Lindsay Clancy and Abortion

Here's an interesting analysis of the abortion/clancy crossover which essentially argues that both are a consequence of feminism's war on biological reality:
 
So where did this figure of 50% come from?
I made it up, using the following rubric:

Public opinion on the Lindsay Clancy case seems to split roughly along sex lines. Not all women will favor exonerating her, but on the other hand, some men certainly will. So I think as a rough estimate 50% will do for purposes of discussion. If your positions on the moral, ethical, and policy questions regarding abortions of medical necessity will vary based on an accurate measure of the percentage of people who hold a particular position about Lindsay Clancy murdering her children, I'd like to learn more. What are your positions? What percentage of shared viewpoint would change your positions?

Specifically, the issue of abortion due to the medical necessity to preserve the mental health of the mother. Do you think public policy should allow abortions for that reason? Up until which trimester? I assume you're already against extending mental health abortions to the fourth trimester and beyond, for obvious but rather arbitrary reasons. But what about the third trimester?

If a pregnant woman gets a prognosis of PTSD, trauma, or the like if she carries the baby to term, but she's already in the third trimester, is it too late to save her sanity? Or do you think we should reform abortion policy to allow abortions of mental health necessity into the third trimester?
 
I agree with you. In fact, I think everybody should have stopped reading at the OP.
I don't. Because I don't think any of this really hinges on the exact percentage. Not sure why that's the part you're stuck on.
 
I stopped reading after that, sorry.
You don't have to apologize. The question of the propriety of abortions of mental health necessity, up through the third trimester, is tough to engage with. I don't blame you for wanting to stop short of that point. If my inference and implication of the popularity of the idea provides you with the escape hatch you're looking for, feel free to use it to get out of this discussion.
 
Last edited:
I don't. Because I don't think any of this really hinges on the exact percentage. Not sure why that's the part you're stuck on.
My hypothesis is that the exact percentage isn't the part he's stuck on. My hypothesis is that he did in fact keep reading, but stopped as soon as he got stuck on something he realized he wouldn't or couldn't address. Probably the propriety of abortions of mental health necessity into the third trimester.

I think that's where everyone is getting stuck. Which I think is good, if that's the case. People getting stuck on the core question is a good start.
 
Last edited:
My hypothesis is that the exact percentage isn't the part he's stuck on.
Yeah, that sounds correct. I'm sure he didn't actually think 91.6% was the percentage either, even though he offered it. But it's much easier to argue about the percentage than the core question.
 
Here's an interesting analysis of the abortion/clancy crossover which essentially argues that both are a consequence of feminism's war on biological reality:
I agree it's interesting.
It's interesting in it's dishonesty and lack of logic.

I'm not going to analyze this deeply, (I did watch it all the way through. To my regret.), but I will point out a few things:
  • It starts with the assertion that feminists are "cheering" the children's deaths, which as far as I can tell, is a false statement. The video supports this by mischaracterizing what is meant when women say they feel sympathetic. What the women are referring to is postpartum depression. One can understand and be sympathetic to the situation that leads to someone committing a crime without condoning the crime.
  • Then it moves to bad analogies using go fund-me donation as a metric to support the previous point. A logical leap that ignores a number of reasons why someone might donate to her defense. The most obvious being sympathy for her mental health condition as a mitigating factor, as opposed to support for her crime. It's an extension of the same lie.
  • Next the video sets up a framework for the pro-choice argument leading to declaring that the mainstream position is "unconditional abortion until birth." I consider this to be a misrepresentation of the "mainstream" position. (Most pro-choice people are not supportive of elective late term abortion. But they also see those cases as medical decisions that should be made by the people involved and qualified: doctors and patients, not unqualified people: lawyers and politicians.)
  • This sets up the leap that kids are stressful after birth as well, so they must support "aborting" kids after birth as well. A position no one actually takes. (I suppose there are some people of both sexes out there who take it, but still....)
  • Next leap: the video asserts that liberal women don't want or value children or parenthood. I just have to look around at reality to see that this is false. This section is just stupid and not grounded in the real world.
  • Now we get to "biology." (I have a degree in biology. I have to put their use of the term in quotes because...it's not really biology now is it?) The point the video is really trying to make is this: Humans have biologically evolved to support a patriarchal society. Fighting for equality is fighting nature. It supports this with a really specious evocation of natural selection.
  • From there it moves further into incel territory. Basically, we are evolved for a patriarchal society. Feminists are rejecting the biological reality that their role is to be mothers and homemakers and that big things like work, math and science (STEM) are the role of men. (Looking around my professional colleagues, I can see that this is wrong.)

Throwing around terms like logic and science does not make your argument logical or scientific.
 
  • Now we get to "biology." (I have a degree in biology. I have to put their use of the term in quotes because...it's not really biology now is it?) The point the video is really trying to make is this: Humans have biologically evolved to support a patriarchal society. Fighting for equality is fighting nature. It supports this with a really specious evocation of natural selection.
Equality of what, exactly? Fighting for equality of opportunity is not fighting nature. But fighting for equality of outcome absolutely is. And a lot of feminists don't fight for equality of opportunity.

"No woman should be authorized to stay at home and raise her children. Society should be totally different. Women should not have that choice, precisely because if there is such a choice, too many women will make that one." - Simone de Beauvoir
  • From there it moves further into incel territory. Basically, we are evolved for a patriarchal society.
Is this part wrong? If so, how and why?

Modern society doesn't need to adhere to how we evolved, and I would argue in some cases we absolutely shouldn't. But we should be aware of those evolutionary effects, and try to account for them.
Feminists are rejecting the biological reality that their role is to be mothers and homemakers and that big things like work, math and science (STEM) are the role of men. (Looking around my professional colleagues, I can see that this is wrong.)
That's a straw man. First off, being a mother is not incompatible with work or STEM. Second, there is such a thing as preference. Fewer women than men want to work in STEM. The ones who do want to and have the talent should be allowed to, absolutely, and I don't think the author is arguing otherwise. But there's no sense in pretending that there isn't a sex difference, or trying to force equality of outcome contrary to that difference in preference.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom