Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Bah, Dawkins is quickly making me wish I had never respected the man.

The sick motivations required to question this kid's motives just cause a seething anger to rise in me.
 
BECAUSE the English teacher didn't know what the clock was, she was mandated to report it. She didn't do anything wrong at all.

That's why I said the teacher who did know what it was is the one who screwed up.

Just to clarify, are you asserting that there is a legal mandate for teachers to report all objects they can't 100% identify to the police?

I'd really like to see that law, because it seems to be a terrible one.

Or, are you trying to say that this object falls into a special category of legal obligation?

If such an obligation exists based on liability or student safety, one imagines the teacher would have been equally mandated to get the other kids away to safety. If the action were in any way based on safety or liability, it would have included an evacuation.

Since an evacuation does not seem to have been conducted, it is very difficult to see calling the police as an action taken for safety or liability reasons, so the only possibility left is punitive.

I would be shocked to find a law on the books requiring teachers to go to such lengths to punish a student, so again, I'd really like to see the legal mandate you're referencing
 
Just to clarify, are you asserting that there is a legal mandate for teachers to report all objects they can't 100% identify to the police?

I'd really like to see that law, because it seems to be a terrible one.

Or, are you trying to say that this object falls into a special category of legal obligation?

If such an obligation exists based on liability or student safety, one imagines the teacher would have been equally mandated to get the other kids away to safety. If the action were in any way based on safety or liability, it would have included an evacuation.

Since an evacuation does not seem to have been conducted, it is very difficult to see calling the police as an action taken for safety or liability reasons, so the only possibility left is punitive.

I would be shocked to find a law on the books requiring teachers to go to such lengths to punish a student, so again, I'd really like to see the legal mandate you're referencing

I think it was perfectly obvious how the identification was made. Mostly by the brown skin and the name.
 
Just to clarify, are you asserting that there is a legal mandate for teachers to report all objects they can't 100% identify to the police?

If true, I've known a few english teachers that would have had to shut down the school every time they passed the science classroom.

"OMG! That student is trying to bring the dead back to life!!!"
 
Here's how you do a debate: You research the discussion before chiming in, you examine both sides of the argument.

THEN you form an opinion.

Oh, well excuse us for not respecting the truethat rules of Effective Debatetm, and don't mind if I go on not respecting them in the future.
 
Here's how you do a debate: You research the discussion before chiming in, you examine both sides of the argument.

THEN you form an opinion.


You don't jump in without knowing the details and then whine because people won't spoon feed you the information you should have already read had you taken time to properly evaluate the story.

Sigh


Just curious.

Have you actually read that school's policy yourself?
 
Bah, Dawkins is quickly making me wish I had never respected the man.

The sick motivations required to question this kid's motives just cause a seething anger to rise in me.

If you can give up respect so easily based on just one situation then perhaps the issue is with you
 
If true, I've known a few english teachers that would have had to shut down the school every time they passed the science classroom.

"OMG! That student is trying to bring the dead back to life!!!"


When I was in Physics class as a senior our instructor wanted to demonstrate about current and spark gaps.

He had a half dozen of us form a chain, holding hands from a Van De Graaff generator to the doorknob of the classroom.

Then he sent another one of us to ask the school Commandant to please come to the classroom.

We all still got in trouble, even though it was his idea.

:mad:
 
The zero tolerance rule is often ridiculously applied. Examples abound in the media. You can google them.

Here's a list and criticism of zero tolerance policies. (You can see that the writer is quite cynical about it all)

http://www.theegglestongroup.com/writing/zerostup.php


However you can also see on the list that he chides the PEANUT being one of those ridiculous zero tolerance things.

But for some children a peanut is a death sentence. Schools are mandated public places. Kids legally have to go to school (or be home schooled) and so the schools are obligated to put protections in place that to the rest of us may seem stupid.


When did peanut butter become so terribly dangerous? It was ubiquitous all the time I was in school. Very nearly a food group of its own.

How did schools manage for all those years without leaving a string of hapless children' bodies behind?

But it's not a store or shopping mall. The teacher's job is to focus on education, any distraction from that is problematic.

If kids could bring toys and gadgets to school then consider how many times a day a teacher would have to stop teaching to confiscate the item and put it aside. It disrupts the learning environment.


And yet, we managed to have 'show and tell'.

You seem to be describing a teacher shortcoming.

Our teachers said "Put that away or I'm taking it from you.". That generally worked. When it didn't they would take it from them. That worked too.

Let's take this completely away from the "Fake bomb" and make it about hand held video games. I don't think most people would argue that hand held video games should have a zero tolerance policy in school.

A. Don't bring them in because it's not the place.


Why not?

B. What if a kid has it stolen, who is liable


Good question. Maybe the kids shouldn't be able to bring anything to the school. For the same reason. No pens. No books. No clothes (some of those are very expensive).

Good thing there's a 'policy' in place. Of course the young 'uns could get a bit cold some times of year.

C. It is a distraction in the classroom


Only when the teacher allows it to be.

You are describing a general failure of the teach8ing community.

The fear mongering in the issue is the problem. And the sad reality is that there have been too many violent acts in schools lately.


More than in the past? Or are they just more well publicized?

So zero tolerance policies are needed.


What violent acts have been prevented by zero tolerance policies?

What evidence is there that such policies have done anything at all to ameliorate this alleged explosion of violent acts in the schools? Can you prove that they are anything more than feel-good CYA measures that are otherwise utterly meaningless, and possibly even detrimental to a healthy learning environment.?

This episode we are discussing certainly put a damper on it.
 
And?

Seriously. What is the point?

That a 14 year old rearranged the guts of a clock and called it an invention? That it was more art than science? So what? I'm at a loss to see what people are thinking here.

Ok. So he made a case mod of a clock, and called it a clock. I'll go one better. I'm thinking he may very well have known, and may very well have intended, that people would see it and think "bomb". Now, he made sure that people would know that it wasn't a bomb. He immediately showed it to a teacher to say, "This is a clock. Check it out." So, there was absolutely zero chance that anyone would think he had a bomb, and, this is important, no one did, in part because he made sure they wouldn't.

Let's step back a moment. Why does this matter? Because he was accused of building a hoax bomb. A key part of a hoax is that it is meant to be believed. It is not a crime to build a fake bomb. It is not a crime to build something that looks like a bomb. It is not a crime to build something that reminds someone of a bomb. The law says a "hoax" bomb for a reason. In order for it to be a hoax, you have to do it in such a way that someone might believe you. He clearly did not intend for anyone to think it was a bomb, and they clearly didn't think it was a bomb. In other words, there was absolutely zero evidence that any crime was committed, and yet he was arrested, handcuffed, and interrogated.

So, once again, giving them every possible benefit of the doubt, they're idiots. If we give them every possible benefit of the doubt, then we would see that the kid built a device that would make people nervous, and play on their fears. He made sure that no one would possibly think that it was actually a bomb. He went out of his way to ensure that there was no bomb hoax in any way associated with the device. Nevertheless, he knew they would be nervous and irritated, because here was this Muslim kid running around saying "I do not have a bomb." He knew that would freak them out because any time a Muslim says anything, they figure he might be a lying weasel and maybe he really did have a bomb. In other words, he was playing a childish prank, to expose their bigotry and make them look stupid.

That's giving them the benefit of every possible doubt. If that was his intention, it worked. They fell for it hook, line, and sinker, and were exposed as idiots. He proved that even if he showed up with a clock, and told people to inspect his clock, and let people see that it was a clock, they would still freak out about the Muslim kid with the electronics. Well played, Ahmed. It worked.

And, if that wasn't your plan? If you just made a case mod of a clock because you thought it was cool? Then the authorities are just plain idiots. They weren't taken in by a clever plan. They just bumbled into looking stupid.

This! They knew it was fake: http://countercurrentnews.com/2015/09/irving-police-chief-admits/
 
When did peanut butter become so terribly dangerous? It was ubiquitous all the time I was in school. Very nearly a food group of its own.

How did schools manage for all those years without leaving a string of hapless children' bodies behind?

Vaccines. Not only do the cause the Autism, they cause peanut allergies.
 
How did schools manage for all those years without leaving a string of hapless children' bodies behind?

A few explanations of that.

For one thing, peanut allergy is on the rise, growing more than 350% in less than 20 years, and growing even more among kids today, because up to around 2008, mothers were advised to avoid peanuts while pregnant and nursing, but research is now pointing to the opposite. In the late 90s, the rate was less than half of a percent of the population, and it was much lower before that. Chances are, when you went to school, no one with a severe allergy was there.

Secondly, not all peanut allergy sufferers have the same symptoms, and the severity of the reaction isn't always easy to predict. So while not all peanut allergic children are going to die if they touch a stray smear of PB +J, we can't really tell ahead of time which ones will, and a lot that don't go into life threatening anaphylaxis, will still have some unpleasant symptoms.

And finally, historically lots of things happened that we didn't talk about widely or diagnose properly. We've always had autistic kids, but we didn't call them that. We've always had cancer, but we explained cancer deaths in a million different ways before we discovered what it was.

So yes, historically it's pretty likely that a bunch of kids died or suffered greatly from peanut allergies in the past. It's likely you wouldn't have heard about it, and it's overwhelmingly likely that a much larger number of students are at risk today.
 
A few explanations of that.

For one thing, peanut allergy is on the rise, growing more than 350% in less than 20 years, and growing even more among kids today, because up to around 2008, mothers were advised to avoid peanuts while pregnant and nursing, but research is now pointing to the opposite. In the late 90s, the rate was less than half of a percent of the population, and it was much lower before that. Chances are, when you went to school, no one with a severe allergy was there.

Secondly, not all peanut allergy sufferers have the same symptoms, and the severity of the reaction isn't always easy to predict. So while not all peanut allergic children are going to die if they touch a stray smear of PB +J, we can't really tell ahead of time which ones will, and a lot that don't go into life threatening anaphylaxis, will still have some unpleasant symptoms.

And finally, historically lots of things happened that we didn't talk about widely or diagnose properly. We've always had autistic kids, but we didn't call them that. We've always had cancer, but we explained cancer deaths in a million different ways before we discovered what it was.

So yes, historically it's pretty likely that a bunch of kids died or suffered greatly from peanut allergies in the past. It's likely you wouldn't have heard about it, and it's overwhelmingly likely that a much larger number of students are at risk today.

That's probably the key actually. Well, that and also the fact that the kids who were diagnosed with life threatening peanut allergies were probably warned not to go to school and probably had to be home schooled.
 
If you can give up respect so easily based on just one situation then perhaps the issue is with you

Dawkins has been putting his foot in his mouth for awhile now. This is just the latest episode.
 
Hasn't anyone here noticed that Ahmed's "invention" is merely a commercial alarm clock with the cover removed? It's a printed circuit board, it has a connection for 120vac and a 9v battery backup. The only thing he "invented" was how to unscrew the case and remount the insides in another case.

image
 
Hasn't anyone here noticed that Ahmed's "invention" is merely a commercial alarm clock with the cover removed? It's a printed circuit board, it has a connection for 120vac and a 9v battery backup. The only thing he "invented" was how to unscrew the case and remount the insides in another case.

image


I think that was about thirteen pages ago. So what?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom