Lily the Muppet Loves Free Food

Obama and Joe the Plumber:

"Wurzelbacher said he planned to become the owner of a small plumbing business that will take in more than the $250,000 amount at which Obama plans to begin raising tax rates.
"Your new tax plan is going to tax me more, isn't it?" the blue-collar worker asked.

Except it turned out the company wasn’t for sale, he couldn’t afford it if it was for sale, and it wouldn’t have been impacted by the changes even if he did find a way to buy it because his taxable earning would not have been close to $250K.

IOW Wurzelbacher was either lying or clueless about how businesses work every step of the way, but as PT Barnum said, you can fool some of the people all the time. AKA republicans can be easily controlled because they are are willing to belvie the most rediculous things.
 
The phrase "spread the wealth around" means steal from the Maker Peter, to the benefit of Taker, Paul.

So you consider your taxes to have been stolen? And any federal spending to be of "your money" to others? You should maybe tell your local schools, police force, fire department, parks commission, post office, municipal services and the like they are thieves.

Then complain to the workforce it is not fair they expect to be paid for the jobs they do.

Im sure everybody will enjoy your "teachings".
 
Under color of Law Theft.

Nor does Marxism 'ask" anything. It takes via force. Ditto the words "contribute" or "give" which are examples of debauchery of the language. "Give" and "contribute" means submit to the gun and the jails or else.

We do indeed have laws about paying taxes, what's your point? Is every president that has overseen the collection of taxes a marxist?

Please define marxism.
 
The phrase "spread the wealth around" means steal from the Maker Peter, to the benefit of Taker, Paul.
Well, duh. What else would it mean?

You're demonstrating a misconception I've long had a problem with -- that government welfare systems take from the rich and give not to the poor, but to the lazy. See, for some reason a lot of people still uphold the mideval conception that poverty/illness/unemployment is primarily caused by "poor morals", ie. laziness.

This simply isn't true. It's empirical. Look up the facts for yourself. Few, if anyone, receive welfare out of laziness. Few, if anyone, remain on welfare to the end of their lives. In fact, there's ample statistics that the benefits of a welfare state outweigh the expenses -- that is, if you understand the meaning of the word "investment".

Call it Socialism, call it Marxist, call it Communism. In fact, smear it as much as you want, for the benefit of whoever accepts or dismisses ideas based on mudslinging. We're only concerned with whether or not it works, both on an individual (for the welfare recipient) and societal level. So far, the answer seems to be yes.

"When I give money to the poor, they call me a saint. When I ask why the poor have no money, they call me a Communist":rolleyes:

Nor does Marxism 'ask" anything. It takes via force. Ditto the words "contribute" or "give" which are examples of debauchery of the language. "Give" and "contribute" means submit to the gun and the jails or else.
Don't be ridiculous. You live in a democratic nation. If you dislike your country's laws, no one will throw you in a gulag for using your rights to have them changed. Until they are, you have to respect the will of the people, which is "from each according to their ability, to each according to their need". Which far predates Marx and Communism, before you start dragging them back into the discussion.
 
Last edited:
Under color of Law Theft.

So... adjusting tax rates upwards = theft under color of Law = Marxist.

You're basically saying that increasing taxes is Marxism?

You're going to have a hard time with my next question if that's your conception.
 
Yes, taxes are "Marxist" even though they predate Marxism and exist even in most right-wing societies.

It's like saying vegetarians are Nazis because Hitler was a vegetarian:boggled:.
 
Yes, taxes are "Marxist" even though they predate Marxism and exist even in most right-wing societies.


I know you're trying to not speak in absolutist terms by using the word "most". But could you, or anyone else for that matter, point to a society that didn't use taxes in one form or another?

I'd be quite interested in examining that.
 
No. The only reason I said "most" is, as you said, that if I didn't, someone would point to some odd example to prove me wrong:p.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom