As a teacher I think you can follow what probably happened that day and when there were protocols to be upheld.
It's not a straight line of misunderstanding and protocols.
A. He set the clock to go off, which apparently means he had to plug it in. Early reports stated it was in his bag but I don't see how that is possible if it had to be plugged in to be used. (I'm still not certain how that happened, so am interested in more information)
Question: If you were teaching the class and the timer went off would you stop teaching to figure out what it was? Would you also want to know why he timed the clock to go off?
My interpretation of the situation:
Ahmed was proud of his invention and wanted to show it to the other teachers but was told not to. He figured it would be funny if it went off and then the teacher would ask him what it was and he'd get to show it off to the class. An INNOCENT act typical of a young boy.
B. The teacher (an idiot like me who would see it as some unknown device) reacts in a negative way. She asks him "what is it?" The class is now intently watching because a scene has been made. Someone (we don't know who, could be a kid, could be the teacher, could be Ahmed) said something about a fake bomb.
Question: We are not talking about a PEN being confused with a sword. We are talking about a wired up contraption. If you were in the situation and you didn't know what it was are you not MANDATED to take it to the office?
Yes or no?
My interpretation of what happened.
Once the commotion was started and the word bomb was mentioned the teacher had to take him and the contraption down to the office and turn the problem over to the principal.
At this point Ahmed is getting nervous. He knows his sister had a history of being accused of a fake bomb threat. This is not his intention. He remembers the other teacher telling him not to show anyone. He feels scared and starts acting nervous because he's afraid he's going to get into trouble.
C. The teacher takes Ahmed to the principals office and asks him what the device is, why he brought it to school. When the answers are not satisfactory the principal calls the police. Please note IT WAS NOT a SCIENCE PROJECT. People keep saying it was a science project and if it was it would be an entirely different story. It was NOT a Science Project. It was his own invention.
Question: If your principal was in the same situation and didn't know what the device was, the kid is acting nervous and the words "bomb" are being discussed, does not your principal have an obligation to call the police?
My interpretation of what happened.
Ahmed's nervous demeanor, and his past history of the bubbles in the bathroom prank, make the principal wonder if he is just ONE PERSON involved in a silly hoax that as a 14 year old kid doesn't realize could be interpreted the wrong way.
They call the police to hand things over to the officials as they are required to do.
The police overreact to the situation.
Seems like most people are arguing "It was OBVIOUS IT WAS A CLOCK they should have just told him to put it away."
I'm saying "call me a damn idiot if you want, but it wouldn't be obvious that it was just a clock to me. So I'd follow protocol." I'd also like to know why the argument seems to be "Anyone who knows what a real bomb looks like would know it's not one!" Well.....um......I completely confess that I don't know what a REAL BOMB looks like and I would wager that most teachers don't either. I really don't understand this rationalization?
My interpretation of the suspension. Even if the beeping device was a wired up bubble machine that started releasing bubbles into the classroom, he would have been suspended for just that act alone.
Previous history showed that he was. But once the word "bomb" started being mentioned (consider the same rule applies at the AIRPORT even as a joke) This situation continued forward to the police.
Even if the situation had STOPPED at the principal's office and they KNEW what the device was, HE STILL WOULD HAVE BEEN SUSPENDED for disrupting the classroom, especially deliberately so.
Again UNDERSTANDING why something happened is not the same as AGREEING with it.
It's also interesting to me how many people are complaining about this SPECIFIC item not being listed on the banned items list. Well gee, I guess the school board will learn from this and add "Homemade inventions" to their list of banned items to avoid ridiculous assertions that they are targeting the student for being a "dark skinned Muslim"
So next year when the list becomes even MORE restrictive and the zero tolerance becomes even more zeroey, you can see who is to blame for it. LOL
Let's start with just a few questions that I asked before, but I hope you will answer simply so that we know where we agree and where we disagree:
1. Do we agree that there is solid, documented evidence that Ahmed was arrested in handcuffs for a hoax bomb? And that after questioning at the police station for an extended period of time without his parents or a lawyer, he was released?
2. No one here knows why he was also suspended at school at the same time because the official information/file has not been released to the public. If you do somehow know the official reasons, then perhaps you can tell us your source? Because no one here has claimed to be able to see the official document or to have read a news report that quotes the official document. In fact all of the recent posts that you are currently rebutting (including my own), may infer a possible reason but have specifically stated that they do not
know the official reason.
Now as to my point in this post:
you are the one inferring (to be kind, I could use your words directed at others of "spinning" or "making up") the official reason for Ahmed's
suspension being because of him disrupting class. This is of course your opinion based on your own experiences. I have a different opinion due to my own experiences with school systems in both large cities and small towns, wealthy and poor, academic and blue collar, post zero tolerance and before, I have never seen anyone suspended for 3 days for bringing in an electronic project (or even a completely non-academically related item- a dead mouse, a cool piece of jewlery, etc.) and showing it around. Yes certainly I know of people who have been told to stop disrupting the class and "put it away." In some cases the teacher has asked, "What the hell are you showing around?" first, but once satisfied it was not dangerous the lessons went on after the item was returned to the backpack. That is what has happened 17 times of 20. The 3 out of 20 times the teacher confiscated the item and handed it back at the end of the day. If the teacher thought it might be threatening in some way, then it was fine for the teacher to contact other teachers and even the principal for more information.
The only times I have ever seen someone suspended has been if the student starting fighting with the teacher or other students, repeatedly over many days refused to follow the instructions of the teacher, someone who hacked into the school computer, and once (once) a high school student who brought a functional shotgun and live shells in the trunk of his car to the school parking lot because he forgot they was there. That was a shotgun! and it resulted in his suspension, which was soon reversed. I even know of a kid who (also post zero tolerance) borrowed a coat that (unknown to him) had a knife in it, and he was not suspended after the parents and student explained. So I find it puzzling that "disrupting" a class one day by bringing in a odd, but science-related, item would result in a 3 day suspension after everything was explained.
As I posted more than once- it was fair enough for the teacher to ask Ahmed to show it was just a clock, and to tell him to put it away or to confiscate it for a day. I will point out that it had a battery backup adapter (in photo) like many other alarm clocks, so it might have rung even if not plugged it, but I don't know if there was a battery in it or not. No one at the school thought it looked like a bomb (we know that because no one treated it like a bomb) and the student identified it from start to finish as a clock, so I am also puzzled by how it could be viewed as a fake bomb if it didn't look like a bomb and no one claimed it was a bomb. Was it a fake, "fake bomb?
But let me suggest a concept that we might compromise on: the school thought that Ahmed disrupted the class by bringing in a fake bomb. The school soon realized that it was just a clock. So they decided to list the suspension as "disrupting class" (of course it was the school that disrupted the class) rather than as "disrupting class by bringing in a fake bomb." In fact, I would be willing to bet that is the scenario. But here is the important point: I don't know what is the official cause of suspension. Meadmaker doesn't know. You don't know (unless you have a source you haven't identified). So we are all speculating as to the suspension. Meadmaker and I have acknowledged that. Will you?