Meadmaker
Unregistered
- Joined
- Apr 27, 2004
- Messages
- 29,033
We are not privy to what he told his teachers or what he told police or how he responded to questions. Although I think the zero-tolerance policy of schools is ridiculous, and is just another manifestation of humans assessing risk incorrectly due to availability bias, there is little doubt that bringing an unrecognizable mass of "homemade" electronic equipment in a small box could cause alarm in a public school in this day and age.
While I agree that it seemed over-the-top to put the kid in handcuffs and to take him down to the station without his parents present, it is not clear to me what the official policy is, nor whether the specific version of events that we've heard from the kid's family is correct.
It is clear to me that it is the official policy of the United States of America that the police cannot put you in handcuffs, throw you in a squad car, take you to the station, fingerprint you, interrogate you, and take your photograph unless there is probable cause to believe that you have committed a crime, and it is clear to me that there was no probable cause to believe that a crime had been committed.
Those that say that such a mess of electronics is clearly a clock are being completely ridiculous. Even if it's obvious that the LED display is doing clock like things, why isn't it possible for it to be a clock plus something else? You can fit a whole computer onto a tiny circuit board now. What if it was also a microphone or a video camera that he was going to place in the staff restroom? What if it was going to blare a loud farting sound in the middle of an assembly? What if it was going to set off a short-circuit and start smoking to set off a fire alarm in the middle of a test? Even an experienced electrical engineer would need some time to break it down and figure out all the things that it could do besides keep time like a clock.
It could have been any of those things. (The smoke one would be difficult, but not incredibly difficult.) It could not have been an explosive device, because it was examined and found to only contain printed circuit boards.
And I suppose it could have been a very, very, clever, explosive device using explosives designed to look exactly like batteries, LEDs and circuit boards. However, the school officials determined that it was not such a device. How do we know, because if they thought there was any possibility that it was such a device, they would have evacuated the school, or at least called the bomb squad for disposal. They didn't do that, because they knew it wasn't a bomb.
As for the other possibilities, some of which would be marginal crimes, lots of students were carrying devices with them that could easily do any of those things, and which also could be real bombs, and yet none of them were questioned. (I am speaking of laptop computers, which are easily modded to blow up, and could be modded to make smoke as well.) It is not a crime to carry something which could be something else.