Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I gather that some have used the suit to indicate that this was all a plot by Ahmed and his family to obtain big money through litigation. My, they are very clever to have planned it out so well and to have predicted the school's and/or police's over-the-top response! This contrasts with the posters who were unimpressed by the clock itself as a science project. Too bad the school and police fell for it as planned and placed themselves in so much legal liability. Whatever the result I suspect that it will cost the police and school if only to mount a defense.

I was previously arguing (and still do) that the USA needs more scientifically interested people like Ahmed, but perhaps it is in legal talent in which he really excels. Frankly I think he has a good case and will probably be able to settle out of court for a significant sum.

yeah, it was a hoax bomb, and they did a magnificent job of manipulating the press. I hope Qatar needs more scam artists because that is where they went. they have plenty of slaves, tho.
 
We've been over this, sunmas. If anyone ever thought it was a real bomb, why didn't they evacuate the building and call a bomb squad?

Ergo no matter what it might have looked like, obviously a real bomb was not at issue.

No, I've been over this, but you haven't. You are committing the fallacy of the excluded middle, also known as a false dichotomy. There are scenarios that exist between (1) high enough concern that an unknown object is a bomb that the school is evacuated; and (2) high enough confidence that an unknown object isn't a bomb that no investigation is required. Some of these scenarios include an unknown object which may be used to cause a disruption to the school, or which is potentially a danger, but not an imminent danger, or is designed to cause alarm among a certain subset of people at a certain time.
 
That's a piss-poor argument. It clearly didn't look enough like a bomb to even warrant calling more than the school administrators and the schoolyard cop.

Why should kids be punished for teachers' ignorance? No bomb threat was made. There's no evidence a bomb hoax was intended.
 
Last edited:
That's a piss-poor argument. It clearly didn't look enough like a bomb to even warrant calling more than the school administrators and the schoolyard cop.

Why should kids be punished for teachers' ignorance? No bomb threat was made. There's no evidence a bomb hoax was intended.

Does the Schweppes can, the pen flashlight and the little twirly wire thing look like a bomb to you? At first glance, it looks as much like a bomb to me as a mess of wires and a transformer in a pencil case (with the packet of desiccant in the corner, IIRC). ETA: Less actually.
 
Last edited:
Does the Schweppes can, the pen flashlight and the little twirly wire thing look like a bomb to you? At first glance, it looks as much like a bomb to me as a mess of wires and a transformer in a pencil case (with the packet of desiccant in the corner, IIRC). ETA: Less actually.

So, what the heck are you going on about the Schweppes can? What is it? An ied?

I can't tell from the photo what it is, but it does have a black mass of an unknown substance in it. Is that unknown substance explosive?

That's the difference between the clock and whatever the heck that thing is that you are talking about. There's a substance there that can't be identified. Everything in Ahmed's gizmo was recognizable. It was a clock.

If Ahmed had stuck a wad of modelling clay inside the pencil box, I would say it was a hoax bomb. He didn't. It was a clock. If he had left it unattended somewhere, I would say it might have been a hoax bomb. He didn't. He showed it to a teacher and said, "Look at my clock."

Well, he has left the country, but he left lawyers behind to remember him by. God Bless America. Land of the Lawsuit.

ETA: So I googled the Schweppes bomb, and saw a better image of it. I hadn't seen the news, so I didn't recognize the photo. I still don't know what the pieces are. I blew up (no pun intended) the photo and could tell that the black thing was a switch. Is the thing in the middle the explosive?

ETA2: So, is the thing in the middle a blasting cap?
 
Last edited:
What a shame it accidentally alarmed during class time, Ahmed couldn't possibly have meant for that to happen.
 
I gather that some have used the suit to indicate that this was all a plot by Ahmed and his family to obtain big money through litigation. My, they are very clever to have planned it out so well and to have predicted the school's and/or police's over-the-top response! This contrasts with the posters who were unimpressed by the clock itself as a science project. Too bad the school and police fell for it as planned and placed themselves in so much legal liability. Whatever the result I suspect that it will cost the police and school if only to mount a defense.
Hardly an unexpected response given the number of people, here and elsewhere, who immediately tried to denigrate Ahmed.
The only think that'll change the attitudes displayed in this case are exposure and financial penalties, hopefully the lawsuit will provide both.
 
So, what the heck are you going on about the Schweppes can? What is it? An ied?

I can't tell from the photo what it is, but it does have a black mass of an unknown substance in it. Is that unknown substance explosive?

That's the difference between the clock and whatever the heck that thing is that you are talking about. There's a substance there that can't be identified. Everything in Ahmed's gizmo was recognizable. It was a clock.

If Ahmed had stuck a wad of modelling clay inside the pencil box, I would say it was a hoax bomb. He didn't. It was a clock. If he had left it unattended somewhere, I would say it might have been a hoax bomb. He didn't. He showed it to a teacher and said, "Look at my clock."

Well, he has left the country, but he left lawyers behind to remember him by. God Bless America. Land of the Lawsuit.

ETA: So I googled the Schweppes bomb, and saw a better image of it. I hadn't seen the news, so I didn't recognize the photo. I still don't know what the pieces are. I blew up (no pun intended) the photo and could tell that the black thing was a switch. Is the thing in the middle the explosive?

ETA2: So, is the thing in the middle a blasting cap?

Or some similar item that can spark an explosion in explosive material, most likely yes. The point being that IEDs can be assembled from the most innocuous materials the bombmaker can imagine putting together. Very very few IEDs use timers these days, as I understand it, which makes the notion that Ahmed's clock was considered a "hoax bomb" all the more ridiculous IMO. I can understand the teachers not being aware of that fact, but the police should have been better informed.
 
I find it interesting what kind of story some conservatives have to make up out-of the-blue in the total lack of evidence to make themselves feel better about an event. These often involves speculating as to the motivation of the victim. "They wanted it" has been used as an excuse for thousands of years, not only in the political arena, and because it is based on what the person was thinking at the time, requires no demonstrable facts and is an easy last resort. Thankfully in the Western world we have moved away from this excuse at least in sexual assault cases.

As I posted before- I don't think at all that was the case here. But further, it doesn't really matter: even if someone is trying to provoke an over-the-top, inappropriate, incorrect action by authorities, and does so, then that person has proven that the authorities acted incorrectly, often immorally and illegally. Ahmed brought in a perfectly reasonable clock project into school, showed it to the most appropriate teacher, explained what it was, and was apparently pressured by multiple school authorities to "confess" it was a hoax bomb, arrested in hand cuffs, and illegally not permitted to contact his parents. The proper school response would probably be to express some minor interest to encourage his known interest in science, and at most to have confiscated the clock until after school as a potential distraction. But even if Ahmed or his parents were incredibly clever and hoped for Ahmed to be arrested and illegally questioned (do you really think someone would wish this for a 14 year old boy?), the one key point is: he was. In this view the authorities were shown a piece of poop and then voluntarily "stepped in it," showing the administrators and the police were willing to violate the rules, and in fact proved that they as a group were far less intelligent than a 14 year old boy and his family.

Why this makes some people feel better about the incident I do not know.

Some here has used the legal suit as evidence of this intent. I easily see it instead as an attempt to get compensation from authorities who changed the life of Ahmed and his family. But whatever the motivation, I gather that the family and their lawyers believe that they have a reasonable chance of convincing a jury that Ahmed's rights were violated. I look forward to the facts presented in the case and to the court's decision.
 
Last edited:
What a shame it accidentally alarmed during class time, Ahmed couldn't possibly have meant for that to happen.
Of course not, plugging it into the wall socket was completely accidental.
 
And your evidence for this ridiculous claim?
What do you think the purpose of this was? Your absolute best-case scenario is he was fraudulently claiming to invent a clock that was actually a mass-produced item sold at Radio Shack which was removed from its case.
 
I gather that the family and their lawyers believe that they have a reasonable chance of convincing a jury that Ahmed's rights were violated. I look forward to the facts presented in the case and to the court's decision.
I gather the family is looking forward to more publicity and a settlement that costs the school district less than defending this lawsuit.
 
No, I was actually making fun of the people who insisted that Ahmed's "invention" was obviously a clock. Presumably the same people would say that the picture I uploaded is obviously a can of Schweppes Gold pineapple soda with an improvised thermometer and swizzle stick. Well, they would if they were being consistent. But they won't be.

And you would be wrong. That thing in the middle is a blasting cap. It does not look like anything else.

There are two very different types of blasting caps. One is non-electric and has no wires sticking out of it. Just an opening on one end for inserting either time fuse or det cord. The other looks like what you see in the photo. a narrow cylinder with wires sticking out the end. The wires are normally shunted together to prevent them from becoming an antennae and causing inadvertent detonation by nearby EMF signals. The length can very a bit. The width is limited by the insertion ports of typical explosives such as TNT.

Having been both a combat engineer and work as a field engineer on industrial automation, I can tell you there are a few industrial sensors that look a little like a blasting cap. But only just a little. They are thicker and have hardware for mounting in fixed positions.

An average person might not know that is a blasting cap. But they also would not be able to properly ID it as something else.

If you want to call it a "thermometer" then you would need to show me an example. I have worked a lot with industrial thermocouples and a bit with RTDs. Both can be in the form of metal cylinders with wires sticking out. But the ones I have worked with are not small enough to be mistaken for blasting caps.

If you really want to try and prove it rather than engage in political rhetoric, I would suggest looking for sensors using in cars or jet engines. I don't know what they look like and they are going to have to be small. But if they are some sort of short squat cylinder they you don't have anything.
 
And your evidence for this ridiculous claim?

everything, of course, from his family manipulating him to the fact that the "invention" is basically taking a digital clock and putting it into a new case, to running off to Qatar as soon as the tyrants there showed them a little folding money. Good riddance
 
Of course not, plugging it into the wall socket was completely accidental.

The cord plugged itself in because it was Islamophobic.

With the lawsuit we see the final act being played out.
 
Strikes me as a particularly frivolous legal claim. The only reason that Ahmed has any notoriety at all is because his family rushed to the media like moths to a flame.

By the way, I think a found a picture of Ahmed's new invention. It looks like a thermometer that lights up when your beverage has reached the optimal temperature. Or maybe it's just a clock.


[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_6744356539343853a3.jpg[/qimg]

This comment shows a distinct lack of cognitive processing. This is the opposite of skeptical thinking. This is knee-jerk rock throwing is the exact reason his family is suing.
 
No, I was actually making fun of the people who insisted that Ahmed's "invention" was obviously a clock. Presumably the same people would say that the picture I uploaded is obviously a can of Schweppes Gold pineapple soda with an improvised thermometer and swizzle stick. Well, they would if they were being consistent. But they won't be.

I've analyzed and given my score for Ahmed's project upthread. Your analysis sounds good in the echo chamber of likeminded Facebook crapspam but utterly falls down when his work is compared with actual bombs and with actual electronics benchwork by young students.

But Hey! Way to go swallowing those pre-chewed preconceptions!
 
Does the Schweppes can, the pen flashlight and the little twirly wire thing look like a bomb to you? At first glance, it looks as much like a bomb to me as a mess of wires and a transformer in a pencil case (with the packet of desiccant in the corner, IIRC). ETA: Less actually.

Every mockup I've ever seen in an IED training environment looked more like the actual bomb picture than the "thing someone thought might look like a bomb" thingie. Seriously. That's what grow ups know. What circulates on Facebook as "looks like a bomb" bullpoop comments and brainless meme posters is NOT what a real bomb looks like.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom