Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Your father/sister asked the cops to put handcuffs back on you so that they could snap a photo of you and then immediately circulate it on the interwebs? Well I'll be damned...

The rule of "so": this dictates that where a sentence or clause starts with the word "so" and purports to characterize another's argument, the likelihood that the response contains a strawman approaches 100 percent.

So (if you forgive me) are you stating that his father/sister asked the cops to put back on handcuffs allowing her to take a photo? I have not seen this claim before, but again I will accept it for now but would appreciate a citation of the original news report, etc.

Assuming your statement is true, the two key points as I see them are (1) the police had handcuffed him prior to the photo and the photo was a re-creation to document this and did not invent the actual fact that he was handcuffed, and (2) the cops were stupid enough to re-cuff him for the photo? Gee, their stupidity was even stronger than I thought!

As to the "rule of so" I still feel that my statement was an accurate distillation of your posts with one correction: you appeared to claim that his sister was a known fake bomber who created the photo (apparently with police assistance) to gain publicity. I had believed that you were proposing that the publicity was for pro-Islamic purposes. But in reading your recent posts, I gather that you believe that this was for pro-money purposes. Sorry for my error.
 
Does it have a clock?

Guilty!!???!!

My god! It does have a clock, a suspicious looking box the manufacturer claims is a hard drive, and a package claimed to be a "battery."

It might be a bomb! Or at least a fake bomb. Should I put it in a bucket of water until the police bomb squad can arrive? I sort of tried this once with a cup of coffee and a keyboard: it never worked right again but at least it didn't explode.
 
Last edited:
I know exactly what you mean- my sister has "staged" photos of me in just the same way from the time I was 5 yeas old. But I have yet to receive any money. Is my sister holding out on me?

By the way- the "so" used in my post was meant as a satirical take in terms of the "logic" of his sister taking the photo implying that it was staged by a fake bomber to manipulate the media and make lots of litigation money. I have tried to find an official definition of the "rule of so" but for purposes of this post I will go with my own informal definition that "so" is used to imply a causation that is not true. And indeed I was implying a "causation" that is not true. Guilty I guess, but perhaps you can provide with evidence otherwise, thus undermining my "rule of so"?


The "rule of so" is a content free taunt ...snip...
Edited by jsfisher: 
Edited for compliance with Rules 0 and 12 of the Membership Agreement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I agree with what you say but the blasting cap size isn't readily apparent in the ISIS Can Bomb pic. Tbf, when I saw the ISIS bomb photo last week I thought, perhaps, that the terrorist had used a standard thermopile from a wall heater. I googled it and found that a thermopile would never work-but the thought did occur to me.


Full Disclosure.I have never worked with blasting caps but do have some experience with wall heaters misbehavin'. Arrrrrgh


It's lying there right next to a soda can. That provides a certain basis for comparison, doesn't it?
 
I hate this arguing- can we at least agree that Ahmed's clock was meant to look like a fake can of soda?
 
My god! It does have a clock, a suspicious looking box the manufacturer claims is a hard drive, and a package claimed to be a "battery."

It might be a bomb! Or at least a fake bomb. Should I put it in a bucket of water until the police bomb squad can arrive? I sort of tried this once with a cup of coffee and a keyboard: it never worked right again but at least it didn't explode.

Oh no. It wasn't a "clock"! It was an "invention" by the Lil' Inventor!
 
The "rule of so" is a content free taunt ...snip...
Edited by jsfisher: 
Moderated content redacted.

It does seem to remove the need to provide facts: if you use the word "so" then everything that follows must be false. I will remember that, although in my profession "so" is often still used to state a true relationship: "We detected glucose only if cells were present in to the media, so the glucose probably came from the cells."
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The "rule of so" is a content free taunt ...snip...
Edited by jsfisher: 
Moderated content redacted.

So, u mad? :D

In fact, it is frequently used on this website by skeptics of all different political backgrounds.

By the way, I took the irony meter out of the box and invented a new one by putting it in another box, where it promptly exploded upon exposure to your post.

I'm an inventor!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It does seem to remove the need to provide facts: if you use the word "so" then everything that follows must be false. I will remember that, although in my profession "so" is often still used to state a true relationship: "We detected glucose only if cells were present in to the media, so the glucose probably came from the cells."

:eye-poppi two points:

1. you were not characterizing a post with you example;
2. "We detected glucose only if cells were present in to the media, so the glucose probably came from the cells." is the most unprofessional sentence I have seen in a long time. F.
 
So, u mad? :D


No.

(There. See how that is handled by normal people? Nothing to pretend about. No need to obfuscate and evade.)

In fact, it is frequently used on this website by skeptics of all different political backgrounds.


Don't know how frequently it is used by other than uber-conservative partisans, but I can see you seem to have overlooked the presence of the word "primarily" in my post, even though you quoted it yourself.

By the way, I took the irony meter out of the box and invented a new one by putting it in another box, where it promptly exploded upon exposure to your post.

I'm an inventor!


Or something.
 
:eye-poppi two points:

1. you were not characterizing a post with you example;
2. "We detected glucose only if cells were present in to the media, so the glucose probably came from the cells." is the most unprofessional sentence I have seen in a long time. F.

1. I was responding to and agreeing with the post from quadraginta I quoted in my own.
2. The terminology in my example was generalized for the Forum. I typically use more technical language and address a more narrow point in my professional writing. Even at that I am uncertain why this is the most unprofessional sentence you have seen in a long time. In fact, it is not particularly different from sentences I see in my field all the time where the medium is analyzed both plus and minus introduction of a particular type of cell to be certain that the source of a given natural product is indeed from the cells and not from the medium (glucose is, in fact, present in many cell culture mediums, not from the cells but from the formulation of the medium). If you still want something more "professional" that I might actually use in my work, "Expression of c-myc was only elevated when a copy of the c-ras gene was co-introduced into the cells, rather than a control vector, so we believe that c-myc is indeed regulated by c-ras (directly or indirectly)." I try to be professional.
 
"so we believe." F

Thanks for clarifying that, And yes, that was a paraphrasing for the Forum. In rereading my post I never used the term "believe." But even so, in my field of science (biochemistry) there are many papers that use the term "believe," such as "In conclusion we believe..." often used to substitute with "we conclude," "we propose," "we suggest." "Believe" is not identical to indicating an article of faith, but instead describes in science the experimenter's conclusion based on the experiments, and offers the readers the logic and rationale by which the experimenter reached this "belief" or conclusion. This allows the reader to understand what the writer concludes, and to judge the experiments for themselves to determine if the reader agrees or not. Scientific writers are, in fact, often encouraged to both help the reader understand what the writer has concluded from the experiments (what the writer "believes" the results indicate) while at the same time not presenting the conclusion as "the voice of God" in the way "The glucose came from the cells!) might imply. The facts for the "so we believe" are alway presented in scientific writing and the reader is allowed to accept the subsequent conclusion based on those facts, or not; "we believe" is used primarily to indicate that in the writer's mind the results lead to the conclusion. We also often use the words "probably" "is likely" and "appears" a lot for the same reasons; so as not to appear to be know-it-alls who are absolutely confident of what their experimental results must mean in all cases and for all eternity.
 
Last edited:
The police held on to the clock for a long time and given that they are under a lot of pressure to justify their actions, this is certainly not a dangerous substance. Further I suspect that it is not even threatening in appearance, because that would be any easy out for the police and would not require permission by Ahmed's family to release as information. I suspect is is just part of the clock mechanism.

It's a packet of desiccant, but to somebody not trained in the art of quickly recognizing whether something is a working bomb or not, like some of the geniuses in this thread, it may in fact look like a packet of explosives. Evidently, Vaultz pencil boxes come with a packet of desiccant to maintain the inside fresh and dry in case somebody wants to transplant some scary looking electrical components into it.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom