Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

He got in the news because he brought something that a normal teacher would consider suspicious (teachers are not bomb experts).

It's some electronics in a small box. What makes it suspicious to a reasonable person? Unless you are suggesting that "normal" teachers, by definition, are not reasonable people? What makes other random objects, also showing no indications of being a bomb, not suspicious?

The point is, de-casing or case modding a wall-plug alarm clock does not represent bomb making. You're farther away from having a working bomb than when you started.

Exactly!
 
What exactly was Islamophobic? We only have Ahmed's side of the story, and even he didn't claim that they referred to his religion or asked any specific questions it.

That's not true. We also have the police side of the story. It is a side of the story which accused him of making a hoax device even as they maintained that he never claimed the device to be a bomb.

You say that there was no probable cause, except that the police (who are professionals trained in what probable cause actually means) thought there was. Maybe they were wrong, but until a judge or a jury decides, I don't think you're justified in making that claim. As far as I can tell, the family seems not to be pursuing legal action. In fact, the family seems to be skedaddling on out of the US with surprising alacrity.

They were called and they had an obligation to respond. Beyond that, and given that they had seen the device and that they acknowledge that at not time did anyone named Ahmed ever suggest it was anything other than a clock, they had probable cause for what? Probable cause, how?
 
"I’m going to be really big on the Internet one day,” Mohamed told Kubiak.
​


Careful what you wish for...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Qatar#Human_rights
The political system of Qatar is an absolute monarchy, with the Emir of Qatar as head of state and head of government. Under the 2003 constitutional referendum it should become a constitutional monarchy. Sharia Law is the main source of Qatari legislation according to Qatar's Constitution.

How could moving you and your family to Qatar from the US be a good move for a parent to make? Some other Mohamed is bound to make the news here soon and steal the negative attention from the kid. I'll bet the daughter is thrilled with the idea.
​
 
The point is, de-casing or case modding a wall-plug alarm clock does not represent bomb making. You're farther away from having a working bomb clock than when you started.

You had a clock, now you have clock parts in a box.
 
Careful what you wish for...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Qatar#Human_rights


How could moving you and your family to Qatar from the US be a good move for a parent to make? Some other Mohamed is bound to make the news here soon and steal the negative attention from the kid. I'll bet the daughter is thrilled with the idea.
[/COLOR][/LEFT]

What would the status of non-citizen, non-Arab Sudanese be in Qatar?
 
Could be unfair - but they didn't help themselves by calling the police in the first place.

I have addressed this many times. They didn’t “call the police”. The school participates in the School Resource Officer (SRO) program. That means the police are already there. An SRO is a cop assigned to a school. The SRO controls traffic before and after school, patrols school grounds during the day, attends school functions like football and basketball games, generally has an office in the school, and is responsible for any potential criminal activity in or around the school.

If a student is getting harassing messages from another student and reports it to the school, that goes to the SRO. If a teacher reports a rumor that Jimmy and Billy are going to have a fist fight at the local park after school, that goes to the SRO. Keyed cars, items stolen from lockers, bring a knife to school, smoking in the boy’s room, in some cases cutting class—all goes to the SRO.

Something of this nature would definitely go to the SRO. That means the police were involved, not because the school decided this was a matter beyond their scope where they had to bring in the cops, but because they already had cops there (the SROs) who were responsible for handling this type of matter.
 
People ain't gonna let a little thing called "facts" get in the way of their "thinking"

Everybody knows that the cops are biased

Everybody knows that the schools are too

Everybody knows that the South is racist

That's why they hang a black or two

That's how it goes and everybody knows.
 
I have addressed this many times. They didn’t “call the police”. The school participates in the School Resource Officer (SRO) program. That means the police are already there. An SRO is a cop assigned to a school. The SRO controls traffic before and after school, patrols school grounds during the day, attends school functions like football and basketball games, generally has an office in the school, and is responsible for any potential criminal activity in or around the school.

If a student is getting harassing messages from another student and reports it to the school, that goes to the SRO. If a teacher reports a rumor that Jimmy and Billy are going to have a fist fight at the local park after school, that goes to the SRO. Keyed cars, items stolen from lockers, bring a knife to school, smoking in the boy’s room, in some cases cutting class—all goes to the SRO.

Something of this nature would definitely go to the SRO. That means the police were involved, not because the school decided this was a matter beyond their scope where they had to bring in the cops, but because they already had cops there (the SROs) who were responsible for handling this type of matter.


The SRO are not the police? Because they are police assigned to the school?

Referring a matter to the SRO in the school as opposed to not referring it to them and addressing it without their involvement is not 'calling the police' because they are police in the school?

Seems like one of those distinctions without a difference.

Less discriminating minds might just see the SRO as a cop who is closer than the ones at the police station.

Which, if I am not mistaken is the point of the SRO program to begin with.
 
The SRO are not the police? Because they are police assigned to the school?

Referring a matter to the SRO in the school as opposed to not referring it to them and addressing it without their involvement is not 'calling the police' because they are police in the school?

Seems like one of those distinctions without a difference.

An SRO is a police officer. But there is a difference. People keep questioning whether the school should have called the police.

If the school did not have an SRO, this type of matter would have been handled by school officials—probably the Principal or Vice-Principal. The school official would only call the police if they believed that charges needed to be filed or that a criminal investigation was needed. In that case, it would be reasonable to question whether the school officials should have called the police.

But for a school with an SRO, there is no such decision made by the school. When the issue is reported to the school officials, they turn it over to the SRO because that is who handles such issues at the school.
 
An SRO is a police officer. But there is a difference. People keep questioning whether the school should have called the police.

If the school did not have an SRO, this type of matter would have been handled by school officials—probably the Principal or Vice-Principal. The school official would only call the police if they believed that charges needed to be filed or that a criminal investigation was needed. In that case, it would be reasonable to question whether the school officials should have called the police.

But for a school with an SRO, there is no such decision made by the school. When the issue is reported to the school officials, they turn it over to the SRO because that is who handles such issues at the school.

This is not 100% true, because of the definition of "such issues". An example will illustrate.

Suppose someone puts a whoopee cushion on a desk in class. The resulting sound disrupts the class. That case is not handed over to the SRO.

Suppose someone's cell phone goes off in class. The resulting noise disrupts the class. That case is not handed over to the SRO.

Suppose someone takes a perfectly ordinary alarm clock and sets it to go off in class. That case isn't handed over to the SRO.

Suppose someone takes a homemade alarm clock that looks like a bomb and sets it to go off in class. That case is handed over to the SRO, except that in order for it to be handed over to the SRO, someone had to decide that it looked like a bomb. The school officials had to decide that there was an issue that warranted a criminal investigation before they handed it over to the SRO.

In my opinion, that's a forgivable mistake on the school's part. Paranoia is a way of life, so why not be extra suspicious. Besides, they aren't supposed to know everything about either bombs or the law. As soon as they have the slightest doubt, call the SRO. Ok.

Of course it would have been cool for them to admit the mistake the next day, instead of writing to parents telling them that this would be a good time to review the forbidden items list, even though that thing wasn't on the forbidden items list.
 
Anything of potentially illegal activity would be turned over to the SRO without the school officials investigating. It would be the job of the SRO to investigate. That does not include violations of school policy that are not violations of the law such as cheating on a test, chewing gum in class, talking back to a teacher, etc. In this case, a teacher reported to the school officials that a student had a device that was “possibly the infrastructure of a bomb”. That would be potential illegal activity that would be turned over to the SRO for investigation.

We can question whether or not the teacher should have reported that, but I don’t think there is any question that once it was reported to the school officials that the matter would be turned over to the SRO for investigation. If the school didn’t have an SRO, then the school officials would have investigated and then we could question whether they should have called the cops based on their investigation.
 
Anything of potentially illegal activity would be turned over to the SRO without the school officials investigating. It would be the job of the SRO to investigate. That does not include violations of school policy that are not violations of the law such as cheating on a test, chewing gum in class, talking back to a teacher, etc. In this case, a teacher reported to the school officials that a student had a device that was “possibly the infrastructure of a bomb”. That would be potential illegal activity that would be turned over to the SRO for investigation.

We can question whether or not the teacher should have reported that, but I don’t think there is any question that once it was reported to the school officials that the matter would be turned over to the SRO for investigation. If the school didn’t have an SRO, then the school officials would have investigated and then we could question whether they should have called the cops based on their investigation.


That's a really roundabout way of agreeing that they called the nearest cop.

Like I said, a distinction without a difference.
 
Without an SRO, the school officials investigate this type of issue.

With an SRO, the SRO investigates this type of issue.

That is the distinction.

With an SRO, the school officials only determine whether the reported incident is a matter of violation of law or violation of school policy. If it is a matter of law, they turn it over to the SRO without investigating or even determining whether an investigation is warranted. That is the SRO’s job.

I already gave some examples. If a teacher reports that Billy and Jimmy are going fight after school, the principal would talk to the students and try to work things out. The principal wouldn’t call the cops. But if the school has a SRO, the school would just turn the matter over to the SRO. That is different from a school deciding to call the cops over a possible future fist fight.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom