Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Do you have any evidence he took it out of the bag and plugged it in ?

Special pleading. That's what the article about the occurrence said happened. If you want to nitpick, I cannot prove it; but it also then cannot be proven that Ahmed ever showed it to his first teacher and was told "that's nice, but don't show it to any other teachers" for example.


At any rate, even though 14 year aren't usually wordsmiths (Is english even his first language ?):

in·vent
inˈvent/Submit
verb
create or design (something that has not existed before); be the originator of.
"he invented an improved form of the steam engine"

Unless you can show me some existing pencil case digital clocks, I think he invented it.

I won't claim this is deliberate prevarication, but it's tempting. Can you take the original "Starry Night" by Van Gogh, stick it into a Walmart frame, and pretend that action allows you to claim credit for the painting? Sure; but should you expect anyone to respect that claim?

You can "invent an improved form of" say a steam engine, because it's possible to fabricate a completely original set of parts that work together in a completely original way with the only thing it has in common with other kinds of steam engines being...well, the use of steam as a motivator; and you can completely honestly in good faith call that a "steam engine", just like any other engine that uses steam.

But pulling the guts whole out of an old Nintendo console and sticking them into an Igloo cooler does not give you the right to be taken seriously when you claim to have "invented a game console that plays old Nintendo games".
 
Motive 1: Holy crap, this 14 year old made a clock from scratch. He's a genius! Let's give him all kinds of free stuff because he's a genius.

Motive 2: Holy crap, the police arresting this poor kid could discourage him and countless others like him from doing nerdy things. Let's give him some tools so that the entire country sees that kids doing this kind of thing is not only welcome but encouraged!
 
Hasn't anyone here noticed that Ahmed's "invention" is merely a commercial alarm clock with the cover removed? It's a printed circuit board, it has a connection for 120vac and a 9v battery backup. The only thing he "invented" was how to unscrew the case and remount the insides in another case.

image


New to the thread, are you?

It used to be considered good etiquette to at least skim over the earlier posts in the thread before sticking your foot in it.

How times have changed.
 
Motive 1: Holy crap, this 14 year old made a clock from scratch. He's a genius! Let's give him all kinds of free stuff because he's a genius.

Motive 2: Holy crap, the police arresting this poor kid could discourage him and countless others like him from doing nerdy things. Let's give him some tools so that the entire country sees that kids doing this kind of thing is not only welcome but encouraged!

I'm not so sure we really want to encourage kids to break apart alarm clocks and stuff them in their pencil boxes and bring them to school and plug them in.
 
Exactly! What the school and police did was beyond stupid, but this kid didn't invent anything. He didn't even improve an existing product, if anything he took a perfectly functioning product and made it less practical.

He's not some electronics prodigy worthy of all the attention he's getting from MIT and Microsoft and Facebook. It's like getting take-out at a restaurant, dumping it all on a dinner plate and claiming you cooked it and then getting nationally known restaurants crowing about what a great chef you are. Or plagiarizing a book but putting it in a new binding and then being hailed as a great budding author by all the big publishers. It's bizarro world.


What's bizarre is the desperation being evidenced by people who want to somehow rewrite the facts.

He's getting what he's getting because of the shabby treatment he received, not because of any demonstration of intrinsic brilliance.

If it hadn't had been for the disgusting overreaction of allegedly mature adults he wouldn't have gotten a thing.

Nice try at misdirection, though.
 
I'm not so sure we really want to encourage kids to break apart alarm clocks and stuff them in their pencil boxes and bring them to school and plug them in.

I'm sure they steal more electricity when they charge their iPhones.
 
At any rate, even though 14 year aren't usually wordsmiths (Is english even his first language ?):

in·vent
inˈvent/Submit
verb
create or design (something that has not existed before); be the originator of.
"he invented an improved form of the steam engine"


Don't be too hard on Checkmite. He can't be expected to have a perfect grasp of the language.

At least, not when it isn't convenient for him.
 
Well said. It's kind of amazing how low an opinion of 14 year olds that people here seem to have. While 14 year olds are just kids in some respects, they are not really kids like 6 year olds, or even 10 year olds are. In Massachusetts, which is hardly some backwater, a 14 year old accused of murder is tried as an adult. There are also thousands, if not tens of thousands of 14 year olds in this country, who could pass for accomplished adults in many disciplines, their youthful appearance notwithstanding.

The vast majority of the kids in this high level performance (including the soloist) are 14 or younger:



I find it interesting that the only people claiming he is being lauded as some sort of prodigy are the ones who want to insist that he isn't.

I think there's a name for that sort of argument ...
 
I'm sure they steal more electricity when they charge their iPhones.

Well, I was thinking about the disruption of having a flashy, beepy thing in class. Of course an iPhone can flash and beep too, but it hurts a hell of a lot more when your teacher confiscates it.

I'll note also that this kid's "invention" probably wasn't even safe, given that it ran off 110V AC power and was secured rather poorly. Would you have been shocked if one of his classmates had been, um ..., shocked?
 
Well, I was thinking about the disruption of having a flashy, beepy thing in class. Of course an iPhone can flash and beep too, but it hurts a hell of a lot more when your teacher confiscates it.

I'll note also that this kid's "invention" probably wasn't even safe, given that it ran off 110V AC power and was secured rather poorly. Would you have been shocked if one of his classmates had been, um ..., shocked?

Your point is not unfair. But I think we know too little of the clock to know if it was an electrical hazard to others or not at this point. And the teachers didn't confiscate it for being dangerous, they thought, against all evidence, that it was a hoax bomb. Which makes the point rather moot.
 
I find it interesting that the only people claiming he is being lauded as some sort of prodigy are the ones who want to insist that he isn't.

Who used the word "prodigy"?

He claims to being "inventing" things that he is not inventing. That's called lying.
 
Special pleading. That's what the article about the occurrence said happened. If you want to nitpick, I cannot prove it; but it also then cannot be proven that Ahmed ever showed it to his first teacher and was told "that's nice, but don't show it to any other teachers" for example.

Sorry, the article I read didn't say he plugged it in, wasn't sure where that came from- Thanks.

I won't claim this is deliberate prevarication, but it's tempting. Can you take the original "Starry Night" by Van Gogh, stick it into a Walmart frame, and pretend that action allows you to claim credit for the painting? Sure; but should you expect anyone to respect that claim?

You can "invent an improved form of" say a steam engine, because it's possible to fabricate a completely original set of parts that work together in a completely original way with the only thing it has in common with other kinds of steam engines being...well, the use of steam as a motivator; and you can completely honestly in good faith call that a "steam engine", just like any other engine that uses steam.

But pulling the guts whole out of an old Nintendo console and sticking them into an Igloo cooler does not give you the right to be taken seriously when you claim to have "invented a game console that plays old Nintendo games".

We'll agree to disagree about what counts as an "invention" to a 14 year old.
 
Just to clarify, are you asserting that there is a legal mandate for teachers to report all objects they can't 100% identify to the police?

I'd really like to see that law, because it seems to be a terrible one.

Or, are you trying to say that this object falls into a special category of legal obligation?

If such an obligation exists based on liability or student safety, one imagines the teacher would have been equally mandated to get the other kids away to safety. If the action were in any way based on safety or liability, it would have included an evacuation.

Since an evacuation does not seem to have been conducted, it is very difficult to see calling the police as an action taken for safety or liability reasons, so the only possibility left is punitive.

I would be shocked to find a law on the books requiring teachers to go to such lengths to punish a student, so again, I'd really like to see the legal mandate you're referencing

First of all the teacher doesn't call the police. The teacher didn't call the police, the principal did.

Second of all YES if they don't know what something is they are mandated to report it to the police.

I'm amazed at how many people are spewing off fake outrage when they don't know what they are talking about.


Say a kid brings some strange GOO to school and it turns out that it's got some toxic mixture in it that could make kids sick. They school has to call the police if they don't know what the strange GOO is.


My own son had to testify at a hearing for a young girl who brought a can of mace to school in her bookbag. She jokingly sprayed it as the class was walking up an enclosed stairway and one of the girls in my son's class almost died. She was hospitalized for several weeks because of how badly it affected her asthma.


This is not a college. These are public schools where kids do dangerous but innocent things all the time. It's reasonable BEYOND reasonable to say that if a teacher finds an unknown object in a kids bag they should report it to the principal.

Then the principal may need to call the police.

But again, at the beginning of the school year all the rules are sent home for the parents to read and sign. It's not like parents don't know the rules.
 
Separately, the business with involving the police was inexcusably ridiculous.

Back on target;

The business with the school and police is the only part of this story that is on target.

Who cares whether he's any good at electronics? It shouldn't be a thing for public discussion. He didn't put himself in the media spotlight by making claims about the clock; he got put there because of the stupid actions of other people.

MIT, Facebook, the White House, yeah, that's all over the top. It's just the typical internet over-reaction that happens with every outrage. So what. That attention will go away. He'll grow up and maybe stay interested in tinkering, maybe not. Scrutinizing the merits of the clock is just another pendulum swing of over-reaction. Let him move on, drift out of the spotlight, go to another school where he will either succeed or not on his own merits.
 
Last edited:
There's a wicker basket next to my bed with some medicine bottles in it. How many wicker baskets with built-in medicine bottles are there?
 
The business with the school and police is the only part of this story that is on target.

Who cares whether he's any good at electronics? It shouldn't be a thing for public discussion. He didn't put himself in the media spotlight by making claims about the clock; he got put there because of the stupid actions of other people.

MIT, Facebook, the White House, yeah, that's all over the top. It's just the typical internet over-reaction that happens with every outrage. So what. That attention will go away. He'll grow up and maybe stay interested in tinkering, maybe not. Scrutinizing the merits of the clock is just another pendulum swing of over-reaction. Let him move on, drift out of the spotlight, go to another school where he will either succeed or not on his own merits.

This time it was positive attention, however. That's rather uncommon in internet outrages...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom