Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

I’ve already said what I am thinking: He had existing electronics projects that he could have brought in to show his teacher, but instead just rearranged clock in case to look somewhat like a bomb (a “suspicious” “threat” to use his own words) because he knew some teachers would freak out over this “innocent” project and expose their racism and Islamophobia. It worked. Much better than I think he could have ever hoped.



There was no crime committed, which is why the police did not charge him with anything. He was arrested (or at least detained, I’m not sure if he was actually arrest), handcuffed, and interrogated because the school reported the device to the police and when the police investigate this suspicious device he refused to explain his intentions, he he built it, and why he brought it to school.

He would only say that it was a clock. The police could clearly see that it was a clock. But it was a clock that clearly some people in some circumstances might perceive to be a bomb. So the police wanted to know what he was up to. He wouldn’t tell them. So they took him downtown until they could sort out what was going on. Once they figured things out, they let him go and determined no charges would be filed because he did not have intentions to use the device to cause alarm.

If he had told the police right away that he was into electronics and had made a homemade clock to show his skills to his engineering teacher and talk to him about staring an electronics or robotics club, I expect the officers would have checked out his story and soon sent him back to class without incident. But he didn’t do that. In fact, it appears the police found out more about this case through newspaper reports than they did from their own interrogation.

Why did he not tell the police all of this when they asked in order to prevent this whole incident, while he so willingly and readily told all of it to the press?

That's what gets me too. It can't be a bomb scare, because it was so obviously fake.
 
Let's take this completely away from the "Fake bomb" and make it about hand held video games. I don't think most people would argue that hand held video games should have a zero tolerance policy in school.

I would be perfectly ok with that policy, assuming it was that all hand held videogames would be confiscated and returned after school. If it was an automatic suspension, I would say that was stupid. If anyone got arrested for having one.....


The fear mongering in the issue is the problem. And the sad reality is that there have been too many violent acts in schools lately. So zero tolerance policies are needed.

Here's what I don't get. You say that the fear mongering is the problem, and then the next two sentences look to me a lot like fear mongering.
 
He was arrested (or at least detained, I’m not sure if he was actually arrest), handcuffed, and interrogated because the school reported the device to the police and when the police investigate this suspicious device he refused to explain his intentions, he he built it, and why he brought it to school.

He would only say that it was a clock.

So, the Police asked him what it was, and he told them the truth...

The police could clearly see that it was a clock

... and they believed him

But it was a clock that clearly some people in some circumstances might perceive to be a bomb."

Bombs usually require something explosive attached; plastique, gelignite, something that actually looks like explosive. If he had attached a large dollop of silly-putty to his clock and poked some wires into it, then perhaps the allegation that he was trying to fool people into thinking it was a bomb might carry some weight, but he didn't do that.

Anyone who looked at this device and thought it was a bomb has to have a few components loose upstairs.

Frankly, this looks more like a bomb than what this kid built.....

PA101%20case.jpg


Why did he not tell the police all of this when they asked in order to prevent this whole incident, while he so willingly and readily told all of it to the press?

He was told not to tell anyone about it. Perhaps he was just doing what he was told. Also, he is obviously a smart kid. Perhaps he knows his constitutional rights....he doesn't have to answer any questions and the Police are not allowed to interview him without a parent or guardian present.
 
He was told not to tell anyone about it. Perhaps he was just doing what he was told. Also, he is obviously a smart kid.



He was told not to show any other teachers; an instruction which he pointedly disobeyed when he took the object out during English class and even plugged it in.
 
He was told not to show any other teachers; an instruction which he pointedly disobeyed when he took the object out during English class and even plugged it in.
A disobedient school kid. Never heard of.
 
The problem for me with this theory and Dawkins' similar flighty notions is that this outcome was extremely unlikely for the circumstances. The circuitry of clock innards is very mundane stuff. Ninety-nine kids named Mohammed out of 100 could have brought that thing to school, and no one would have batted an eyelash. This being a planned publicity stunt would have been a full-court bank shot.

Yes. I think I agree.
 
You don't think the lenticular picture of a tiger the tiny size, or the lack of explosive material would occasion a blink or two?

I believe the outside of the case looked something like this:
http://www.vaultz.net/pencil-box-3d-lenticular-tiger-vaultz-vz00384.html

Now I don't know what kind of action movies you're watching, but...

That tiger looks exactly like Hector Salamanca's face in his final moments on Breaking Bad. .

Do I need to tell you how that ended? Also, check the device on the back of the wheel chair. Identical to what the boy had in the case.
 
Last edited:
He was told not to tell anyone about it. Perhaps he was just doing what he was told. Also, he is obviously a smart kid. Perhaps he knows his constitutional rights....he doesn't have to answer any questions and the Police are not allowed to interview him without a parent or guardian present.

Or perhaps he was just a terrified child and was too frightened to frame any other coherent answer for the four uniformed adults who had handcuffed him and were subjecting him to a hostile interrogation.

Dave
 
I'm just not seeing the claim that it was intended to look like a bomb. You could have imitated explosive with white clay, blocks of paraffin wax, or even bars of glycerin soap. You can get all of these at Walmart.

I'm not seeing the idea that it was a project since no one has mentioned anything that he built or modified on the 1980s Radio Shack clock. It appears that he only took it out of the plastic case.

I'm also not understanding why the police were called. This seems like a conversation with a councilor.

I'm also not understanding why some keep claiming that it looked like a suitcase or briefcase bomb. The pencil case that he put it in is only 8.25" x 5.5" x 2.5". I think someone said they were expensive. Amazon lists them for $15. If you still can't visualize the size just think about typewriter paper. A standard sheet is 8 1/2" x 11". Paper back books are typically half a sheet which makes them 8.5" x 5.5". So, his ominous case was the size of a thick paper back. I could have fit three of those in the lunchbox I used to take to school.
 
If you still can't visualize the size just think about typewriter paper. A standard sheet is 8 1/2" x 11". Paper back books are typically half a sheet which makes them 8.5" x 5.5". So, his ominous case was the size of a thick paper back. I could have fit three of those in the lunchbox I used to take to school.

How much high explosives will fit in them?
 
So, the Police asked him what it was, and he told them the truth...



... and they believed him



Bombs usually require something explosive attached; plastique, gelignite, something that actually looks like explosive. If he had attached a large dollop of silly-putty to his clock and poked some wires into it, then perhaps the allegation that he was trying to fool people into thinking it was a bomb might carry some weight, but he didn't do that.

Anyone who looked at this device and thought it was a bomb has to have a few components loose upstairs.

Frankly, this looks more like a bomb than what this kid built.....

[qimg]https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/98915197/JREF/PA101%20case.jpg[/qimg]




He was told not to tell anyone about it. Perhaps he was just doing what he was told.

If his intention was a hoax it doesn't have to look a lot like a bomb. Most of us don't know what a bomb should look like, I would think even your typical police would not.

Perhaps he knows his constitutional rights....he doesn't have to answer any questions and the Police are not allowed to interview him without a parent or guardian present.
Are you sure that police are not allowed to interview him without a parent or guardian. In general I agree they should not.

Also, he is obviously a smart kid.
If he didn't plan this in order to stir up trouble then I would say he may be smart but lacks common sense. But he is a 14 year old maybe nerdy type so maybe that is normal.
 
Or perhaps he was just a terrified child and was too frightened to frame any other coherent answer for the four uniformed adults who had handcuffed him and were subjecting him to a hostile interrogation.

Dave

Yes. You might be able to find a 14 year old who, suddenly under suspicion and facing hostile treatment and repeated questioning by police officers, could respond in a clear, calm, reasoned way that would put their suspicions at ease. But that kid would be an exception.

And it's not surprising or suspicious that later, with time to think it through and questioned by sympathetic people, he explains it more clearly.
 
What does that have to do with anything, anyway?

It is part of the narrative of the event that has been presented. Do you contend it is appropriate to be skeptical/not be skeptical about only certain aspects of this event?
 
What does that have to do with anything, anyway?


As Checkmite points out, it has a lot to do with the narrative that this kid is a nerdy whiz kid whose obvious talents and creativity were shamelessly quashed by Islamophobic know-nothings. That narrative explains all of the rewards he has been given. Not every kid who is suspended from school unjustly (maybe) or arrested unjustly (probably) gets an invitation to the White House, an internship at Twitter, and a 3D printer from Microsoft.

As to how we judge his treatment by the school and police, what he actually built or didn't build is somewhat relevant. For example, the highly credible accusation that he didn't build anything worthwhile at all should lead a skeptic to question his motive for bringing his "invention" to school.

I can't really come up with an innocent motive. Either he wanted to pass off somebody else's work as his own in order to impress his science teacher, in which case I don't really see the difference between that and plagiarism (which any 14 year old should know is a no-no). Or he wanted to create a disruption in school, by plugging in a beeping, flashy thing concealed in a pencil case during his classes.

For the record, I don't think that he intended the device to be a bomb hoax, nor do I think he suspected the police would get involved, or even that he would get in trouble with the school. But he also did nothing worthy of praise either.
 
He may not have made any electrical modifications, however he did make a case mod. The crystal display is clearly screwed into the pencil case. And it may have been a lot cleaner and well put together before the police got their hands on it. In any event, he's 14, you shouldn't expect a masterpiece. He was tinkering, told everyone he was tinkering, and was proud of his tinkering. Give the 14-year old a break.

Being a nerd is not a crime.
 
He may not have made any electrical modifications, however he did make a case mod. The crystal display is clearly screwed into the pencil case. And it may have been a lot cleaner and well put together before the police got their hands on it. In any event, he's 14, you shouldn't expect a masterpiece. He was tinkering, told everyone he was tinkering, and was proud of his tinkering. Give the 14-year old a break.

Being a nerd is not a crime.

As the former president of the chess club in high school I can say maybe it was. Although we had not invented the term nerd at that time. I would have been called a Poindexter if I had glasses.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom