Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

You deleted the next sentence, Belz? Did you think that people were just going to think, huh, where did that sentence go?

I never understand some posters' need for their posts to be quoted in their entirety even if one is responding to a particular point or claim, or even if the cut stuff is irrelevant to the response.

Richard Dawkins. You have not heard of him? Cool.

Ok, so you pulled it out of Dawkins' ass.
 
Let's not. The argument has not been convincingly made that they thought it was, nor has it been made that it could be reasonably believed to be.

I am certainly willing to be convinced that they thought it was real, make your best argument.
 
Now, now! He has Richard Dawkins.

RICHARD. FREAKING. DAWKINS! He didn't just make it up, I tell you!

Oh, and lest you think I cut the rest of your post for some nefarious reason, here it is:

well the various reasons have been expertly covered ad naseum (activist father, activist angry sister, obviously staged photographs, the fact that the "invention" was nothing of the sort, but rather a grossly incompetently constructed suit case bomb clock :rolleyes:. Read the thread....)

Now we are discussing motive, which is of course long green. SHOW ME THE MONEY! Ca-ching!
 
Last edited:
I am feeling evil tonight: the Sun converts 4 million tons of matter to energy, so it gets very hot.

By the Rule of So this statement must be wrong. Does this mean the Sun is cold or that it is powered in some other way?

Your understanding of Rule Of So is incomplete and unusable in current form.
 
I'm sure you'll be posting the evidence for this anytime, now.


Yep, any time.

you know that the Lil' Inventor and his family demanded $15 million, right?

for "inventing" a way to make a perfectly useful clock significantly less useful
 
I get that you do not understand what the rule of so means, and you are angrily lashing out at me in frustration. It is a shorthand that skeptics use, don't let it bother you.

Sorry to hurt your feelings. No need to respond, I will assume that you consider this post chicken ****. Good luck with all that.

So all skeptics use the rule of so?
 
I may need to reconsider my entire suspicion of racism playing a role in Ahmed's detention, questioning, and arrest, or that this was unusual in any way. I just read this on the web:

"15-year old girl white Catholic arrested at school for fake bomb threat! Melissa Briggs was detained, questioned by 7 adults at the principal's office, and carried off to the local police station in handcuffs for bringing a hoax bomb into school. Her English teacher states: 'There is was- a fake bomb clearly designed to look like a 12 oz Schweppes Ginger Ale can sitting right next to a detonator-like object in her purse! I found them when I went over to Ms. Briggs when she opened her purse for a tissue and the can fell out, making a big clunk noise. Luckily I had seen the ISIS photo on the web and I knew instantly what it was, or at least what it was supposed to be!' On closer inspection it turned out to be a can with soda in it rather than explosive, and a tampon; school authorities and police then realized that Ms. Briggs clearly intended to bring to school a hoax bomb that looked exactly like not a bomb, probably as a threat. One authority noted, 'I must thank some of the posters on ISF for cluing me in on the hoax bomb connection. Otherwise I probably would have thought that it was only a can of soda and a tampon.'

Ms. Briggs repeatedly refused to cooperate and sign a confession, instead feebly insisting that these objects were soda for her school lunch and a tampon in case she had a period. She pointed out that she had in fact indicated as much to her home room teacher, who advised her to not drink so many sweet beverages.

But in consulting the web and using his imagination, this reporter understands that Ms. Briggs's 96 year old uncle has admitted to being in the Communist Party in 1957 (well, he stated that the FBI accused him of this) and he and Ms. Briggs had been at a wedding together last weekend when they certainly could have hatched this plot. Notably this reporter has also learned that Ms. Briggs brought in some chocolate chip cookies into school the same day and had been disrupting her home room class by showing them to her schoolmates. She also claimed that she made them herself, although later investigation indicated that they were from a commercially available mix. Catholics are known to eat flesh and drink blood in their rituals, elevating the concerns. And Catholics were known to previously burn non-believers to death, as well as forming the majority religion in the IRA. 'We knew about her already,' said school authorities darkly, but they were not permitted to provide any details'

The police ultimately declined to charge her, although the school has slapped her with a 3 day suspension for bringing in an object that some stupid person might consider threatening (she should have known better given this was against the rules). Notably her father, when notified hours later, showed up at the police station but requested to not have the handcuffs removed until after he could take a quick photo of them on his daughter, which he then used as part of a fake-outrage publicity stunt. The family has threatened to file a legal suit; impartial observers are undecided if this was simply a hoax to generate bleeding heart sympathy for Catholics or a money grubbing attempt. A few liberals have suggested that perhaps the homeroom teacher should have just told her "Hush!" but this reporter feels that the girl had it coming and had plotted the entire bomb hoax knowing how the school authorities would react.

A search on the web reveals that hundreds of patriotic Americans have already seen through this transparent farce and have realized the truth about this Catholic Communist Terrorist, urging her and her family to go "home" to Ireland. When the father said, 'Well, maybe we should,although we came to the USA from Paris' the web erupted with bloggers indicating that this was only confirmation that the family were indeed Papist terrorists."
 
No, you are quite wrong. In what way were you trying to characterize another poster's argument or position. Thought exercise, how was what you a strawman? Answer it wasn't.

Thus endeth the lesson in logic 101.

Back to the lil inventor, someone said he ended up "on top." He ended up in Qatar, which is about as far from on top as you can get!:D

Oh, I mis-understood your own posts. Sorry. So the Rule of So only applies to characterizing another poster's argument as a strawman. In which case I should expect that the person invoking the rule would at the same time explain exactly why the offending post was a strawman, right? Because simply using the term "so" doesn't invalidate the argument, but a set of facts or counter-argument does. In fact, this sort of makes the Rule of So, when used as a counter-response, kind of useless unless accompanied by and authentic counter-response. If fact, why use it at all?

Well, thanks for the enlightenment.

By the way- Qater is one of the most wealthy nations in the world, I believe the wealthiest in per capita income with over $88,000 per person in 2010, although the wealth distribution is more bimodal than even in the USA. I suspect that Ahmed's family will end up in the better portion of that curve or they wouldn't be so willing to emigrate. And oil prices have dropped. But in any case I would not worry too much about them in their new home, and certainly don't think about them living in a sandy hut in the middle of an empty desert.
 
I may need to reconsider my entire suspicion of racism playing a role in Ahmed's detention, questioning, and arrest, or that this was unusual in any way. I just read this on the web:

"15-year old girl white Catholic arrested at school for fake bomb threat! Melissa Briggs was detained, questioned by 7 adults at the principal's office, and carried off to the local police station in handcuffs for bringing a hoax bomb into school. Her English teacher states: 'There is was- a fake bomb clearly designed to look like a 12 oz Schweppes Ginger Ale can sitting right next to a detonator-like object in her purse! I found them when I went over to Ms. Briggs when she opened her purse for a tissue and the can fell out, making a big clunk noise. Luckily I had seen the ISIS photo on the web and I knew instantly what it was, or at least what it was supposed to be!' On closer inspection it turned out to be a can with soda in it rather than explosive, and a tampon; school authorities and police then realized that Ms. Briggs clearly intended to bring to school a hoax bomb that looked exactly like not a bomb, probably as a threat. One authority noted, 'I must thank some of the posters on ISF for cluing me in on the hoax bomb connection. Otherwise I probably would have thought that it was only a can of soda and a tampon.'

Ms. Briggs repeatedly refused to cooperate and sign a confession, instead feebly insisting that these objects were soda for her school lunch and a tampon in case she had a period. She pointed out that she had in fact indicated as much to her home room teacher, who advised her to not drink so many sweet beverages.

But in consulting the web and using his imagination, this reporter understands that Ms. Briggs's 96 year old uncle has admitted to being in the Communist Party in 1957 (well, he stated that the FBI accused him of this) and he and Ms. Briggs had been at a wedding together last weekend when they certainly could have hatched this plot. Notably this reporter has also learned that Ms. Briggs brought in some chocolate chip cookies into school the same day and had been disrupting her home room class by showing them to her schoolmates. She also claimed that she made them herself, although later investigation indicated that they were from a commercially available mix. Catholics are known to eat flesh and drink blood in their rituals, elevating the concerns. And Catholics were known to previously burn non-believers to death, as well as forming the majority religion in the IRA. 'We knew about her already,' said school authorities darkly, but they were not permitted to provide any details'

The police ultimately declined to charge her, although the school has slapped her with a 3 day suspension for bringing in an object that some stupid person might consider threatening (she should have known better given this was against the rules). Notably her father, when notified hours later, showed up at the police station but requested to not have the handcuffs removed until after he could take a quick photo of them on his daughter, which he then used as part of a fake-outrage publicity stunt. The family has threatened to file a legal suit; impartial observers are undecided if this was simply a hoax to generate bleeding heart sympathy for Catholics or a money grubbing attempt. A few liberals have suggested that perhaps the homeroom teacher should have just told her "Hush!" but this reporter feels that the girl had it coming and had plotted the entire bomb hoax knowing how the school authorities would react.

A search on the web reveals that hundreds of patriotic Americans have already seen through this transparent farce and have realized the truth about this Catholic Communist Terrorist, urging her and her family to go "home" to Ireland. When the father said, 'Well, maybe we should,although we came to the USA from Paris' the web erupted with bloggers indicating that this was only confirmation that the family were indeed Papist terrorists."

Did you type that out yourself?

If so..... Why????
 
Oh, I mis-understood your own posts. Sorry. So the Rule of So only applies to characterizing another poster's argument as a strawman. In which case I should expect that the person invoking the rule would at the same time explain exactly why the offending post was a strawman, right? Because simply using the term "so" doesn't invalidate the argument, but a set of facts or counter-argument does. In fact, this sort of makes the Rule of So, when used as a counter-response, kind of useless unless accompanied by and authentic counter-response. If fact, why use it at all?

Well, thanks for the enlightenment.

By the way- Qater is one of the most wealthy nations in the world, I believe the wealthiest in per capita income with over $88,000 per person in 2010, although the wealth distribution is more bimodal than even in the USA. I suspect that Ahmed's family will end up in the better portion of that curve or they wouldn't be so willing to emigrate. And oil prices have dropped. But in any case I would not worry too much about them in their new home, and certainly don't think about them living in a sandy hut in the middle of an empty desert.

:eek: I am starting to understand that the rule of so is far too complex for some people.

As for the lil inventor, I'm sure he will do fine, lots of slaves.... Errrr immigrant workers to help out with the inventing.
 
Using 16.5's quote to enlighten me as to the Rule of So:

"The rule of "so": this dictates that where a sentence or clause starts with the word "so" and purports to characterize another's argument, the likelihood that the response contains a strawman approaches 100 percent."
OK, just to test my new knowledge: by this rule if I post that "Giordano argues that the Sun is powered by coal. But we know that the Sun is powered by nuclear fusion, so Giordano is wrong on this topic" have I now properly invoked the Rule of So?
 
Did you type that out yourself?

If so..... Why????

Well I did read it on the web, but only after typing and posting it myself.

Why? For some posters to compare in their own brains my own absurd tale of Ms. Briggs to the Ahmed case. But I have given up changing anyone's minds here on the forum. Perhaps I view it as a mind worm that might (just might) slowly eat through the solidified views of some posters and eventually get them to reconsider their positions. When no one else is looking and they are alone with their logic and sense of fairness.
 
Last edited:
:eek: I am starting to understand that the rule of so is far too complex for some people. As for the lil inventor, I'm sure he will do fine, lots of slaves.... Errrr immigrant workers to help out with the inventing.

I must still have failed to understand it. Darn! I think that I have noted in other threads that many of the right-wing ideas go completely over my head. I guess that I am just stupid in that way- I can't seem to really understand the logic. But often it must seem so obvious to the original poster that they don't wish to bother to explain it to me. And here all I wanted to know was why the use of the word "so" in responding to another post by itself invalidated the response virtually 100% of the time.

I am glad that I could relieve you of your concern about Ahmed's family.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom