Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

You have made repeated references that things look like bombs that don't look like bombs. Tampons being the lamest one.

The kids clock only looks like a bomb if your only reference point is action movies. Any adult that looks a a clock circuit and concludes "bomb" is not really trying. And we already know they did not think it was a bomb. And the whole assembly is visible.

So you have no point. They did not think it was a bomb. The kid never claimed it was a bomb. And the real bomb does look suspicious even though it was not assembled in the photo. Had it been assembled it would have looked even more like a bomb since the inside of the can is concealed and the outside was modified.

I enjoy how people dictate what high school teachers should know about what a *********** bomb should look like. The scam artists were counting on that.

Off to slavers bay in *********** Qatar.
 
I get that you do not understand what the rule of so means, and you are angrily lashing out at me in frustration. It is a shorthand that skeptics use, don't let it bother you.


Awww. Isn't that cute. Pretending to be superior while merely being supercilious.

Keep going like that and you'll work your way all the way up to being sophomoric.

Think of it as a goal you can set yourself. Self-improvement.

Of a sort.

Sorry to hurt your feelings. No need to respond, I will assume that you consider this post chicken ****. Good luck with all that.


You haven't got the leverage to hurt my feelings. I'm not invested at all in anything you have to say.

Sorry.

Pointing out the inanity of your pretenses is just an amusement to pass the time.
 
Awww. Isn't that cute. Pretending to be superior while merely being supercilious.

Get going like that and you'll work your way all the way up to being sophomoric.

Think of it as a goal you can set yourself. Self-improvement.

Of a sort.

You haven't got the leverage to hurt my feelings. I'm not invested at all in anything you have to say.

Sorry.

Pointing out the inanity of your pretenses is just an amusement to pass the time.

Say, you managed to get through that post without resorting to calling me chicken ****, while complaining about how things you don't understand are taunts. But you are just here, passing the time.

Hey that mean guy is saying things you don't understand, that chicken **** is taunting us.
 
I enjoy how people dictate what high school teachers should know about what a *********** bomb should look like.

<snip>


What they "should" know is irrelevant in this case because their behavior and actions made it crystal clear what they did know.

Hypotheticals are pointless. Nothing but a red herring.

Try and discuss what actually happened, not what could have happened if the teachers were even less competent than they managed to be this time.
 
I enjoy how people dictate what high school teachers should know about what a *********** bomb should look like. The scam artists were counting on that.

Off to slavers bay in *********** Qatar.

You keep ignoring that they knew it was not a bomb. Your post and point is irrelevant because of that.
 
You have made repeated references that things look like bombs that don't look like bombs. Tampons being the lamest one.

The kids clock only looks like a bomb if your only reference point is action movies. Any adult that looks a a clock circuit and concludes "bomb" is not really trying. And we already know they did not think it was a bomb. And the whole assembly is visible.

So you have no point. They did not think it was a bomb. The kid never claimed it was a bomb. And the real bomb does look suspicious even though it was not assembled in the photo. Had it been assembled it would have looked even more like a bomb since the inside of the can is concealed and the outside was modified.

It's a little tedious to have to rebut stuff that has been rebutted several times in the thread already. Clearly you have not read a very large portion of the thread, or at least you've forgotten what you have read. The point about the ISIS bomb is that bombs can be made to look pretty much like anything. You can always insert functional parts of a bomb into innocuous looking items, and you can dress up the whole thing to look like something else (e.g. an alarm clock, or a radio, or a pencil box). Anyway, I'll give you a short overview of the thread since you seem to have arrived late and have already stated some things which are false:

(1) Ahmed kept the pencil case closed with a twisted piece of wire (evidently because he couldn't close the clasp with the A/C power cord sticking out of the box); (2) the clock display was mounted inside the box, so it was not visible outside the box; (3) while it was possible, upon careful examination, to see that the display and buttons performed many of the same functions of an alarm clock, there was no way for a layman to determine that it was not capable of doing something more nefarious in addition; (4) the mains transformer was not secured, and hot wires or terminals were probably exposed, so the device actually was an electrical hazard; (5) the material from which either the white silica packet under the netting or the black box lining was composed is not at all obvious to a layman; (6) treating the device as a serious bomb threat has an exorbitantly high cost to the school, so it would probably require a probability level of 1% or higher, which is unlikely to be reached given that school officials had some familiarity with Ahmed, and there was nothing smoking or on fire; (7) even though school officials didn't worry that the "invention" was a bomb, they probably did worry that its purpose was to disrupt the school in some way (which Ahmed actually went out of his way to do in English class, despite having been warned by his engineering teacher to not show the device to anybody else); (8) in school officials' opinions, Ahmed was not forthcoming about the purpose of the device and the reason for bringing it to school; (9) repeating "it's a clock" is not sufficient, since not only is the device a rather pointless clock, it still leaves unanswered the question of motive; (10) anybody who claims that it was obviously a clock is suffering from serious hindsight bias; (11) anybody who claims that there was obviously anti-Muslim bias in the actions of the school officials is suffering from availability bias; if something similar had happened to a white, Christian kid, and it almost certainly has, you don't hear about it; it is only when somebody gets to scream that he was targeted because of his underprivileged ethnicity that the news media picks up the story.
 
"Know" is pretty strong... Let's agree that they knew it was a hoax bomb.

If they knew it was a hoax bomb then they knew it was not a bomb. But they did not know it was a hoax bomb since the kid said it was a clock and that was all he ever called it.

Was the kid playing them for fools? It does look that way. But the people at the school did the work of creating a mountain out of a molehill.
 
It's a little tedious to have to rebut stuff that has been rebutted several times in the thread already. Clearly you have not read a very large portion of the thread, or at least you've forgotten what you have read. The point about the ISIS bomb is that bombs can be made to look pretty much like anything. You can always insert functional parts of a bomb into innocuous looking items, and you can dress up the whole thing to look like something else (e.g. an alarm clock, or a radio, or a pencil box). Anyway, I'll give you a short overview of the thread since you seem to have arrived late and have already stated some things which are false:

(1) Ahmed kept the pencil case closed with a twisted piece of wire (evidently because he couldn't close the clasp with the A/C power cord sticking out of the box); (2) the clock display was mounted inside the box, so it was not visible outside the box; (3) while it was possible, upon careful examination, to see that the display and buttons performed many of the same functions of an alarm clock, there was no way for a layman to determine that it was not capable of doing something more nefarious in addition; (4) the mains transformer was not secured, and hot wires or terminals were probably exposed, so the device actually was an electrical hazard; (5) the material from which either the white silica packet under the netting or the black box lining was composed is not at all obvious to a layman; (6) treating the device as a serious bomb threat has an exorbitantly high cost to the school, so it would probably require a probability level of 1% or higher, which is unlikely to be reached given that school officials had some familiarity with Ahmed, and there was nothing smoking or on fire; (7) even though school officials didn't worry that the "invention" was a bomb, they probably did worry that its purpose was to disrupt the school in some way (which Ahmed actually went out of his way to do in English class, despite having been warned by his engineering teacher to not show the device to anybody else); (8) in school officials' opinions, Ahmed was not forthcoming about the purpose of the device and the reason for bringing it to school; (9) repeating "it's a clock" is not sufficient, since not only is the device a rather pointless clock, it still leaves unanswered the question of motive; (10) anybody who claims that it was obviously a clock is suffering from serious hindsight bias; (11) anybody who claims that there was obviously anti-Muslim bias in the actions of the school officials is suffering from availability bias; if something similar had happened to a white, Christian kid, and it almost certainly has, you don't hear about it; it is only when somebody gets to scream that he was targeted because of his underprivileged ethnicity that the news media picks up the story.
Again you appear to be taking the position that since a bomb can be made to not look like a bomb then anything that doesn't look like a bomb must be an attempt at making a bomb or a fake bomb. And then simply denying it is a fake bomb and claiming it is what it is only makes it even more suspicious. Although no one ever seriously thought it was a bomb. So it was even even worse: a deviously constructed fake bomb that didn't even look like a fake bomb. You state that from the outside one couldn't see the display; I don't know if this was true or not, but if true then from the outside when not plugged in it looked like a pencil case with a twist tie. Very sly!

I will ignore any empty, evidence free, purely imagined speculation as to Ahmed's motivations. He explained to his teacher what it was and why he took it to school. And it was a clock as he readily told everyone who asked. Apparently at this point he unwillingness to be "forthcoming" in the principal's office (as characterized by the school) probably relates to his stated unwillingness to lie by "confessing" that it was a fake bomb. Do you know more as to what his "lack of full cooperation" as stated by the school means? I would certainly advise my kid to say nothing under the circumstances; Ahmed apparently was willing to state more: it was a clock.

To state the obvious: why would he show it to a teacher and explain it was a clock if he planned to later use it as a fake bomb? Wouldn't he expect the first teacher to share the initial reveal that it was just a repackaged clock?

As to the rest, sure I agree that a 14 year old should be arrested for poor clock making skills. Gee, if only I could arrange that for the guy who made my alarm clock...

More seriously I have no problem with his clock being confiscated for the day by the school as a potential distraction. I don't think that I or anyone else here suggested otherwise. But to suspend and arrest him? Come on! Perhaps after it was confiscated a good teacher would explain how to make it safer and encourage him to try a harder project?

As to the " white" kids who surely have had this happen to them: strange I would have thought that at least one of their stories would have made iit to the right-wing blogospheres, given all the mean empty speculation that is already out there seeking to besmirch Ahmed and his family. Strange I can't think of one example myself. Strange that 16.5s nephew was only suspended for a knife, wherea Ahmed was suspended and arrested for a clock.. But it was a poor cloch; even childish.
 
Last edited:
This kid came out on top with a plot that was dependent on a teacher overreacting. The school overreacting. Cops overreacting.

This is like a comic book super villains plot that somehow worked.
 
It's a little tedious to have to rebut stuff that has been rebutted several times in the thread already. Clearly you have not read a very large portion of the thread, or at least you've forgotten what you have read. The point about the ISIS bomb is that bombs can be made to look pretty much like anything. You can always insert functional parts of a bomb into innocuous looking items, and you can dress up the whole thing to look like something else (e.g. an alarm clock, or a radio, or a pencil box). Anyway, I'll give you a short overview of the thread since you seem to have arrived late and have already stated some things which are false:
If I have made a false statement than quote it. Either you can do that or you are a lying. Back up that claim!


Now about your points:
(1) Ahmed kept the pencil case closed with a twisted piece of wire (evidently because he couldn't close the clasp with the A/C power cord sticking out of the box); (2) the clock display was mounted inside the box, so it was not visible outside the box;

The buttons needed to set the clock are all on the inside. The school staff had access to the inside of the box when the kid shut down the alarm. So the box could not have been closed all the time. And somebody opened it, so they knew what they had.

(3) while it was possible, upon careful examination, to see that the display and buttons performed many of the same functions of an alarm clock, there was no way for a layman to determine that it was not capable of doing something more nefarious in addition;
There is no explosive material there. There is nothing that looks like an explosive material there. That does not require any expertise to determine.

(4) the mains transformer was not secured, and hot wires or terminals were probably exposed, so the device actually was an electrical hazard;
Agreed but also irrelevant to it being a bomb.


(5) the material from which either the white silica packet under the netting or the black box lining was composed is not at all obvious to a layman;
Only true if a school full of layman has no one in it that has never seen a silica packet. They are rather common and found in a great many products.

(6) treating the device as a serious bomb threat has an exorbitantly high cost to the school, so it would probably require a probability level of 1% or higher, which is unlikely to be reached given that school officials had some familiarity with Ahmed, and there was nothing smoking or on fire;
It would be no more disruptive than a fire drill that they would have to conduct anyway. If they thought they had a bomb anything less would have been irresponsible given the liabilities involved.

(7) even though school officials didn't worry that the "invention" was a bomb, they probably did worry that its purpose was to disrupt the school in some way (which Ahmed actually went out of his way to do in English class, despite having been warned by his engineering teacher to not show the device to anybody else);
Agreed.

(8) in school officials' opinions, Ahmed was not forthcoming about the purpose of the device and the reason for bringing it to school; (9) repeating "it's a clock" is not sufficient, since not only is the device a rather pointless clock, it still leaves unanswered the question of motive;
He is not required to given them the motive that they want. The demonstrated motive is that he wanted to show off is "invention."

(10) anybody who claims that it was obviously a clock is suffering from serious hindsight bias;
No payload means no bomb. So no hind sight bias.

(11) anybody who claims that there was obviously anti-Muslim bias in the actions of the school officials is suffering from availability bias; if something similar had happened to a white, Christian kid, and it almost certainly has, you don't hear about it; it is only when somebody gets to scream that he was targeted because of his underprivileged ethnicity that the news media picks up the story.

Prove it. Show me the white Christian kid getting treated the same way. We already have stories making national press and social media about skirt lengths. I am sure a white kid with a fake bomb are going to make the news somewhere. If there was an arrest I am sure a small town news sources is going to cover it. Otherwise all you have is your assumption.

If there is no arrest then they were not treated the same way.
 
Last edited:
I am feeling evil tonight: the Sun converts 4 million tons of matter to energy, so it gets very hot.

By the Rule of So this statement must be wrong. Does this mean the Sun is cold or that it is powered in some other way?
 
Prove it. Show me the white Christian kid getting treated the same way. We already have stories making national press and social media about skirt lengths. I am sure a white kid with a fake bomb are going to make the news somewhere. If there was an arrest I am sure a small town news sources is going to cover it. Otherwise all you have is your assumption.

If there is no arrest then they were not treated the same way.

White and other non muslim kids have been arrested or heavily disciplined for extremely silly things in school. It's pretty easy to find examples those stories, but I doubt most of them make the news. Are they exactly the same is this incident? No, but no two stories are exactly the same. It's still proves that there is a history of schools overreacting independent of race or religion. People are invoking race/religion in this incident because it fits a prexisting narrative, not because they have actual evidence that it motivated the actions of the school administrators or police.
 
An admission from the perps? Please, scam artists like that are too smart for that.

I got it from Richard Dawkins. He is skeptical, like me.

Cool post otherwise tho...
:rolleyes:

Dawkins is a brilliant scientist and inspiring thinker. I would be happy to meet him. But when it comes to certain social issues, his brain is clearly broken in important ways.

Richard Dawkins appears to have linked a grisly video of a Islamic State child soldier beheading a man and the case of 'clock boy', Ahmed .

His friends such as Lawrence Krauss have tried to stop him from doing this kind of thing... to no avail. The guy is seriously warped. So sad... and you thought "Brights" was cringe-worthy... FFS....
 
What do you think the purpose of this was? Your absolute best-case scenario is he was fraudulently claiming to invent a clock that was actually a mass-produced item sold at Radio Shack which was removed from its case.
And what has this got to do with 16.5's claim that the clock was a "hoax bomb". Other than a distraction attempt...
 
everything, of course, from his family manipulating him to the fact that the "invention" is basically taking a digital clock and putting it into a new case, to running off to Qatar as soon as the tyrants there showed them a little folding money. Good riddance
:rolleyes: So you've absolutely nothing but your imagination to support your claim of a "hoax bomb" then. Rather as expected.
 
I'm concerned that the fact that the famous photo of our Lil' Inventor was in fact staged by his sister (a/k/a The Real Bomb Hoax) is going to cut into Qatorians ability to GET *********** PAID
Is there something relevant to the matter at hand in this rant? :confused:
Nice to see you're keeping up the tradition of the green ink brigade though.
 
I'm sorry- his photo was posed and taken by his sister, so now this means "staged" by a known (fake) bomber to manipulate the media into a pro-Islamic cause.

Interesting vest you sewed on that button.
He desperately needs something to support his prejudices.
 
I am feeling evil tonight: the Sun converts 4 million tons of matter to energy, so it gets very hot.

By the Rule of So this statement must be wrong. Does this mean the Sun is cold or that it is powered in some other way?

No, you are quite wrong. In what way were you trying to characterize another poster's argument or position. Thought exercise, how was what you a strawman? Answer it wasn't.

Thus endeth the lesson in logic 101.

Back to the lil inventor, someone said he ended up "on top." He ended up in Qatar, which is about as far from on top as you can get!:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom