someone to whom the mental illness defense applies?
I don't know a lot about the exact positions of demonstrators (on either side) and I haven't read any public responses. (Perhaps you would like to submit some that demonstrate the positions you describe?)

Back in the 1980s, I remember an episode of Quincy M.D. that dealt with a mentally ill person who had committed murder. On the show, Quincy was advocating a legal idea of "Quilty, but mentally ill" or something to that effect. The idea being that rather than finding a person "Not Guilty" due to insanity, They would be found guilty of the crime, but their sentence/rehabilitation/whatever would be based on their mental condition. The idea, as I recall, being that an insanity plea was not a get out of jail card, but rather a mitigating factor in sentencing. (This seems similar to the "bifurcated trial" the prosecution requested.)

So... public reactions.

Does someone who thinks she is not responsible (or not fully responsible) due to mental illness think she's innocent and should have no consequences? Or do they think that those consequences should be different than in a non-insanity related crime? Either way, I think it says nothing about abortion. Whatever link you are making appears tenuous, given the information I have.

Similarly, someone thinking that her defense specifically or the insanity defense in general is bogus does not indicate that they are anti-abortion either.

This seems to be an attempt at a "gotcha" based on poorly thought out logic.

Prove me wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom