Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

We are not privy to what he told his teachers or what he told police or how he responded to questions. Although I think the zero-tolerance policy of schools is ridiculous, and is just another manifestation of humans assessing risk incorrectly due to availability bias, there is little doubt that bringing an unrecognizable mass of "homemade" electronic equipment in a small box could cause alarm in a public school in this day and age.

While I agree that it seemed over-the-top to put the kid in handcuffs and to take him down to the station without his parents present, it is not clear to me what the official policy is, nor whether the specific version of events that we've heard from the kid's family is correct.

It is clear to me that it is the official policy of the United States of America that the police cannot put you in handcuffs, throw you in a squad car, take you to the station, fingerprint you, interrogate you, and take your photograph unless there is probable cause to believe that you have committed a crime, and it is clear to me that there was no probable cause to believe that a crime had been committed.

Those that say that such a mess of electronics is clearly a clock are being completely ridiculous. Even if it's obvious that the LED display is doing clock like things, why isn't it possible for it to be a clock plus something else? You can fit a whole computer onto a tiny circuit board now. What if it was also a microphone or a video camera that he was going to place in the staff restroom? What if it was going to blare a loud farting sound in the middle of an assembly? What if it was going to set off a short-circuit and start smoking to set off a fire alarm in the middle of a test? Even an experienced electrical engineer would need some time to break it down and figure out all the things that it could do besides keep time like a clock.

It could have been any of those things. (The smoke one would be difficult, but not incredibly difficult.) It could not have been an explosive device, because it was examined and found to only contain printed circuit boards.

And I suppose it could have been a very, very, clever, explosive device using explosives designed to look exactly like batteries, LEDs and circuit boards. However, the school officials determined that it was not such a device. How do we know, because if they thought there was any possibility that it was such a device, they would have evacuated the school, or at least called the bomb squad for disposal. They didn't do that, because they knew it wasn't a bomb.

As for the other possibilities, some of which would be marginal crimes, lots of students were carrying devices with them that could easily do any of those things, and which also could be real bombs, and yet none of them were questioned. (I am speaking of laptop computers, which are easily modded to blow up, and could be modded to make smoke as well.) It is not a crime to carry something which could be something else.
 
It is clear to me that it is the official policy of the United States of America that the police cannot put you in handcuffs, throw you in a squad car, take you to the station, fingerprint you, interrogate you, and take your photograph unless there is probable cause to believe that you have committed a crime, and it is clear to me that there was no probable cause to believe that a crime had been committed.

If the police acted improperly here, it would hardly be the first time that police have done so. I suspect they would argue that the intention to cause alarm was probable cause. Or giving evasive answers to questions was probable cause. It's for a court to sort out I suppose. If it happened to my son, I would certainly retain a lawyer and threaten to sue (although I most certainly would not have gone to the media).

It could have been any of those things. (The smoke one would be difficult, but not incredibly difficult.) It could not have been an explosive device, because it was examined and found to only contain printed circuit boards.

And I suppose it could have been a very, very, clever, explosive device using explosives designed to look exactly like batteries, LEDs and circuit boards. However, the school officials determined that it was not such a device. How do we know, because if they thought there was any possibility that it was such a device, they would have evacuated the school, or at least called the bomb squad for disposal. They didn't do that, because they knew it wasn't a bomb.

As for the other possibilities, some of which would be marginal crimes, lots of students were carrying devices with them that could easily do any of those things, and which also could be real bombs, and yet none of them were questioned. (I am speaking of laptop computers, which are easily modded to blow up, and could be modded to make smoke as well.) It is not a crime to carry something which could be something else.

There are costs and benefits to any action. If you think the probability of something being a bomb is low, you might not think it is worth the cost of an evacuation (which is large) compared to the benefit (reduction of risk). That doesn't mean the probability of it being a bomb is zero, however. Likewise, the fact that everyday items brought to school can be used in dangerous fashion is also subject to a cost benefit analysis. It would simply be too costly to prohibit students from bringing laptops to school, let alone check out each one carefully each day. The risk that a student will take advantage of this "loophole" to bring in a disruptive or dangerous device is simply one that the school as determined to accept. That tolerance does not need to extend to a mess of unrecognizable electronics in a pencil box, nor should it.
 
It's interesting that conservatives are against big government....unless it's aimed at making life horrible for minorities.

their fear of over-reaching government doesn't apply to police, only to policies that help the poor or minorities. Every thread here about a police over-reaction ends up with them defending the cops and attacking the victim, no matter what.
 
Looks like he could build one hell of a bomb with all the stuff Microsoft gave him.

Maybe he can 3D print a better "case" for his Radio Shack clock. Like one that doesn't have to be opened in order to read the time. Maybe he could even 3D print some buttons, so he can actually set the time on the clock. As opposed to just plugging it in and watching it flash 12:00 and saying "look what I made!"
 
I suspect they would argue that the intention to cause alarm was probable cause. Or giving evasive answers to questions was probable cause.

They might argue it. Woe be unto us if any court ever accepts such ridiculous arguments. The first example is not inherently ridiculous, but it doesn't fit the facts of the case, specifically, saying, "this is a clock". The second is just scary. If the cops can arrest you based on "evasive answers", (or "passive-aggressive" answers), there is something seriously wrong here.

That tolerance does not need to extend to a mess of unrecognizable electronics in a pencil box, nor should it.

I agree, but there's a difference between school policy and arrest. If they had given the kid a detention, we wouldn't be discussing the case.


As an aside, you have said the family are "milking it", Absolutely. And why not? It has turned out very well for this kid. What's wrong with it?
 
The 14 year olds I work with on robotics teams do much more impressive work than Ahmed did here. He should join his local robotics team.

Reports early in the cycle stated that he had been on the robotics team in middle school and his HS didn't have one.

Just a clarifier, I have no disagreement with the remainder of your post.
 
What makes you think they're "milking" this.

The family rightly complained, which was picked up and various people decided to demonstrate their disapproval of the actions of the authorities.
There's little reason to go to the news media, except to milk it. There's little reason to accept all of the invitations to give interviews, except to milk it. I have a 14 year old son. I doubt he or any of his friends would like to be interviewed on national TV, especially when it means that he's being asked to bad-mouth his school and his teachers. Let's just say that I'm skeptical of the media narrative that Obama, Zuckerberg, Twitter, and Microsoft (and most of the so-called skeptics here) have accepted without much question, or much in the way of evidence as to exactly what transpired.

Justified anger at how their son had been treated would be sufficient reason.

No need to milk it.

<slight strawman>

I suppose it was rather uppity of his family though


</slight strawman>
 
Bill Mahar is the type of guy that you hate when you disagree with him, but like when he's on your side.

I thought he got this exactly right.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=33&v=aGit-XltUB4

I completely disagree with one of Maher's points, which seems to be that extra scrutiny of a 14 year old Muslim kid in high school is appropriate just because of his religion. I think the additional risk from the higher probability that he is a jihadist on a terror mission is so small as to be negligible. It is so completely swamped by other factors (e.g. whether the kid is a good student or not, or has been depressed, or comes from a broken home) that it is much better for society to refrain from such ethnic profiling. I honestly don't believe ethnic profiling happened in this case. I suspect that Ahmed was known to his teachers to be a good student and a nice kid, and that such impressions would have trumped any general Islamophobia.
 
I completely disagree with one of Maher's points, which seems to be that extra scrutiny of a 14 year old Muslim kid in high school is appropriate just because of his religion.

I think you misunderstood him. I think he understood it. As do I. The school is less then an hour from where muslim extremists targeted and event.
 
I think you misunderstood him. I think he understood it. As do I. The school is less then an hour from where muslim extremists targeted and event.

A) what event
B) what's the statute of limitation in miles on how far we cast the net of suspicion at anyone who fits an unspecified profile?
C) how vague can we make the profile? Can we we target anyone with any name kinda Arab sounding?
 
A) what event
B) what's the statute of limitation in miles on how far we cast the net of suspicion at anyone who fits an unspecified profile?
C) how vague can we make the profile? Can we we target anyone with any name kinda Arab sounding?

A) Draw Mohammad
b) 120 miles
c) Very vague and yes.
 

And you can understand why they may be a little more worried about Islamic extremism then many places..... and actually far right anti-goverment extremists as well.... and spree killings considering the gun culture... ect
 
Ahmed states in a video posted by The Dallas Morning News: "I closed it with a cable, 'cause I didn't want to lock it to make it seem like a threat, so I just used a simple cable so it won't look that much suspicious." If it was just an "innocent looking clock", why did he think there was any chance of it appearing threatening or suspicious to begin with? If he himself admits it had the potential to look suspicious, is it totally unfathomable to think that someone else could've thought it was suspicious looking?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom