Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Without an SRO, the school officials investigate this type of issue.

With an SRO, the SRO investigates this type of issue.

That is the distinction.

With an SRO, the school officials only determine whether the reported incident is a matter of violation of law or violation of school policy. If it is a matter of law, they turn it over to the SRO without investigating or even determining whether an investigation is warranted. That is the SRO’s job.

I already gave some examples. If a teacher reports that Billy and Jimmy are going fight after school, the principal would talk to the students and try to work things out. The principal wouldn’t call the cops. But if the school has a SRO, the school would just turn the matter over to the SRO. That is different from a school deciding to call the cops over a possible future fist fight.


You can keep repeating that all you want to but repetition doesn't make it any more plausible.

SRO == Cop

The principal has the discretion to relinquish authority to the cops ... or not.

The principal has the discretion to relinquish authority to the SRO ... or not.

Your contention is that this is somehow qualitatively different, but you have offered no rational explanation aside from the relatively trivial difference that one cop is closer than the other cops.

You'll have to do better than that to sound convincing.
 
If the school did not have an SRO, the issue would have gone to someone like the Principal. The Principal may have decided that the teacher’s suspicions were unfounded and told her to give the clock back to the student. Or the Principal may have questioned the student and then decided it was just an electronics project and ended it there. Or the Principal may have decided to call in the student’s parents to discuss what was going on. Or the Principal may have decided that this needed to be turned over to the police.

With an SRO, the Principal just identifies the teacher’s report as being related to potential criminal activity and turns it over to the SRO to decide what to do because that is the SRO’s job.

An SRO is a bit different from just a near-by police officer. An SRO works closely with the school patrolling the grounds, acting sometimes as disciplinarian and counselor, providing safety advice to the school and parents, and lecturing in some classrooms. The SRO typically has an office in the, probably very near the principal’s office.

When the principal gets a teacher brining in something claimed to resemble the infrascure of a bomb, the principal just walks it to the office room next door and hands it over to the SRO to deal with.

Technically the principal doesn’t have to do that, but not doing that would be a bit odd. It would be like a principal trying to diagnose a student’s illness instead of turning the issue over to the school nurse.
 
<snip>

Technically the principal doesn’t have to do that, but not doing that would be a bit odd. It would be like a principal trying to diagnose a student’s illness instead of turning the issue over to the school nurse.


This would be because the SRO is an education professional with superior educational skills and qualifications to the principal, the same way a school nurse is a medical professional with superior medical skills and qualifications to the principal?

So, of course the principal would defer to to SRO, not being qualified to make the judgement on his own.

But he would be if the SRO cop was not in such close proximity?

Sorry. It still doesn't wash.

It sounds more like handing the problem off to someone else when the opportunity arises, only one situation is more convenient than the other.
 
That's not true. We also have the police side of the story. It is a side of the story which accused him of making a hoax device even as they maintained that he never claimed the device to be a bomb.



They were called and they had an obligation to respond. Beyond that, and given that they had seen the device and that they acknowledge that at not time did anyone named Ahmed ever suggest it was anything other than a clock, they had probable cause for what? Probable cause, how?

If you had read the thread up until this point, you would have seen that I have addressed this point several times. It is not necessary for somebody to claim a non-bomb is a bomb in order for it to be a hoax bomb. And there is no safe harbor that is created by announcing that something intended to be mistaken for a bomb is not a bomb. For example, if I walk in wearing a wired-up suicide vest and announce that those things that look like sticks of dynamite sticking out of the vest are really wax candles (and they really are wax candles), I am not absolved of committing a hoax. The people who write these laws, and the people who enforce them, are not total idiots after all.
 
What would the status of non-citizen, non-Arab Sudanese be in Qatar?

Why "non-Arab?" I would have thought the family considered themselves Arab. Admittedly, the Qataris might not consider them Arab, but that's a different issue in my book.
 
I would hope law enforcement would not be so stupid as to not recognize when a device lacks the components of a bomb----it's not a bomb if it doesn't have a timing device AND detonator AND explosive. Otherwise it's just a clock in a box.
 
This would be because the SRO is an education professional with superior educational skills and qualifications to the principal, the same way a school nurse is a medical professional with superior medical skills and qualifications to the principal?

So, of course the principal would defer to to SRO, not being qualified to make the judgement on his own.

But he would be if the SRO cop was not in such close proximity?

Sorry. It still doesn't wash.

It sounds more like handing the problem off to someone else when the opportunity arises, only one situation is more convenient than the other.

An SRO is technically a cop, but fulfills some of the duties that school officials would otherwise do if there was no SRO. An SRO is sort of a quasi-school-official. It isn’t a matter of proximity. It is a matter of roles.

It is not a matter of handing the problem off to someone else when the opportunity arises, it is a matter of handing off the problem in all cases. With an SRO, ANY case of a potentially criminal nature gets handed off to the SRO because that is the SRO’s role.

I gave the example of a rumor of an after-school fist fight. Without an SRO, that issues would go to someone like the principal because that is who handles those types of issues at the school. It would be rather silly for the principal to call in the police over that issue.

But with an SRO, that issue would go to the SRO because that is who handles those types of issues at the school. The police would be involved in something as simple as a rumor of a possible fight, not because the school “called in the police” but because the school has an SRO who is responsible for handling that type off issue.

This is probably the least controversial issue of the whole incident. If a school with an SRO gets a report of a student with a device that is possibly the infrastructure for a bomb, that goes to the SRO because that is who handles that type of issue at that school.
 
This is probably the least controversial issue of the whole incident. If a school with an SRO gets a report of a student with a device that is possibly the infrastructure for a bomb, that goes to the SRO because that is who handles that type of issue at that school.


I never said it was controversial. I said that claiming an SRO isn't a cop is a distinction without a difference.
 
I never said it was controversial. I said that claiming an SRO isn't a cop is a distinction without a difference.

I’m feeling confused.

An SRO is a cop. An SRO is a sub-category of cop.

The question is whether the school should have gotten the police involved.

For a school without an SRO, the school officials ONLY involve the police if they feel the issues warrants police involvement.

For a school with an SRO, the school officials ALWAYS involve the police because that is the SRO’s role.

The difference is that in the first case, the school has to make a decision whether a report of potentially criminal nature warrants calling in the police. In the latter, the school doesn’t make that judgment call because a police officer is assigned the task handling all such reports. In the former, the school chooses to escalate the issue to the police. In the latter, there is no escalation because EVERY such issue goes to the SRO (who is also the police).

If the school didn’t have an SRO, we could question whether the school should have called in the police. But with an SRO, there is no question because such matters are always turned over to the SRO (the police) as a matter of course.
 
I would hope law enforcement would not be so stupid as to not recognize when a device lacks the components of a bomb----it's not a bomb if it doesn't have a timing device AND detonator AND explosive. Otherwise it's just a clock in a box.

This has been addressed many times. Nobody thought it was a bomb. It wasn’t just a clock in a box. It was a clock in a box that also appeared to be (at least to some people) a possible infrastructure to a bomb or something that could be used as a hoax bomb.
 
In the latter, there is no escalation because EVERY such issue goes to the SRO (who is also the police).

But this still dances around the issue. Yes, every "such issue" goes to the SRO.

But someone still has to decide that a particular incident is a "such issue".

As I put it many pages ago, they are required to report all suspicious items, but they aren't required to be suspicious when they see a clock. It's not a huge deal in my mind that they contacted the SRO. After all, there's no reason to expect that every teacher would instantly recognize that the device is harmless.

However, we can still point and laugh when they do it.

As for the cops themselves, that's much worse. They should have enough knowledge to know that the device is not dangerous, and they asked enough questions to knyow that the device was not presented as something dangerous. However, they apparently don't like "passive aggressive" kids, so they arrested him anyway.
 
Hello...........back up again for the umpteenth time.

The reason that the device and situation was turned over to the cops, SROs or whatever the heck you want to call it, is that the STUDENT refused to cooperate with the principal.

Remember, this has been stated as much as possible by both the school and the police and has never been disputed by Ahmed.

When they asked him why he brought it to school he shut down. Now everyone can jump and skirt that issue however much they want, but the evidence is there. He didn't tell them what was going on. They had no choice but to turn it over to the cops.

It's utterly nonsensical for people to pretend this situation is anything other than what the facts flat out show us.

The fact that the science or engineering teacher was never involved in the situation in the office is a clear indication that he didn't tell them what was going on.

Now people can spin their stupid narratives of profiling and Islamaphobia all they want, but if you have a kid bringing something like this to school and then setting up to go off in the classroom ON PURPOSE which he admits he did, has a history of pulling pranks in school and then refuses to cooperate with the principal beyond just sitting there saying "It's not a bomb, it's a clock" then of COURSE you have an obligation to turn it over to the cops.


All you bomb detecting geniuses out there don't realize that they had no choice because of the way it went down.
 
Hello...........back up again for the umpteenth time.

The reason that the device and situation was turned over to the cops, SROs or whatever the heck you want to call it, is that the STUDENT refused to cooperate with the principal.

Remember, this has been stated as much as possible by both the school and the police and has never been disputed by Ahmed.

When they asked him why he brought it to school he shut down. Now everyone can jump and skirt that issue however much they want, but the evidence is there. He didn't tell them what was going on. They had no choice but to turn it over to the cops.

It's utterly nonsensical for people to pretend this situation is anything other than what the facts flat out show us.

The fact that the science or engineering teacher was never involved in the situation in the office is a clear indication that he didn't tell them what was going on.

Now people can spin their stupid narratives of profiling and Islamaphobia all they want, but if you have a kid bringing something like this to school and then setting up to go off in the classroom ON PURPOSE which he admits he did, has a history of pulling pranks in school and then refuses to cooperate with the principal beyond just sitting there saying "It's not a bomb, it's a clock" then of COURSE you have an obligation to turn it over to the cops.


All you bomb detecting geniuses out there don't realize that they had no choice because of the way it went down.

That's not true. The cops didn't like his answer that it was merely a clock. They wanted to know what it was, why he built it, why he brought it to school, and what he used it for but weren't happy when he told them the truth: it's a clock, I like to build things, to show my teacher, to tell time.

That police don't like your answers doesn't make you guilty of a crime. They tend to believe there must be an evil explanation for everything and often can't seem to wrap their little minds around facts of innocence.
 
Hello...........back up again for the umpteenth time.

The reason that the device and situation was turned over to the cops, SROs or whatever the heck you want to call it, is that the STUDENT refused to cooperate with the principal.

Remember, this has been stated as much as possible by both the school and the police and has never been disputed by Ahmed.

When they asked him why he brought it to school he shut down. Now everyone can jump and skirt that issue however much they want, but the evidence is there. He didn't tell them what was going on. They had no choice but to turn it over to the cops.
(remainder snipped)
What your evidence that Ahmed "shut down" when he was talking to the principal? And that it was the reason the principal then turned the affair over to the SRO?
 
This has been addressed many times. Nobody thought it was a bomb. It wasn’t just a clock in a box. It was a clock in a box that also appeared to be (at least to some people) a possible infrastructure to a bomb or something that could be used as a hoax bomb.

My underwear might appear to be (at least to some people) a possible infrastructure for a bomb (or something that could be used as a hoax bomb) but that's no reason to arrest me for not going commando.
 
What would the status of non-citizen, non-Arab Sudanese be in Qatar?
Why "non-Arab?"
Because I may have made incorrect assumptions about ethnicity.

I would have thought the family considered themselves Arab. Admittedly, the Qataris might not consider them Arab, but that's a different issue in my book.
No, actually, when I am asking what the status of someone is, as considered by a certain group, what that certain group thinks is of greater relevance than than what that someone thinks.
 
Because I may have made incorrect assumptions about ethnicity.


No, actually, when I am asking what the status of someone is, as considered by a certain group, what that certain group thinks is of greater relevance than than what that someone thinks.

I understand, but I think the proper question is "What would be the status of a non-citizen, Sudanese Arab in Qatar?" And I actually think the answer is "pretty low relative to a Qatari citizen, but not that low relative to most of the resident population." According to the wiki, Qatar has 278,000 citizens out of a resident population of 1.8 million. Most of the expatriates are from South Asia.

I predict that Ahmed's father is going to wear out his welcome pretty fast. He just strikes me as something of a blowhard who would not do well in an authoritarian country like Qatar.
 
This has been addressed many times. Nobody thought it was a bomb. It wasn’t just a clock in a box. It was a clock in a box that also appeared to be (at least to some people) a possible infrastructure to a bomb or something that could be used as a hoax bomb.

"I'm too stupid to know what a bomb looks like" is not something I want anyone with authority to ever say. Even in sunmaster's hoax bomb with all faked parts, THERE WAS THE EXPLOSIVE COMPONENT. A timing device does not a bomb make.
 
[SNIP]


I don't mind repeating the answer for you. The evidence that Ahmend "shut down" is that the principal says so, and the principal is a school official, and school officials follow precise procedures, and therefore are incapable of being wrong or making self-serving false claims. If Ahmed hadn't shut down, the principal wouldn't have involved the police, so because he did involve the police, Ahmed must have shut down. It's airtight!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you had read the thread up until this point, you would have seen that I have addressed this point several times. It is not necessary for somebody to claim a non-bomb is a bomb in order for it to be a hoax bomb.

So what has the police department said regarding the weight of evidence supporting the perception (a perception apparently motivating his arrest) that he intended to provoke alarm?

Because as I am seeing it, we have a case here of some folk considering the suggestion that police may have acted incompetently to be an outrageous one (because they are the experts at policing, and experts wouldn't act incompetently, I guess,... so,... QED) and being outraged that good skeptical folk would not give the police the benefit of the doubt (if someone is in handcuffs, they must have done something, after all). And yet these same good folk seem to consider the police as a source that cannot be relied upon when they release a statement regarding the incident saying that nope, that hoaxing thing,... it didn't happen.

And there is no safe harbor that is created by announcing that something intended to be mistaken for a bomb is not a bomb. For example, if I walk in wearing a wired-up suicide vest and announce that those things that look like sticks of dynamite sticking out of the vest are really wax candles (and they really are wax candles), I am not absolved of committing a hoax.

This is not analogous to this case. This case involves a metal box stuffed with unremarkable electronic components.

I will add that even the scenario you posit could easily and trivially not be considered a hoax bomb under the law.

20.jpg


For instance, if that kid showed up at your door next Saturday it would probably not be considered a "hoax bomb" for purposes of the law even if he didn't even bother to tell you that this was a simulated device (he probably would even be able to get away with lying and telling you that it was real).

The above would be more than a sufficient trigger for the absurd "zero tolerance" policies in many schools, however. But even then, that is not what we are dealing with in the case of Ahmed. In the case of Ahmed we are dealing with a metal box stuffed with unremarkable electronic components.

The people who write these laws, and the people who enforce them, are not total idiots after all.

I have no idea what leads you to conclude this. Being tangentially associated with the writing of some laws in no way confers immunity against idiocy. The people who write these laws and the people who enforce them probably include geniuses as well as total idiots and are probably not remarkable when compared to the general population (which also includes geniuses and total idiots).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom