Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Oh boy! More evidence that the medium of Twitter saps intelligence.
(Or at least encourages omission of vital context)

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry...-of-committing-fraud_55fed260e4b08820d918fe9b

(Dawkins steps in it with an implication the kid planed it all to get the attention.)

I think Dawkins is questioning the boy's touted abilities and then wondering aloud why he would simply take the casing off a commercially available clock - IF that's what he did. It seems a fair question, and he offers more than one possibility such as that he may have wanted to get credit that was not his due. I doubt that Ahmed calculated he would get an invitation to the White House or that Dawkins thinks this either. Either way, Dawkins thinks the arrest was an over-reaction.

I think it is fair enough that Dawkins is leery of jumping on the feel-good narrative bandwagon.
 
Oh boy! More evidence that the medium of Twitter saps intelligence.
(Or at least encourages omission of vital context)

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry...-of-committing-fraud_55fed260e4b08820d918fe9b

(Dawkins steps in it with an implication the kid planed it all to get the attention.)

(A case of the blind watchmaker?)

If this kid did it on purpose in order to gain attention and a future full of scholarships, job opportunities, ect........ I almost respect that.
 
I'm pleased to see Muslims accepting 20th century technology. There may be hope.
 
If this kid did it on purpose in order to gain attention and a future full of scholarships, job opportunities, ect........ I almost respect that.

If he really did engineer the whole situation the he probably is a very smart boy. He played those jobsworth busybodies like a pro!
 
They suspected it was a hoax bomb, not a real bomb.

Ahmed is quoted as saying, "They arrested me and they told me that I committed the crime of a hoax bomb, a fake bomb"

Except that it wasn't a hoax bomb, and they knew it wasn't a hoax bomb. They knew it wasn't a hoax bomb, because when he showed it to people, he called it a clock.

A hoax is not a replica. It is not a (just) a fake. It is not something that looks like something else. It is a thing which is intended to make people think that it is the other thing. If you say, "look at my clock", then it isn't a hoax bomb. It's a clock, that is being reported as a clock.
 
If he himself admits it had the potential to look suspicious, is it totally unfathomable to think that someone else could've thought it was suspicious looking?


Not at all unreasonable. Fortunately, he went out of his way to tell them it is a clock, and have them examine it so that they could see it was a clock.
 
It's interesting to see how many people, such as Dawkins and several posters in this thread, go out of their way to note that "but arresting him was going too far."

Well that's the point, isn't it? Is it reasonable to be suspicious, and to give it some scrutiny? Yes, it is. They did so. They looked at it, and knew that it was a clock.

Is it reasonable to think that he was setting them up? Deliberately playing a prank, and then playing dumb about how anyone could have thought it was anything other than a clock? That's a little bit more difficult, and would depend a lot on how he acted when they confronted him, and perhaps a bit about his or his family's history as well. However, I can certainly give them a benefit of the doubt and say that they might well think he was playing a prank on them.

So, if that's the case, what should they have done? They should have done the exact opposite of what they did. If they really thought that was what he was doing, they could have said, "Nice try, Ahmed. Go back to class and you can pick your clock up after school." Instead, they called the police, which is why we are here, and why Ahmed is going to the White House.

ETA: I just read what Dawkins actually wrote. It's subtly different than what I thought it was, based on descriptions alone.
 
Last edited:
It's interesting to see how many people, such as Dawkins and several posters in this thread, go out of their way to note that "but arresting him was going too far."

Well that's the point, isn't it? Is it reasonable to be suspicious, and to give it some scrutiny? Yes, it is. They did so. They looked at it, and knew that it was a clock.

Is it reasonable to think that he was setting them up? Deliberately playing a prank, and then playing dumb about how anyone could have thought it was anything other than a clock? That's a little bit more difficult, and would depend a lot on how he acted when they confronted him, and perhaps a bit about his or his family's history as well. However, I can certainly give them a benefit of the doubt and say that they might well think he was playing a prank on them.

So, if that's the case, what should they have done? They should have done the exact opposite of what they did. If they really thought that was what he was doing, they could have said, "Nice try, Ahmed. Go back to class and you can pick your clock up after school." Instead, they called the police, which is why we are here, and why Ahmed is going to the White House.

"Pick up your clock after school."? Yeah, that probably would have been the most sensible solution.
 
If anything, it should be more of an embarrassment for those screaming, "It looks like a Bomb!" because what they are actually saying is... "I'm so ignorant about common electronic goods that I can't tell the inside of a standard alarm clock from a bomb timing device."

There's a lot of that going around.
 
Last edited:
Except that it wasn't a hoax bomb, and they knew it wasn't a hoax bomb. They knew it wasn't a hoax bomb, because when he showed it to people, he called it a clock.

A hoax is not a replica. It is not a (just) a fake. It is not something that looks like something else. It is a thing which is intended to make people think that it is the other thing. If you say, "look at my clock", then it isn't a hoax bomb. It's a clock, that is being reported as a clock.



After his engineering teacher advised him not to show it to other teachers, it went off during English class, which might have been avoidable, because according to a USA today article: "Police said the student had the briefcase in his English class, where he plugged it into an electrical outlet and it started to make noise."

What if this teacher genuinely thought it resembled something that looked like a bomb regardless of him saying it was a clock? Maybe this teacher thought he deliberately made the alarm go off and had the intention of bringing a dubious device to school that could easily be misinterpreted as a bomb to stir up controversy? It wasn't a conventional looking clock, and he himself said it had the potential to look suspicious in an interview.
 
Last edited:
Really bummed about Dawkins. He's written some terrific books explaining and popularizing complicated biological concepts. Now he has exposed himself as having terrible judgment, clouded by bigotry. I don't care if this kid did nothing but take the innards of a clock and chuck them into a book case, and called it the second coming of Marconi. To deflect from the absurd overreaction by the authorities by twisting logic like a pretzel, in claiming that a teenager intended to get arrested so he could be invited to the White House, reveals a crank, a fantasist and a nut.

It's a shame because his books have value for us all who care about spreading scientific knowledge. This idiocy on his part detracts from that.
 
To deflect from the absurd overreaction by the authorities by twisting logic like a pretzel, in claiming that a teenager intended to get arrested so he could be invited to the White House, reveals a crank, a fantasist and a nut.

Did you actually read the Tweet? I thought the same thing as what you said based on descriptions of what he said. However, his actual words didn't say that. It was much more reasonable.
 
I think Dawkins is questioning the boy's touted abilities and then wondering aloud why he would simply take the casing off a commercially available clock - IF that's what he did. It seems a fair question, and he offers more than one possibility such as that he may have wanted to get credit that was not his due. I doubt that Ahmed calculated he would get an invitation to the White House or that Dawkins thinks this either. Either way, Dawkins thinks the arrest was an over-reaction.

I think it is fair enough that Dawkins is leery of jumping on the feel-good narrative bandwagon.

It wasn't fair enough that I was! Or that a few other people in this thread were.

Notice the tweets that describe Dawkins now as a "conspiracy theorist who thinks a kid planned to get arrested so he could be famous". As if desiring fame is an unimaginable motivation for a 14 year old. But more to the point, Dawkins actually does not posit that the kid planned to get arrested; just that he intentionally misrepresented the "clock" he claimed to have "built".

I can't stand Dawkins; but in this case he happens to share my assessment. I think the "clock" looks like it was simply taken out of its original plastic shell and set into the pencil case intact; and I disagree with the popular assessment that this act constitutes an "impressive engineering feat" for a person of this age or indeed any age. It seems to me the procedure required no disconnection, reconnection, modification, or substitution of any of the clock's components - in fact, it wouldn't have required even a passing, most basic familiarity with or understanding of what the components involved even were, or what they did.

Why did he do it? I can only speculate of course. Based on his claims of how he presented the clock to his teacher, and the way he represents the "project" in the YouTube video, my assessment is that his intention was the same as mine in the anecdote I added a couple of pages ago - he intended to pass the clock off as an original creation, made by himself out of selected, previously unrelated parts and assembled using a claimed special knowledge of electronics that he did not necessarily have.

I further suggest that the engineering teacher he first showed the clock to, and whose reaction some have criticized as lukewarm, or not vocally "supportive enough" either at the time or afterwards, had this reaction because he recognized the "invention" as an obvious imposture, and did not want to call out the boy in front of his classmates but neither wanted to reward such casual charlatanry with gushing praise. I think it's possible this teacher has not spoken publicly about the incident for precisely this reason, and because he fears the reaction if he intimates that the "invention" was phony.
 
What if this teacher genuinely thought it resembled something that looked like a bomb regardless of him saying it was a clock?

People should not be arrested based on what other people sincerely think. Having people sincerely think things about you is not a crime, nor is it even probable cause to suspect a crime.
 
Did you actually read the Tweet? I thought the same thing as what you said based on descriptions of what he said. However, his actual words didn't say that. It was much more reasonable.


Dawkins' tweet, in response to a tweet asking what he thought Ahmed's motives were:

I don't know. Possibly wanted to be arrested? Police played into his hands? Anyway, now invited to White House, crowdfunded etc.


So, yes, I read it. Posing an absurd accusation in the form of a question doesn't erase responsibility.
 
I think it's possible this teacher has not spoken publicly about the incident for precisely this reason, and because he fears the reaction if he intimates that the "invention" was phony.

The teacher has not spoken publicly about this because the school has a (very appropriate) policy not to speak publicly about student disciplinary issues. I assume that the school principal has reminded all the teachers about that policy.
 
The teacher has not spoken publicly about this because the school has a (very appropriate) policy not to speak publicly about student disciplinary issues. I assume that the school principal has reminded all the teachers about that policy.

Nor do I think this whole line is relevant. If a 14 year old kid took shortcuts on a school project, passing off a factory electronic device as his own construction (if that's what happened), that still has nothing at all to do with subsequent events where a) police were called, b) said student is cuffed and taken into custody.

Why on Earth does Richard Dawkins care that a teenage kid possibly misrepresented a school project? It's because he wants to turn the muzzie into a villain. If he really thought there was no justification for the arrest, he would have said that and be done with it. But no, he had to go a tirade about a 9th grader's completely unrelated academic ethics.
 
It wasn't fair enough that I was! Or that a few other people in this thread were.

Notice the tweets that describe Dawkins now as a "conspiracy theorist who thinks a kid planned to get arrested so he could be famous". As if desiring fame is an unimaginable motivation for a 14 year old. But more to the point, Dawkins actually does not posit that the kid planned to get arrested; just that he intentionally misrepresented the "clock" he claimed to have "built".

I can't stand Dawkins; but in this case he happens to share my assessment. I think the "clock" looks like it was simply taken out of its original plastic shell and set into the pencil case intact; and I disagree with the popular assessment that this act constitutes an "impressive engineering feat" for a person of this age or indeed any age. It seems to me the procedure required no disconnection, reconnection, modification, or substitution of any of the clock's components - in fact, it wouldn't have required even a passing, most basic familiarity with or understanding of what the components involved even were, or what they did.

Why did he do it? I can only speculate of course. Based on his claims of how he presented the clock to his teacher, and the way he represents the "project" in the YouTube video, my assessment is that his intention was the same as mine in the anecdote I added a couple of pages ago - he intended to pass the clock off as an original creation, made by himself out of selected, previously unrelated parts and assembled using a claimed special knowledge of electronics that he did not necessarily have.

I further suggest that the engineering teacher he first showed the clock to, and whose reaction some have criticized as lukewarm, or not vocally "supportive enough" either at the time or afterwards, had this reaction because he recognized the "invention" as an obvious imposture, and did not want to call out the boy in front of his classmates but neither wanted to reward such casual charlatanry with gushing praise. I think it's possible this teacher has not spoken publicly about the incident for precisely this reason, and because he fears the reaction if he intimates that the "invention" was phony.

I don't know what you have said here that is in opposition to anything I have said.
 
Nor do I think this whole line is relevant. If a 14 year old kid took shortcuts on a school project, passing off a factory electronic device as his own construction (if that's what happened), that still has nothing at all to do with subsequent events where a) police were called, b) said student is cuffed and taken into custody.

Why on Earth does Richard Dawkins care that a teenage kid possibly misrepresented a school project? It's because he wants to turn the muzzie into a villain. If he really thought there was no justification for the arrest, he would have said that and be done with it. But no, he had to go a tirade about a 9th grader's completely unrelated academic ethics.

I think you are over-interpreting. He didn't cast aspersions on "the muzzie" (your terminology, by the way) and he says explicitly that the arrest was unjustified. As for why Dawkins is commenting on the issue, it is probably for the same reason any of us are. Because we - that is, you and me, and the other internet commentariat - feel perfectly entitled to air our opinions on anything that grabs our attention.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom