Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

I still don't get it,,, thought I did,,, nope apparently I don't.

I wouldn't be too worried about it - I'm intrigued by nomenclature, so it was fun for me to play with. But "not getting it?" I don't blame you. It's a silly notation system notably inferior to the ones in use.
 
Mainstream cult physics, without a doubt.

Yup, brainwashed by the Powers That Be.

I've literally had hoax theorists tell me the entire engineering profession has been brainwashed by folks answering to NASA, for decades now. That's why the entire mainstream engineering profession accepts Apollo as real when it "clearly" isn't.
 
the interior will always be warmer than the exterior(once you have put a snow block door in place) even if there are no people in it or candles burning.

Citation, please.
 
Yeah, I obviously had to wing it in maths to get my doctorate in physics.

Dave

I wouldn't be too worried about it - I'm intrigued by nomenclature, so it was fun for me to play with. But "not getting it?" I don't blame you. It's a silly notation system notably inferior to the ones in use.

I had no trouble getting my college diploma in electronic technology. But that was in the 80s, after all its not like designing a cct requires doing math. Nah, just insert various value components until you get operation something like what you had in mind.
 
Citing my personal experience. We would leave the hut, go ice fishing for hours, come back and the hut interior was warmer than exterior air.

Numberless anecdote rejected.

The soil maintains a constant temperature of roughly 50 degrees F, but way below the surface. There are laws and building codes for how deep posts and pilings need to be sunk, for that reason. Fence or sign posts that are set too shallow tend to get shoved up out of the soil by the action of freezing water expanding. In the sign industry around here, 4x4 posts are set 30" deep, minimum, deeper in colder parts of the state (higher altitude). The soil below what is called "frost line" never freezes (never? Well, hardly ever), so if the posts or pilings are standing on that they won't frost heave.

The soil above frontline will be cold, and variable depending on insolation and ambient temperatures. The soil 6" down below your snow cave might even be colder than ambient, if the temps have been down for a while.
 
Last edited:
Numberless anecdote rejected.

The soil maintains a constant temperature of roughly 50 degrees F, but way below the surface. There are laws and building codes for how deep posts and pilings need to be sunk, for that reason. Fence or sign posts that are set too shallow tend to get shoved up out of the soil by the action of freezing water expanding. In the sign industry around here, 4x4 posts are set 30" deep, minimum, deeper in colder parts of the state (higher altitude). The soil below what is called "frost line" never freezes (never? Well, hardly ever), so if the posts or pilings are standing on that they won't frost heave.

The soil above frontline will be cold, and variable depending on insolation and ambient temperatures. The soil 6" down below your snow cave might even be colder than ambient, if the temps have been down for a while.

Frost heaving and frost line are well known in areas above 49N
Yes, and the temp of the soil between that constant temp layer and the surface is a gradient, and between there and the top of the snow is also a gradient that reaches the ambient air temp at the transition between snow and air ( at night or in deep shade).

Around here that ambient air can easily reach -30 C and snow cover easily be 3 feet. Our posts, pilings, water lines, sewer lines all need to be 6 feet down and even then we get frozen municipal water supply lines freezing if snow cover is light and temps stay too low too long. Septic fields sport frost fences to keep animals and snowmachines from packing the snow down, destroying insulative properties and freezing the field.
Nowadays it would be fairly easy to get temps involved in a snow hut at it's completion and over an unoccupied time period. Can purchase a remote digital thermometer at Canadian Tire for under $30. Maybe my daughter will give me permission to put my grandkids to work making one in the back yard in February. Unfortunately my health issues would mean it would take me a few days to pile up the snow and hollow it out. (A sure path to possible tragic failure)
Interesting but I suspect OT.

Back in my teens we would see what it took to destroy them before we left. You could get up on top and jump, hard, on it and even then only a knockout the size of your feet would punch through, often leaving you hanging by the armpits.
 
Last edited:
All known. Frost heaving and frost line are well known in areas above 49N
Yes, and the temp of the soil between that constant temp layer and the surface is a gradient, and between there and the top of the snow is also a gradient that reaches the ambient air temp at the transition between snow and air ( at night or in deep shade).

Around here that ambient air can easily reach -30 C and snow cover easily be 3 feet. Our posts, pilings, water lines, sewer lines al need to be 6 feet down and even then we get frozen municipal water supply lines freezing if snow cover is light and temps stay too low too long.
Nowadays it would be fairly easy to get temps involved in a snow hut at it's completion and over an unoccupied time period. Can purchase a remote digital thermometer at Canadian Tire for under $30. Maybe my daughter will give me permission to put my grandkids to work making one in the back yard in February. Unfortunately my health issues would mean it would take me a few days to pile up the snow and hollow it out. (A sure path to possible tragic failure)

Your window of opportunity for this experiment will precede mine. ;) But I'm willing to try it here when we finally get snow. Actually, this year I expect massive snowfall, as I think that's where we are in the cycle-ish weather pattern of dry and wet winters here.

I'm in the market for a new remote thermometer gizmo anyway, I guess I'll lurk Home Depot for the multi-sensor package to go on sale. One for ambient, one for the chicken coop and another dedicated to mad science would be ideal.
 
Last edited:
Your window of opportunity for this experiment will precede mine. ;) But I'm willing to try it here when we finally get snow. Actually, this year I expect massive snowfall, as I think that's where we are in the cycle-ish weather pattern of dry and wet winters here.

I'm in the market for a new remote thermometer gizmo anyway, I guess I'll lurk Home Depot for the multi-sensor package to go on sale. One for ambient, one for the chicken coop and another dedicated to mad science would be ideal.

Great.
I also contacted a professor at the University of Manitoba, who does a lot of work on cold weather survival.
I kept the email to the point not giving hint to which take on this point I fall on. I'll pm you a copy.
 
Awesome, I look forward to it.

See, despite the efforts of woo merchants, we can find ways to discuss actual science around here. This is much more interesting discussion and useful to the OP topic than wogoga's number system. Because it's about heat flow, heat retention and heat rejection.
 
Awesome, I look forward to it.

See, despite the efforts of woo merchants, we can find ways to discuss actual science around here. This is much more interesting discussion and useful to the OP topic than wogoga's number system. Because it's about heat flow, heat retention and heat rejection.

I look forward to the responses...and will (if the snow allows) build one of my own for a third data point.
 
As you know, Bob, heat is transferred by convection, conduction, and radiation. Our sensory apparatus for measuring temperature is flawed in that it measures subjectively the skin surface temperature compared to the internal body temperature and how much heat we are dumping. When we have a fever our skin surface is hot, and we feel hot, but we also feel cold because our body is dumping heat. Most of that is convective heat flow but radiative heat flow is very important to our sense of temperature.

You are a Snickers powered meat candle illuminating the universe in the 30THz region. Have you ever been in an old house with heavy plaster walls? In cold weather the walls will never come up to room temperature, so your body heat radiates out and is absorbed by the walls. Even though the air temp will be at the comfort zone, you will always feel chilly. When the walls are warmer, they are radiating heat nearer your radiated temperature, with the net result that your body heat "reflects back" to you and you don't feel chilly. This is why radiant subfloor heating is so effective - the air temperature can be in the lower end of normal house comfort zone or below and still not feel chilly. Sorta.

So stepping into an igloo, quinzee or snow cave from outdoors, you are no longer illuminating sky, frozen trees and cold ground with your body heat, and even small air flow (convective, anyone) from wind or walking will continuously strip the thin layer of body-warmed air from your skin surface, so sitting down in still air will allow the air nearest your body to warm and stay close.
 
Last edited:
The professor got back to me saying that with no other heat source, interior and exterior temps will be the same after sitting empty.

Though it seems no one has tried it.

Is a foot of snow enough insulation to create a gradient between interior and exterior? When heat is lost from the earth as frost goes further down, is there enough flow to cause a noticeable gradient?

I did find this:
http://www.fsavalanche.org/temperature-gradient/
although in avalanche prone areas the snow pack would be very deep.
 
Last edited:
My apologies, I appear to have got it wrong. Your system is less simple and more confusing than I thought, and is clearly a lot harder to master than scientific notation despite giving no advantages over it.


The Hindu-Arabic numeral system is apriori simpler and more effective than the Roman numerals. Nevertheless, to the persons having grown up with Roman numerals, the new decimal system seemed more confusing than the accustomed one.

Thus, as long as you have to translate e.g. 8p2998 m/s into 299,800 km/s, or 0n25 meter into 2.5 Angstrom = 2.5 x 10^-10 meter, the new systems only represents an additional complication. Yet if you have assimilated the concept eight.po as "hundred mega" (2p1 ∙ 6p1), or as "zero point one billion" (…999n1 ∙ …009p1), or as "ten raised to the power of eight", then 8p2998 is easily recognizable as around "eight.po three = 8p3". And in a mental calculation it is easier to use the concept "eight.po two nine nine eight meter" than "two hundred ninety nine thousand eight hundred kilo-meter".


Moving the order of magnitude in front of the significant digits is odd and counter intuitive.


From a logical point of view, it seems more reasonable to move from the general to the specific, e.g. starting with country, continuing with town, street, apartment, and ending with name of addressee. (It is true that postal address is written the other way round, but it is normally read from bottom to top by the postal service.) Thus in principle, we should even start with the unit. Order of magnitude is meaningless without unit. And significant digits are meaningless without order of magnitude and unit. (One must not confuse the absence of a unit with the default unit piece.)

From the psychological point of view, it is less demanding to understand "meter eight.po three eight four" than "three-point-eight-four times ten-raised-to-the-power-of-eight meter". After "meter" we know that we deal with distance in space, after "meter eight.po three" we may recognize a distance close to a light-second. The rest simply adds less and less important accuracy.


No, I think I see how it works, and why it doesn't. He notates negative exponents from 1 to 9 by subtracting the exponent from 10, from 10 to 99 by subtracting it from 100, from 100 to 990 by subtracting it from 1000, ...


The principle is more straightforward: In order to get a negative exponent, we simply apply the standard subtraction rule, i.e. we regularly subtract from zero:

…01000 minus …00001 equals …00999
…00100 minus …00001 equals …00099
…00010 minus …00001 equals …00009
…00001 minus …00001 equals …00000
…00000 minus …00001 equals …99999

pi = …000p314159… ≈ 0p31416 = p31416 ≈ p314
1/pi = …999n318309… ≈ 9n31831 = n31831 ≈ n318​

Let us also reexamine "83n375 ∙ 90n2 = 73n75" (3.75 x 10^-17 ∙ 2 x 10^-10 = 7.5 x 10^-27) of my previous post. 83n means an exponent of …99983 (i.e. 17 below zero). 90n means an exponent of …99990 (i.e. 10 below …00000). In this system multiplication of numbers always results in direct addition of exponents. So we get "…99983 + …99990 = …99973" resp. "83n ∙ 90n = 73n".

I always get confused when I have to multiply or divide numbers in scientific notation with negative exponents. In the system proposed here, multiplication always results in addition, and division in subtraction of an exponent. And computer science demonstrates every day that implementing negative numbers by regular subtraction from zero works fine.

If you have learned the elementary charge as 1.602 x 10^-19 Coulomb, then creating the exponent by regular subtraction from zero as in 81n1602 Coulomb obviously seems more complicated. Yet after having grasped the principle of regular subtraction from zero, you can logically derive the meaning of 81n16 C. In case of 160 Zepto-Coulomb or 0.16 Atto-Coulomb however, the meaning is much less straightforward.

What is the electric charge of the electrons of one mole of hydrogen (with total weight of 1 gram = 7n1 kg). One mole of hydrogen contains 23p6022 ≈ twenty.three.po six electrons with each an elementary charge of 81n1602 C ≈ eighty.one.ne one six Coulomb. As 23p6 = 23p1 ∙ 0p6 and 81n16 = 81n1 ∙ 0p16 we get 23p1 ∙ 81n1 ∙ 0p6 ∙ 0p16 = 4p1 ∙ 0p96 = 4p96 ≈ 5p1 Coulomb = 100 kiloC.

How much energy corresponds to 1 kg according to E = mc2? E ≈ 1 kg ∙ 8p3 m/s ∙ 8p3 m/s = 16p9 kg m2/s2 = sixteen.po nine Joule.

When you do similar calculations with Apollo units such as slugs for mass (see #196) and miles for distance, then such simple mathematical relations become quite opaque.


3p126 I read as 126x103=126000 [slip corrected]


Such reading would destroy the main advantage of the number system, which is easy recognizability of orders of magnitude. The most important information is next to the po-ne-indicator: 3p126. In case of 23p6022.1408, the last digit "8" is the least important part. For comparison: 6.022,140,8 x 10^23.


So, for example, 6.626e-34 is not significantly harder to type than 66n6626 - two extra characters not requiring shift or control keys - and its actual magnitude is much clearer.


The decisive point: 66n = six.six.ne or sixty.six.ne is a schematically created concept in the same way as 'ten' = one.po, 'hundred' = two.po, and 'nano' = one.ne. And "six.six.ne six six two six" is also shorter and simpler than "six point six two six exponent minus thirty four".

All my examples and calculations of this thread are correct; at least nobody has brought forward evidence that they are wrong. The only relevant error I am aware of is post #1, corrected already in my next post. The most important post is probably #196, after which the thread degenerated more and more.

Cheers, Wolfgang
 
Last edited:
The Hindu-Arabic numeral system is apriori simpler and more effective than the Roman numerals. Nevertheless, to the persons having grown up with Roman numerals, the new decimal system seemed more confusing than the accustomed one.

Except nobody has grown up with them because they are more complex than Arabic numerals, which is why no-one uses them.

[...snip...]

All my examples and calculations of this thread are correct; at least nobody has brought forward evidence that they are wrong.

No they aren't, and yes they have.
 
All my examples and calculations of this thread are correct...

No they aren't. But your problem doesn't lie so much in arithmetical error as it does in conceptual incompetence. How you think heat shields work is not how they actually work. You can express your wrong model as arithmetically as you want, but it doesn't make it any more correct.

...at least nobody has brought forward evidence that they are wrong.

Wow. Just, wow.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom