Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

It's also interesting to me that the kid is accused of being "passive aggressive", is that code for not actually aggressive but sticking to his guns ?
Insufficient grovelling to the authorities I suspect.

An interview with the "suspect."
http://www.latimes.com/visuals/video/la-na-ahmed-video20150916-embeddedvideo.html

Yep, I wanna buy him a soldering station. Anyone here with crowd funding experience? Seriously.
I think there's one already.

A bit of the future just died.
Maybe it's time to end the war on nerds... :mad:
Yep let's eliminate people's interest in innovation.

So, um, this device that they supposedly thought was a bomb...uh, did anyone treat it As such? You know, clear the area, safely detonate it, and so forth?
Nope.

It's Texas, they have a zero tolerance policy for science in school!
It does seem that way.
 
No what I mean is what I said. (Seriously WTF is up with the knee jerk rage induced posting style on this site where people don't ever bother to read what was actually written before spewing out a fuming litany of bullspit.


Again, his engineering teacher TOLD him not to show it to the other teachers. They didn't call the cops immediately did they....stop.........think..........who was he probably talking to.............think try........


OK so he's being passive aggressive and withholding because his ENGINEERING TEACHER told him not to tell anyone else. That's probably why they called the cops.

It probably had more to do with his DEMEANOR than what he was actually saying.

Walks out grumbling....................I don't even know why I bother trying to have a rational reasonable discussion on this site EVER.

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

If they had given him a detention for being disrespectful to a teacher, this wouldn't have made headlines.

They arrested him and led him away in handcuffs.

Who cares what his DEMEANOR was? Really. Unless he was being violent, who cares? In the old days, even if he was being violent that wouldn't have mattered, because he's a pretty scrawny 14 year old and the staff could pretty easily subdue him and put him in his place. However, in these times, you could get sued for that, so if he had been being violent or threatening to be violent, then our idiotic society has created a situation where arrest could be warranted. However, he wasn't. There's just no excuse.

I would need more information to determine the exact sort of stupidity that was being displayed here, but I don't need more information to determine that this was stupid.


Of course, this is the best thing that ever happened to him. He's going to get some money, and a trip to the White House, and his 15 minutes of fame.

ETA: This is odd. There's an exclamation point in the title area of this post. I didn't put it there, (on purpose anyway), and I can't see a way to get rid of it.
 
Last edited:
If they had given him a detention for being disrespectful to a teacher, this wouldn't have made headlines.

They arrested him and led him away in handcuffs.

Who cares what his DEMEANOR was? Really. Unless he was being violent, who cares? In the old days, even if he was being violent that wouldn't have mattered, because he's a pretty scrawny 14 year old and the staff could pretty easily subdue him and put him in his place. However, in these times, you could get sued for that, so if he had been being violent or threatening to be violent, then our idiotic society has created a situation where arrest could be warranted. However, he wasn't. There's just no excuse.

I would need more information to determine the exact sort of stupidity that was being displayed here, but I don't need more information to determine that this was stupid.


Of course, this is the best thing that ever happened to him. He's going to get some money, and a trip to the White House, and his 15 minutes of fame.

ETA: This is odd. There's an exclamation point in the title area of this post. I didn't put it there, (on purpose anyway), and I can't see a way to get rid of it.


He is still suspended because you are not supposed to bring things like that to school. There's a zero tolerance policy.

Again, the original teacher who saw the clock should have walked him down to the office and said "Hey Ahmed made this cool clock and we're going to turn it in now for him to pick up after school."

Had he done that none of this would have been an issue.

Instead the teacher told him to hide it from others and not show anyone. Then the boy gets "caught" with it in the bag. The reaction the boy had most likely contributed to the way it appeared to the English teacher. He seemed "busted" or "in trouble" and "nervous."

The other teacher told him it was something to be secretive about. He's a 14 year old kid, in interviews you can see that he's a pretty respectful kid. So it's clear that his reaction to being "caught" with something that the other teacher told him was wrong to have, most likely contributed to how he responded to the English teacher.


Compare it to a kid bringing a pocket knife to school with him that his boy scout troop got over the weekend.

If a kid came up and showed you it in school, would you

A. Tell him, "hey this is cool but you can't have this in school. Let's take it to the principals office now."

or


B. Tell him to hide it in his bag and not show it to other teachers.

That's what caused the entire mess.

And again, the picture of him in handcuffs is absolutely ridiculous.


The kid mentioned in the interview that he's thinking of changing schools. Smart move Ahmed, maybe some benefactor will pay for your education at a private school! I hope they do.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it's unfortunate but there are rules about zero tolerance policies in school.

Far too many people debate the way they are just blanketed rules. But they have to be, purely for the amount of time it would take and the amount of legal issues that would open up if it wasn't just a blanket policy.


The goal isn't to punish the child but to deter kids from bringing things in like this. That doesn't mean kids don't bring things in like this, they are KIDS after all. He doesn't know any better.

That's why I keep pointing out that the teacher is wrong.

And this is why also his suspension STILL STANDS. He's still suspended. Or did everyone miss that.

In my opinion the problem was his reaction to getting busted with it and how he came across to the English teacher. I believe this is because of the actions of the first teacher.

There was no reason for them to call the police. They could have simply suspended him.



ETA not a "clock" a home made device like that. So let's take it out of the "terrorism" arena for a second. Let's say Ahmed wasn't this super great engineer and he put together this wired up device and he's going over his friends house after school to work on it. Totally innocent. (as he was in this case) But a wire glitches and it sets of a spark that hits paper in his bag and sets the bag on fire.

It would create an issue that would interrupt the educational process for the day. They'd have to do a fire alarm and put it out, investigate what happened etc. All based on an innocent act by the kid. So just don't bring things like that to school guys, it's unnecessary and not the place.
 
Last edited:
I recognize that I have a peculiar bent to come up with conspiracy theories. I don’t trust myself much on those theories. It is just a matter of considering all angles. Maybe I have played too much Forum Mafia.

So, where does my CT fail?

I think your CT is possibly correct in a very broad sense. The kid may have deliberately made something that looked like a fake bomb.


Now, let's parse that sentence above. He didn't make something that looked like a bomb. He didn't make something that was intended to look like a bomb. He may have made something that was intended to look like a fake bomb. That second level of misdirection is actually pretty important.

No one thought it was a bomb. No one was intended to think it was a bomb. He wasn't trying to create a threat using a fake bomb. He was, if your CT is correct, trying to create a mental image using some sort of parody device, which obviously was not a bomb.

When questioned about whether or not he was deliberately making something that could be mistaken for a fake bomb. He may very well have disingenuously said that it was just a clock, when he knew very well that it was a clock that was modded to give the appearance of a bad parody of a movie-style bomb.

In other words, he may have been having a little joke, and displayed an attitude. Arresting him for that is a sign that we live in very weird times, and a sign that the authorities involved were idiots.


And, the above gives the authorities every possible benefit of the doubt. If you do that, they seem like idiots. That's the most generous possible interpretation of their behavior.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it's unfortunate but there are rules about zero tolerance policies in school.

Far too many people debate the way they are just blanketed rules. But they have to be, purely for the amount of time it would take and the amount of legal issues that would open up if it wasn't just a blanket policy.


The goal isn't to punish the child but to deter kids from bringing things in like this. That doesn't mean kids don't bring things in like this, they are KIDS after all. He doesn't know any better.

That's why I keep pointing out that the teacher is wrong.

And this is why also his suspension STILL STANDS. He's still suspended. Or did everyone miss that.

In my opinion the problem was his reaction to getting busted with it and how he came across to the English teacher. I believe this is because of the actions of the first teacher.

There was no reason for them to call the police. They could have simply suspended him.



ETA not a "clock" a home made device like that. So let's take it out of the "terrorism" arena for a second. Let's say Ahmed wasn't this super great engineer and he put together this wired up device and he' going over his friends house after school to work on it. Totally innocent. (as he was in this case) But a wire glitches and it sets of a spark that hits paper in his bag and sets the bag on fire.

It would create an issue that would interrupt the educational process for the day. They'd have to do a fire alarm and put it out, investigate what happened etc. All based on an innocent act by the kid. So just don't bring things like that to school guys, it's unnecessary and not the place.

How is it not the place? A school is meant to be a place of learning to do new things and trying to be creative; your attitude toward this sort of thing is apparently stifle creativity and advocate for conformity. Everyone must do exactly the same thing with no deviation. Well that's just stupid, as far as I'm concerned. This child may or may not be a mechanical prodigy, but he was trying something new, something that his teacher had very likely encouraged in the past or he wouldn't have thought to bring it in to show that teacher. That type of attitude should be cheered on and nurtured, not stifled and hidden from the world. The school was intolerant and is CLEARLY in the wrong here; how you can't see that is utterly beyond me at this point.
 
He brought it to English class in his bag, where the alarm started beeping during class. The English teacher complained about the beeping. He built the device. He knew how it worked. He knew it had an alarm. He knew the alarm would go off during class. Yet, he did not disable the device. He did not even turn off the alarm. So he has a device that he built and knows how to operate that he knows may appear as suspicious or a threat, which he has been told not to show to other teachers, but he sets up the device to set off an alarm during class. I can’t imagine why he would do that unless he wanted to draw attention to the device.
Oh, I can.

I know I'm supposed to turn my phone to silent during meetings. I know that. My phone has a simple switch to turn off the ringtone - it takes less than five seconds to do. But damned if my phone doesn't suddenly go off in the middle of a meeting and I have to scrabble about to turn the ringer off while everyone glares at me.

I certainly don't do it to draw attention to myself.
 
How is it not the place? A school is meant to be a place of learning to do new things and trying to be creative; your attitude toward this sort of thing is apparently stifle creativity and advocate for conformity. Everyone must do exactly the same thing with no deviation. Well that's just stupid, as far as I'm concerned. This child may or may not be a mechanical prodigy, but he was trying something new, something that his teacher had very likely encouraged in the past or he wouldn't have thought to bring it in to show that teacher. That type of attitude should be cheered on and nurtured, not stifled and hidden from the world. The school was intolerant and is CLEARLY in the wrong here; how you can't see that is utterly beyond me at this point.


Ok it's stupid as far as you are concerned. I get that. I constantly see people rant and rave about this fantasy land version of the school system and how it's supposed to be this bastion of learning and open mindedness.

Cheering on the childrens minds expecting to learn at every moment

I talk about this in my classes. I call it the Cosby show version of teaching.


In reality you have kids that show up, are not taken care of properly by parents at home, live in foster homes, are not properly fed or nurtured, who have bad attitudes and bully other children.

(I love this ying yang reality people have when discussing the education system. On the one hand they lament the lack of funding, the bullying, the lack of supplies needed, the busted social structures in homes, the way teachers are over worked.

Then in the same breath they expect teachers to be these super enthusiastic Mary Poppins learning advocates who place learning above all other legal issues.)


Teachers have enough crap to deal with every day BEFORE they even get to teaching, to have to take on more unnecessary legal issues and problems.

If you want to homeschool your kids, then by all means you can do whatever you want. But when you are in a system with policies in place they are there for a reason.

Your response is the same kind of response I see when people freak out because a child at a school has been diagnosed with a life threatening peanut allergy and the school enacts a zero tolerance policy in bringing peanut butter to school.

It may not make sense to you but it's done there for a bigger problem.

Some problems you might not realize

A. Recording devices
B. Electronic devices used for cheating on tests
C. Video taping devices.


(Awaits the inevitable "why should a teacher worry that they are being recorded or taped, if they are doing a good job they shouldn't care at all!!" Not realizing these are in place to protect other students and their privacy. Based on the number of suicides occurring when kids use social media and tape recording devices to embarrass their classmates)

But continue. I'd love to hear why you think in all your vast experience as an educator in a school system think this policy is crippling the brilliance of enthusiastic students.
 
Last edited:
When they searched his computer did it show any links to ISIS or Al Qaeda websites?
 
I'm just glad that things are working out well for the kid. Everyone at that school is now looking a complete idiot, and the cops don't look too good in this either (he was being detained by five officers? Really?). No doubt all these people are influenced by their psychopathic mayor.
 
BBC News: Ahmed's clock - Just what is a 'suspicious' object?

"One of the problems is that few people will have actually seen an explosive device in real life. Ahmed's clock consisted of a circuit board and power supply connected to a digital display by a few wires. "It looks like a movie bomb to me," said one of his questioners. But social media was ablaze with people ridiculing that judgement."


A few years back, I was travelling on the London Underground and - comign to the major station where I was due to change lines (London Bridge) - I noticed that on the ledge behind the seats there was one of those small paper carrier bags with string handles. Looking down into it, I saw a Filofax on top of what I quickly realised was obviously a mobile phone charger. I took it off the train and handed it in to staff on the gateline, remarking that it was a good job nobody had spotted the wires and jumped top the wrong conclusion, thus triggering a security alert.
 
Charles Stross suggests starting Bring a Clock to School Day.


Many years ago at secondary school I too built a clock using a couple of ICs and a small breadboard. Mine even had flashing red LEDs and yet no-one cried "bomb".
:rolleyes:
 
Oh, I can.

I know I'm supposed to turn my phone to silent during meetings. I know that. My phone has a simple switch to turn off the ringtone - it takes less than five seconds to do. But damned if my phone doesn't suddenly go off in the middle of a meeting and I have to scrabble about to turn the ringer off while everyone glares at me.

I certainly don't do it to draw attention to myself.
Even less fun when the ringtone is a song by AC, going "Beat beat beat beat beat beat beat YOUR WIFE!" :)
 
I see the kid is going to the White House....Cool. Praise from Obama for being interested in science and engineering.

Now for a real "incident".....

Some years ago, we got a call of a "suspicious object". Sitting in the quadrangle, days before Commencement, was a suitcase with a red LED glowing and a red push-button.
No threats, no "intelligence".
While we were cordoning off the area, several more complaints came in, from all over the campus. There were a total of 7 of these devices at various points around the campus.
Severe panic.....We were just about to call the local National Guard base where they have an EOD unit... When it was learned that this was an "art project", and that the student's professor had forgotten to notify everyone.
When pressed, the button on each box caused a taped message to play from a cheap cassette player inside.

Most folks are, as noted, conditioned by TV and movies and expect a big, glowing, countdown clock to be attached to a bomb.
Few seem to realize that you also need a quantity of explosive....
 
It looks like a movie bomb.
If by movie bomb you mean "electronic device that doesn't resemble a real bomb and no rational person would have any reason to believe it does" then I would agree with you.

I hope no police officer actually said it looked like a movie bomb.

Ranb
 
Compare it to a kid bringing a pocket knife to school with him that his boy scout troop got over the weekend.
If a kid came up and showed you it in school, would you
A. Tell him, "hey this is cool but you can't have this in school. Let's take it to the principals office now."
or
B. Tell him to hide it in his bag and not show it to other teachers.
That's what caused the entire mess.

The difference between a pocket knife and a clock is not negligible.
Is suspension the appropriate response to children bringing anything other than their books and pens to school?
If he had been disruptive, or had gone around pretending he had a bomb, I could understand the suspension, but as it is, I can't see how what he has done is any worse than bringing a drawing or painting to show to his arts teacher, or a poem to show to his English teacher.

And doesn't it seem likely that the engineering teacher didn't confiscate the object because he didn't think it violated any rules?
But since he knew a beeping blinking object could potentially be disruptive he advised the kid to keep it in his bag, which he did.

I wonder how the story would have gone had he a whitey name...
A good American name like McVeigh or Kaczynski.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom