Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

:eek: I am starting to understand that the rule of so is far too complex for some people.

As for the lil inventor, I'm sure he will do fine, lots of slaves.... Errrr immigrant workers to help out with the inventing.

No sir, not making up your own reality and using it as a premise for further conjecture. Nope.
 
Using 16.5's quote to enlighten me as to the Rule of So:

"The rule of "so": this dictates that where a sentence or clause starts with the word "so" and purports to characterize another's argument, the likelihood that the response contains a strawman approaches 100 percent."
OK, just to test my new knowledge: by this rule if I post that "Giordano argues that the Sun is powered by coal. But we know that the Sun is powered by nuclear fusion, so Giordano is wrong on this topic" have I now properly invoked the Rule of So?
No... I don't think that's quite right. At least as I've seen it in use. The sentence must first start with the word 'so' and not just contain it.

"So Giordano argues that the Sun is powered by coal?" I think would be a more accurate representation.




But... the more I think of the provided definition... the more it looks just like a perfectly functional informal fallacy (a strawman fallacy) that's been clumsily repackaged, as a young child might, and presented as if it's some new, insightful fallacy that proves devastating to any other argument that has been confronted by it.
 
you know that the Lil' Inventor and his family demanded $15 million, right?

for "inventing" a way to make a perfectly useful clock significantly less useful

People arrested without reason tend to demand money. My little brother demanded money after he was arrested without good reason and got it.
 
So you want to introduce facts to support your argument, Travis?
 
No... I don't think that's quite right. At least as I've seen it in use. The sentence must first start with the word 'so' and not just contain it.

"So Giordano argues that the Sun is powered by coal?" I think would be a more accurate representation.

But... the more I think of the provided definition... the more it looks just like a perfectly functional informal fallacy (a strawman fallacy) that's been clumsily repackaged, as a young child might, and presented as if it's some new, insightful fallacy that proves devastating to any other argument that has been confronted by it.

That is why I said a clause... It has not been repackaged it has been entirely redesigned streamlined and set to eleven. I will admit that it is not a clock that you can't see, tho, which is actually less useful than the watch that Bruce Willis' dad keistered in pulp fiction.
 
No... I don't think that's quite right. At least as I've seen it in use. The sentence must first start with the word 'so' and not just contain it.

"So Giordano argues that the Sun is powered by coal?" I think would be a more accurate representation.




But... the more I think of the provided definition... the more it looks just like a perfectly functional informal fallacy (a strawman fallacy) that's been clumsily repackaged, as a young child might, and presented as if it's some new, insightful fallacy that proves devastating to any other argument that has been confronted by it.
So you think! I do think I understand it now. Thanks. I may have been confused because my post that 16.5 first cited as indicative of the Rule didn't use that form of construction. You definition fits more with my older understanding: using "so" sort of as a clearing of the throat before presenting an exaggerated form of the original argument. Not "so" as an if...then form of argument. But presenting the counter argument stills seems necessary to distinguish the two.
 
... activist angry sister, obviously staged photographs, ...

That seems to me to just be opportunistically taking advantage of the kid's arrest after it happened. I can't see how it can be interpreted as evidence that they had been intending for the arrest to happen beforehand.
 
That seems to me to just be opportunistically taking advantage of the kid's arrest after it happened. I can't see how it can be interpreted as evidence that they had been intending for the arrest to happen beforehand.

And, yet again, there's still the problem of why, if they knew that the police would show up and handcuff the kid for having a clock, that the kid is the problem rather than the police's response.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom