I was applying the standard of your average high school English teacher, you know, the kind that suspends a kid for having a small swiss army knife in his backpack.*
*actually happened to my nephew.
A small knife is a knife, and is expressly prohibited by most school systems and could have hurt someone. I suspect that your nephew should have know this in advance (and I realize that he may have accidently left it in his backpack, so I am not certain that he should have been suspended if so, but the rules were themselves not ex post facto). Evan a pretend knife is also banned by most school systems, and here I am more torn- I can see the reasons to discourage students bringing in even obviously pretend knives to school, but given they are not dangerous I would hope that the repercussions would be a fraction of those for intentionally bringing in a real knife of almost any size.
I've accidently brought a multitool keychain to an airport and it was confiscated; it was not cheap. It was silly to think that I could hijack a plane with a 1.5 inch blade, but I should have known the rules and I am not complaining about it.
But a clock? Was there really a prior school rule that a student should not bring in a clock? And if there was a rule that anything that looked threatening should not be brought to school, then would a typical student see a repackaged clock that he announces as such to his teacher, and calls a clock whenever someone asks, be considered threatening? Come on! And was your nephew arrested when he brought in a knife, whereas Ahmed brought in a clock?
This discussion goes on and on and I already noted that there is now endless repetition of the same points. I will therefore bring up what I hope is my final point: in attempting to research some of the many statements in this thread that are totally unsupported by any evidence, I discovered an incredible rightwing echo chamber on the web through which distorted or undocumented statements are blogged, picked up by other rightwing bloggers, often distorted yet further, until these unsupported and undocumented states become viewed as "true" because so many sites are stating them to one another, so they must be real. The wording itself is also often distorted even when a fact is alluded to ("Ahmed's sister admits to making terrorist threats" when in fact she complained that other students accused her of making such threats, a very different statement indeed).
In conclusion my research yesterday turned me into a reluctant supporter of Ahmed's family's decision to leave the USA. There is so much hatred, meanness, and bigotry expressed in these websites that, if it was directed against me and my kids, I too would come to believe for their sake that we should emigrate. I also presume that there were more quiet, personal threats as well that would have caused be to be in fear of their personal safety, but the public ones would be enough for me.
Congratulations to all of these sites who further convince Muslims that there are many people in the USA who are racist and religious bigots and who will never accept them as fellow people. Personally, I don't think that these sites are doing anything more than helping the Islamic terrorists in their goals of obtaining more supporters.
Last edited: