Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Taxes and spending cut, the Depression ended quickly.

That was just because the capitalist swine who created the problem had the funds to artificially re-inflate the ecconomic bubble they created.

Just a year and a half into Warren Harding's administration, the economy lifted itself, and the Roaring 20s followed.

How did that work out,over the period between Harding and the next Democratic POTUS? Did their fix for the problem work better than FDR's, long term?
 
Like we're ever going to get Robert to admit that The Great Depression only ended when WW2 finally forced the government to spend enough money.
 
Obama and Joe the Plumber:

"Wurzelbacher said he planned to become the owner of a small plumbing business that will take in more than the $250,000 amount at which Obama plans to begin raising tax rates.
"Your new tax plan is going to tax me more, isn't it?" the blue-collar worker asked.
After Obama responded that it would, Wurzelbacher continued: "I've worked hard . . . I work 10 to 12 hours a day and I'm buying this company and I'm going to continue working that way. I'm getting taxed more and more while fulfilling the American Dream."
"It's not that I want to punish your success," Obama told him. "I want to make sure that everybody who is behind you, that they've got a chance for success, too.
Then, Obama explained his trickle-up theory of economics.
"My attitude is that if the economy's good for folks from the bottom up, it's gonna be good for everybody. I think when you spread the wealth around, it's good for everybody"

"From each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs."
Karl Marx

Higher income taxes <> Marxism... or else Eisenhower was the biggest Marxist this country has ever had.

Being in favor of whatever "wealth spreading" he was referring to <> abolishing markets and dictating wages and prices. Those are two completely different statements.

Talking about a vague goal like "spreading wealth" is not a policy statement. Policy is when you actually outline what's being done and how it's being done. That's why when someone like Obama says something like that, you can read into it anything you like and it doesn't really characterize his economic policy.

Other Marxist examples include Obamacare, Obama Motors, Obama Student Loans, Obama Banking, Obama Stimulus, Obama debt, Obama Green colored Lemon Energy Socialism, etc., etc, etc.
You've just made a list of Obama policies that you don't like. That really isn't connecting it to Marxism.

Can you give a definition of Marxism at all?
 
Last edited:
When government steps in to break up a business by reason of the fact that it is too successful, that is not in the interest of anyone, especially the consumer.

But hang on...

Isn't the reason given that capitalism is the best system because it engenders competition, driving prices down and quality up because company 'a' is trying to better company 'b'.

That's your whole line on capitalism, as far as I can see, that, due to the above mechanism, it's the best (the only, I think you would say) way to do things.

Now you have some serious cognitive dissonance going on if you think that removing the competition element from capitalism is going to be a good thing.

You've just advocated that capitalism works for the consumer without the element of competition. How on earth can it work in the consumer's favour then?
 
Robert, you know "Marxist" means something specific, right? It's not just a synonym for "**** Robert doesn't like."
 
So you say, but with the industrial revolution, exactly the opposite happened -- people took the crappy pay jobs because it was better than the alternative. And they thus improved their lives. And things got better.

Ridiculous social strictures about "living wages" put a boulder in the freeflowing river of advancement. Of course, there are many other boulders in the way, among them ridiculous tax rates that precede and help cause the poverty as business flees. High expenses for security to compensate for the crime -- which they don't need in more prosperous neighborhoods -- symptomatic of government failing at its primary duty to secure the rights of people. Required "studies" before you build anything.

Watch as Rome collapses, the politicians blaming everyone but themselves.


I find a certain irony in this attitude. The obvious response to this is for workers to band together and say 'we will not work for less than this', thereby ensuring that no-one sells their labour for less than it is worth to them (a reasonable proposition, I think).

I normally find that those advocating the argument beerina (and others) posit above are dead against workers banding together to drive up the price of their labour to the point that they can live on their wages.

I think that's ironic.
 
Other Marxist examples include Obamacare, Obama Motors, Obama Student Loans, Obama Banking, Obama Stimulus, Obama debt, Obama Green colored Lemon Energy Socialism, etc., etc, etc.

All right, "teacher." What is so bad about those two items I highlited. Why is the new student loan program worse than the old? Why is the Obama plan for banking reform worse than that piece of crap that that idiot Phil Gramm foisted off on us?

Or maybe I could start another thread if this one looks too crowded by the time your head stops hurting from having to post a logical explanation for something that the Rushblob has not already imbedded in your mind skull.
 
Obama and Joe the Plumber: snip...

This again!? Joe was claiming to be in a position to have the skills and resources to purchase and run a plumbing company that makes over a quarter million a year and is upset that he would have to pay taxes on that. The only story here is what a selfish jerk Joe is. The resources and strengths of this country have helped Joe to prosper well beyond what the average American makes and when asked to give back, well within his means, he starts crying.

It is not Marxism to ask the wealthiest to give a bit more its good economic policy that will continue to allow America to grow and prosper. It use to be people were proud to be able contribute to their nations prosperity.

And now for my one question as allowed per robert;preys single question policy.

What is your definition of marxism?
 
This again!? Joe was claiming to be in a position to have the skills and resources to purchase and run a plumbing company that makes over a quarter million a year and is upset that he would have to pay taxes on that. The only story here is what a selfish jerk Joe is. The resources and strengths of this country have helped Joe to prosper well beyond what the average American makes and when asked to give back, well within his means, he starts crying.

It is not Marxism to ask the wealthiest to give a bit more its good economic policy that will continue to allow America to grow and prosper. It use to be people were proud to be able contribute to their nations prosperity.

And now for my one question as allowed per robert;preys single question policy.

What is your definition of marxism?

Under color of Law Theft.

Nor does Marxism 'ask" anything. It takes via force. Ditto the words "contribute" or "give" which are examples of debauchery of the language. "Give" and "contribute" means submit to the gun and the jails or else.
 
All right, "teacher." What is so bad about those two items I highlited. Why is the new student loan program worse than the old? Why is the Obama plan for banking reform worse than that piece of crap that that idiot Phil Gramm foisted off on us?

Or maybe I could start another thread if this one looks too crowded by the time your head stops hurting from having to post a logical explanation for something that the Rushblob has not already imbedded in your mind skull.


Because everything that Government touches turns into crap.
 
But hang on...

Isn't the reason given that capitalism is the best system because it engenders competition, driving prices down and quality up because company 'a' is trying to better company 'b'.

That's your whole line on capitalism, as far as I can see, that, due to the above mechanism, it's the best (the only, I think you would say) way to do things.

Now you have some serious cognitive dissonance going on if you think that removing the competition element from capitalism is going to be a good thing.

You've just advocated that capitalism works for the consumer without the element of competition. How on earth can it work in the consumer's favour then?

In the game of life, there are winners and losers. Some winners are so successful that others decline to compete. But not for long. Even the Green Bay Packers can lose. And have lost.
 
Under color of Law Theft.

Nor does Marxism 'ask" anything. It takes via force. Ditto the words "contribute" or "give" which are examples of debauchery of the language. "Give" and "contribute" means submit to the gun and the jails or else.

And in which text, with page reference please, did Marx mention guns and jails?

I don't seem to be familiar with that part of his manefest ideology in his texts. I can't see it going down too well while he lectured at Jewish working mens clubs circa 1888. I wonder if robert would approve of people making an "honest" wage then, by renting space behind a piece of rope pulled taut for people with nowhere else to sleep. Or the child labour movement that saw a majority of kids illiterate as they could not afford to waste time unpaid at school?
 
In the game of life, there are winners and losers. Some winners are so successful that others decline to compete. But not for long. Even the Green Bay Packers can lose. And have lost.

So I make a maguffin monopoly and there is no other market share.
And this is good for competition because others will later compete.
Except nobody will invest against the monopoly.

So you are wrong. And apparently don't understand a 'monopoly' being the state in which there is no viable competition or avenue of competition.

Ever visited reality robert?
 
Oh, no. Obama turned a Pelosi/Bush recession into a Pelosi/Obama Depression. Just like FDR turned a depression beginning in 1929 to The Great Depression of the 1930s.

When history doesn’t support you, you just invent your own!
The Dec 2007 – June 2009 recession was over a year old when Obama took office and ended 5 months after he was elected and it’s “free fall” stage occurred under Bush, before Oabam took office.

Similarly the Great depression started in 1929, and US unemployment hit 24% before FDR took office in 1933. After mid 1933 US unemployment steadily improved until 1937 when “deficit hawks” pushed through austerity measures and the US economy promptly started to decline once more.
 
Because everything that Government touches turns into crap.

So do you not have any actual critique to offer other than it being the government?

Why specifically would those two initiatives fail? And come to that why are they marxist?
 
Like we're ever going to get Robert to admit that The Great Depression only ended when WW2 finally forced the government to spend enough money.

The Great Depression didn't end till several years after WW II, when the pointless destruction caused by the policies of Hoover and FDR and the pointless destruction of WW II had finally been overcome.
 
The Great Depression didn't end till several years after WW II, when the pointless destruction caused by the policies of Hoover and FDR and the pointless destruction of WW II had finally been overcome.

Erm...No. No, that's completely wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom