Let's start with just a few questions that I asked before, but I hope you will answer simply so that we know where we agree and where we disagree:
1. Do we agree that there is solid, documented evidence that Ahmed was arrested in handcuffs for a hoax bomb? And that after questioning at the police station for an extended period of time without his parents or a lawyer, he was released?
SPOILERS IN PLACE FOR BREVITY
YEP and I've only said a hundred gazillion times that I think the cops ********** up but hey lets pretend I haven't said that over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over again.
So are you clear now?
Yep but based on what I know about protocol and what I have seen with the support of the School Board I assumed it was for "disrupting the learning environment"
What's funny about this is I said this BEFORE I learned that he was previously suspended for doing the bubble schtick. But hey! People don't want to believe you when you're right all the time.
So why let it bother me now right?
Now as to my point in this post:
you are the one inferring (to be kind,
I like your use of the word "inferring" and I'd agree with you there.
I have never seen anyone suspended for 3 days for bringing in an electronic project
Well I'll just say this. You haven't told us where you teach so I've got two options here.
Either you work in a very small town or you've been retired for some time now.
I'm gonna guess the latter.
I'm gonna guess the latter because based on what you're writing you are talking PRE COLUMBINE and the world has changed.
We just had ANOTHER school shooting in Oregon this week. Teachers are now finding themselves in the position of protecting the SAFETY of the students from other STUDENTS in the classroom in a way that didn't really exist before.
Obviously most people don't give a rats ass what is like to feel like you have to hide in a closet with kids while people shoot up your school. But just the idea of this can create a psychological issue for teachers. They don't want to be called idiots and berated by others for over reaction. They don't want to upset parents. They don't want to wrongly accuse a child.
So zero tolerance and protocol seek to resolve these issues.
The only times I have ever seen someone suspended has been if the student starting fighting with the teacher
I work in NYC so perhaps I have a different paradigm. Most of your stories seem very dramatic to me.
Over crowded classrooms and kids "pranking" can create a situation that disrupts the learning environment.
Your situations do not match what we see in schools here. Where do you work?
As I posted more than once-
Yep no one thought it was a bomb. Thank you for conceding this point.
But let me suggest a concept that we might compromise on: the school thought that Ahmed disrupted the class by bringing in a fake bomb. The school soon realized that it was just a clock. So they decided to list the suspension as "disrupting class" (of course it was the school that disrupted the class) rather than as "disrupting class by bringing in a fake bomb." In fact, I would be willing to bet that is the scenario. But here is the important point: I don't know what is the official cause of suspension. Meadmaker doesn't know. You don't know (unless you have a source you haven't identified). So we are all speculating as to the suspension. Meadmaker and I have acknowledged that. Will you?
No.
I don't concede. I think the teachers didn't think it was a fake bomb at all. I think they didn't KNOW what it was, what he was up to. He set the timer to go off in the class and he had a history of disrupting the class in the past and they wanted to know what he was up to.
I also think that although I am speculating the suspension, I have stated for over two weeks now that I think he was suspended for disrupting the classroom.
The reason I don't think he was suspended for a fake bomb threat is simply this
HIS PARENTS while speaking to the media and working the "fake bomb" angle, have not released the real reason for the suspension to the news.
We only found out about the "bubbles" suspension from another kid who spilled the beans.
I do not believe that if Ahmed had on his record that he brought a "hoax bomb" to school, that his parents would not release the records to the media in order to bolster their claim and their law suit.
I think they are NOT releasing their son's record because it will show precisely this
Ahmed has a history of being disruptive in the classroom.
He has suspensions in the past for doing some bubble schtick.
He was suspended for yet again,
disrupting the learning environment.
I am cheerfully awaiting to be proven wrong. But the more information that comes out, the more it backs up what I have said for over two weeks now.