Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"


I don't believe that article is completely correct in its description. I quite remember discussing that case on these sumptuous forums when it occurred; and I quite distinctly remember that media articles, blogs, and forum posts at the time liked to call it a science project or a science fair experiment (as the Slate article does) when in fact it was not done for any class, or fair, or organized activity of any sort whatsoever, but rather something this girl put together on a whim after seeing it done on YouTube and decided to set off in the front yard of the school with her friends that day for entertainment.

Much like the media reporting on Ahmed's Radio Shack clock, the story is creatively reinterpreted by those reporting and spreading it for maximum outrage. She wasn't just a girl trying to replicate a YouTube video for kicks, she was a dedicated student, perfecting and experimenting with a "science project", and the school disciplining her for setting off an unauthorized (albeit miniscule) chemical explosion on school grounds in the midst of a crowd of other students was an overreaction by a stuffy establishment frightened by this brave girl's scientific inquisitiveness and noncomformity. In the Clock Caper, the police thought it was a prank "bomb"; that wasn't a good enough story, so instead we say "they all thought it was a bomb", so that not only can we can condemn the overreaction, but we can taunt the teachers and police for being "too stupid to know what a real bomb would look like" and being "too dumb to recognize a clock" that's been removed from its case - unlike the student, on the other hand, who is obviously quite bright enough to have "invented" this "homemade clock" out of kit or hobby parts (but not really).
 
I blame them for all the things they did after their suspiciousness lead them to thoroughly examine the device. Specifically ... for trying to get him to sign away his rights. ...

Speaking of that: if he had signed, would that have stood up in court? I know that contracts signed by minors aren't considered to be valid, but what about a minor signing that sort of thing?
 
I don't believe that article is completely correct in its description. I quite remember discussing that case on these sumptuous forums when it occurred; and I quite distinctly remember that media articles, blogs, and forum posts at the time liked to call it a science project or a science fair experiment (as the Slate article does) when in fact it was not done for any class, or fair, or organized activity of any sort whatsoever, but rather something this girl put together on a whim after seeing it done on YouTube and decided to set off in the front yard of the school with her friends that day for entertainment.

Much like the media reporting on Ahmed's Radio Shack clock, the story is creatively reinterpreted by those reporting and spreading it for maximum outrage. She wasn't just a girl trying to replicate a YouTube video for kicks, she was a dedicated student, perfecting and experimenting with a "science project", and the school disciplining her for setting off an unauthorized (albeit miniscule) chemical explosion on school grounds in the midst of a crowd of other students was an overreaction by a stuffy establishment frightened by this brave girl's scientific inquisitiveness and noncomformity. In the Clock Caper, the police thought it was a prank "bomb"; that wasn't a good enough story, so instead we say "they all thought it was a bomb", so that not only can we can condemn the overreaction, but we can taunt the teachers and police for being "too stupid to know what a real bomb would look like" and being "too dumb to recognize a clock" that's been removed from its case - unlike the student, on the other hand, who is obviously quite bright enough to have "invented" this "homemade clock" out of kit or hobby parts (but not really).

The problem is that I don't understand why you whole long screed is even important. She was apparently a good student with no history of trouble.

She did something that was kind of neat and did not do anything to hurt anybody. For this, she was given ten days suspension and basically kicked out of that school for a year.

Seems to have continued her education and is studying mechanical engineering.

The issue is the crazy overreaction by the schools in both of these cases.
 
I don't believe that article is completely correct in its description. I quite remember discussing that case on these sumptuous forums when it occurred; and I quite distinctly remember that media articles, blogs, and forum posts at the time liked to call it a science project or a science fair experiment (as the Slate article does) when in fact it was not done for any class, or fair, or organized activity of any sort whatsoever, but rather something this girl put together on a whim after seeing it done on YouTube and decided to set off in the front yard of the school with her friends that day for entertainment.

Much like the media reporting on Ahmed's Radio Shack clock, the story is creatively reinterpreted by those reporting and spreading it for maximum outrage. She wasn't just a girl trying to replicate a YouTube video for kicks, she was a dedicated student, perfecting and experimenting with a "science project", and the school disciplining her for setting off an unauthorized (albeit miniscule) chemical explosion on school grounds in the midst of a crowd of other students was an overreaction by a stuffy establishment frightened by this brave girl's scientific inquisitiveness and noncomformity. In the Clock Caper, the police thought it was a prank "bomb"; that wasn't a good enough story, so instead we say "they all thought it was a bomb", so that not only can we can condemn the overreaction, but we can taunt the teachers and police for being "too stupid to know what a real bomb would look like" and being "too dumb to recognize a clock" that's been removed from its case - unlike the student, on the other hand, who is obviously quite bright enough to have "invented" this "homemade clock" out of kit or hobby parts (but not really).

Dude/dudette. They were stupid

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2
 
I don't believe that article is completely correct in its description. I quite remember discussing that case on these sumptuous forums when it occurred; and I quite distinctly remember that media articles, blogs, and forum posts at the time liked to call it a science project or a science fair experiment (as the Slate article does) when in fact it was not done for any class, or fair, or organized activity of any sort whatsoever, but rather something this girl put together on a whim after seeing it done on YouTube and decided to set off in the front yard of the school with her friends that day for entertainment.

Much like the media reporting on Ahmed's Radio Shack clock, the story is creatively reinterpreted by those reporting and spreading it for maximum outrage. She wasn't just a girl trying to replicate a YouTube video for kicks, she was a dedicated student, perfecting and experimenting with a "science project", and the school disciplining her for setting off an unauthorized (albeit miniscule) chemical explosion on school grounds in the midst of a crowd of other students was an overreaction by a stuffy establishment frightened by this brave girl's scientific inquisitiveness and noncomformity. In the Clock Caper, the police thought it was a prank "bomb"; that wasn't a good enough story, so instead we say "they all thought it was a bomb", so that not only can we can condemn the overreaction, but we can taunt the teachers and police for being "too stupid to know what a real bomb would look like" and being "too dumb to recognize a clock" that's been removed from its case - unlike the student, on the other hand, who is obviously quite bright enough to have "invented" this "homemade clock" out of kit or hobby parts (but not really).

Dude/dudette. They were stupid

Sent from my GT-S6802 using Tapatalk 2

QFT


The highlighted part is what makes it so particularly stupid.

Nobody has said that Ahmed ever claimed it was a bomb. The school and police knew it was not a bomb. Ahmed says he always told them it was a clock - and there is no reason to disbelieve him. It doesn't even disagree with the accounts stated by the school or police where a teacher identified the clock as a fake bomb.

"What's that?"
"My clock I made"
"It looks like a fake bomb"
"It's a clock"
"Oh noes it's a fake bomb disguised as a perfectly functioning clock with invisible explosives - and why are you being passive aggressive about my manifest stupidity?"
"Arrest this child and see if we can do this illegally*"


*This website looks kosher and would suggest the parents could have a case:

If the police arrest or detain a child and refuse the child’s request to call his parents or another adult, or to talk to an attorney, there can be more consequences than the child’s statements being kept out in court. The parents could file a complaint with the police department or local government against the officers or department involved. If the situation was particularly serious and the child was physically abused or deprived of food, water, or rest while being interrogated by police, the parents could file a lawsuit on behalf of the child for violation of the child’s civil rights.
 
QFT


The highlighted part is what makes it so particularly stupid.

Nobody has said that Ahmed ever claimed it was a bomb. The school and police knew it was not a bomb. Ahmed says he always told them it was a clock - and there is no reason to disbelieve him. It doesn't even disagree with the accounts stated by the school or police where a teacher identified the clock as a fake bomb.

"What's that?"
"My clock I made"
"It looks like a fake bomb"
"It's a clock"
"Oh noes it's a fake bomb disguised as a perfectly functioning clock with invisible explosives - and why are you being passive aggressive about my manifest stupidity?"
"Arrest this child and see if we can do this illegally*"


*This website looks kosher and would suggest the parents could have a case:

Oi, I already posted that website; no stealing my thunder! :D
 
Looks like he could build one hell of a bomb with all the stuff Microsoft gave him.
 

Attachments

  • achmed bomb.jpg
    achmed bomb.jpg
    50.9 KB · Views: 12
Most 14 year olds are "inventing" things with LEGO blocks, at best. What he was doing has real world relevance for engineering.

The LEGOs that kids much younger than 14 play with these days are not the LEGOs you're thinking of. They use Lego Mindstorms, which is basically robotics. It's absolutely huge now, and there are all kinds of competitions for 9 year olds up through high school. It's much more involved than ripping apart a 30 year old alarm clock and mounting it in a pencil case. Still, kudos to the kid for what most likely was a great publicity stunt. There's nothing like milking victimhood to get ahead in the world.
 
The LEGOs that kids much younger than 14 play with these days are not the LEGOs you're thinking of. They use Lego Mindstorms, which is basically robotics. It's absolutely huge now, and there are all kinds of competitions for 9 year olds up through high school. It's much more involved than ripping apart a 30 year old alarm clock and mounting it in a pencil case. Still, kudos to the kid for what most likely was a great publicity stunt. There's nothing like milking victimhood to get ahead in the world.

What makes you think they're "milking" this.

The family rightly complained, which was picked up and various people decided to demonstrate their disapproval of the actions of the authorities.
 
This website looks kosher and would suggest the parents could have a case:

From a legal standpoint, I doubt there is a case. It would depend on state law. Note that the quote mentions three options:

1. Statements are kept out of court. Since no charges will be filed, this doesn’t matter.

2. A complaint filed with police or local government. The mayor seems to have quite a thing against Muslims, so a complaint with local government hasn’t much chance. The police chief already says he is investigating the matter. There probably won’t be any legal action, but there is a chance of disciplining the officers or establishing new policies.

3. A lawsuit if the child was abused or deprived food, water, or rest. There is no indication that happened.

The officers may not have broken any laws or polices, and even any statements made may have been permissible in court, depending on the circumstances and state law. However, it seems unreasonable that the child could not contact his parents. I would think the police would want to contact the parents themselves. Actually, if the father had been contacted I expect the whole matter could have been straightened out before it got to the point of hauling the kid off to jail.

Hopefully the investigation will at least result in establishing new policies regarding contacting the parents, if such policies are not already in place.
 
The LEGOs that kids much younger than 14 play with these days are not the LEGOs you're thinking of. They use Lego Mindstorms, which is basically robotics. It's absolutely huge now, and there are all kinds of competitions for 9 year olds up through high school. It's much more involved than ripping apart a 30 year old alarm clock and mounting it in a pencil case. Still, kudos to the kid for what most likely was a great publicity stunt. There's nothing like milking victimhood to get ahead in the world.

A proper response to this would get me yellow carded at bare minimum. But thanks for your predictable and obvious contribution of dubious merit to the conversation.
 
What makes you think they're "milking" this.

The family rightly complained, which was picked up and various people decided to demonstrate their disapproval of the actions of the authorities.

There's little reason to go to the news media, except to milk it. There's little reason to accept all of the invitations to give interviews, except to milk it. I have a 14 year old son. I doubt he or any of his friends would like to be interviewed on national TV, especially when it means that he's being asked to bad-mouth his school and his teachers. Let's just say that I'm skeptical of the media narrative that Obama, Zuckerberg, Twitter, and Microsoft (and most of the so-called skeptics here) have accepted without much question, or much in the way of evidence as to exactly what transpired.
 
The LEGOs that kids much younger than 14 play with these days are not the LEGOs you're thinking of. They use Lego Mindstorms, which is basically robotics. It's absolutely huge now, and there are all kinds of competitions for 9 year olds up through high school. It's much more involved than ripping apart a 30 year old alarm clock and mounting it in a pencil case. Still, kudos to the kid for what most likely was a great publicity stunt. There's nothing like milking victimhood to get ahead in the world.

The 14 year olds I work with on robotics teams do much more impressive work than Ahmed did here. He should join his local robotics team.


However, that's still not the point. The quality of the work is not significant. The point is that it was a clock, and he told everyone it was a clock. Therefore, it was not a hoax bomb.

Some idiots have taken various "replica weapons" policies and laws to be interpreted so broadly that anything that anyone could possibly mistake for a weapon falls under the weapons policies. That is stupid. If you make a mistake, that is not my violating a policy. It is not a bomb unless it can explode. It is not a fake bomb unless it is manufactured to look substantially similar to something that can explode. Even if it is a fake bomb, it is not a hoax bomb unless you do something to make people think it is a bomb. If you tell people, "this is a clock", then it is not a hoax bomb.

Pwengthold brought up the slide rule analogy, and that analogy isn't bad, but it doesn't capture the thought that, perhaps, there is a device that is deliberately meant to make people anxious about bombings. I'll give another analogy to illustrate what I mean.

Suppose a different student, we'll call him Abdul, shows up at school one day with a pressure cooker, and he says to a teacher, "I have a pressure cooker." The teacher examines it, and finds that it is indeed, an empty pressure cooker. He asks the kid, "Why did you bring in this pressure cooker?" and Abdul refuses to answer.

Obviously, this kid is doing something wrong. He knows full well that when they see a Muslim kid with a pressure cooker going into school what they will think. This is a very bad situation.

So what's the difference between the hypothetical Abdul and the very real Ahmed? None. Because Abdul has not committed a crime. The pressure cooker is not a hoax bomb. He told everyone it was a pressure cooker. He is being a jerk and making some sort of political statement, but he isn't trying to make anyone think he is trying to blow something up. He is saying, "You shouldn't freak out when you see Muslims doing something you don't understand." Abdul deserves a detention for creating a nuisance with a political statement, but he shouldn't be arrested.

As for Ahmed, it is possible he was doing exactly what my hypothetical Abdul was doing, or it is possible he likes to tinker with electronics and thought he made a cool looking pencil case themed clock. I don't care which one it was, he shouldn't be in handcuffs, and good on him for getting a White House invite out of the deal, and shame on the Irving PD for playing into his hands if indeed he was trying some sort of publicity stunt.
 
Last edited:
Um, they weren't suspicious. They never thought it might be a bomb. They accused him of making a hoax bomb. Despite the fact that he never claimed or pretended it was a bomb.

As I said yesterday, it's like bringing a slide rule to school and being accused of bringing a toy gun. Or a fake Swiss army knife

I hate the zero tolerance policies with a passion but in my experience this has nothing to do with race I and friends of mine were hit up with very similar idiocy back in the day.

I was in high school during the columbine Era, which was also the Era of the bullet necklace fad. Several friends as well as myself redirected varying levels of punishment for said necklaces (fake bullets btw). As if one who would shoot up the school would bring one bullet, and wear it like a murderous barney fife.

This is a failure of a silly policy not racism.
 
The 14 year olds I work with on robotics teams do much more impressive work than Ahmed did here. He should join his local robotics team.


However, that's still not the point. The quality of the work is not significant. The point is that it was a clock, and he told everyone it was a clock. Therefore, it was not a hoax bomb.

Some idiots have taken various "replica weapons" policies and laws to be interpreted so broadly that anything that anyone could possibly mistake for a weapon falls under the weapons policies. That is stupid. If you make a mistake, that is not my violating a policy. It is not a bomb unless it can explode. It is not a fake bomb unless it is manufactured to look substantially similar to something that can explode. Even if it is a fake bomb, it is not a hoax bomb unless you do something to make people think it is a bomb. If you tell people, "this is a clock", then it is not a hoax bomb.

Pwengthold brought up the slide rule analogy, and that analogy isn't bad, but it doesn't capture the thought that, perhaps, there is a device that is deliberately meant to make people anxious about bombings. I'll give another analogy to illustrate what I mean.

Suppose a different student, we'll call him Abdul, shows up at school one day with a pressure cooker, and he says to a teacher, "I have a pressure cooker." The teacher examines it, and finds that it is indeed, and empty pressure cooker. He asks the kid, "Why did you bring in this pressure cooker?" and Abdul refuses to answer.

Obviously, this kid is doing something wrong. He knows full well that when they see a Muslim kid with a pressure cooker going into school what they will think. This is a very bad situation.

So what's the difference between the hypothetical Abdul and the very real Ahmed? None. Because Abdul has not committed a crime. The pressure cooker is not a hoax bomb. He told everyone it was a pressure cooker. He is being a jerk and making some sort of political statement, but he isn't trying to make anyone think he is trying to blow something up. He is saying, "You shouldn't freak out when you see Muslims doing something you don't understand." Abdul deserves a detention for creating a nuisance with a political statement, but he shouldn't be arrested.

As for Ahmed, it is possible he was doing exactly what my hypothetical Abdul was doing, or it is possible he likes to tinker with electronics and thought he made a cool looking pencil case themed clock. I don't care which one it was, he shouldn't be in handcuffs, and good on him for getting a White House invite out of the deal, and shame on the Irving PD for playing into his hands if indeed he was trying some sort of publicity stunt.

We are not privy to what he told his teachers or what he told police or how he responded to questions. Although I think the zero-tolerance policy of schools is ridiculous, and is just another manifestation of humans assessing risk incorrectly due to availability bias, there is little doubt that bringing an unrecognizable mass of "homemade" electronic equipment in a small box could cause alarm in a public school in this day and age.

While I agree that it seemed over-the-top to put the kid in handcuffs and to take him down to the station without his parents present, it is not clear to me what the official policy is, nor whether the specific version of events that we've heard from the kid's family is correct.

Those that say that such a mess of electronics is clearly a clock are being completely ridiculous. Even if it's obvious that the LED display is doing clock like things, why isn't it possible for it to be a clock plus something else? You can fit a whole computer onto a tiny circuit board now. What if it was also a microphone or a video camera that he was going to place in the staff restroom? What if it was going to blare a loud farting sound in the middle of an assembly? What if it was going to set off a short-circuit and start smoking to set off a fire alarm in the middle of a test? Even an experienced electrical engineer would need some time to break it down and figure out all the things that it could do besides keep time like a clock.
 
Last edited:
It's interesting that conservatives are against big government....unless it's aimed at making life horrible for minorities.
 
It's interesting that conservatives are against big government....unless it's aimed at making life horrible for minorities.

I'm completely against the zero tolerance policies of the government-run public schools. However, I'm also against double standards. And I think the accusations that this kid's ethnicity played a meaningful role in his treatment by the school and the police are completely unsupported. On the other hand, I think the mind-boggling attention and rewards he is receiving now have everything to do with his ethnicity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom