Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

And you would be wrong. That thing in the middle is a blasting cap. It does not look like anything else.

There are two very different types of blasting caps. One is non-electric and has no wires sticking out of it. Just an opening on one end for inserting either time fuse or det cord. The other looks like what you see in the photo. a narrow cylinder with wires sticking out the end. The wires are normally shunted together to prevent them from becoming an antennae and causing inadvertent detonation by nearby EMF signals. The length can very a bit. The width is limited by the insertion ports of typical explosives such as TNT.

Having been both a combat engineer and work as a field engineer on industrial automation, I can tell you there are a few industrial sensors that look a little like a blasting cap. But only just a little. They are thicker and have hardware for mounting in fixed positions.

An average person might not know that is a blasting cap. But they also would not be able to properly ID it as something else.

If you want to call it a "thermometer" then you would need to show me an example. I have worked a lot with industrial thermocouples and a bit with RTDs. Both can be in the form of metal cylinders with wires sticking out. But the ones I have worked with are not small enough to be mistaken for blasting caps.

If you really want to try and prove it rather than engage in political rhetoric, I would suggest looking for sensors using in cars or jet engines. I don't know what they look like and they are going to have to be small. But if they are some sort of short squat cylinder they you don't have anything.

Thank you for your analysis, but you've unintentionally proven my point. Not very many people know what a blasting cap looks like. I have a PhD in experimental physics, and I had no idea what a blasting cap looked like. To me it looks like a thermocouple, or maybe a tampon.
 
I'm concerned that the fact that the famous photo of our Lil' Inventor was in fact staged by his sister (a/k/a The Real Bomb Hoax) is going to cut into Qatorians ability to GET *********** PAID
 
Thank you for your analysis, but you've unintentionally proven my point. Not very many people know what a blasting cap looks like. I have a PhD in experimental physics, and I had no idea what a blasting cap looked like. To me it looks like a thermocouple, or maybe a tampon.
I saw the photos of the kid's clock. There is a packet in the lower right corner that looks totally out of place in a clock. Is it a dessicant packet? What is it and why is it there?
 
Thank you for your analysis, but you've unintentionally proven my point. Not very many people know what a blasting cap looks like. I have a PhD in experimental physics, and I had no idea what a blasting cap looked like. To me it looks like a thermocouple, or maybe a tampon.


Most people who have worked on construction sites where blasting was necessary would recognize one instantly. I've seen hundreds during the process of drill holes being loaded out.

I knew what it was as soon as I saw the photo.

Maybe not Ph.D. stuff. That might not be the best metric to qualify by.
 
Most people who have worked on construction sites where blasting was necessary would recognize one instantly. I've seen hundreds during the process of drill holes being loaded out.

I knew what it was as soon as I saw the photo.

Maybe not Ph.D. stuff. That might not be the best metric to qualify by.

the best metric would probably be a high school English teacher who knew that our Lil' inventor's sister had a suspension for making threatening comments
 
Thank you for your analysis, but you've unintentionally proven my point. Not very many people know what a blasting cap looks like. I have a PhD in experimental physics, and I had no idea what a blasting cap looked like. To me it looks like a thermocouple, or maybe a tampon.

No, it only proves that you made up crap to support your opinions. You need it to look like a thermocouple so you decided that is what it looked like to you even though you don't have a valid reference for it being a thermocouple. A reasonable assumption by an uninformed person would be that they just don't know what it is.

The critical difference between that clock and the ISIS bomb is that the ISIS bomb shows a container with unknown contents that appears to be altered next to an explosive device. The clock is an open case with circuits and wires with no concealed parts and no wires disappearing anywhere. But again a reasonable assumption by and uninformed person would again be that they just don't know what it is. Otherwise it just ends up being a Rorschach test for individual bias.
 
I gather the family is looking forward to more publicity and a settlement that costs the school district less than defending this lawsuit.

As I stated, we will just have to see if this comes to trial, the evidence that each side can produce, and if it comes to that, the court's decision. Yes, many cases are settled out out court even when the accusation is true.

But again- the school district and police really stepped in it whether that was the intent of Ahmed and his family or not. Unless you maintain that calling the police and having the guy arrested in handcuffs and questioned without access his parents for bringing in a clock (and telling people it was a clock) was the right thing to do legally, morally appropriately, and was politically astute.
 
Last edited:
everything, of course, from his family manipulating him to the fact that the "invention" is basically taking a digital clock and putting it into a new case, to running off to Qatar as soon as the tyrants there showed them a little folding money. Good riddance

Were you the poster who wanted evidence that the authorities were racist in their actions or was it someone else? Because you seem to be assuming that his family manipulated him and that their goal is the cash. I guess both statements depend on interpreting actions as evidence of intent. My apologies if it was another poster, but that demand for evidence of racism was certainly made in this thread.
 
Last edited:
I feel the need to point out that the soda can was a bomb designed to not look like a bomb. And now some are maintaining that the clock didn't look like a bomb, so by that logic it was designed to not look like a bomb so that it would be thought to be a bomb (was an intentionally fake fake bomb). Seems a bit complicated to wrap my mind around- no one thought it was a bomb, no one said it was a bomb, no one now maintains that it was a bomb, but some bombs don't look like bombs so this thing that didn't look like a bomb must have been intended to be a fake bomb. By that criterion my laptop could get me arrested for planting a fake bomb in my office at work because it doesn't look like a bomb and indeed it is not a bomb.
 
Last edited:
the best metric would probably be a high school English teacher who knew that our Lil' inventor's sister had a suspension for making threatening comments

I have yet to see that citation about his sister; I will believe it is true but I would really like to see the evidence and the actual facts. Perhaps this is another case of the school district and police having it in for Ahmed's family, or perhaps his sister is, indeed, a "bad 'un."

In any case, and just for information- am I to be held responsible for my sister's actions? If so I need to get my affairs in order because I can see some jail time for me in my future. I am Jewish and not Islamic if that makes a difference.
 
I saw the photos of the kid's clock. There is a packet in the lower right corner that looks totally out of place in a clock. Is it a dessicant packet? What is it and why is it there?

The police held on to the clock for a long time and given that they are under a lot of pressure to justify their actions, this is certainly not a dangerous substance. Further I suspect that it is not even threatening in appearance, because that would be any easy out for the police and would not require permission by Ahmed's family to release as information. I suspect is is just part of the clock mechanism.
 
I'm concerned that the fact that the famous photo of our Lil' Inventor was in fact staged by his sister (a/k/a The Real Bomb Hoax) is going to cut into Qatorians ability to GET *********** PAID

I'm sorry- his photo was posed and taken by his sister, so now this means "staged" by a known (fake) bomber to manipulate the media into a pro-Islamic cause.

Interesting vest you sewed on that button.
 
I'm sorry- his photo was posed and taken by his sister, so now this means "staged" by a known (fake) bomber to manipulate the media into a pro-Islamic cause.

Interesting vest you sewed on that button.

No need to be sorry, and your post was an excellent example of the Rule of So.

Yes it was "posed" or "staged" if your prefer by his sister. "pro-Islamic"? I think you mean "PRO-MO-MONEY!!!!
 
No need to be sorry, and your post was an excellent example of the Rule of So.

Yes it was "posed" or "staged" if your prefer by his sister. "pro-Islamic"? I think you mean "PRO-MO-MONEY!!!!

I know exactly what you mean- my sister has "staged" photos of me in just the same way from the time I was 5 yeas old. But I have yet to receive any money. Is my sister holding out on me?

By the way- the "so" used in my post was meant as a satirical take in terms of the "logic" of his sister taking the photo implying that it was staged by a fake bomber to manipulate the media and make lots of litigation money. I have tried to find an official definition of the "rule of so" but for purposes of this post I will go with my own informal definition that "so" is used to imply a causation that is not true. And indeed I was implying a "causation" that is not true. Guilty I guess, but perhaps you can provide with evidence otherwise, thus undermining my "rule of so"?
 
What part of the mechanism? It's a packet (pillow) containing a substance.

I would have told you if I knew for a fact. I presented the logic in my post as to why this certainly wasn't a dangerous material, and very likely was not even threatening in appearance in any way to anyone in a large group of people hoping to find something that could be used to publicly justify their actions in their treatment of Ahmed. Remember- no one ever claimed it was a bomb or treated it like a bomb, so if the packet was meant to be suspicious it failed ingloriously.

A packet of desiccant? A backup capacitor or battery? Some peanut butter crackers for lunch? Something to prevent a part from rattling around? I really can't tell. Is it even wired in? Some people have indicated that it is just a re-assembled Radio Shack alarm clock; maybe they know?

Edited: it looks a lot like any of a series of mesh storage sacks and some wallets I see on the web, but I have no specific identification. It must be small based on the dimensions of the clock, but I haven't seen any mention of what it is, or that anyone took it to be explosives, on any web site I have called up so far. In fact it must not have been suspicious on closer examination because even the websites that I have seen that loudly believe the clock to be a fake bomb fail to mention it.
 
Last edited:
I know exactly what you mean- my sister has "staged" photos of me in just the same way from the time I was 5 yeas old. But I have yet to receive any money. Is my sister holding out on me?

By the way- the "so" used in my post was meant as a satirical take in terms of the "logic" of his sister taking the photo implying that it was staged by a fake bomber to manipulate the media and make lots of litigation money. I have tried to find an official definition of the "rule of so" but for purposes of this post I will go with my own informal definition that "so" is used to imply a causation that is not true. And indeed I was implying a "causation" that is not true. Guilty I guess, but perhaps you can provide with evidence otherwise, thus undermining my "rule of so"?

Your father/sister asked the cops to put handcuffs back on you so that they could snap a photo of you and then immediately circulate it on the interwebs? Well I'll be damned...

The rule of "so": this dictates that where a sentence or clause starts with the word "so" and purports to characterize another's argument, the likelihood that the response contains a strawman approaches 100 percent.
 
Were you the poster who wanted evidence that the authorities were racist in their actions or was it someone else? Because you seem to be assuming that his family manipulated him and that their goal is the cash. I guess both statements depend on interpreting actions as evidence of intent. My apologies if it was another poster, but that demand for evidence of racism was certainly made in this thread.


And when such evidence was proffered it was rejected, with assertions that just because it was a relatively small town in Texas that didn't mean they were bigots, in spite of the town's general approbation for its sensationalist Islamophobe mayor.

Anyone notice Irving's most recent appearance in the news? Armed, masked protesters picketing the mosque, whining about "the Islamization of America". Whatever the hell that means.

Yeah. No bigots there.

:rolleyes:
 
I feel the need to point out that the soda can was a bomb designed to not look like a bomb. And now some are maintaining that the clock didn't look like a bomb, so by that logic it was designed to not look like a bomb so that it would be thought to be a bomb (was an intentionally fake fake bomb). Seems a bit complicated to wrap my mind around- no one thought it was a bomb, no one said it was a bomb, no one now maintains that it was a bomb, but some bombs don't look like bombs so this thing that didn't look like a bomb must have been intended to be a fake bomb. By that criterion my laptop could get me arrested for planting a fake bomb in my office at work because it doesn't look like a bomb and indeed it is not a bomb.


Does it have a clock?

Guilty!!???!!
 
And you would be wrong. That thing in the middle is a blasting cap. It does not look like anything else.

There are two very different types of blasting caps. One is non-electric and has no wires sticking out of it. Just an opening on one end for inserting either time fuse or det cord. The other looks like what you see in the photo. a narrow cylinder with wires sticking out the end. The wires are normally shunted together to prevent them from becoming an antennae and causing inadvertent detonation by nearby EMF signals. The length can very a bit. The width is limited by the insertion ports of typical explosives such as TNT.

Having been both a combat engineer and work as a field engineer on industrial automation, I can tell you there are a few industrial sensors that look a little like a blasting cap. But only just a little. They are thicker and have hardware for mounting in fixed positions.

An average person might not know that is a blasting cap. But they also would not be able to properly ID it as something else.

If you want to call it a "thermometer" then you would need to show me an example. I have worked a lot with industrial thermocouples and a bit with RTDs. Both can be in the form of metal cylinders with wires sticking out. But the ones I have worked with are not small enough to be mistaken for blasting caps.

If you really want to try and prove it rather than engage in political rhetoric, I would suggest looking for sensors using in cars or jet engines. I don't know what they look like and they are going to have to be small. But if they are some sort of short squat cylinder they you don't have anything.

I agree with what you say but the blasting cap size isn't readily apparent in the ISIS Can Bomb pic. Tbf, when I saw the ISIS bomb photo last week I thought, perhaps, that the terrorist had used a standard thermopile from a wall heater. I googled it and found that a thermopile would never work-but the thought did occur to me.


Full Disclosure.I have never worked with blasting caps but do have some experience with wall heaters misbehavin'. Arrrrrgh
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom