Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

So what has the police department said regarding the weight of evidence supporting the perception (a perception apparently motivating his arrest) that he intended to provoke alarm?

Because as I am seeing it, we have a case here of some folk considering the suggestion that police may have acted incompetently to be an outrageous one (because they are the experts at policing, and experts wouldn't act incompetently, I guess,... so,... QED) and being outraged that good skeptical folk would not give the police the benefit of the doubt (if someone is in handcuffs, they must have done something, after all). And yet these same good folk seem to consider the police as a source that cannot be relied upon when they release a statement regarding the incident saying that nope, that hoaxing thing,... it didn't happen.

Well, I like to reserve judgment on these things until I have enough information. Unfortunately, because Ahmed is a juvenile, and because he was a student of the school, neither the police nor the school officials can give their side of the story without the permission of Ahmed's guardians. And Ahmed's guardians are not granting permission. Some people might actually read something into that refusal to grant permission, and not something that reflects well on the accuracy of Ahmed's version of events.
 
Well, I like to reserve judgment on these things until I have enough information. Unfortunately, because Ahmed is a juvenile, and because he was a student of the school, neither the police nor the school officials can give their side of the story without the permission of Ahmed's guardians. And Ahmed's guardians are not granting permission. Some people might actually read something into that refusal to grant permission, and not something that reflects well on the accuracy of Ahmed's version of events.

Never mind Ahmed's version of events. The police have made a statement and in this statement they've made it clear that at no time did he say that the device was anything but a clock and in this statement they say that there's no evidence supporting the perception that he intended to provoke alarm.

So now we have a "hoax bomb" which was never said to be a bomb and which was never intended to cause alarm.

By this point, we are forced to believe that he had a secret mission implanted, Total Recall style. He was supposed to create a hoax bomb by bringing in a device that looked no more like a bomb than any other random object that you might have around the house and telling people that he showed the device to that it was something other than a bomb. And yet, being that he is a clever Muslim, he would know that someone would interpret it to be not a bomb, but a hoax bomb, and thus subject the school to ridicule (since the device is, in fact, a box with non-remarkable electronic parts). Of course, he would know none of this consciously.

He is now about to return to his Qatari overseers to be debriefed under hypnosis. After that, the cyclopean underground CO2 factory will be activated to trigger a runaway greenhouse effect that will transform the climate into one more suitable for the reptiloid alien overlords who actually run Qatar.

I guess we can't rule out any of that. :rolleyes:
 
Never mind Ahmed's version of events. The police have made a statement and in this statement they've made it clear that at no time did he say that the device was anything but a clock and in this statement they say that there's no evidence supporting the perception that he intended to provoke alarm.

So now we have a "hoax bomb" which was never said to be a bomb and which was never intended to cause alarm.

By this point, we are forced to believe that he had a secret mission implanted, Total Recall style. He was supposed to create a hoax bomb by bringing in a device that looked no more like a bomb than any other random object that you might have around the house and telling people that he showed the device to that it was something other than a bomb. And yet, being that he is a clever Muslim, he would know that someone would interpret it to be not a bomb, but a hoax bomb, and thus subject the school to ridicule (since the device is, in fact, a box with non-remarkable electronic parts). Of course, he would know none of this consciously.

He is now about to return to his Qatari overseers to be debriefed under hypnosis. After that, the cyclopean underground CO2 factory will be activated to trigger a runaway greenhouse effect that will transform the climate into one more suitable for the reptiloid alien overlords who actually run Qatar.

I guess we can't rule out any of that. :rolleyes:


It is at least as plausible as the idea that an SRO isn't a cop.

More, mebbe.
 
But this still dances around the issue. Yes, every "such issue" goes to the SRO.

But someone still has to decide that a particular incident is a "such issue".

As I put it many pages ago, they are required to report all suspicious items, but they aren't required to be suspicious when they see a clock. It's not a huge deal in my mind that they contacted the SRO. After all, there's no reason to expect that every teacher would instantly recognize that the device is harmless.

The school officials would determine whether this particular incident was a "such issue" based on the nature of the report of the incident. In this case, the teacher reported that a student was in possession of a suspicious device that was possibly the infrastructure of a bomb. That is a report of a potential violation of law rather than a potential violation of school rules, so it goes to the SRO. The school officials don’t really make a judgment as to whether the teacher’s report is valid; that is up to the SRO to determine.

Whether or not the teacher should have reported the device as being possibly the infrastructure of a bomb is questionable. But once the teacher makes that report, it is not really questionable that the school officials turned it over to the SRO to investigate.
 
The reason that the device and situation was turned over to the cops, SROs or whatever the heck you want to call it, is that the STUDENT refused to cooperate with the principal.

Remember, this has been stated as much as possible by both the school and the police and has never been disputed by Ahmed.

Where do you get that? I don’t recall hearing anything about the principal (only “school officials”), and never heard anything about the student not cooperating with the principal or school officials; only that he was not cooperating with the police (the two SROs, their sergeant, and another sergeant that happened to come along).

The situation was turned over to the SROs because that is who handles this type of situation at the school. The student was arrested because he wouldn’t tell the police his intentions with the device.
 
That's not true. The cops didn't like his answer that it was merely a clock. They wanted to know what it was, why he built it, why he brought it to school, and what he used it for but weren't happy when he told them the truth: it's a clock, I like to build things, to show my teacher, to tell time.

That is not what he told the police. He did not tell the police that he likes to build things. He did not tell the police that he brought it to show his teacher. He did not tell the police that he used it to tell time. According to the police statement, he would only say that it was a clock and was not forthcoming with any other details. Therefore, without any other information to go on, he was arrested for possession of a hoax bomb (defined as a device intended to cause alarm or draw attention from law enforcement in any way).
 
My underwear might appear to be (at least to some people) a possible infrastructure for a bomb (or something that could be used as a hoax bomb) but that's no reason to arrest me for not going commando.

Yes. It is subjective. There are also many factors involved such as the person’s behavior and the specific circumstances. What one person finds suspicious or alarming, may not be to another person.

We have seen this with other incidents at schools, such as the kid arrested for writing a story about killing a dinosaur.

This case is a bit more clear-cut. The student acknowledges that before he brought it to school he knew it looked like “a threat” and “suspicious” (that’s why he closed it with a cable instead of using the lock). It does somewhat resemble a Hollywood style briefcase bomb (sans explosives). The engineering teacher presumably recognized that it was just a clock, but also presumably recognized that to other it may look like a bomb because he told the student not to show it to other teachers.

We don’t know what motivated the English teacher to report it as being possibly the infrastructure for a bomb. That teacher may be overly suspicious by nature. Or that teacher may be a huge Islamophobia who thinks all Arabs are terrorists and that it therefore must be a bomb in the making. Or maybe a combination of both. We don’t know.
 
That is not what he told the police. He did not tell the police that he likes to build things. He did not tell the police that he brought it to show his teacher. He did not tell the police that he used it to tell time. According to the police statement, he would only say that it was a clock and was not forthcoming with any other details. Therefore, without any other information to go on, he was arrested for possession of a hoax bomb (defined as a device intended to cause alarm or draw attention from law enforcement in any way).


Any chance we can get you to share the transcripts you have of Ahmed's interrogation by the police?

After all, you wouldn't be trying to to extrapolate all of that from a police statement to the press.

Would you?
 
So what has the police department said regarding the weight of evidence supporting the perception (a perception apparently motivating his arrest) that he intended to provoke alarm?

The police said that the student was not forthcoming with information about his intentions when questioned, and therefore was arrested pending further investigation, and that they later discovered through the media that the student’s intentions were to show a home electronics project and not to cause alarm, and that therefore there was no basis for the charge of a hoax bomb and the charges were dropped.

ETA: The police also said something along the lines that if someone had a hoax bomb that they would expect the suspect to lie and maintain that it was just something innocent like a clock. Something to that effect -- I don't have the exact quote handy.
 
Last edited:
Any chance we can get you to share the transcripts you have of Ahmed's interrogation by the police?

After all, you wouldn't be trying to to extrapolate all of that from a police statement to the press.

Would you?

Yes. I am extrapolating that from the police Chief’s public statement that “the student would only say that it was a clock and was not forthcoming at that time about any other details.” I have not heard anything from Ahmed that contradicts that statement.
 
Yes. I am extrapolating that from the police Chief’s public statement that “the student would only say that it was a clock and was not forthcoming at that time about any other details.” I have not heard anything from Ahmed that contradicts that statement.

What else is he meant to have said but "it's a clock" to the question of "what is it?"
 
Yes. It is subjective. There are also many factors involved such as the person’s behavior and the specific circumstances. What one person finds suspicious or alarming, may not be to another person.

So where do you draw the line? It seems like it could be arbitrarily drawn anywhere (and that it was) and that some people are perfectly fine with that. Is there any due process here? Should there be? Should reason play any role in this whatsoever?

We have seen this with other incidents at schools, such as the kid arrested for writing a story about killing a dinosaur.

And such cases are also unreasonable.

This case is a bit more clear-cut. The student acknowledges that before he brought it to school he knew it looked like “a threat” and “suspicious” (that’s why he closed it with a cable instead of using the lock).

Are you sure about this? What is the timeline? Are you just repeating the assumption of conservative reports playing gotcha games (and taking things out of context) that was made because it fit in with a story they wanted to hear (dangerous jihadi child playing dumb but caught in a lie by the clever people at Breitbart.com --or whatever) or is the actual timeline that, at some point in the day, he became aware that some might think that it looked like a "threat" because a teacher told him exactly this?

It's funny how this seems to be a litmus test with authoritarian types wanting to see one particular story and others not so much.

It does somewhat resemble a Hollywood style briefcase bomb (sans explosives).

It's a box! OK, it's a box with a handle!

By the way, we have a name for a briefcase bomb without explosives in the English language. It's called a "briefcase" (which is not what this looked like since it was way too small).

As it happens, my underwear also looks like an underwear bomb without explosives.

The engineering teacher presumably recognized that it was just a clock, but also presumably recognized that to other it may look like a bomb because he told the student not to show it to other teachers.

Bizarrely, what the police reported was that three teachers reported this alleged threat.

The police said that the student was not forthcoming with information about his intentions when questioned, and therefore was arrested pending further investigation,

And what does "being forthcoming" look like when you are being intentionally intimidated by being tossed in a room with at least five officers and being asked about your "bomb" or "hoax bomb"? What does it look like when you might genuinely think that there's really not much to say about it (despite his use of the word "invention", the videos where he talks about it do not strike one as a person talking about something very special --instead he seems to characterize it as a very simple project). If you get dragged out of your class by the principal and a police officer and get tossed in with five officers, are you going to be composed? If you are not composed, would this be something that might be expected under these circumstances or are we going to end up with a situation where being composed would also be taken as evidence of being guilty of something?

I know that I am not 14 and that if I suddenly became faced with even one officer (much less five) asking me about alleged bomb making (or hoax bomb making) activities I would be even less forthcoming than Ahmed. Knowing what I know about how these things can turn out, and knowing that I have rights and so forth, I would probably ask to speak with an attorney and refuse to make further comments. This is probably the safest course of action anyone can take under these circumstances. The chances of your situation being improved by "cooperating" with police under these circumstances are sufficiently offset by the chances of your situation being greatly worsened that risking arrest (which might easily happen anyway even with cooperation --all they have to say is that they believed that you were lying and this amounts to some sort of non-cooperation which in turn amounts to an excuse to be able to claim probable cause for something) and hoping that you can get things sorted out later might be the optimal course of action. That does not make such an arrest reasonable, however.

and that they later discovered through the media that the student’s intentions were to show a home electronics project and not to cause alarm, and that therefore there was no basis for the charge of a hoax bomb and the charges were dropped.

You are doing it again. :rolleyes: The whole arrest, the calling for backup, etc. is a reasonable response because the police would not respond unreasonably. At the same time, you are dismissing the officer's comments regarding how there was no evidence of an intent to cause alarm as merely a police department spokesperson repeating media reports and not really representing any sort of investigation (that's not what he says, by the way --correctly or incorrectly, you are making an inference here and the inference implies that you believe the officer to be unreliable).
 
The school officials would determine whether this particular incident was a "such issue" based on the nature of the report of the incident. In this case, the teacher reported that a student was in possession of a suspicious device that was possibly the infrastructure of a bomb. That is a report of a potential violation of law rather than a potential violation of school rules, so it goes to the SRO. The school officials don’t really make a judgment as to whether the teacher’s report is valid; that is up to the SRO to determine.

Whether or not the teacher should have reported the device as being possibly the infrastructure of a bomb is questionable. But once the teacher makes that report, it is not really questionable that the school officials turned it over to the SRO to investigate.

Agreed. Once someone reports it as possibly criminal, it has to go to the SRO.

And whoever makes the report is the person we can laugh at.

And we know that the principal, in his letter home to parents the following day suggested that they review the prohibited items policy, so we know that we can laugh at him, too.

And we know that the police arrested him despite there being no evidence of a crime, so we can point and laugh at them, too, except that once handcuffs come out, it's not quite as funny.
 
Yes. I am extrapolating that from the police Chief’s public statement that “the student would only say that it was a clock and was not forthcoming at that time about any other details.” I have not heard anything from Ahmed that contradicts that statement.

The thing I don't understand is what "other details" were they looking for?

All he would tell them is that it was a clock. Maybe that's because it was a clock.

As for how the interrogation went, a lot of people say we have only one side of the story. That's not true. We have zero sides of the story. Ahmed and his family were pretty tight lipped about it, but we know that he told them it was a clock, which makes sense to me, because it was a clock. You are right that we have no evidence that he told them that its purpose was to tell time, but that's what clocks do, so maybe he used different words, such as "It's a clock."

I'm guessing that Ahmed's answers might have been influenced somewhat by his emotional state at the time, which, for a normal person, would include some combination of confusion, fear, and anger. However, that requires speculation.
 
Never mind Ahmed's version of events. The police have made a statement and in this statement they've made it clear that at no time did he say that the device was anything but a clock and in this statement they say that there's no evidence supporting the perception that he intended to provoke alarm.

At the same time, they insist that the arrest was proper, which means, at the time, there was probable cause. After further investigation, they determined that their evidence that it was a hoax bomb (e.g. Ahmed's reluctance to be forthcoming, and his "passive-aggressiveness") had an innocent explanation, and was not due to a desire to cover up the fact that he intended to cause alarm. I think you read too much into their statement that there's no evidence supporting the charge. Kind of like with Bill Clinton's interpretation of the word "is," there is now no evidence. It is not the case that there was no evidence on September 14, 2015.

So now we have a "hoax bomb" which was never said to be a bomb and which was never intended to cause alarm.

But it was believed to have been intended to cause alarm at the time of the arrest. People seem to forget that Ahmed wasn't actually charged with anything. He was arrested. That is all. Hundreds of innocent people are arrested every day in this country, many of them teenagers. The hope is that all of them are released without charge, although, unfortunately, we know that's not true.

<snip not particularly clever nonsense>

I guess we can't rule out any of that. :rolleyes:

We can of course. What we can't rule out is that Ahmed acted suspiciously because he did have the intent to cause trouble (although not necessarily do anything illegal). We also can't rule out that the school and police would have acted exactly the same way if Ahmed were white and named Billy-Bob. It is also possible that Ahmed is steeped in Muslim victimhood and decided to exacerbate the incident once it became clear there was an opportunity to do so. The family seems to be quite media savvy after all, and they have milked this incident far beyond what I thought possible.
 
What else is he meant to have said but "it's a clock" to the question of "what is it?"

I'm willing to bet that the police asked other questions besides "what is it?" For example, "why did you bring this to school?" is likely to have been asked. And the response "it's a clock" is not an adequate answer to that question.
 
Agreed. Once someone reports it as possibly criminal, it has to go to the SRO.

And whoever makes the report is the person we can laugh at.

And we know that the principal, in his letter home to parents the following day suggested that they review the prohibited items policy, so we know that we can laugh at him, too.

And we know that the police arrested him despite there being no evidence of a crime, so we can point and laugh at them, too, except that once handcuffs come out, it's not quite as funny.

It's kind of weird that you want to laugh at the teacher. Not only did Ahmed interrupt her class intentionally, but he had something that did not look remotely like anything that is normal to have in school. The people who are claiming it looked like a clock, and only a clock, are suffering from hindsight bias. Even if the display did clock-like things, there was no reason to believe that it was only a clock and didn't do anything else that could be disruptive to the school environment. On top of that, it was actually dangerous, as many in this thread have noted. It was both an electrical shock hazard and a fire hazard, since it could be (and was) connected to A/C power without proper shielding of hot wires and without proper mounting of the transformer.

In any event, this incident went viral not because it was an alleged case of school official stupidity, which are legion, but because it was an alleged case of Islamophobia. You may think it's appropriate to point and laugh at the English teacher, but Ahmed did not get invited to the White House because he had a stupid teacher.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom