Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Dawkins says; “If this is true, what was his motive?"

Take a few brief minutes and Google shop for the things that are sold as clocks or with clocks in them.

By that standard putting one in a pencil case isn't particularly unusual.
 
Dawkins says; “If this is true, what was his motive?"

Take a few brief minutes and Google shop for the things that are sold as clocks or with clocks in them.

By that standard putting one in a pencil case isn't particularly unusual.

Dawkings was a dickhead

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2
 
Damn right the engineering teacher was a bit dim. But the fact that Ahmed showed it to the engineering teacher, and then followed the engineering teacher's instructions on what to do with it, should be protection enough from suspension.

Let's work the peanut butter sandwich analogy a little further. Suppose a kid quite innocently brings a peanut butter sandwich to school and shows it to his teacher. If the teacher says, "OK, you can keep the sandwich but don't let anybody else see it," then another teacher finds out about it, does that warrant a suspension of the kid? Or does it, perhaps, warrant a quick "Learn the rules and don't be so stupid next time" dressing down for the teacher?

Whatever policies are put in place to protect the students, there should also be some protection for students who follow teachers' reasonable-sounding instructions.

Dave


I agree that the teacher is the one who caused the issue and it should be taken into consideration.


But again, zero tolerance policies are put in place for a reason. If they didn't exist then every day you'd have kid accidentally doing something or a parent thinking "Well I don't care if Janie can die from eating peanut butter, Billy likes it."

Seriously teachers and administrators have enough to deal with every day than to sort out each one of these cases on an individual basis. That's the purpose of a zero tolerance policy. It deters students and it makes the consequence straight across the board with no bias.

Take this situation and look at how because of the Arab Muslim "bomb" etc it opens up a whole can of worms for legal action.

I hate to reference Sarah Palin (my god!!!) but she did make a good point when she pointed out that there have been plenty of cases like this where a kid accidentally brought something to school and was suspended. But because it was a white kid who brought a toy gun the conversation ended right there.

Imagine if they suspended Ahmed without all the police involvement but they let Jimmy get away with it because he brought a toy miniature gun?

Do you see how it could spin out of control? Law suits etc. So with a zero tolerance policy it's across the board, no exceptions everyone is treated the same no matter what.
 
But no policy was violated.

It wasn't a bomb.

It wasn't a fake bomb.

It is conceivable that it was intended to be a fake fake (yes, that's what I meant) bomb. It is also conceivable that it was something that was mistaken for a fake bomb.


Once again, if you give the school officials every possible benefit of the doubt, it becomes similar to the case where a kid was suspended for chewing a pop tart into the shape of a gun. In that case, it wasn't a gun. No one could have possibly suspected it was a gun. However, it was somehow still considered a replica of a gun, violating the replica weapons policy. That's stupid, because a symbol of a weapon is not a replica weapon.

Maybe, in this case, the clock was a symbolic representation of a weapon. Maybe, it was deliberately constructed to be a bomb-themed clock. i.e. a clock that was intended to be reminiscent of something that has been used as a replica bomb in a work of fiction.

If there is any policy that the school has in place that is so broad that it would cover this device, it is a stupid policy.

More likely, the policy doesn't cover this sort of device at all, but administrators are so eager to find violations of a policy that they misinterpret their own policy in such a way that it covers whatever they feel like it ought to cover on any given day.


It's funny I use this example ALL the time in my classes to teach why we shouldn't follow the media headlines.

As I said before when you work with teachers and the administrations in schools you will instantly know why the story of the damn pop tart is total BS.

Here's why, no teacher on the freakin' planet is going to be paying attention to what shape a kid is eating his food in the cafeteria. When I bring this up in class the teachers all laugh at the idea that ANY teacher ANYWHERE is going to be hovering over the children watching them eat their food.


The real story about the kid "with the poptart" is not that he "ate it into a shape of gun" it's that he then picked it up and went down the line of his friends at the table and pretended to shoot them. He could have gotten up with an EMPTY HAND and done the same thing and he would have been suspended.

Granted in this kids case it happened months after the Sandy Hook shooting and I'm sure the teachers were very sensitive to that and that may have influenced their reaction.

But he was NOT suspended for biting his food into the shape of a gun, he was suspended for pretending to shoot his classmates.

That's what is so annoying about the case with Ahmed. They aren't allowed to really respond to what happened to Ahmed because the issue is confidential so the family can go to the media and say whatever they want but the school can't defend their decision without violating student confidentiality rules.

People have huge knee jerk reactions based on half the story.


http://www.cbsnews.com/news/examiner-recommends-school-board-uphold-pop-tart-suspension/


ETA Just in case people are wondering, there are two distinctions drilled into a teachers head about intervention and suspension regarding a child's behavior in the classroom. One is their legal rights, the other is that the only time it is considered actionable is if it "Disrupts the learning environment."
 
Last edited:
Imagine if they suspended Ahmed without all the police involvement but they let Jimmy get away with it because he brought a toy miniature gun?

Without all the police involvement, it is a totally different story.
 
It's funny I use this example ALL the time in my classes to teach why we shouldn't follow the media headlines.

As I said before when you work with teachers and the administrations in schools you will instantly know why the story of the damn pop tart is total BS.

Here's why, no teacher on the freakin' planet is going to be paying attention to what shape a kid is eating his food in the cafeteria. When I bring this up in class the teachers all laugh at the idea that ANY teacher ANYWHERE is going to be hovering over the children watching them eat their food.


The real story about the kid "with the poptart" is not that he "ate it into a shape of gun" it's that he then picked it up and went down the line of his friends at the table and pretended to shoot them. He could have gotten up with an EMPTY HAND and done the same thing and he would have been suspended.

Granted in this kids case it happened months after the Sandy Hook shooting and I'm sure the teachers were very sensitive to that and that may have influenced their reaction.

But he was NOT suspended for biting his food into the shape of a gun, he was suspended for pretending to shoot his classmates.

That's what is so annoying about the case with Ahmed. They aren't allowed to really respond to what happened to Ahmed because the issue is confidential so the family can go to the media and say whatever they want but the school can't defend their decision without violating student confidentiality rules.

People have huge knee jerk reactions based on half the story.


http://www.cbsnews.com/news/examiner-recommends-school-board-uphold-pop-tart-suspension/


ETA Just in case people are wondering, there are two distinctions drilled into a teachers head about intervention and suspension regarding a child's behavior in the classroom. One is their legal rights, the other is that the only time it is considered actionable is if it "Disrupts the learning environment."

Lets get this straight. They suspended a kid for biting his food into a biscuit gun.

Brilliant.

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2
 
Lets get this straight. They suspended a kid for biting his food into a biscuit gun.

Brilliant.

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2

I love how you read what I wrote and interpreted it the way you did. This is what I mean about reading comprehension.:confused:
 
Without all the police involvement, it is a totally different story.

Absolutely, the police involvement and reaction and handcuffs particularly are ridiculous. I'm very glad they got that picture and shared it.


But this is why I think the teacher (I'm not sure who it was, perhaps the science teacher) in my opinion is the one who caused the whole mess.

We've seen Ahmed interviewed and he seems like a well mannered well spoken young man. I can't be sure but I believe that because the teacher told him to hide it and be secretive about having it, it changed the way he would have normally responded to the teacher.

You know, some people have said he may have wanted to show it off. Maybe he did, maybe he had the little timer go off and thought that the teacher would come up and be really impressed at his cool invention. deconstruction.

But then when the teacher freaked out Ahmed got scared and nervous remembering what the other teacher said and he shut down and that is what made the whole thing seem more suspicious.
 
Last edited:
But he was NOT suspended for biting his food into the shape of a gun, he was suspended for pretending to shoot his classmates.

I don't want to derail with a discussion about the actual specifics of the pop tart boy case. My point was that if you give Ahmed's school administrators every possible benefit of the doubt, then you might end up saying he brought a representation of a weapon into the school. Even if you do that, which would be stupid, the thing in his possession was not a "hoax bomb", and therefore was not in any way criminal.

Those handcuffs on Ahmed are not some irrelevant footnote to this story. They are the story.
 
I don't want to derail with a discussion about the actual specifics of the pop tart boy case. My point was that if you give Ahmed's school administrators every possible benefit of the doubt, then you might end up saying he brought a representation of a weapon into the school. Even if you do that, which would be stupid, the thing in his possession was not a "hoax bomb", and therefore was not in any way criminal.

Those handcuffs on Ahmed are not some irrelevant footnote to this story. They are the story.

No they aren't. The handcuffs were a decision made by the police department, not the school or the teacher.

Look it's very simple, you are not supposed to bring suspicious looking objects like that to school. Period the end.

The boy didn't know any better, he's a KID, he brought it to school because he was proud of his invention.

Teachers are mandated reporters of several things. One of those things is suspicious looking objects. It's not up to the teacher to stand there and analyze or try to figure out what the object is. They simply go to the principal and report it.

Simple right? What's this weird thing, I don't know, let's take it down to the office.

Science teacher sees it, "Hey Ahmed cool clock but you aren't really supposed to bring this to school, let me walk you down to the office and we'll turn it in."

The science teacher could have explained to the principal that it was a clock and dismantled the wires and taken it apart, put it back in the little suit case and left it at the office. Phone call home to parents, don't let him bring these things to school he could get in trouble.

Done.

Instead the teacher tells him to hide it and not to show it to the other teachers.

Now stop right there and realize that the teacher knows there's a zero tolerance policy, knows that maybe the other teachers won't realize, HAS EYES and can see it could seem strange.

Instead of being the responsible adult he tells a kid to LIE and to be secretive.

Totally wrong on all accounts.


The person who screwed up here is that teacher.

Oh and the cops, the cops are just ridiculous jerks.
 
Look it's very simple, you are not supposed to bring suspicious looking objects like that to school. Period the end.

Hogwash!

Show me that policy. You can't do it because there is no such policy. Period. The end.
 
But this is why I think the teacher (I'm not sure who it was, perhaps the science teacher) in my opinion is the one who caused the whole mess.

It's probably true that the science teacher could have handled it better. However, when it comes to assigning blame for the kid getting hauled away by police, I am inclined to blame the people who called the police, and the police themselves.
 
It is me being totally thick but I find it difficult to keep up with the novel like posts on here
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom