Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

But again, zero tolerance policies are put in place for a reason. If they didn't exist then every day you'd have kid accidentally doing something or a parent thinking "Well I don't care if Janie can die from eating peanut butter, Billy likes it."

Seriously teachers and administrators have enough to deal with every day than to sort out each one of these cases on an individual basis. That's the purpose of a zero tolerance policy. It deters students and it makes the consequence straight across the board with no bias.

OK, then. Zero tolerance policies are not, by nature, unreasonable. Now let's look at the zero tolerance policy itself. Is it zero tolerance for anything intended to look like a weapon, or zero tolerance for anything that a sufficiently uninformed and unintelligent observer could mistake for a weapon? The first is reasonable, but clearly was not infringed. The second, I would argue, is quite unreasonable; yet even this appears not to have been infringed, in that no one seems to have seriously believed the item was in fact a bomb. So we have to go to a ridiculous level of abstraction to set a policy that conforms to the actions taken; the policy must be that it is forbidden to bring in anything, whether intended to look like a weapon or not, and however little resembling a weapon, that could be taken by someone else to be an unsuccessful attempt to make something that resembles a weapon. By that definition, even a rucksack is effectively forbidden. In fact, it's hard to imagine what isn't. And the level of abstraction required makes a mockery of any concept of objectivity, because it's based on one person's belief concerning another person's thought processes. So if a policy was violated, it can only have been a stupid and ridiculously excessive policy; and if one wasn't, then there are a lot of indefensible actions going on here.

Dave
 
Fair call, but I will when I will.

Just seems to be whole paragraphs of obvious
 
OK, then. Zero tolerance policies are not, by nature, unreasonable. Now let's look at the zero tolerance policy itself. Is it zero tolerance for anything intended to look like a weapon, or zero tolerance for anything that a sufficiently uninformed and unintelligent observer could mistake for a weapon? The first is reasonable, but clearly was not infringed. The second, I would argue, is quite unreasonable; yet even this appears not to have been infringed, in that no one seems to have seriously believed the item was in fact a bomb. So we have to go to a ridiculous level of abstraction to set a policy that conforms to the actions taken; the policy must be that it is forbidden to bring in anything, whether intended to look like a weapon or not, and however little resembling a weapon, that could be taken by someone else to be an unsuccessful attempt to make something that resembles a weapon. By that definition, even a rucksack is effectively forbidden. In fact, it's hard to imagine what isn't. And the level of abstraction required makes a mockery of any concept of objectivity, because it's based on one person's belief concerning another person's thought processes. So if a policy was violated, it can only have been a stupid and ridiculously excessive policy; and if one wasn't, then there are a lot of indefensible actions going on here.

Dave


The zero tolerance rule is often ridiculously applied. Examples abound in the media. You can google them.

Here's a list and criticism of zero tolerance policies. (You can see that the writer is quite cynical about it all)

http://www.theegglestongroup.com/writing/zerostup.php


However you can also see on the list that he chides the PEANUT being one of those ridiculous zero tolerance things.

But for some children a peanut is a death sentence. Schools are mandated public places. Kids legally have to go to school (or be home schooled) and so the schools are obligated to put protections in place that to the rest of us may seem stupid.

But it's not a store or shopping mall. The teacher's job is to focus on education, any distraction from that is problematic.

If kids could bring toys and gadgets to school then consider how many times a day a teacher would have to stop teaching to confiscate the item and put it aside. It disrupts the learning environment.

Let's take this completely away from the "Fake bomb" and make it about hand held video games. I don't think most people would argue that hand held video games should have a zero tolerance policy in school.

A. Don't bring them in because it's not the place.

B. What if a kid has it stolen, who is liable

C. It is a distraction in the classroom

The fear mongering in the issue is the problem. And the sad reality is that there have been too many violent acts in schools lately. So zero tolerance policies are needed.
 
Let's take this completely away from the "Fake bomb" and make it about hand held video games. I don't think most people would argue that hand held video games should have a zero tolerance policy in school.

A. Don't bring them in because it's not the place.

B. What if a kid has it stolen, who is liable

C. It is a distraction in the classroom

The fear mongering in the issue is the problem. And the sad reality is that there have been too many violent acts in schools lately. So zero tolerance policies are needed.

Good point. I can see how a fake handheld video game would be disruptive. In fact, the item in question could pass as a fake handheld video game. Would that still require the police?
 
I'll tell you one thing for me that makes me think there is at least a small chance that this was a publicity stunt. Maybe engineered by the father... probably not... but maybe. Maybe a small chance.

His father was the defense attorney for the Koran at a trail put on by that lunatic Terry Jones. Remember him, the guy, at least me, could not believe captured the worlds attention a few years back. Well apparently the Koran needed a defense attorney and this kids dad got the job. He didn't do a great job as the Koran lost at trail and was sentenced to death by fire. The dad also ran for President of Sudan twice.

Now the dad seems like a great guy. Most surely is. Seems to believe in a more liberal version of Islam, kind of the enlightened version, at least I like to see. But also, it's a bit of a coincidence.... Maybe the dad, who has a history of seeking the public eye.... sought the public eye. Not probably, in fact probably not.... but maybe.


The problem for me with this theory and Dawkins' similar flighty notions is that this outcome was extremely unlikely for the circumstances. The circuitry of clock innards is very mundane stuff. Ninety-nine kids named Mohammed out of 100 could have brought that thing to school, and no one would have batted an eyelash. This being a planned publicity stunt would have been a full-court bank shot.
 
No, I am not kidding.

There is no policy against "suspicious looking objects." Period. The end.

ETA: See Dave Rogers' post.

Yes there is. And I'm not doing your research FOR you. But you are making a really stupid argument here. Of course there is a policy about suspsicious looking objects.

Ok whatever. :thumbsup:
 
Good point. I can see how a fake handheld video game would be disruptive. In fact, the item in question could pass as a fake handheld video game. Would that still require the police?

No but most likely because the school would know what the object was. If it was dismantled then it might be cause for confusion.

The cops mishandled this but the school did exactly what it is legally obligated to do.

I'll give you an example of what a legal obligation looks like. There's a question on a teaching test.


You are a third grade teacher on a field trip at the zoo. One of the children runs off from the group. In this situation you should

A. Go get the child.

B. Ask your teaching assistant to go get the child.

C. Ask one of the students to go get the child

D. Call the school and report the incident to the principal.


The answer is D. LEGALLY the teacher is not allowed to leave her group. She's also obviously not allowed ask another kid to go off. And as for B?

Well if the teaching assistant were to get injured running off after the child she could sue the school. So that's out too.

The protocol you are supposed to follow is to call the principal and the principal will call the zoo's security office and have the security guard find the child.

Now in real life the teaching assistant would just go get the kid. But when it's now entering a legal situation the situation has changed.


BECAUSE the English teacher didn't know what the clock was, she was mandated to report it. She didn't do anything wrong at all.

That's why I said the teacher who did know what it was is the one who screwed up.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

But he was NOT suspended for biting his food into the shape of a gun, he was suspended for pretending to shoot his classmates.

He also had a history of disciplinary problems.

That's what is so annoying about the case with Ahmed. They aren't allowed to really respond to what happened to Ahmed because the issue is confidential so the family can go to the media and say whatever they want but the school can't defend their decision without violating student confidentiality rules.

People have huge knee jerk reactions based on half the story.

This is true for all stories in the media, but it's particularly true for stories about kids being treated unfairly by schools. Invariably, it's the kid's side of the story (often embellished by the parents, sometimes with the help of a lawyer) that gets reported in the media and sets the narrative. I waited 4 days after the story broke to form an opinion specifically because I suspected that I was hearing spin and not necessarily truth.

What's fascinating about this story isn't what actually happened, but the viral response to it. This kid has gotten rewards other kids can only dream of: an invitation to the White House, an invitation to tour Facebook, $10,000 of Microsoft schwag, a summer internship at Twitter, free science camp, and - according to Mark Cuban - full scholarships to private high schools.

That's all a bit much for a knee-jerk reaction. And, yes, I'll admit I'm jealous. I have a 14 year old son who likes science and computers too. I briefly considered suggesting to him that he rip apart an old phone, stuff it in a shoebox, bring it to school, and claim he invented a phone. But then I realized he would probably just get suspended and nobody would care.
 
Yes, how dare one ask for evidence to support a claim!!

There's a difference between asking for evidence that has to be researched specifically to be found and something that would take two seconds on google.

Let me guess, you both believe the School is lying, the School Board that supported the suspension is lying, CNN is lying, etc etc etc.

Do your own research Becky. :blush:
 
He also had a history of disciplinary problems.



This is true for all stories in the media, but it's particularly true for stories about kids being treated unfairly by schools. Invariably, it's the kid's side of the story (often embellished by the parents, sometimes with the help of a lawyer) that gets reported in the media and sets the narrative. I waited 4 days after the story broke to form an opinion specifically because I suspected that I was hearing spin and not necessarily truth.

What's fascinating about this story isn't what actually happened, but the viral response to it. This kid has gotten rewards other kids can only dream of: an invitation to the White House, an invitation to tour Facebook, $10,000 of Microsoft schwag, a summer internship at Twitter, free science camp, and - according to Mark Cuban - full scholarships to private high schools.

That's all a bit much for a knee-jerk reaction. And, yes, I'll admit I'm jealous. I have a 14 year old son who likes science and computers too. I briefly considered suggesting to him that he rip apart an old phone, stuff it in a shoebox, bring it to school, and claim he invented a phone. But then I realized he would probably just get suspended and nobody would care.


This is such a good point and GOOD FOR AHMED!! I'm glad he's getting these rewards, and your sentiment is telling. I'm sure many other parents and kids are wondering the same thing.

Now if because of this the schools really specified ZERO TOLERANCE for anything being brought to school, it would make sense that they are realizing exactly that potential.

Are they being reactive? To most of us yes, but for those who realize that they are there to educate kids and have enough of a problem doing that, these become ridiculous distractions and unnecessary in school.

So the zero tolerance gets even more zeroy. And people wonder why. LOL


:cool:
 
Last edited:
There's a difference between asking for evidence that has to be researched specifically to be found and something that would take two seconds on google.

Not really, no.

Let me guess, you both believe the School is lying, the School Board that supported the suspension is lying, CNN is lying, etc etc etc.

Do your own research Becky. :blush:

Here's some advice: stop guessing.
 
Here's how you do a debate: You research the discussion before chiming in, you examine both sides of the argument.

THEN you form an opinion.


You don't jump in without knowing the details and then whine because people won't spoon feed you the information you should have already read had you taken time to properly evaluate the story.

Sigh
 
Here's how you do a debate: You research the discussion before chiming in, you examine both sides of the argument.

THEN you form an opinion.


You don't jump in without knowing the details and then whine because people won't spoon feed you the information you should have already read had you taken time to properly evaluate the story.

Sigh

Since when? Did the mods even bother to post an announcement?

My face is to be aghasted! :jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom