It interests me how often here in this section or in the politics section of the Forum certain people will go to any lengths to try to make their prior statements "right" in some way, any way, no matter what.
Now we are discussing whether any object that shows the time and has wires in it be should be considered a "fake" bomb, and thus is prohibited by school rules against apparent weapons.
1. Obviously if this clock was intended to be a fake bomb, it was a complete failure. There was no attempt to include shapes in or on it that look anything like explosives, cartoon, movie, or real. It looked like a digital clock in a box. And the kid never made any claims it was a bomb: he voluntarily showing it to his engineering teacher, took his advice to not show anyone else until the alarm went off, at which time the kid showed it was innoculous to his English teacher and stated quite correctly that it was a clock when asked by a long string of authority figures.
2. It simply looked like a clock mounted in a relatively plain pencil case that would appeal to most children. How did this plain box of a clock look anything more like a fake bomb than the typical alarm clock, except that the case was built at home? We all have equal or more dangerous looking clocks in our cars and next to our beds. I have count down timers at my work. Was the kid's clock counting down like a movie bomb? It was simply counting up and displaying time in common with any digital clock.
3. For all we know the engineering teacher told the kid to not show it around school because, like any cool object, it would be disruptive to most classroom environments, just as if I brought in a weak laser pointer or a cool autumn leaf. Even if the teacher feared others might think of it as a bomb, it was not likely that the engineering teacher himself thought it looked like a fake bomb, but probably because he feared that the other teachers were really stupid (the latter was proven correct unfortunately).
4. Pens and pencils are allowed in school, yet are clearly more able to be used as weapons than a clock. I don't think that school rules ban anything that a crazy stupid person might be able to interpret as a fake or real weapon. I hope not.
5. I personally am convinced that the race and religion of the poor boy played a critical role in the nature of the response. But even if that was not not the case: I agree that it was fair to ask the boy what the alarm sound in his backpack was coming from. It was fair, on seeing the object, to ask the boy what it was and even, perhaps, to ask him to open it (obviously no one thought it was a real bomb- that is not how they reacted at all). Once it was clear that is was just a clock, it might have even been reasonable to send it to the principal's office until the boy could pick it up at the end of the day. But that was not the reaction as soon as the English teacher saw it, and the rest of the school's was clownish and stupid (and probably racist). I am deeply sorry for what the boy was forced to experience.