Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Let me teach you a little trick. When truethat writes "From what you've read?", she's clearly drawing attention to the portion of Meadmaker's post where he used the words "from what I've read," and responding to that. Her entire post is clearly on the same, focused point, so she is only responding to that initial portion of Meadmaker's post. In that portion, he is discussing the school's response, not the police's. In fact, he makes a rather extraordinary (and I think, as truethat clearly does, baseless) assertion that three teachers signed a criminal complaint. Outside of this post, truethat has focused her attention on the response of the teachers and the school, since that is where her expertise lies. She has pretty consistently declined to defend or rationalize the actions of the police.

"Irving police released a report Tuesday that lists three MacArthur High teachers as complainants against the teen on the charge of “hoax bomb.”"
quoted from:http://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/Ir...-Accused-of-Making-a-Hoax-Bomb-327794401.html

Shall I try to find the police report itself?

Meadmaker stated that "from what I've (he) read." Truethat claimed that he made it up. Frankly not only is it apparently true, but even if was false as a fact it is still indeed something that Meadmaker read, rather than something he himself make up.

But I already tried to get away from this nonsensical discussion. I made a very straightforward statement in my prior post: we know why he was arrested, if not why he was suspended. Let's leave it there and see if Truethat agrees or not.

By the way I notice the Truethat has stated that she knows why he was suspended even though the school system is unwilling to provide that information to the public, so perhaps she can provide her source?
 
Last edited:
"Irving police released a report Tuesday that lists three MacArthur High teachers as complainants against the teen on the charge of “hoax bomb.”"
quoted from:http://www.nbcdfw.com/news/local/Ir...-Accused-of-Making-a-Hoax-Bomb-327794401.html

Shall I try to find the police report itself?

I would appreciate it. I can't find it myself, and I've found absolutely zero corroboration of the sentence you quoted from that story (which was from Wednesday, September 16th).
 
In fact, he makes a rather extraordinary (and I think, as truethat clearly does, baseless) assertion that three teachers signed a criminal complaint.

Extraordinary and baseless? I find your assertion of baselessness baseless. Giordano rapidly found a reference, as could anyone else interested. Here's one: http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/news/world/americas/article4558924.ece ) I haven't seen the actual report.

I also don't know the actual title of the form. I called it a "criminal complaint", as did one article I read. I don't know the actual title or the role that document played in the process of arresting Ahmed.
 
You mean at my office?



Yeah, it really was.



Yes, I mean at your office. And no, it really wasn't.



A simple warning would have been enough. But closing the entire corridor?



Once you realize that the actual purpose of closing the corridor was not to actually protect people from injury, but in fact to protect the building management and contractor from a judgment of negligence if someone had gotten injured, you'll realize that a sign would not have been enough. I'm confident that you'll then also realize that measures like that one are not "coddling" of individuals, but actually self-defensive actions on the part of those entities you currently mistake for being coddling.
 
Last edited:
I would appreciate it. I can't find it myself, and I've found absolutely zero corroboration of the sentence you quoted from that story (which was from Wednesday, September 16th).

I twice now posted that I wanted to return to the simple question of if people agree that it was documented that Ahmed was arrested for a "false bomb" threat, and I tried to move beyond a "he said she said" waste of everyone's time. But I am glad that we apparently agree that Meadmaker's cautious statement, and my quote of it, was correct: he certainly could have read that three teachers signed the police complaint- I cited the NBS news report that stated just thus, and is one of the places Meadmaker might have read this. He did not "make it up" as accused by Truethat.



I had trouble finding an electronic/on line copy of any police report involving this arrest to verify if indeed three teachers had signed it or not (possibly because of the litigation that is ongoing in this case); I presume the news reporters were provided a hard copy. But I did find a number of additional new reports that also claimed that the released police report cited three MacArthur High teachers as complainants, such as this one:http://www.theverge.com/2015/9/16/9335965/ahmed-mohamed-14-year-old-arrested-clock-hoax-bomb. I don't know when an electronic copy may become available (the current electronic records end in Feb 2013), but we have to wait to see if these news report quotes are accurate. But they are clearly news reports, including an established news source (NBC), and make it clear that Meadmaker likely did exactly what he posted: "from what I read" three teachers signed the complaint.

Edited: I see that Meadmaker has now provided yet another citation by which he likely read this statement, exactly as he had posted.
 
Last edited:
Three day suspension? I got that for setting a fire in a classroom. He got it for adults feeling fear of the unknown about his electronics research platform.

I just wanted to emphasize this. Based on my own experience as a teacher, that as a parent of once-teenage boys, and those of the many other teachers in my family, a three day suspension would not be handed out, for white kids for bringing a slightly distracting item as a science "project" to class. I don't know why officially Ahmed was suspended, but I don't see how, as Truethat claims, it would be in any way fair or normal to suspend any student because ignorant adults misinterpreted his clock project and refused to believe his accurate and fully logical explanation. But of course my own experiences did not involve a dark skin Muslim in Texas.
 
Yeah it's his skin color. Let's just stick with that.

Yeah.

I love this argument ....it's his SKIN COLOR

It shows how reductive people's arguments get. How patently outside the paradigm of intelligence.


It's his skin color. Let's keep saying that. Say it in a husky voice "it's his SKIN COLOR brrrr" "It's his skin color...grrrrr" "It's his skin color arrgggggg"

Yeah it's his "skin color"

Because Americans in Texas have "never ever seen dark skin color" it's a shock to their world.

Keep spinning the story

And btw he's not a "dark skinned Muslim" he's pretty light skinned compared to my own kid to tell you the truth.
 
Last edited:
Extraordinary and baseless? I find your assertion of baselessness baseless. Giordano rapidly found a reference, as could anyone else interested. Here's one: http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/news/world/americas/article4558924.ece ) I haven't seen the actual report.

I also don't know the actual title of the form. I called it a "criminal complaint", as did one article I read. I don't know the actual title or the role that document played in the process of arresting Ahmed.

I agree that your reporting of the assertion was not baseless, but my assertion of baselessness was not basless. First, it makes absolutely no sense. The police interrogated the kid and therefore could draw their own conclusions about probable cause. A legal arrest could be executed without relying on any complainant, and in fact, the police said he was arrested specifically because he wasn't forthcoming in the interrogation. Second, the police report is nowhere to be found and has not been referenced in the news except in those very early days. Finally, you initially provided no link or reference of any kind.

As for the assertion itself, a little Google sleuthing has convinced me that it is sourced entirely from that NBC-DFW article, and, except for a little mangling in a couple of references (e.g. stating that the teachers signed a complaint), all references are clearly based on that preliminary report of a preliminary report. I am willing to bet that it was due to a misunderstanding, and that no such report was released to the media.
 
Yeah it's his skin color. Let's just stick with that.

Yeah.

I love this argument ....it's his SKIN COLOR

It shows how reductive people's arguments get. How patently outside the paradigm of intelligence.


It's his skin color. Let's keep saying that. Say it in a husky voice "it's his SKIN COLOR brrrr" "It's his skin color...grrrrr" "It's his skin color arrgggggg"

Yeah it's his "skin color"

Because Americans in Texas have "never ever seen dark skin color" it's a shock to their world.

Keep spinning the story

And btw he's not a "dark skinned Muslim" he's pretty light skinned compared to my own kid to tell you the truth.

Yeah, it's a completely ridiculous assertion. Given the current political environment (especially with the Department of Justice treating disparate impact as prima facie evidence of a Title VII violation), it is far more likely that a member of a disadvantaged minority is given the benefit of the doubt by public school teachers compared to a member of the majority. In any case, despite the palpable anti-Texan bias in this thread, the Irving school district actually has a very diverse student population. I doubt that a brown-skinned Muslim kid there would stick out in the slightest.
 
Once you realize that the actual purpose of closing the corridor was not to actually protect people from injury, but in fact to protect the building management and contractor from a judgment of negligence if someone had gotten injured, you'll realize that a sign would not have been enough. I'm confident that you'll then also realize that measures like that one are not "coddling" of individuals, but actually self-defensive actions on the part of those entities you currently mistake for being coddling.

You can be "confident" of anything that helps you sleep at night. The point of the matter is that you have no clue why they did what they did, and I'm actually in a better position to judge the reasons, since I actually live in Canada, and you don't.
 
I agree that your reporting of the assertion was not baseless, but my assertion of baselessness was not basless. First, it makes absolutely no sense. The police interrogated the kid and therefore could draw their own conclusions about probable cause. A legal arrest could be executed without relying on any complainant, and in fact, the police said he was arrested specifically because he wasn't forthcoming in the interrogation. Second, the police report is nowhere to be found and has not been referenced in the news except in those very early days. Finally, you initially provided no link or reference of any kind.

As for the assertion itself, a little Google sleuthing has convinced me that it is sourced entirely from that NBC-DFW article, and, except for a little mangling in a couple of references (e.g. stating that the teachers signed a complaint), all references are clearly based on that preliminary report of a preliminary report. I am willing to bet that it was due to a misunderstanding, and that no such report was released to the media.
I'm glad that you have decided this is all from one news source, even though the wording in the various different news stories was somewhat different. As for me,I recognize that I have only the multiple news reports and no reason to think they aren't true, but I am willing to wait for the release of an Internet version of the police report to see myself. As to why you think it makes no sense: I don't see any reason the teachers could not have signed as complaints. They were the initial witnesses who brought in the police. The police interviewed the kid too, but the initial complaints from the initial witnesses are almost always listed in police reports. And i did provide multiple news links, as did Meadmaker too. I don't even understand why you think "initial" news reports or my waiting until you asked to provide a citation even matters here. But no police report is available yet on the web, with or without teachers' signatures. One must exist, so let's see this one question after it appears, okay?

But more so I noted the change of topic as well as the factless speculation. This exchange begin only with the question of if Meadmaker read the claim, as he posted- clearly he did and stated as much cautiously and very accurately attributed it to what he read.

But look how far this is from the main topic: the police arrested and handcuffed this kid for a fake bomb threat. that is the point I keep trying to come back to. Truethat- do we agree on this much?
 
Last edited:
:covereyes
Yeah it's his skin color. Let's just stick with that.

Yeah.

I love this argument ....it's his SKIN COLOR

It shows how reductive people's arguments get. How patently outside the paradigm of intelligence.


It's his skin color. Let's keep saying that. Say it in a husky voice "it's his SKIN COLOR brrrr" "It's his skin color...grrrrr" "It's his skin color arrgggggg"

Yeah it's his "skin color"

Because Americans in Texas have "never ever seen dark skin color" it's a shock to their world.

Keep spinning the story

And btw he's not a "dark skinned Muslim" he's pretty light skinned compared to my own kid to tell you the truth.

Frankly I think that it was because he was a dark skinned Muslim that generated more suspicion, but I've always noted that I can't prove it. Nor can you ever prove that it wasn't. So you keep repeating your version too, okay?

Do you agree with my statement as to the reason for his arrest?
 
And please note I have said from DAY ONE that he was suspended for disrupting the learning environment. WAY before more details came out regarding Ahmed's behavior in the past.


He is still suspended because you are not supposed to bring things like that to school. There's a zero tolerance policy.

People with low reading comprehension skills might think that you originally said something else.

ETA: The rest of your post is also wrong.

It's also worth pointing out that a suspension is not an arrest. The child was arrested having doing nothing arrest-worthy.


There is a separate issue about whether even the suspension was justified - on the basis of the available information it seems not.
 
Yeah it's his skin color. Let's just stick with that.

Yeah.

I love this argument ....it's his SKIN COLOR

It shows how reductive people's arguments get. How patently outside the paradigm of intelligence.


It's his skin color. Let's keep saying that. Say it in a husky voice "it's his SKIN COLOR brrrr" "It's his skin color...grrrrr" "It's his skin color arrgggggg"

Yeah it's his "skin color"

Because Americans in Texas have "never ever seen dark skin color" it's a shock to their world.

Keep spinning the story

And btw he's not a "dark skinned Muslim" he's pretty light skinned compared to my own kid to tell you the truth.

When your strawmen are so out there you can't even find a post that vaguely looks like what you're arguing against to quote then it's probably time to quit whilst you're behind.
 
It's also worth pointing out that a suspension is not an arrest. The child was arrested having doing nothing arrest-worthy.


There is a separate issue about whether even the suspension was justified - on the basis of the available information it seems not.

As someone who understands the protocol it seems completely justified based on the available information.

That is why I pointed out that the School Board, despite the benefit of hindsight and knowing the "big picture" upheld the suspension.


People keep trying to spin this as he was suspended for bringing a hoax bomb to school. They read through the rules and Code etc. And they keep stopping at the part that "it looks like a mock weapon"

That's not why he was suspended.


The same way they react to the POP TART GUN and insist that the kid was suspended for eating the pop tart into the shape of a gun.


That's not why he was suspended either.


Both kids were suspended for disrupting the learning environment. Just because people don't understand the policy doesn't change anything.

The "hoax bomb" argument has absolutely nothing to do with the suspension.


It's very obvious that his interactions with the police are an entirely different matter.
 
Last edited:
When your strawmen are so out there you can't even find a post that vaguely looks like what you're arguing against to quote then it's probably time to quit whilst you're behind.

Considering that the post to which I was responding said EXACTLY what I replied to, I can only surmise that we have yet another example of problems with reading comprehension.

I can't find a post VAGUELY looking like what I'm arguing, even though the post said THIS verbatim?


I just wanted to emphasize this. Based on my own experience as a teacher, that as a parent of once-teenage boys, and those of the many other teachers in my family, a three day suspension would not be handed out, for white kids for bringing a slightly distracting item as a science "project" to class. I don't know why officially Ahmed was suspended, but I don't see how, as Truethat claims, it would be in any way fair or normal to suspend any student because ignorant adults misinterpreted his clock project and refused to believe his accurate and fully logical explanation. But of course my own experiences did not involve a dark skin Muslim in Texas.

Frankly I think that it was because he was a dark skinned Muslim that generated more suspicion, but I've always noted that I can't prove it. Nor can you ever prove that it wasn't. So you keep repeating your version too, okay?

Do you agree with my statement as to the reason for his arrest?
 
Last edited:
Let me teach you a little trick. When truethat writes "From what you've read?", she's clearly drawing attention to the portion of Meadmaker's post where he used the words "from what I've read," and responding to that. Her entire post is clearly on the same, focused point, so she is only responding to that initial portion of Meadmaker's post. In that portion, he is discussing the school's response, not the police's. In fact, he makes a rather extraordinary (and I think, as truethat clearly does, baseless) assertion that three teachers signed a criminal complaint. Outside of this post, truethat has focused her attention on the response of the teachers and the school, since that is where her expertise lies. She has pretty consistently declined to defend or rationalize the actions of the police.


Thank you!!! It's been pretty scary in here for a while.:(
 
Hey- I'm a teacher as well as a parent. Most of the people in my family are teachers. If a clock creates an entire incident, then the problem is that some administrators and yes, teachers, are trying to do more than teach and keep the kids under them safe. And yes, there are people good at teaching and people bad at it. It is certainly known that teachers make mistakes. And some did in this case after they simply asked the boy what he had and asked her to show it to them. As I previously posted, asking and confirming the identity of an item a student brought to school is perfectly fair. Once confirmed as safe, asking them to not use it in such as way as to disrupt class is fair too. The most extreme reasonable reaction would have been to confiscate the clock and return it to the boy at the end of class- all done! Detaining him for a clock and calling the police to arrest him in handcuffs is not reasonable and probably illegal itself.

You previously expressed the concept that the boy should have ignored the engineers request to not show the clock to others, and that the boy, by following this advice, made the device look more suspicious. Now you are arguing that by it beeping, he was guilty of disrupting class. Damn if he did and damned if he didn't, right? You have even alluded to this being a "banned" object, and given clocks are not expressly banned (can you show me where this rule is if you disagree) then you are relying on a clock looking like a bomb. But it didn't because no one who saw it actually thought it looked like a bomb. So you may say it looked like a fake bomb- but only to people who don't know what a bomb, fake or real, looks like. If someone sees my pen and thinks it like it looks like a sword, would that be justification for me being suspended from my teaching job?

As a teacher I think you can follow what probably happened that day and when there were protocols to be upheld.

It's not a straight line of misunderstanding and protocols.


A. He set the clock to go off, which apparently means he had to plug it in. Early reports stated it was in his bag but I don't see how that is possible if it had to be plugged in to be used. (I'm still not certain how that happened, so am interested in more information)

Question: If you were teaching the class and the timer went off would you stop teaching to figure out what it was? Would you also want to know why he timed the clock to go off?

My interpretation of the situation:

Ahmed was proud of his invention and wanted to show it to the other teachers but was told not to. He figured it would be funny if it went off and then the teacher would ask him what it was and he'd get to show it off to the class. An INNOCENT act typical of a young boy.

B. The teacher (an idiot like me who would see it as some unknown device) reacts in a negative way. She asks him "what is it?" The class is now intently watching because a scene has been made. Someone (we don't know who, could be a kid, could be the teacher, could be Ahmed) said something about a fake bomb.

Question: We are not talking about a PEN being confused with a sword. We are talking about a wired up contraption. If you were in the situation and you didn't know what it was are you not MANDATED to take it to the office?

Yes or no?


My interpretation of what happened.

Once the commotion was started and the word bomb was mentioned the teacher had to take him and the contraption down to the office and turn the problem over to the principal.

At this point Ahmed is getting nervous. He knows his sister had a history of being accused of a fake bomb threat. This is not his intention. He remembers the other teacher telling him not to show anyone. He feels scared and starts acting nervous because he's afraid he's going to get into trouble.



C. The teacher takes Ahmed to the principals office and asks him what the device is, why he brought it to school. When the answers are not satisfactory the principal calls the police. Please note IT WAS NOT a SCIENCE PROJECT. People keep saying it was a science project and if it was it would be an entirely different story. It was NOT a Science Project. It was his own invention.

Question: If your principal was in the same situation and didn't know what the device was, the kid is acting nervous and the words "bomb" are being discussed, does not your principal have an obligation to call the police?




My interpretation of what happened.

Ahmed's nervous demeanor, and his past history of the bubbles in the bathroom prank, make the principal wonder if he is just ONE PERSON involved in a silly hoax that as a 14 year old kid doesn't realize could be interpreted the wrong way.

They call the police to hand things over to the officials as they are required to do.


The police overreact to the situation.



Seems like most people are arguing "It was OBVIOUS IT WAS A CLOCK they should have just told him to put it away."

I'm saying "call me a damn idiot if you want, but it wouldn't be obvious that it was just a clock to me. So I'd follow protocol." I'd also like to know why the argument seems to be "Anyone who knows what a real bomb looks like would know it's not one!" Well.....um......I completely confess that I don't know what a REAL BOMB looks like and I would wager that most teachers don't either. I really don't understand this rationalization?




My interpretation of the suspension. Even if the beeping device was a wired up bubble machine that started releasing bubbles into the classroom, he would have been suspended for just that act alone.

Previous history showed that he was. But once the word "bomb" started being mentioned (consider the same rule applies at the AIRPORT even as a joke) This situation continued forward to the police.

Even if the situation had STOPPED at the principal's office and they KNEW what the device was, HE STILL WOULD HAVE BEEN SUSPENDED for disrupting the classroom, especially deliberately so.



Again UNDERSTANDING why something happened is not the same as AGREEING with it.

It's also interesting to me how many people are complaining about this SPECIFIC item not being listed on the banned items list. Well gee, I guess the school board will learn from this and add "Homemade inventions" to their list of banned items to avoid ridiculous assertions that they are targeting the student for being a "dark skinned Muslim"

So next year when the list becomes even MORE restrictive and the zero tolerance becomes even more zeroey, you can see who is to blame for it. LOL



 
Last edited:
People keep trying to spin this as he was suspended for bringing a hoax bomb to school. They read through the rules and Code etc. And they keep stopping at the part that "it looks like a mock weapon"

That's not why he was suspended.

In this thread, absolutely no one is spinning it that way, although some people, including you, did so earlier the thread.

At this point in the thread, everyone except you seems to understand that we do not know why he was suspended, because the school district has not, and can not, release that information.

On the other hand, we do know why he was arrested. We also know what the principal said in a letter home to parents.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom