Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

The difference between a pocket knife and a clock is not negligible.
Is suspension the appropriate response to children bringing anything other than their books and pens to school?
If he had been disruptive, or had gone around pretending he had a bomb, I could understand the suspension, but as it is, I can't see how what he has done is any worse than bringing a drawing or painting to show to his arts teacher, or a poem to show to his English teacher.

And doesn't it seem likely that the engineering teacher didn't confiscate the object because he didn't think it violated any rules?
But since he knew a beeping blinking object could potentially be disru1ptive he advised the kid to keep it in his bag, which he did.


A good American name like McVeigh or Kaczynski.


Come on, this line of reasoning is ridiculous. First up if the engineering teacher didn't think any thing was wrong with it, then why did he tell him not to show it to the other teachers?

Number 2 it doesn't appear that they thought it was a "real bomb' but more like a joke mock up bomb. Bomb experts chiming in that it doesn't look like a real bomb is irrelevant.

Number 3 a peanut butter sandwich is not normally considered a lethal weapon, but it can be lethal to even ONE STUDENT.

The policies are put in place to protect students, not to dodge teaching opportunities or to punish kids.

The engineering teacher was wrong.
 
Come on, this line of reasoning is ridiculous. First up if the engineering teacher didn't think any thing was wrong with it, then why did he tell him not to show it to the other teachers?

[...]

The engineering teacher was wrong.

Damn right the engineering teacher was a bit dim. But the fact that Ahmed showed it to the engineering teacher, and then followed the engineering teacher's instructions on what to do with it, should be protection enough from suspension.

Let's work the peanut butter sandwich analogy a little further. Suppose a kid quite innocently brings a peanut butter sandwich to school and shows it to his teacher. If the teacher says, "OK, you can keep the sandwich but don't let anybody else see it," then another teacher finds out about it, does that warrant a suspension of the kid? Or does it, perhaps, warrant a quick "Learn the rules and don't be so stupid next time" dressing down for the teacher?

Whatever policies are put in place to protect the students, there should also be some protection for students who follow teachers' reasonable-sounding instructions.

Dave
 
Oh, I can.

I know I'm supposed to turn my phone to silent during meetings. I know that. My phone has a simple switch to turn off the ringtone - it takes less than five seconds to do. But damned if my phone doesn't suddenly go off in the middle of a meeting and I have to scrabble about to turn the ringer off while everyone glares at me.

I certainly don't do it to draw attention to myself.

I was thinking the same thing. Who has not had an alarm clock (or cell phone) go off at the wrong time? Who has not had trouble remembering how to turn the alarm off on an unfamiliar clock?

I think that is almost universal.

I am getting comments on my FB feed now that the clock was actually part of an assigned project. I have not yet seen any news accounts that verify that.
 
Damn right the engineering teacher was a bit dim.

I'm not sure about that. The only bit of the engineering teacher's words or actions I've seen is a single sentence paraphrased by the Ahmed.

Unless you've seen a different source than I have, we really don't know what he said.
 
Come on, this line of reasoning is ridiculous. First up if the engineering teacher didn't think any thing was wrong with it, then why did he tell him not to show it to the other teachers?

Number 2 it doesn't appear that they thought it was a "real bomb' but more like a joke mock up bomb. Bomb experts chiming in that it doesn't look like a real bomb is irrelevant.

Number 3 a peanut butter sandwich is not normally considered a lethal weapon, but it can be lethal to even ONE STUDENT.

The policies are put in place to protect students, not to dodge teaching opportunities or to punish kids.

The engineering teacher was wrong.

But no policy was violated.

It wasn't a bomb.

It wasn't a fake bomb.

It is conceivable that it was intended to be a fake fake (yes, that's what I meant) bomb. It is also conceivable that it was something that was mistaken for a fake bomb.


Once again, if you give the school officials every possible benefit of the doubt, it becomes similar to the case where a kid was suspended for chewing a pop tart into the shape of a gun. In that case, it wasn't a gun. No one could have possibly suspected it was a gun. However, it was somehow still considered a replica of a gun, violating the replica weapons policy. That's stupid, because a symbol of a weapon is not a replica weapon.

Maybe, in this case, the clock was a symbolic representation of a weapon. Maybe, it was deliberately constructed to be a bomb-themed clock. i.e. a clock that was intended to be reminiscent of something that has been used as a replica bomb in a work of fiction.

If there is any policy that the school has in place that is so broad that it would cover this device, it is a stupid policy.

More likely, the policy doesn't cover this sort of device at all, but administrators are so eager to find violations of a policy that they misinterpret their own policy in such a way that it covers whatever they feel like it ought to cover on any given day.
 
Once they knew it was a nothing but a clock, "broader explanation" could only means "something we could charge him with". And I admire the kid keeping his cool and "maintaining it was a clock". Never give police a "broader explanation".

I'm not defending Ahmed's suspension or arrest, but according to the police, when they interrogated him he didnt tell them that it was made for an engineering project or that he brought it to school to show to his engineering teacher. I think that's what they mean about him not providing a "broader explanation".
 
Oh my gods and monsters, are you serious?

He is still suspended because you are not supposed to bring things like that to school. There's a zero tolerance policy.
Citation please

Again, the original teacher who saw the clock should have walked him down to the office and said "Hey Ahmed made this cool clock and we're going to turn it in now for him to pick up after school."

Had he done that none of this would have been an issue.

Instead the teacher told him to hide it from others and not show anyone. Then the boy gets "caught" with it in the bag. The reaction the boy had most likely contributed to the way it appeared to the English teacher. He seemed "busted" or "in trouble" and "nervous."

The other teacher told him it was something to be secretive about. He's a 14 year old kid, in interviews you can see that he's a pretty respectful kid. So it's clear that his reaction to being "caught" with something that the other teacher told him was wrong to have, most likely contributed to how he responded to the English teacher.
citation please that the engineering teacher told him to "hide" it


Compare it to a kid bringing a pocket knife to school with him that his boy scout troop got over the weekend.

If a kid came up and showed you it in school, would you

A. Tell him, "hey this is cool but you can't have this in school. Let's take it to the principals office now."

or


B. Tell him to hide it in his bag and not show it to other teachers.

That's what caused the entire mess.

And again, the picture of him in handcuffs is absolutely ridiculous.
Invalid comparison as knives are specifically disallowed in schools and science projects are not
The kid mentioned in the interview that he's thinking of changing schools. Smart move Ahmed, maybe some benefactor will pay for your education at a private school! I hope they do.
I don't. I hope he gets the best free education America can provide. That means leaving Texas.
 
Last edited:
Come on, this line of reasoning is ridiculous. First up if the engineering teacher didn't think any thing was wrong with it, then why did he tell him not to show it to the other teachers?

Number 2 it doesn't appear that they thought it was a "real bomb' but more like a joke mock up bomb. Bomb experts chiming in that it doesn't look like a real bomb is irrelevant.

Number 3 a peanut butter sandwich is not normally considered a lethal weapon, but it can be lethal to even ONE STUDENT.

The policies are put in place to protect students, not to dodge teaching opportunities or to punish kids.

The engineering teacher was wrong.

I can't read minds so I don't know what the STEM teacher said or thought or why. If you want information on Randi's million dollar challenge I'm sure you can ask around.
 
I'm not defending Ahmed's suspension or arrest, but according to the police, when they interrogated him he didnt tell them that it was made for an engineering project or that he brought it to school to show to his engineering teacher. I think that's what they mean about him not providing a "broader explanation".

None of the reports I've seen lead me to that conclusion. All the reports I've seen lead me to the conclusion the cops were questioning him with preconceived notions to which he failed to conform, instead insisting he made a clock to make a clock. Which made him "passive aggressive."
 
I'm not defending Ahmed's suspension or arrest, but according to the police, when they interrogated him he didnt tell them that it was made for an engineering project or that he brought it to school to show to his engineering teacher. I think that's what they mean about him not providing a "broader explanation".

From what I've read, it sounds like the police wanted a "better" explanation than "I built a clock." Like, they can't conceive of somebody wanting to build a clock, when you can just buy one at a store for $10. Obviously, the kid was just trying to cause trouble. If you look at the environment the kid's living in, this does not seem like a stretch. If you read the article somebody posted earlier, you know that Irving's mayor regularly gives lectures on her belief that Muslims have secret Sharia courts, and they're using them to try to take over the US.

I commend him on being savvy enough to not say that it's an engineering project. I was under the impression that he'd built it on his own initiative, not as a school project. If that's the case, saying that it's an "engineering project" would be a mistake. The police would go to the teacher, ask him if he gave Ahmed the assignment, and when he said "No", they would return and say "You lied to us. That's perjury."
 
This child may or may not be a mechanical prodigy, but he was trying something new, something that his teacher had very likely encouraged in the past or he wouldn't have thought to bring it in to show that teacher.

Point of information - he's a high school freshman and school just started. It was entirely his own whim to try and impress his teacher in that fashion.
 
Invalid comparison as knives are specifically disallowed in schools and science projects are not

1. It was not a science project; it doesn't seem he even tried to show it to a science teacher

2. Non-functional lookalike weapons are specifically disallowed in schools, and as it seems the teachers and police considered it to be a "prop bomb" (rightly or wrongly), that's likely the rule he was disciplined under.
 
Charles Stross suggests starting Bring a Clock to School Day.


Many years ago at secondary school I too built a clock using a couple of ICs and a small breadboard. Mine even had flashing red LEDs and yet no-one cried "bomb".
:rolleyes:

But, is any part of your real name Mohammed (or similar)?:confused::confused:
 
commend him on being savvy enough to not say that it's an engineering project.

Ah, I was under the mistaken impression that it was a school assignment. So what I should have said was that, according to the police, Ahmed didn't tell them "I made it to impress my engineering teacher" or something similar.
 
1. It was not a science project; it doesn't seem he even tried to show it to a science teacher

2. Non-functional lookalike weapons are specifically disallowed in schools, and as it seems the teachers and police considered it to be a "prop bomb" (rightly or wrongly), that's likely the rule he was disciplined under.

1) A teacher tasked with teaching STEM isn't a science teacher. Good to know.
2) Ahmed never claimed it was anything but a clock. But he's just a kid, so we don't need to give his voice any respect. And he's Muslim so we can all agree he's probably lying.


And the reason he's not being charged for the hoax bomb accusation is . . .

Wait for it ......


It wasn't a hoax bomb but just a clock.
 
It interests me how often here in this section or in the politics section of the Forum certain people will go to any lengths to try to make their prior statements "right" in some way, any way, no matter what.

Now we are discussing whether any object that shows the time and has wires in it be should be considered a "fake" bomb, and thus is prohibited by school rules against apparent weapons.

1. Obviously if this clock was intended to be a fake bomb, it was a complete failure. There was no attempt to include shapes in or on it that look anything like explosives, cartoon, movie, or real. It looked like a digital clock in a box. And the kid never made any claims it was a bomb: he voluntarily showing it to his engineering teacher, took his advice to not show anyone else until the alarm went off, at which time the kid showed it was innoculous to his English teacher and stated quite correctly that it was a clock when asked by a long string of authority figures.

2. It simply looked like a clock mounted in a relatively plain pencil case that would appeal to most children. How did this plain box of a clock look anything more like a fake bomb than the typical alarm clock, except that the case was built at home? We all have equal or more dangerous looking clocks in our cars and next to our beds. I have count down timers at my work. Was the kid's clock counting down like a movie bomb? It was simply counting up and displaying time in common with any digital clock.

3. For all we know the engineering teacher told the kid to not show it around school because, like any cool object, it would be disruptive to most classroom environments, just as if I brought in a weak laser pointer or a cool autumn leaf. Even if the teacher feared others might think of it as a bomb, it was not likely that the engineering teacher himself thought it looked like a fake bomb, but probably because he feared that the other teachers were really stupid (the latter was proven correct unfortunately).

4. Pens and pencils are allowed in school, yet are clearly more able to be used as weapons than a clock. I don't think that school rules ban anything that a crazy stupid person might be able to interpret as a fake or real weapon. I hope not.

5. I personally am convinced that the race and religion of the poor boy played a critical role in the nature of the response. But even if that was not not the case: I agree that it was fair to ask the boy what the alarm sound in his backpack was coming from. It was fair, on seeing the object, to ask the boy what it was and even, perhaps, to ask him to open it (obviously no one thought it was a real bomb- that is not how they reacted at all). Once it was clear that is was just a clock, it might have even been reasonable to send it to the principal's office until the boy could pick it up at the end of the day. But that was not the reaction as soon as the English teacher saw it, and the rest of the school's was clownish and stupid (and probably racist). I am deeply sorry for what the boy was forced to experience.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom