Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

What civil rights did they violate?

Ahmed's.

As a minor, the police should not have been questioning him without a parent or guardian present. At one point, Ahmed even asked if he could call his parents; the police denied him that right. And that's setting aside how ridiculous it was to call the police to begin with.
 
Ahmed's.

As a minor, the police should not have been questioning him without a parent or guardian present. At one point, Ahmed even asked if he could call his parents; the police denied him that right. And that's setting aside how ridiculous it was to call the police to begin with.

I don't think legally that is a civil right.
 
I don't think legally that is a civil right.

My brief google search tells me that it is not. In fact, it's not even improper or unusual for police to question children without parental consent. I think this refers to California law, but I doubt Texas law constrains police more than California law does.
 
What exactly was Islamophobic? We only have Ahmed's side of the story, and even he didn't claim that they referred to his religion or asked any specific questions it.

I posted that in a tongue in cheek way as a bit of a troll - but to isolate the events with Ahmed on that day: it was an incredible over-reaction, so this is what makes it easy for them to earn the label "islamaphobe", because people will imagine that they overreacted precisely because this kid was known as "ISIS Boy", was a muslim - and because they had just seen True Lies the weekend before. I know Bill Maher believes the reaction to have been justified given the broader atmosphere of terrorism and/or school shootings - and these are probably in the mix. However its easy to imagine additional motivations involving fever dreams of Islamic terror and the boy's religion playing a part as well.

In any event, this whole thing has become a lens for political tribalism as practiced in the US - so what matters more than the truth is what becomes claimed to be the truth and who is claiming it, and how these claims discern the Good Guys from the Bad.

I'm just saying there's plenty of ways these school officials and their mayor have fed the fire here and made it easier for people motivated to imagine islamaphobia being an issue here to believe that to be true. Not just with the events of Ahmed but in other ways as well - such as the board issuing a 70+ page report on the potential covert infiltration of Islamism in the school curriculum and the Mayor staking a political gambit on the prevention of Sharia law (as proxy for the Islamist takeover).

And note, any Texans feeling embarrassed about being imagined to be an "islamaphobic state", that I am speaking from Canada - where our recent election campaign earned some of the same condescending shaking heads of do-gooder Liberals, wondering "what's wrong with Canada?" to have engaged in such a tawdry anti-muslim election campaign -> on top of the recent offenses of introducing the world to Rob Ford and Justin Beiber, our stock is not so high on the Left Wing Stock Market anymore!

In any event, I just stepped in to share that awesome episode of Rationally Speaking on why empathy is overrated and to troll you guys a bit.

I hope it was as much fun for you as it was for me! ;)
 
Last edited:
I posted that in a tongue in cheek way as a bit of a troll - but to isolate the events with Ahmed on that day: it was an incredible over-reaction, so this is what makes it easy for them to earn the label "islamaphobe", because people will imagine that they overreacted precisely because this kid was known as "ISIS Boy", was a muslim - and because they had just seen True Lies the weekend before. I know Bill Maher believes the reaction to have been justified given the broader atmosphere of terrorism and/or school shootings - and these are probably in the mix. However its easy to imagine additional motivations involving fever dreams of Islamic terror and the boy's religion playing a part as well.

In any event, this whole thing has become a lens for political tribalism as practiced in the US - so what matters more than the truth is what becomes claimed to be the truth and who is claiming it, and how these claims discern the Good Guys from the Bad.

I'm just saying there's plenty of ways these school officials and their mayor have fed the fire here and made it easier for people motivated to imagine islamaphobia being an issue here to believe that to be true. Not just with the events of Ahmed but in other ways as well - such as the board issuing a 70+ page report on the potential covert infiltration of Islamism in the school curriculum and the Mayor staking a political gambit on the prevention of Sharia law (as proxy for the Islamist takeover).

And note, any Texans feeling embarrassed about being imagined to be an "islamaphobic state", that I am speaking from Canada - where our recent election campaign earned some of the same condescending shaking heads of do-gooder Liberals, wondering "what's wrong with Canada?" to have engaged in such a tawdry anti-muslim election campaign -> on top of the recent offenses of introducing the world to Rob Ford and Justin Beiber, our stock is not so high on the Left Wing Stock Market anymore!

In any event, I just stepped in to share that awesome episode of Rationally Speaking on why empathy is overrated and to troll you guys a bit.

I hope it was as much fun for you as it was for me! ;)

<SNIP>
Edited by jsfisher: 
Edited for compliance with Rule 11 of the Membership Agreement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Another way the school officials and the cops could have prevented outsiders from imagining them to be islamophobes is to not have handled the situation with the kid and the clock in an islamophobic way.

I mean that would have been a good start! ;)

A good start would not be lumping the "school officials' in with the police.


I mean seriously at this point people are just playing games. We've had school shooting after school shooting go down and it's not been Muslims pulling them off. It's been predominantly white kids.

The arguments in this thread are just stupid. We all know that regardless if the teacher supposed she knew what the device was, she had to turn it in. End of story.

Why? Because of the way parents react to liability issues.


The only way the Islamaphobia angle works is if you drag in the police and the mayor. That's called what again?


Equivocation
 
The only way the Islamaphobia angle works is if you drag in the police and the mayor. That's called what again?

Could be unfair - but they didn't help themselves by calling the police in the first place.

But I mean, seems to be a trend too even when Islamaphobia (or accusations thereof) arent involved, like those horror stories about kids being arrested for picking up a stick on the ground and pretending its a gun while on recess... ( I did that how many times??)

All I'm saying is they didn't help themselves that much by overreacting as they did - if the kid was being manipulative to make a point they walked RIGHT into it.

So i admit I have less empathy (or perhaps sympathy is a better word!) than I otherwise would since this also speaks to a general level of incompetence/lack of awareness on their part as well.

The best, most charitable interpretation is that they sleepwalked into a cluster-duck and engineered their own demise in the public image through their actions. The reaction is over the top in many respects too - I understand they are getting harassment fairly often, some of it threatening violence. In that respect, they do earn some amount of sympathy I realize I must now confess!
 
What exactly was Islamophobic? We only have Ahmed's side of the story, and even he didn't claim that they referred to his religion or asked any specific questions it.

It's OK to slander southerners, big brush them as bigots and stereotype their styles but Allah forbid that you utter one word of criticism of Islam.
 
Ahmed's.

As a minor, the police should not have been questioning him without a parent or guardian present. At one point, Ahmed even asked if he could call his parents; the police denied him that right. And that's setting aside how ridiculous it was to call the police to begin with.

Where are the lawsuits? If civil rights were violated and laws broken why aren't lawyers flocking to file these high profile and likely very lucrative cases?
 
My brief google search tells me that it is not. In fact, it's not even improper or unusual for police to question children without parental consent. I think this refers to California law, but I doubt Texas law constrains police more than California law does.


That is an interesting case. It seems to hinge entirely on the claim that the minor waived his Miranda rights when being interrogated, and that in the court's opinion he was mature enough to be able to make that judgement call.

I know a lot of adults aren't mature enough to make that call. In fact it is a technique frequently employed by police when interrogating suspects, where they suggest that prosecutors will be much harder on the suspect if they don't cooperate right away, and instead choose to ask for a lawyer.
 
My brief google search tells me that it is not. In fact, it's not even improper or unusual for police to question children without parental consent. I think this refers to California law, but I doubt Texas law constrains police more than California law does.

According to this, it might or might not be "improper or unusual" for cops to question minors alone depending on the specific circumstances.
http://criminal.findlaw.com/juvenile-justice/police-questioning-of-minors.html

But in this particular case, the kid asked to call his father and was refused. That's what is unlawful.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articl...civil-rights-by-keeping-away-his-parents.html
 
Where are the lawsuits? If civil rights were violated and laws broken why aren't lawyers flocking to file these high profile and likely very lucrative cases?

I don't know how many such cases there really are. When a kid's interrogation results in an arrest I suspect the main legal focus becomes excluding whatever he said from the criminal proceedings.

But there are civil lawsuits:
http://www.oregonlive.com/beaverton/index.ssf/2014/05/parent_sues_beaverton_school_d.html
http://www.wfmj.com/story/15421592/youngstown-mother-sues
http://www.today.com/parents/maryland-free-range-parents-cleared-neglect-t27901
http://www.policeone.com/juvenile-crime/articles/2097290-Parents-sue-police-over-8-year-olds-arrest/

What's really chilling is that if you Google "parents sue police," most of the cases are situations where police killed children.
 
My brief google search tells me that it is not. In fact, it's not even improper or unusual for police to question children without parental consent. I think this refers to California law, but I doubt Texas law constrains police more than California law does.

According to this, it might or might not be "improper or unusual" for cops to question minors alone depending on the specific circumstances.
http://criminal.findlaw.com/juvenile-justice/police-questioning-of-minors.html

But in this particular case, the kid asked to call his father and was refused. That's what is unlawful.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articl...civil-rights-by-keeping-away-his-parents.html

This. The moment Ahmed asked to call his parents his rights were being violated when the police refused to allow him to do so. The police can question minors, but they are required to allow them to call their parents or a lawyer (or both) if the minor expresses that wish. It goes along with the whole "everyone is entitled to representation" gig that the law mandates. The police refused to allow Ahmed to call his parents; they therefore violated his civil rights. Simple as that.
 
This. The moment Ahmed asked to call his parents his rights were being violated when the police refused to allow him to do so. The police can question minors, but they are required to allow them to call their parents or a lawyer (or both) if the minor expresses that wish. It goes along with the whole "everyone is entitled to representation" gig that the law mandates. The police refused to allow Ahmed to call his parents; they therefore violated his civil rights. Simple as that.

I love how people just google around until they find a news article that fits their views and present that as evidence without going to the primary sources actually linked in that article to determine if the author has his facts right.

In this case, he doesn't. Here is the link to the Texas statute. The section cited in the article in no way gives Mohammed the right to have his parents present before the police can interrogate or arrest him (technically, it's not called an arrest when a juvenile is involved, but it is treated as an arrest for purposes of probable cause and the like). The cited section clearly refers to the fact that a juvenile cannot be left unattended in a holding room, and that he is entitled to have a parent or guardian or attorney with him, but there is no requirement that the police contact the parent, guardian, or attorney or make sure they're there first. The context is clear that the police aren't allowed to exclude a parent, guardian, or attorney from the holding room, if they're already there, not that you can't put the kid in there without them. That would be a pretty ridiculous restriction, since the kid could prevent you from putting him in a holding room by just demanding to have a parent with him, even though the parent couldn't be located or was otherwise unavailable.
 
I love how people just google around until they find a news article that fits their views and present that as evidence without going to the primary sources actually linked in that article to determine if the author has his facts right.

In this case, he doesn't. Here is the link to the Texas statute. The section cited in the article in no way gives Mohammed the right to have his parents present before the police can interrogate or arrest him (technically, it's not called an arrest when a juvenile is involved, but it is treated as an arrest for purposes of probable cause and the like).
.....

What you've cited describes circumstances in which police may hold a minor in custody. Where does it say that they may interrogate him in connection with potential criminal charges without a parent or lawyer present, and may refuse his request to call a parent or lawyer? Why would a minor have fewer rights against the police than an adult?

And you seem to have missed this part:
(b)A person taking a child into custody shall promptly give
notice of the person ’s action and a statement of the reason for
taking the child into custody, to:
(1) the child ’s parent, guardian, or custodian; and
(2) the office or official designated by the juvenile
board.

And from the story I cited:

The executive director of the Texas chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union said that answer is not good enough.

“Once they’re being questioned, they have a right to refuse answering,” Terri Burke told The Daily Beast. “And, unless it’s something like a traffic violation, [police] immediately need to release the child to their parents.”

At the very least, Mohamed should have been able to speak with his parents.

“If a child seeks to have a short conference with his parents, [the police] cannot deny them that. He has a right to talk to them. Kids don’t lose their rights because they’re kids or because they live in Texas.”[
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articl...civil-rights-by-keeping-away-his-parents.html
 
Last edited:
Where are the lawsuits? If civil rights were violated and laws broken why aren't lawyers flocking to file these high profile and likely very lucrative cases?
I think if his rights were violated there would already be a lawsuit or at least a statement from the lawyers that his rights were violated. They did hire lawyers in September to look into the situation.
 
What you've cited describes circumstances in which police may hold a minor in custody. Where does it say that they may interrogate him in connection with potential criminal charges without a parent or lawyer present, and may refuse his request to call a parent or lawyer? Why would a minor have fewer rights against the police than an adult?

An adult doesn't have a right to have a lawyer present when he's interrogated. He does have a right to keep his mouth shut, however, until he does have a lawyer present, and even then. You're not even entitled to be reminded of your Miranda rights. It's just that if you aren't, anything you say can't be used against you as evidence in a court of law.

And you seem to have missed this part:

Depends on the definition of "promptly." I think within a couple of hours is pretty prompt, for all intents and purposes. Since his sister was allowed to be there and take a picture of Ahmed while he was still in handcuffs, it sure doesn't seem like a lot of time elapsed during which Ahmed was squirreled away in some CIA black site.



First of all, the police didn't deny Ahmed the right to talk to his parents. They only denied (allegedly) him the right to talk to them immediately when he requested. I don't see anywhere in the statute that demands they interrupt an interrogation or an arrest to find the kids' parents. That seems impractical. Second, I would take what an ACLU lawyer says in a news story with a large grain of salt. They tend to exaggerate since a large part of their job is political.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom