Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

No. The only reason I said "most" is, as you said, that if I didn't, someone would point to some odd example to prove me wrong:p.


So when people, like R. Prey complains about taxes and calls them theft, what is he really saying? Surely he can't be suggesting that a society can exist without any taxes whatsoever. Is it a specific tax that becomes akin to theft? How does one make that case, that this tax is thievery while this other tax is not?

Just a reminder, the Founders of the United States didn't revolt against taxation. They revolted against taxation without representation. Since we have representation, where again does the concept of thievery apply? I understand we don't agree with all the decisions our representatives make. However, there's recourse through elections and initiatives to change these decisions if we choose.

So again, why the call it thievery? And please, feel free to present an alternative.
 
Like we're ever going to get Robert to admit that The Great Depression only ended when WW2 finally forced the government to spend enough money.
Gearing up for WWII, the money was spent on manufacturing, not bailing out auto cos and banks, so yes it did have a positive effect. Rosie the Riveter was born.

SFAIK, prior to that CCC etc were money wasters in terms of economic impact ending the great depression.
 
Just a reminder, the Founders of the United States didn't revolt against taxation. They revolted against taxation without representation. Since we have representation, where again does the concept of thievery apply?

Given the current status of Congress, one could aregue the the average American does not have representation.
 
That was not the purpose of those orgs.
Keynsian stimulus before Keynes wrote his treatise; I'd say it was specifically intended by FDR et al to end the depression.

The REA/TVA did at least supply some benefit.
 
Given the current status of Congress, one could aregue the the average American does not have representation.


The current state? I think it could be argued that the average citizen hasn't had the ear of congress for quite a long time. However, if we wanted to change that, the power is still in the hands of the people. We simply lack either the resolve, the urgency or the unity to change that.
 
Keynsian stimulus before Keynes wrote his treatise; I'd say it was specifically intended by FDR et al to end the depression.

The REA/TVA did at least supply some benefit.

You're thinking to much in terms of an economist.

The CCC and other orgs were mostly to get the unemployed people doing something and get paid for doing it. With 25% unemployment many folks might have found the prospect of Communist Revolution in the USA very tempting. Programs like the CCC had the benefit of keeping folks working, with the added bonus of having them doing infrastructure work.

Not everything was framed in terms of Keynasian economics.
 
So... adjusting tax rates upwards = theft under color of Law = Marxist.

You're basically saying that increasing taxes is Marxism?

You're going to have a hard time with my next question if that's your conception.

When taxes are collected in order to support the General Welfare, as they are supposed to be under the US Const., those taxes are not Marxist. But when taxes are collected for the benefit of special individuals, groups or interests, that is Marxist, or Fascist but it isn't lawful nor ethical nor Constitutional.
 
So when people, like R. Prey complains about taxes and calls them theft, what is he really saying? Surely he can't be suggesting that a society can exist without any taxes whatsoever. Is it a specific tax that becomes akin to theft? How does one make that case, that this tax is thievery while this other tax is not?

Just a reminder, the Founders of the United States didn't revolt against taxation. They revolted against taxation without representation. Since we have representation, where again does the concept of thievery apply? I understand we don't agree with all the decisions our representatives make. However, there's recourse through elections and initiatives to change these decisions if we choose.

So again, why the call it thievery? And please, feel free to present an alternative.

Already answered. If it's not for the General Welfare, it is theft.
 
When taxes are collected in order to support the General Welfare, as they are supposed to be under the US Const., those taxes are not Marxist. But when taxes are collected for the benefit of special individuals, groups or interests, that is Marxist, or Fascist but it isn't lawful nor ethical nor Constitutional.

So you don't know what the words "fascist" or "marxist" mean. Well, when the student is ready, the teacher will appear.

(Or whatever that silly little line is.)

Already answered. If it's not for the General Welfare, it is theft.

So now you support welfare and other social programs? It's hard to keep up with your wandering opinions. :boggled:
 
When taxes are collected in order to support the General Welfare, as they are supposed to be under the US Const., those taxes are not Marxist. But when taxes are collected for the benefit of special individuals, groups or interests, that is Marxist, or Fascist but it isn't lawful nor ethical nor Constitutional.

marxism and fascism have no relationship.
feel free to prove me wrong.

please show me how the communist manifesto supports your claim.
 
Well, as support to the low income families is considered to be an aspect of General Welfare, Robert can prove the taxes are intended for "specific groups" right after he supplies a reference to when Marx advocated the collection of taxes for individuals or particular groups. As marxism is an ethos of social and financial equality the idea seems directly opposed to it.
 
But when taxes are collected for the benefit of special individuals, groups or interests, that is Marxist, or Fascist but it isn't lawful nor ethical nor Constitutional.
What individuals and special interests are you kvetching about?
 
Because everything that Government touches turns into crap.


Maybe in the U.S. perhaps. Elsewhere, governments sometimes manage to do a competent job. I'm sitting in a country whose governments managed to avoid almost all of the major pitfalls that have befallen the U.S. the last few years.


Gearing up for WWII, the money was spent on manufacturing, not bailing out auto cos and banks, so yes it did have a positive effect. Rosie the Riveter was born.


Rosie the Riveter was born when many of the men were drafted and sent off to fight and the factories needed someone else to take their place.


Already answered. If it's not for the General Welfare, it is theft.


Now you just need to define "General Welfare". Please be precise.
 
I like the minimum wage laws. I would hate to earn 4.25 an hour when I could be making 7.25 hour. 10 hours 4.25 42.50$ 10 hours 7.25 72.50$ Which one would you prefer making? Minimum wage jobs are minimum because thats the least they can get away with paying someone to do the job. If minimum wage was 1.50 an hour, you would likely see more minimum wage jobs paying 1.50 an hour. It has nothing to do with profits period.
 
I like the minimum wage laws. I would hate to earn 4.25 an hour when I could be making 7.25 hour. 10 hours 4.25 42.50$ 10 hours 7.25 72.50$ Which one would you prefer making? Minimum wage jobs are minimum because thats the least they can get away with paying someone to do the job. If minimum wage was 1.50 an hour, you would likely see more minimum wage jobs paying 1.50 an hour. It has nothing to do with profits period.


:confused::confused::confused:
your post seems to prove otherwise.
it has EVERYTHING to do with profits.
 
When taxes are collected in order to support the General Welfare, as they are supposed to be under the US Const., those taxes are not Marxist. But when taxes are collected for the benefit of special individuals, groups or interests, that is Marxist, or Fascist but it isn't lawful nor ethical nor Constitutional.

Sorry. Marxism abolishes all private property. Fascist isn't even an economic system.

But that's OK... my last one for now.

You have said Obama is Marxist, and FDR is Socialist.

Please compare Obama's policies to FDR and explain why one policy is Marxist but the other Socialist.
 
Last edited:
The phrase "spread the wealth around" means steal from the Maker Peter, to the benefit of Taker, Paul.

You think construction companies are "takers?" What about military contractors?

Or do you only lump those on social assistance programs in this category? If so then what do you think the poor do with that money? Do they not spend it on needed commodities? Does this not allow them to get by until they do gain full employment again?

I know you hate multiple questions so here is just one: what do you think should be done to help the poor regain their economic foothold?

Gearing up for WWII, the money was spent on manufacturing, not bailing out auto cos and banks, so yes it did have a positive effect. Rosie the Riveter was born.

SFAIK, prior to that CCC etc were money wasters in terms of economic impact ending the great depression.

You don't think auto companies manufactured anything? You think that our economy can survive not having banks around?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom