Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I would be amused, if it weren't so pitiful, by people so desperate to characterize a kid as a juvie delinquent budding terrorist that they have to try and morph soap bubbles and a clock in a pencil box into "chemicals and bomb making parts".

What's hysterical here is that you are proving my point. The SCHOOL never said anything about bomb making parts in their statements.

The people REACTING to the situation are the ones who keep spinning that story over and over and over again.

The irony here would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

People have no idea that THEY are the ones making it about hoax bombs etc and in reality THEY are the ones making it racist. Because that's not got anything to do with why Ahmed was suspended. Show me a statement from the school that says it was.

So who is the real racist here? The school? Or the people who can't conceive of ANY other reason that a Muslim kid would be suspended from school except for "they thought he was a terrorist." Why? Why is that those people can't understand a suspension like any other suspension that any kid would get for disrupting the learning environment.

Why can those people only seem to see Ahmed Mohammed as a potential terrorist rather than a kid who deliberately set a timer to go off in the class and has a history of disruptions in the classroom and was suspended.

Says more about them than it does the school.


:D:D:D
 
Last edited:
Thank goodness our zero tolerance policies are in place to save our children from the horrors of soap bubbles.

It is amazing we ever survived school in the bad old days, much less graduated.

We're so overprotected nowadays. From bad words, bubbles, contrary opinions...

Where I work, a few months ago they renovated a section of our floor, and changed the carpet there. A couple days after that section re-opened, they closed it again with a warning "beware level change. Passage forbidden." See, between the old and new carpet there's about a centimeter difference in height, and that's _way_ too dangerous for us to walk through there. Someone might break a leg or something.:rolleyes:
 
I would be amused, if it weren't so pitiful, by people so desperate to characterize a kid as a juvie delinquent budding terrorist that they have to try and morph soap bubbles and a clock in a pencil box into "chemicals and bomb making parts".

What's hysterical here is that you are proving my point. The SCHOOL never said anything about bomb making parts in their statements.


Am I?

Umm, I never made the claim that the school said anything of the sort.

The reason that phrase is in quotes is because that's what you said.

Now that's hysterical.

The irony here would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

<snip>


Indeed.

 
The people REACTING to the situation are the ones who keep spinning that story over and over and over again.

The irony here would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

People have no idea that THEY are the ones making it about hoax bombs etc

If by THEY, you mean the police, who arrested Ahmed for making a hoax bomb, then you would have a point.

Although, from what I read, three teachers signed the criminal complaint that got Ahmed arrested, in which case, you really wouldn't have a point.

Because that's not got anything to do with why Ahmed was suspended. Show me a statement from the school that says it was.

Why should we do your research for you?



But as you well know, no one can show any statement from the school at all saying why Ahmed was suspended. The school won't release that information unless Ahmed's parents were to consent to the release. Anyone who says "Ahmed was suspended because....." is pretending to have information they don't really have.


But we do know why he was arrested.
 
What's hysterical here is that you are proving my point. The SCHOOL never said anything about bomb making parts in their statements.

The people REACTING to the situation are the ones who keep spinning that story over and over and over again.

The irony here would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

People have no idea that THEY are the ones making it about hoax bombs etc and in reality THEY are the ones making it racist. Because that's not got anything to do with why Ahmed was suspended. Show me a statement from the school that says it was.

So who is the real racist here? The school? Or the people who can't conceive of ANY other reason that a Muslim kid would be suspended from school except for "they thought he was a terrorist." Why? Why is that those people can't understand a suspension like any other suspension that any kid would get for disrupting the learning environment.

Why can those people only seem to see Ahmed Mohammed as a potential terrorist rather than a kid who deliberately set a timer to go off in the class and has a history of disruptions in the classroom and was suspended.

Says more about them than it does the school.


:D:D:D


I will grant that instead of being racist, the school system in question might equally regard every student of every age and color as an adversary, a rival to their authori-tye, constantly sizing them all up as potential threats according to their level of compliance and their ability, taking into account that greater ability always means greater threat. And the teachers might indeed see all the students, rather than just the colored ones, as intrusions upon their perfect solitary performances of teachering.

If that is indeed the case, then I seriously suggest that they just stop. Stop teaching, find a new career. Close the schools, sell the buildings, fire the school board, refund the tax money. It's a lost cause. It's worse than worthless; it's actively harmful. Home school, volunteer community school, private school, religious school, even no school at all would be better. Better a kid not learn evolution, than learn to despise ability.
 
I will grant that instead of being racist, the school system in question might equally regard every student of every age and color as an adversary, a rival to their authori-tye, constantly sizing them all up as potential threats according to their level of compliance and their ability, taking into account that greater ability always means greater threat. And the teachers might indeed see all the students, rather than just the colored ones, as intrusions upon their perfect solitary performances of teachering.

If that is indeed the case, then I seriously suggest that they just stop. Stop teaching, find a new career. Close the schools, sell the buildings, fire the school board, refund the tax money. It's a lost cause. It's worse than worthless; it's actively harmful. Home school, volunteer community school, private school, religious school, even no school at all would be better. Better a kid not learn evolution, than learn to despise ability.


What nonsense. LOL


This DRAMA is ridiculous.


A teacher isn't some tyrant dictating that all the children must sit in their seats not moving and trembling under the huge amounts of material being crammed down their throats.

It's absolute NONSENSE. Granted there may be bad apples in the bunch but most teachers start teaching because they want to make a difference in the world and are drawn to the industry.

Show me a teacher who ever salaciously rubbed their hands together and said "Mwhahahaha just what I've always wanted, a chance to force people into some dictatorship where I can force them to see the world MY WAY! AND!! I get paid a **** salary in the process!!! Wheeeeeeee!!!!!!"


Nonsense.


How about like I said pages ago. They are there to teach, they are often overwhelmed by overcrowded classrooms and children of different abilities whose parents aren't always involved either because they can't be or just don't want to be.

They are just trying to get through a lesson. Someone mentioned before the "12:15 book drop" and that's how I see this situation.

Kids pranking the teacher and the teacher has to stop teaching and sort out the disruption and it throws off the entire day with wasted time.


It's sad to me that people have this made up version of what "Teachers" do.

They are usually trying to just encourage equitable learning in the classroom

But back to your narrative of diabolical evil teachers trying to drum the enthusiasm out of students.

Like I said, you must have Pink Floyd playing in the background every time you write up one of these posts.

:rolleyes:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YR5ApYxkU-U
 
If by THEY, you mean the police, who arrested Ahmed for making a hoax bomb, then you would have a point.

Although, from what I read, three teachers signed the criminal complaint that got Ahmed arrested, in which case, you really wouldn't have a point.



Why should we do your research for you?



But as you well know, no one can show any statement from the school at all saying why Ahmed was suspended. The school won't release that information unless Ahmed's parents were to consent to the release. Anyone who says "Ahmed was suspended because....." is pretending to have information they don't really have.


But we do know why he was arrested.

From what you've read? Um NOPE from what you MADE UP. You guys are the ones spinning this narrative.


It doesn't match the facts AT ALL. But hey don't let a little thing like the truth get in the way of your story.

Carry on.


And please note I have said from DAY ONE that he was suspended for disrupting the learning environment. WAY before more details came out regarding Ahmed's behavior in the past.

And it matches what I said about the kid with the "POP TART GUN" but people STILL spin that narrative that the kid was suspended because he "bit the pop tart into the shape of gun"

Like teachers have SO LITTLE to do in the classroom that they have time to hover over students watching how they eat their food. ::rolleyes::
 
Last edited:
And please note I have said from DAY ONE that he was suspended for disrupting the learning environment. WAY before more details came out regarding Ahmed's behavior in the past.


He is still suspended because you are not supposed to bring things like that to school. There's a zero tolerance policy.

People with low reading comprehension skills might think that you originally said something else.

ETA: The rest of your post is also wrong.
 
Last edited:
We're so overprotected nowadays. From bad words, bubbles, contrary opinions...

Where I work, a few months ago they renovated a section of our floor, and changed the carpet there. A couple days after that section re-opened, they closed it again with a warning "beware level change. Passage forbidden." See, between the old and new carpet there's about a centimeter difference in height, and that's _way_ too dangerous for us to walk through there. Someone might break a leg or something.:rolleyes:

You are aware that closure was not made to protect people from tripping and hurting themselves, correct?
 
We're so overprotected nowadays. From bad words, bubbles, contrary opinions...

Where I work, a few months ago they renovated a section of our floor, and changed the carpet there. A couple days after that section re-opened, they closed it again with a warning "beware level change. Passage forbidden." See, between the old and new carpet there's about a centimeter difference in height, and that's _way_ too dangerous for us to walk through there. Someone might break a leg or something.:rolleyes:

Please keep in mind that not everyone is healthy and well-balanced. Some people will struggle and can fall and hurt themselves on what the rest of us would think is very reasonable.

The ADA regulations actually specify a number for this (1/4"? 1/2"?) it doesn't take much.
 
You are aware that closure was not made to protect people from tripping and hurting themselves, correct?

You mean at my office?

Yeah, it really was.

If you mean at the school, yes, I know. You'll notice the post I was replying to and the comment I was making.

Please keep in mind that not everyone is healthy and well-balanced. Some people will struggle and can fall and hurt themselves on what the rest of us would think is very reasonable.

A simple warning would have been enough. But closing the entire corridor?
 
Last edited:
From what you've read? Um NOPE from what you MADE UP. You guys are the ones spinning this narrative.


It doesn't match the facts AT ALL. But hey don't let a little thing like the truth get in the way of your story.

Carry on.
I don't know why you are attempting to continue in maintaining this. I rapidly found this quote (on-line) from the Police Chief:

“I get that. I understand the concern,” the chief responded. “The officers pretty quickly determined that they weren’t investigating an explosive device. What their investigation centered around is the law violation of bringing a device into a facility like that that is intended to create a level of alarm. In other words, a hoax bomb — something that is not really a bomb, but is designed and presented in a way that it creates people to be afraid.”

This is from just one site (http://www.rawstory.com/2015/09/irv...med-didnt-have-a-bomb-when-they-arrested-him/)
 
I don't know why you are attempting to continue in maintaining this. I rapidly found this quote (on-line) from the Police Chief:

“I get that. I understand the concern,” the chief responded. “The officers pretty quickly determined that they weren’t investigating an explosive device. What their investigation centered around is the law violation of bringing a device into a facility like that that is intended to create a level of alarm. In other words, a hoax bomb — something that is not really a bomb, but is designed and presented in a way that it creates people to be afraid.”

This is from just one site (http://www.rawstory.com/2015/09/irv...med-didnt-have-a-bomb-when-they-arrested-him/)

There are two separate issues here. I believe truehat is referring to Ahmed's suspension, which was imposed by the school obviously, and not to the arrest, which was imposed by the police. The suspension was reviewed and upheld. We do not know why Ahmed was suspended, but the best guess is that it was for disrupting the learning environment and/or creating a safety hazard (which the "invention," after being plugged into A/C power, almost certainly was).
 
Like teachers have SO LITTLE to do in the classroom that they have time to hover over students watching how they eat their food. ::rolleyes::

Hey- I'm a teacher as well as a parent. Most of the people in my family are teachers. If a clock creates an entire incident, then the problem is that some administrators and yes, teachers, are trying to do more than teach and keep the kids under them safe. And yes, there are people good at teaching and people bad at it. It is certainly known that teachers make mistakes. And some did in this case after they simply asked the boy what he had and asked her to show it to them. As I previously posted, asking and confirming the identity of an item a student brought to school is perfectly fair. Once confirmed as safe, asking them to not use it in such as way as to disrupt class is fair too. The most extreme reasonable reaction would have been to confiscate the clock and return it to the boy at the end of class- all done! Detaining him for a clock and calling the police to arrest him in handcuffs is not reasonable and probably illegal itself.

You previously expressed the concept that the boy should have ignored the engineers request to not show the clock to others, and that the boy, by following this advice, made the device look more suspicious. Now you are arguing that by it beeping, he was guilty of disrupting class. Damn if he did and damned if he didn't, right? You have even alluded to this being a "banned" object, and given clocks are not expressly banned (can you show me where this rule is if you disagree) then you are relying on a clock looking like a bomb. But it didn't because no one who saw it actually thought it looked like a bomb. So you may say it looked like a fake bomb- but only to people who don't know what a bomb, fake or real, looks like. If someone sees my pen and thinks it like it looks like a sword, would that be justification for me being suspended from my teaching job?
 
There are two separate issues here. I believe truehat is referring to Ahmed's suspension, which was imposed by the school obviously, and not to the arrest, which was imposed by the police. The suspension was reviewed and upheld. We do not know why Ahmed was suspended, but the best guess is that it was for disrupting the learning environment and/or creating a safety hazard (which the "invention," after being plugged into A/C power, almost certainly was).

I was not addressing the suspension, nor was Truethat (look at her (?) post #1167 that I quoted in my own). We were addressing the arrest!

This is not that I am not suspicious of the suspension, knowing of the level of action by a student that it takes in my own school system to be suspended! But the justification for the suspension is not public information so I will not speculate on it.
 
Last edited:
I don't know why you are attempting to continue in maintaining this. I rapidly found this quote (on-line) from the Police Chief:

“I get that. I understand the concern,” the chief responded. “The officers pretty quickly determined that they weren’t investigating an explosive device. What their investigation centered around is the law violation of bringing a device into a facility like that that is intended to create a level of alarm. In other words, a hoax bomb — something that is not really a bomb, but is designed and presented in a way that it creates people to be afraid.”

This is from just one site (http://www.rawstory.com/2015/09/irv...med-didnt-have-a-bomb-when-they-arrested-him/)
And this is exactly why no charges were filed. He never presented the device as anything other than an electronics project.

If he was suspended for creating a disruption, the disruption itself was caused by adults failing to recognize a project for what it was. Ahmed initiated the disruption by not keeping it in his bag/unplugged but the disruption to the school day happened when an adult decided to report the incident.

Three day suspension? I got that for setting a fire in a classroom. He got it for adults feeling fear of the unknown about his electronics research platform.
 
I read it again. I don't think you're correct.

So apparently you don't believe that Truethat was responding to Meadmaker's last line in his post. The last line of Meadmaker's post stated, "But we do know why he was arrested." and Truethat's first line of her response stated, "From what you've read? Um NOPE from what you MADE UP. You guys are the ones spinning this narrative."


This is after Meadmaker clearly states in his own post that we can never know that official reason for the suspension because that is non-public information, and clearly changes the narrative to the discussion of basis of the arrest: "But as you well know, no one can show any statement from the school at all saying why Ahmed was suspended. The school won't release that information unless Ahmed's parents were to consent to the release. Anyone who says "Ahmed was suspended because....." is pretending to have information they don't really have."

This is kind of silly. I am certain how virtually anyone would interpret this exchange. But if you want to just make it absolutely clear:

We know that Ahmed was arrested by the police on suspicion of creating a bomb hoax. We do not specifically why he was suspended at the same time by the school because that is not public information.

If Truethat still objects she can post her objection.
 
Last edited:
So apparently you don't believe that Truethat was responding to Meadmaker's last line in his post. The last line of Meadmaker's post stated, "But we do know why he was arrested." and Truethat's first line of her response stated, "From what you've read? Um NOPE from what you MADE UP. You guys are the ones spinning this narrative."


This is after Meadmaker clearly states in his own post that we can never know that official reason for the suspension because that is non-public information, and clearly changes the narrative to the discussion of basis of the arrest:

"But as you well know, no one can show any statement from the school at all saying why Ahmed was suspended. The school won't release that information unless Ahmed's parents were to consent to the release. Anyone who says "Ahmed was suspended because....." is pretending to have information they don't really have."

This is kind of silly. I am certain how virtually anyone would interpret this exchange. But if you want to just make it absolutely clear:

We know that Ahmed was arrested by the police on suspicion of creating a bomb hoax. We do not specifically why he was suspended at the same time by the school because that is not public information.

If Truethat still objects she can post her objection.

Let me teach you a little trick. When truethat writes "From what you've read?", she's clearly drawing attention to the portion of Meadmaker's post where he used the words "from what I've read," and responding to that. Her entire post is clearly on the same, focused point, so she is only responding to that initial portion of Meadmaker's post. In that portion, he is discussing the school's response, not the police's. In fact, he makes a rather extraordinary (and I think, as truethat clearly does, baseless) assertion that three teachers signed a criminal complaint. Outside of this post, truethat has focused her attention on the response of the teachers and the school, since that is where her expertise lies. She has pretty consistently declined to defend or rationalize the actions of the police.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom