Kinetic energy at atmospheric reentry from lunar mission

No, I think I see how it works, and why it doesn't.

So because he wants to avoid subtracting when he wants to work with numbers less than one, he subtracts on all numbers less than one?

That's unnecessary, unworkable, and probably insane. I think you're right.
 
I
Thus, 3n126 = 0.00126, (126 x 10^-3) and 3p251 is 10^3 x 2.51 =2510.

.

.000126 is not 126 X 10-3It is 1.26X10-4 or 126 X10-6
I read 3n251 as indeed 251X10-3 = 0.251

3p126 I read as 126X103=251000

But if I am simply reading it wrong , I believe I am still correct in it's not being "less complicated", and that introducing letters into numbers will just make algebra even more flummoxing to high school students.
 
No, I think I see how it works, and why it doesn't. He notates negative exponents from 1 to 9 by subtracting the exponent from 10, from 10 to 99 by subtracting it from 100, from 100 to 990 by subtracting it from 1000, ... The result is that you can multiply by simply adding exponents and then dropping a leading 1; except that sometimes you have to multiply by adding exponents and not dropping the leading 1. There will be a rule determining which you have to do, but that adds an operation that isn't necessary with traditional scientific notation, so at best his notation adds one extra step. This is a result of his idea that, for a negative exponent, any number of leading 9s may be discarded; unfortunately, that idea simply doesn't work infallibly.

Dave

What?
Thats lunacy, even more unecessarily complicated than I thought it was supposed to work.
 
The issue reminds me of a problem in survival training here in the north.
Specifically on the matter of building s snow hut shelter.
I have heard it said that these are warmer than the ambient air temps because snow is frozen water which solidifies at zero C. So the interior can't be colder than that.

No, its warmer because snow is a good insulator and the ground below the hut is warmer than the air above the snow. Heat comes from the earth.

When I hear this I marvel that we can build steel buildings that don't heat people to death. After all steel solidifies at a bit above 1300C and cannot be colder than that.
The problem is, that's not why snow shelters are warmer than ambient, and your explanation differs from all other versions I've ever heard, because it's wrong. Ground temp won't contribute anything, because the frost line is 30 inches below the surface, minimum.

The correct explanation is that the interior of the snow cave can be warmed all the way up to the freezing point of water, which can be very much warmer than ambient.

Thus, steel buildings cannot be warmed to greater than the melting point of steel.
 
I'll give him this: it avoids the use of superscripts and the repetitive "x 10^" that we're presently struck with. You can type it out in Notepad.

Also not a real advantage. These days, using the letter e to replace "x 10^" is pretty much universal, courtesy of Excel. So, for example, 6.626e-34 is not significantly harder to type than 66n6626 - two extra characters not requiring shift or control keys - and its actual magnitude is much clearer.

Dave
 
Jrrarglblarg said:
Thus, steel buildings cannot be warmed to greater than the melting point of steel.

Well, they can, but they're not very buildingy by then.
 
The problem is, that's not why snow shelters are warmer than ambient, and your explanation differs from all other versions I've ever heard, because it's wrong. Ground temp won't contribute anything, because the frost line is 30 inches below the surface, minimum.

The correct explanation is that the interior of the snow cave can be warmed all the way up to the freezing point of water, which can be very much warmer than ambient.

Thus, steel buildings cannot be warmed to greater than the melting point of steel.

Snow shelter construction.
-pick an area at least twice the diameter of the finished shelter
-use shovel or snowshoe to mix up the snow on the ground and pile it up in the area where you want the finished shelter to be.
-Make coffee, sing take pictures,,, whatever, for at least an hour
-dig an entrance and hollow out the pile. The turning and piling will have mixed up different temp layers of snow, the outer foot solidifies.
- the interior will always be warmer than the exterior(once you have put a snow block door in place) even if there are no people in it or candles burning.

Heat has to come from somewhere and it isn't the ambient air.

Yes, the addition of people and/or candles(making sure there are air holes in the sides and top of the shelter) will warm it up to the point of the melting of water.
Slept in a few myself when I was young and invincible.
 
Last edited:
.000126 is not 126 X 10-3It is 1.26X10-4 or 126 X10-6
I read 3n251 as indeed 251X10-3 = 0.251

3p126 I read as 126X103=251000
But if I am simply reading it wrong , I believe I am still correct in it's not being "less complicated", and that introducing letters into numbers will just make algebra even more flummoxing to high school students.

tee hee:(
 
Also not a real advantage. These days, using the letter e to replace "x 10^" is pretty much universal, courtesy of Excel. So, for example, 6.626e-34 is not significantly harder to type than 66n6626 - two extra characters not requiring shift or control keys - and its actual magnitude is much clearer.

Dave

I'm in full agreement.
 
I believe his mantissa is always a number less than 10; there's an implied decimal after the 1. Thus, 1.26 x 10-3.

Like I said "less" confusing????
Now we just imply where the decimal point is supposed to be, and that whole hot mess that deals with numbers smaller than zero, and have a good percentage more high school students run away from science and engineering because we not only use letters for variables but also introduce a couple into numbers themselves.


Hell, compared to this idiotic number notation, understanding the dissipation of heat in re-entry vehicles is easy-peasy.
 
So veering into the actual physics/engineering, how much of the heat is taken up by the surrounding air and how much goes into the ablative material's phase transition from solid to plasma?

The document I thought had the actual numbers in it, didn't. Let me pick through my library.

Let me guess though that it's a damn sight less than goes into raising the temperature of the spacecraft?

To this non-engineer one thing is quite obvious, the air below the capsule is not static, it heats up and flows away to be replaced by cooler air. A torch would be the opposite, it heats up gases that are then directed to an object, those gases may flow away but are being replaced by more, previously heated gases
 
..the air below the capsule is not static, it heats up and flows away to be replaced by cooler air.

Yes, there is a convective component to the model. There is also a radiant component whereby the heated atmospheric gas applies heat to the heat shield via infrared. That's part of the brilliance of the design: the gases produced in the ablation process are substantially opaque to infrared. This principle is also applied in ablative linings for rocket nozzles.
 
Yes, there is a convective component to the model. There is also a radiant component whereby the heated atmospheric gas applies heat to the heat shield via infrared. That's part of the brilliance of the design: the gases produced in the ablation process are substantially opaque to infrared. This principle is also applied in ablative linings for rocket nozzles.

I did not mean to imply that convection was the only or even primary form of heat transfer.
However, to any layman it is the most obvious.
Have a too hot cup of coffee, blow on it. Blow more air on it faster and see the temp lower faster.

The ablative process should be fairly obvious to any science minded lay person as well. It takes heat to cause something to change phase. When we boil water the temp of the water does not go up beyond that of its boiling point which is why boiling is called a low temperature cooking process. It is also why altitude affects cooking time when boiling (a matter fully understood and taught in Home Economics classes when I was a kid)
The steam produced can otoh be raised well above the temp of boiling water.

So yeah, I also see that heating a heat shield to the point that causes it to become a gas will mean that the still solid part of that shield cannot yet be above its phase change temp.
 
True enough. Look how hard it was to figure it out.

I still don't get it,,, thought I did,,, nope apparently I don't.
otoh I recall having absolutely no trouble at all when I was 12-13 years old and being taught scientific notation.
It
Made
Sense


Hell, significant digits was harder. Maybe it's just because I am a Canuck, you know, American Light.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom