Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I was applying the standard of your average high school English teacher, you know, the kind that suspends a kid for having a small swiss army knife in his backpack.*

*actually happened to my nephew.

A small knife is a knife, and is expressly prohibited by most school systems and could have hurt someone. I suspect that your nephew should have know this in advance (and I realize that he may have accidently left it in his backpack, so I am not certain that he should have been suspended if so, but the rules were themselves not ex post facto). Evan a pretend knife is also banned by most school systems, and here I am more torn- I can see the reasons to discourage students bringing in even obviously pretend knives to school, but given they are not dangerous I would hope that the repercussions would be a fraction of those for intentionally bringing in a real knife of almost any size.

I've accidently brought a multitool keychain to an airport and it was confiscated; it was not cheap. It was silly to think that I could hijack a plane with a 1.5 inch blade, but I should have known the rules and I am not complaining about it.

But a clock? Was there really a prior school rule that a student should not bring in a clock? And if there was a rule that anything that looked threatening should not be brought to school, then would a typical student see a repackaged clock that he announces as such to his teacher, and calls a clock whenever someone asks, be considered threatening? Come on! And was your nephew arrested when he brought in a knife, whereas Ahmed brought in a clock?

This discussion goes on and on and I already noted that there is now endless repetition of the same points. I will therefore bring up what I hope is my final point: in attempting to research some of the many statements in this thread that are totally unsupported by any evidence, I discovered an incredible rightwing echo chamber on the web through which distorted or undocumented statements are blogged, picked up by other rightwing bloggers, often distorted yet further, until these unsupported and undocumented states become viewed as "true" because so many sites are stating them to one another, so they must be real. The wording itself is also often distorted even when a fact is alluded to ("Ahmed's sister admits to making terrorist threats" when in fact she complained that other students accused her of making such threats, a very different statement indeed).

In conclusion my research yesterday turned me into a reluctant supporter of Ahmed's family's decision to leave the USA. There is so much hatred, meanness, and bigotry expressed in these websites that, if it was directed against me and my kids, I too would come to believe for their sake that we should emigrate. I also presume that there were more quiet, personal threats as well that would have caused be to be in fear of their personal safety, but the public ones would be enough for me.

Congratulations to all of these sites who further convince Muslims that there are many people in the USA who are racist and religious bigots and who will never accept them as fellow people. Personally, I don't think that these sites are doing anything more than helping the Islamic terrorists in their goals of obtaining more supporters.
 
Last edited:
I was applying the standard of your average high school English teacher, you know, the kind that suspends a kid for having a small swiss army knife in his backpack.*

*actually happened to my nephew.

In this case, you would, I guess, agree with my ongoing assertion that the entire incident was caused by a teacher with a lack of imagination, unable to move past their first knee jerk free associated notion "ooh, bomb, hur dur" when they saw it.
 
In conclusion my research yesterday turned me into a reluctant supporter of Ahmed's family's decision to leave the USA. There is so much hatred, meanness, and bigotry expressed in these websites that, if it was directed against me and my kids, I too would come to believe for their sake that we should emigrate. I also presume that there were more quiet, personal threats as well that would have caused be to be in fear of their personal safety, but the public ones would be enough for me.

Congratulations to all of these sites who further convince Muslims that there are many people in the USA who are racist and religious bigots and who will never accept them as fellow people. Personally, I don't think that these sites are doing anything more than helping the Islamic terrorists in their goals of obtaining more supporters.

I totally agree. My recommendation to Ahmed to live the rest of his life in the U.S. would have been to change his name to Andy Martinez and move to LA.
 
In this case, you would, I guess, agree with my ongoing assertion that the entire incident was caused by a teacher with a lack of imagination, unable to move past their first knee jerk free associated notion "ooh, bomb, hur dur" when they saw it.

Well, one must keep in mind that the teacher's responsibility includes more than just one kid.

Plus, this obviously wasn't the teacher's first experience with the kid, may not have been the first run in with his family including his "outspoken" father and sister.
 
The clock project is something I would have done as a kid. If I had an old clock I might have put it in something else for a case that I thought made it into a cool looking clock. The pencil case qualifies. A lot of people do the same thing. Think about the clocks people make from gears or car parts. Same thing. Transferring the clock to a different case is not unusual. (At the same time, while he may THINK he's done something special, this doesn't make him some kind of genius.)

If I had, in my mind, built what I considered a cool clock, I probably would have been proud of it and want to show my friends. (Not so much teachers: those were my dad's friends. My dad was a teacher.) I probably would have done that by bringing it to school. (That's where my friends would be and the most convenient place for show and tell.) If it needed plugging in, I probably would have plugged it in before class to show a friend. Also not particularly unusual. (Although I probably would have unplugged it unless it had a battery to charge.)

I can understand the school being concerned and taking him to the office, however.

But a line was crossed. Maybe not by the school, but by the police. My understanding is that the police do not get to question minors while denying them access to their parents. Additionally, a child is not required to answer any questions from the police. The police ARE required to cease questioning if the child asks for a parent (or a lawyer).

My standing instructions to my kids growing up was that if the police questioned you, say nothing if I'm not there. As adults, my advice is to say nothing without a lawyer. This stance came after I witnessed police officers manipulating kids they were questioning. (I witnessed this. I was not involved.)

If this happened the way I understand it, the officers who questioned him broke the law. (Does that make the officers criminals?) They did so by questioning him without access to his parents. In this, the lawsuit is correct. How much it's worth? Probably not 15 million.
 
<snip>

But a line was crossed. Maybe not by the school, but by the police. My understanding is that the police do not get to question minors while denying them access to their parents. Additionally, a child is not required to answer any questions from the police. The police ARE required to cease questioning if the child asks for a parent (or a lawyer).

Nope. We've been through this in the thread. First, the police did not deny him access to his parents. They, at worst (and this is alleged, but not confirmed), denied allowing him to call his parents before he was questioned. That is not illegal. They effectively made an arrest. They are entitled to question him even if a guardian or a lawyer is not present. He also has the right to be silent. If they did not read him his Miranda rights, and did not have good reason to believe he understood them (which is problematic for a minor), then his testimony cannot be used against him in a court of law. That is all. I have looked at the statutes in Texas, and the only thing the police may have done wrong is arrest him without sufficient probable cause. I very much doubt a court would rule that there wasn't sufficient probable cause, but it's possible. We don't really know all the facts because Ahmed's family has not consented to the release of information by either the school or the police.

My standing instructions to my kids growing up was that if the police questioned you, say nothing if I'm not there. As adults, my advice is to say nothing without a lawyer. This stance came after I witnessed police officers manipulating kids they were questioning. (I witnessed this. I was not involved.)

Yes, I completely agree with this. I have told my own kids the same thing.
 
Last edited:
Well, one must keep in mind that the teacher's responsibility includes more than just one kid.

Plus, this obviously wasn't the teacher's first experience with the kid, may not have been the first run in with his family including his "outspoken" father and sister.

"Obviously"?

Well, she had him in class, but other than that?

Not that it matters. All the teacher did was send him to the office after his alarm clock went off in class. I don't have a problem with that. Neither does anyone else. I don't know why it's even a subject.
 
"Obviously"?

Well, she had him in class, but other than that?

Not that it matters. All the teacher did was send him to the office after his alarm clock went off in class. I don't have a problem with that. Neither does anyone else. I don't know why it's even a subject.

Why does there have to be something other than seeing him in class.

Maybe the kid was a sketchy little weirdo, you know the type....
 
If you consider pointing out logical fallacies a"taunt" I'm certain that there is very little that skeptics like me can do for you.


Pointing out logical fallacies consists of making the assertion and then generally detailing why it is a logical fallacy.

Whining "Rule of So!! Rule of So!!" does not fall into that category. It is nothing but a mantra.

By the way, is this some sort of performance art? Because it would appear that calling a fellow poster "chicken ****" is quite the taunt in and of itself.
Yeah?

So what. Unlike the defenders of the "Rule of So", I am not trying to pretend it isn't.
 
Last edited:
Nope. We've been through this in the thread. First, the police did not deny him access to his parents. They, at worst (and this is alleged, but not confirmed), denied allowing him to call his parents before he was questioned. That is not illegal. They effectively made an arrest. <snip>


There appears to be some difference of opinion on this detail among the cop groupies, but I will leave it to them to resolve it between themselves.
 
Pointing out logical fallacies consists of making the assertion and then generally detailing why it is a logical fallacy.

Whining "Rule of So!! Rule of So!!" does not fall into that category. It is nothing but a mantra.

Yeah?

So what. Unlike the defenders of the "Rule of So", I am not trying to pretend it isn't.

I get that you do not understand what the rule of so means, and you are angrily lashing out at me in frustration. It is a shorthand that skeptics use, don't let it bother you.

Sorry to hurt your feelings. No need to respond, I will assume that you consider this post chicken ****. Good luck with all that.
 
Oh, good. When will you post the admission by Ahmed's family that the scenario you posted is correct?

Of course you made it up. It's your interpretation based on totally insufficient evidence.

An admission from the perps? Please, scam artists like that are too smart for that.

I got it from Richard Dawkins. He is skeptical, like me.

Cool post otherwise tho...
 
So you don't, in fact, having anything other than your made-up scenario.

You deleted the next sentence, Belz? Did you think that people were just going to think, huh, where did that sentence go?

Richard Dawkins. You have not heard of him? Cool.

Keep apologizing for scam artists.
 
What untenable position? I submit that ISIS's bomb is no more recognizable as a bomb, to a layman, than Ahmed's "clock." I think that's "obvious" to quote those who thought that it was obvious that Ahmed's contraption was "just a clock." The fact is, it was obviously out of place in a school environment. Anything out of place should be treated with suspicion. It is irrelevant that, for example, a laptop can be made into a bomb. The school has to allow laptops because they're important for learning. A Vaultz pencil case with a mess of wiring, an exposed transformer, and a packet of desiccant inside, that has been plugged into 120V AC power and has beeped in class, is not something that requires being given the benefit of the doubt.

You can boast all you want about how good you are at distinguishing blasting caps from tampons or thermocouples, or Radio Shack alarm clock innards from suspicious electrical wiring, but the fact is, most school officials, are not trained in that fine art.

You have made repeated references that things look like bombs that don't look like bombs. Tampons being the lamest one.

The kids clock only looks like a bomb if your only reference point is action movies. Any adult that looks a a clock circuit and concludes "bomb" is not really trying. And we already know they did not think it was a bomb. And the whole assembly is visible.

So you have no point. They did not think it was a bomb. The kid never claimed it was a bomb. And the real bomb does look suspicious even though it was not assembled in the photo. Had it been assembled it would have looked even more like a bomb since the inside of the can is concealed and the outside was modified.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom