Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Of course it was!! Muslims have a MASSIVE image problem. ISIS doesn't help. The Many backwards countries governed by Islam don't help. 9/11 didn't help. Many people have a natural suspicion of Muslims. Yes it has over the top, stupid, ect. But it's going to continue to happen as long as the image problem exists.
Don't you think the teachers would have had a decent idea what the kid was like?

I suggest the teachers had to be seriously bigoted not to know enough about one of their students that he was into technology and not into jihadism.

It sounds like the mayor of the town isn't much better.

Irving Mayor Defends School And Cops, Doesn't Apologize For Arrest Of Muslim Teen Over Clock

What protocol says arrest the kid first, find out if there is actually a problem second?
 
Yes, it's unfortunate but there are rules about zero tolerance policies in school.

Far too many people debate the way they are just blanketed rules. But they have to be, purely for the amount of time it would take and the amount of legal issues that would open up if it wasn't just a blanket policy.


The goal isn't to punish the child but to deter kids from bringing things in like this. That doesn't mean kids don't bring things in like this, they are KIDS after all. He doesn't know any better.

That's why I keep pointing out that the teacher is wrong.

And this is why also his suspension STILL STANDS. He's still suspended. Or did everyone miss that.

In my opinion the problem was his reaction to getting busted with it and how he came across to the English teacher. I believe this is because of the actions of the first teacher.

There was no reason for them to call the police. They could have simply suspended him.



ETA not a "clock" a home made device like that. So let's take it out of the "terrorism" arena for a second. Let's say Ahmed wasn't this super great engineer and he put together this wired up device and he's going over his friends house after school to work on it. Totally innocent. (as he was in this case) But a wire glitches and it sets of a spark that hits paper in his bag and sets the bag on fire.

It would create an issue that would interrupt the educational process for the day. They'd have to do a fire alarm and put it out, investigate what happened etc. All based on an innocent act by the kid. So just don't bring things like that to school guys, it's unnecessary and not the place.

"Not the place," for 'things like this!?" IT WAS AN EDUCATIONAL EXCERCISE, FOR CRISSAKES!

The kid brought it in to show his electronics teachers! There was nothing.....lemme repeat that again....NOTHING!....wrong whatsoever with what this kid did. Sure, it's just a 3 day suspension. As a pparent, I would fight tooth and nail against that suspension. It's the principal of the matters.

"Yeah, the kid didn't do anything wrong. But he's still going to be punished anyways, just because..."

********.
 
How is it that the Engineering Teacher failed to identify the device as a clock? I mean this is someone who is supposed to teach this sort of thing to kids right?
 
How is it that the Engineering Teacher failed to identify the device as a clock? I mean this is someone who is supposed to teach this sort of thing to kids right?

I could be wrong but I thought all the teachers were cool till he showed his English teacher.

They went psycho paranoid
 
Surely if anyone of the random adults involved had actually suspected it was any sort of bomb, the school would have been evacuated?

It appears not so I still don't understand needing the police.

^^^^^^^^^^This! Gawds, a person I work with saw the photo, and was like: "Yup. Looks like a bomb to me." At which point, her and I got into an argument about it. My point was, if it actually LOOKS LIKE A BOMB, THE SCHOOL SHOULD HAVE BEEN EVACUATED IMMEDIATELY! PERIOD!

Whatever teacher tries to claim it looked like a bomb, outta be fired for not notifying the office, and getting his or students the hell outta there.

I'm not defending Ahmed's suspension or arrest, but according to the police, when they interrogated him he didnt tell them that it was made for an engineering project or that he brought it to school to show to his engineering teacher. I think that's what they mean about him not providing a "broader explanation".

That interrogation is both illegitimate, and highly illegal. Therefore, I do not consider it to be any evidence of anything.
 
Last edited:
Don't you think the teachers would have had a decent idea what the kid was like?

I suggest the teachers had to be seriously bigoted not to know enough about one of their students that he was into technology and not into jihadism.

There's countless stories of buffoon administrators at schools suspending kids of all backgrounds for the silliest of things, so I don't see any particular reason to invoke bigotry as the explanation behind this particular act of stupidity. You don't have to be into jihadism to make a fake bomb. Bombs have been a concern for schools for several decades now.
 
There's countless stories of buffoon administrators at schools suspending kids of all backgrounds for the silliest of things, so I don't see any particular reason to invoke bigotry as the explanation behind this particular act of stupidity. You don't have to be into jihadism to make a fake bomb. Bombs have been a concern for schools for several decades now.
But if you have a student who makes a clock, says it's a clock and you know the kid is a nerdy engineering type, where does the fake bomb threat even come from here? How did that even become an issue?

Was the school evacuated?
Did the kid joke it was a bomb?


I don't agree that a white kid with a briefcase clock would have been ignored. But I do think if a nerdy engineering type white kid told his teacher it was a clock he made, none of the rest would have happened.
 
There's countless stories of buffoon administrators at schools suspending kids of all backgrounds for the silliest of things, so I don't see any particular reason to invoke bigotry as the explanation behind this particular act of stupidity. You don't have to be into jihadism to make a fake bomb. Bombs have been a concern for schools for several decades now.

IT WASN'T A BOMB!
IT DID NOT RESEMBLE A BOMB!
IT WAS NOT A "HOAX BOMB!"

NEWS AT 11!
 
I'm not american so could be totally wrong, but from viewing from the other side of the world it just looks like

Kid goes to school
Has pieces of plastic with wires hanging out of it
Shows everyone it is a clock
Goes to one teacher who realises
He ain't white. He is Muslim, so it must be a bomb
Cops turn up try to get him to say it is a fake bomb. He won't. Because it is a clock as he says
They don't bother evacuating the school and arrest him even though it is plainly a clock as he says
 
There's countless stories of buffoon administrators at schools suspending kids of all backgrounds for the silliest of things, so I don't see any particular reason to invoke bigotry as the explanation behind this particular act of stupidity. You don't have to be into jihadism to make a fake bomb. Bombs have been a concern for schools for several decades now.

the news reports include the kid walking into the room of cops and one he didn't know said, "yeah, that's who I thought it was." Taken at face value that seems slightly pre judging.
 
The whole zero tolerance based on "it looks like a fake weapon to me" is completely stupid. It results, time and time again, in students being suspended because of totally arbitrary and subjective things. Should a student be suspended for bringing one of these to school? Looks like a fake weapon to me... How about one of these... A Parker Pen? Yeah, pull the other one, I've seen James Bond movies, it's clearly a well disguised fake explosive assassination device!

Seriously. Why should anyone get suspended from school because of "Well it looks like a [fill in blank] to me"? Stupidity!


Now a couple of things for correction.....

The English Teacher (as far as we know) didn't do it. The English teacher confiscated the clock and put it on his/her desk. It was a few periods later when Ahmed was pulled from class to be arrested. Clearly the English teacher had shown it to someone else who then overreacted.

Second, it was not a briefcase. It was a pencil case.
 
Second, it was not a briefcase. It was a pencil case.

For those who don't have kids and don't pay attention to what sort of school supplies are popular these days:

Pencil cases like this are all the rage with school kids right now. They are about 8 inches by 4 inches by two inches, hard-sided, with hinges, latches, and handles, little corner things made of metal, many of them are entirely made of metal. They look a bit like briefcases, only much much smaller.

The only difference was that this one had a digital display.

Probably half of the kids in the school have them, maybe more. The non-nerd, non-geek kids use them to store pencils, pens, drugs, knives, cell phones* and the other accouterments of high school life.


*Now a cell phone really can be used as a detonator. They ought be arresting kids with cell phones**.


**The nerd and geek kids could have informed the school authorities of that, if the school authorities were not so busy getting the geeky nerd*** kid arrested.

***In my world, getting called a geek or a nerd is a compliment. It really is, I hope to god my kids grow up to be geeky nerds.

http://www.vaultz.net/school/shop-classroom/pencil-boxes-and-pouches.html
 
Last edited:
I don't think it was an excuse as much as an explanation. It's expected that people are going to treat Muslims with suspicion, violence even, because of a perception that is forged by violent actions perpetrated by a small minority of them. That, and they're different. It's silly, but it's very human.

Oddly I have had no problem being friendly with everyone of them I have ever actually met. More oddly there is no race with which I have ever been unfriendly. Now, as to the ones known to want to harm all of us I believe I am on record rather prominently here!!! BTW I actually do have friends who are republicans. We avoid politics and religion in discussions!!
 
There's countless stories of buffoon administrators at schools suspending kids of all backgrounds for the silliest of things, so I don't see any particular reason to invoke bigotry as the explanation behind this particular act of stupidity. You don't have to be into jihadism to make a fake bomb. Bombs have been a concern for schools for several decades now.

How many of them went off? In the US of course? I ask as I am mighty certain that I know the answer.
 
the news reports include the kid walking into the room of cops and one he didn't know said, "yeah, that's who I thought it was." Taken at face value that seems slightly pre judging.

Repeated for emphasis. The kid had never seen the cop before but the cop knew the was an EVIL MUSLIM TERRORIST in the school already.
 
the news reports include the kid walking into the room of cops and one he didn't know said, "yeah, that's who I thought it was." Taken at face value that seems slightly pre judging.

The police claim the cop said, "that's not who I thought it was."

I can see the mistake.

But the police chief could not explain why if they thought it was a bomb they didn't evacuate the school, nor why the boy's parents weren't called.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom