Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

Obviously, we really just have one side of the story, but it does seem like the kid suffered a huge injustice. I still doubt very much it had anything to do with the color of his skin or his ethnicity, although perhaps the lack of outrage does. Even though Sikhs have the right skin-tone, they don't count as disadvantaged minorities because they tend to have well above-average incomes in whatever country they reside.
 
Obviously, we really just have one side of the story, but it does seem like the kid suffered a huge injustice. I still doubt very much it had anything to do with the color of his skin or his ethnicity, although perhaps the lack of outrage does. Even though Sikhs have the right skin-tone, they don't count as disadvantaged minorities because they tend to have well above-average incomes in whatever country they reside.

And this affects the behavior of a bigoted bully how, now?

Sorry, I think you're wrong as could be. Bullying is never about the victim and what positive social value or status they do or do not have; bullying is about the bully tearing down others in an attempt to raise their own sense of self worth. Anyone who can be counted as the Other is a potential target, and if the victim has some level of social status (ie, wealth) that actually makes them more attractive as a victim.

As for why Ahmed's Clock blew up the internet but this case didn't, well, solve that Better mousetrap and laugh all the way to the bank.
 
And this affects the behavior of a bigoted bully how, now?

Sorry, I think you're wrong as could be. Bullying is never about the victim and what positive social value or status they do or do not have; bullying is about the bully tearing down others in an attempt to raise their own sense of self worth. Anyone who can be counted as the Other is a potential target, and if the victim has some level of social status (ie, wealth) that actually makes them more attractive as a victim.

As for why Ahmed's Clock blew up the internet but this case didn't, well, solve that Better mousetrap and laugh all the way to the bank.

Sorry, you misunderstood, and perhaps if I clear up the confusion you'll understand why Ahmed's story did go viral, and this one didn't. My claim is that bigotry against successful ethnic groups does not interest leftists. The rate of hate crimes against Jews far exceeds the rate of hate crimes against Muslims, and yet it is Islamophobia that concerns the left, not antisemitism (in fact, antisemitism is almost de rigueur on the left these days). The institutionalized bigotry against Chinese-Americans in college admissions is almost as large as it was against Jews pre-1960, and yet, the left doesn't care. Far from not caring, they actually are responsible for perpetrating it (and covering it up as much as possible).

When a neo-Nazi shoots up a Jewish community center in Kansas, but through an ironic twist of fate manages only to kill Christians, it's not even charged as a hate crime. And when four Jews are killed in a Kosher supermarket in Paris, Obama refers to them as random folks in a deli. Yet when three Muslims are killed by a nutjob because of a fight over parking spaces, it's billed as an Islamophobic hate crime immediately, and federal agencies are still working hard to come up with any shred of evidence of a religious motivation (I assume no luck so far, or else it would have been trumpeted by now).

This is the state of things I claim. The latest story didn't go viral because the Sikh community is not considered sufficiently vilified by the right for the left to want to protect them. And by protect them, I don't actually mean protect them in the usual sense. I mean use them as pawns in their game to attack the right as xenophobes and bigots.
 
Sorry, you misunderstood, and perhaps if I clear up the confusion you'll understand why Ahmed's story did go viral, and this one didn't. My claim is that bigotry against successful ethnic groups does not interest leftists. The rate of hate crimes against Jews far exceeds the rate of hate crimes against Muslims, and yet it is Islamophobia that concerns the left, not antisemitism (in fact, antisemitism is almost de rigueur on the left these days). The institutionalized bigotry against Chinese-Americans in college admissions is almost as large as it was against Jews pre-1960, and yet, the left doesn't care. Far from not caring, they actually are responsible for perpetrating it (and covering it up as much as possible).

When a neo-Nazi shoots up a Jewish community center in Kansas, but through an ironic twist of fate manages only to kill Christians, it's not even charged as a hate crime. And when four Jews are killed in a Kosher supermarket in Paris, Obama refers to them as random folks in a deli. Yet when three Muslims are killed by a nutjob because of a fight over parking spaces, it's billed as an Islamophobic hate crime immediately, and federal agencies are still working hard to come up with any shred of evidence of a religious motivation (I assume no luck so far, or else it would have been trumpeted by now).

This is the state of things I claim. The latest story didn't go viral because the Sikh community is not considered sufficiently vilified by the right for the left to want to protect them. And by protect them, I don't actually mean protect them in the usual sense. I mean use them as pawns in their game to attack the right as xenophobes and bigots.
I hope people read your links to expose your cherry picking of quotes to reach your conclusion.
 
Obviously, we really just have one side of the story, but it does seem like the kid suffered a huge injustice. I still doubt very much it had anything to do with the color of his skin or his ethnicity, although perhaps the lack of outrage does. Even though Sikhs have the right skin-tone, they don't count as disadvantaged minorities because they tend to have well above-average incomes in whatever country they reside.

I heard about this one quite a few days ago.

Through social media. Who pressured various news sites to cover it.

What I haven't seen, yet, are the howls of some vague hoax from right-wing sites.
 
And yet, 12 days later, few people in the liberal blogosphere appear to give a ****. There hasn't been an invitation to the White House at any rate. There must be some element that's missing. What could it be?

Maybe we need to get Dawkins rage-tweeting against Backpack Boy.
 
Sorry, you misunderstood, and perhaps if I clear up the confusion you'll understand why Ahmed's story did go viral, and this one didn't.

Here's what I think happened with Ahmed. It got a little bit of traction in the media, including some social media, that got the attention of the President's science advisor. That advisor wrote a memo to the President, who was sympathetic, and sent out his famous tweet.

Now Obama was involved, and the right wing went ballistic, and we had a massive publicity storm.

As for this case, there are a few really important differences, but the one that overshadows all of them is that this kid actually made a threat, albeit a joking one.

The idea that such an obvious joke would result in 3 days of jail for a 12 year old boy is ridiculous, and in my opinion disgusting, but at least there is a rational basis for it.
 
<snip>

As for this case, there are a few really important differences, but the one that overshadows all of them is that this kid actually made a threat, albeit a joking one.

<snip>


The only account I have seen is this one. (From the link upthread.)

But Singh says he is innocent, and that it was another student who caused the whole mess by mistaking his backpack for a bomb.


“I thought it was just a joke, so I started laughing and then he started laughing too,” Singh said of the accusation during an interview with the Dallas Morning News. “The next thing you know, I’m reading with my friend and police come in, grab me and take me outside.”
There's nothing in that statement which can be interpreted as a threat on the part of Singh.

I don't think laughing at some other twelve-year old's silly joke counts.

Have you seen some other accounts which are significantly different?
 
The only account I have seen is this one. (From the link upthread.)

​
There's nothing in that statement which can be interpreted as a threat on the part of Singh.

I don't think laughing at some other twelve-year old's silly joke counts.

Have you seen some other accounts which are significantly different?

Yes, but I just skimmed them. I got the feeling that when he was "laughing", he was joking about it being a bomb. I'll see what I can find.

ETA: Conflicting accounts. The police claim he made a threat.

It appears that his backpack was the sort that had a built in phone charger. Another kid (joked or threatened, accounts vary) that he would tell the school authorities that Amaan had a bomb. Exactly who said what when is hard to put together from the conflicting and biased accounts.

One thing is clear. This is total BS. A twelve year old kid is taken away to a detention center, and his parents don't even know where he is. Insane. Totally insane.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, you misunderstood, and perhaps if I clear up the confusion you'll understand why Ahmed's story did go viral, and this one didn't. My claim is that bigotry against successful ethnic groups does not interest leftists. The rate of hate crimes against Jews far exceeds the rate of hate crimes against Muslims, and yet it is Islamophobia that concerns the left, not antisemitism (in fact, antisemitism is almost de rigueur on the left these days). The institutionalized bigotry against Chinese-Americans in college admissions is almost as large as it was against Jews pre-1960, and yet, the left doesn't care. Far from not caring, they actually are responsible for perpetrating it (and covering it up as much as possible).

When a neo-Nazi shoots up a Jewish community center in Kansas, but through an ironic twist of fate manages only to kill Christians, it's not even charged as a hate crime. And when four Jews are killed in a Kosher supermarket in Paris, Obama refers to them as random folks in a deli. Yet when three Muslims are killed by a nutjob because of a fight over parking spaces, it's billed as an Islamophobic hate crime immediately, and federal agencies are still working hard to come up with any shred of evidence of a religious motivation (I assume no luck so far, or else it would have been trumpeted by now).

This is the state of things I claim. The latest story didn't go viral because the Sikh community is not considered sufficiently vilified by the right for the left to want to protect them. And by protect them, I don't actually mean protect them in the usual sense. I mean use them as pawns in their game to attack the right as xenophobes and bigots.

I don't believe that one being Muslim and the other being Sikh has anything to do with the story going viral or not. There's a multitude of reasons why a story goes viral, and in the case of Ahmed a lot of it had to with him being perceived as an electronic nerd to get picked up by social media. This element was missing from the good Sikh. But it could have been a lot of other factors, too.
 
For example, the "victim" is younger, the family recently moved to the area (Texas, natch), the parents are less than fluent in English, there was no suspicious electrical device,.

Bullpoop! Every electrical device is a suspicious electrical device.
 
Mr Grunshaw said that other worrying issues were raised in the boy's school work - not just the "terrorist" house line - and these were "reported through the appropriate channels".

I wonder what those other issues could be? As with Clock Boy, we are only getting part of the story. Or perhaps the school is full of dung.
 
I wonder what those other issues could be?


He is clearly Muslim.

But seriously, I saw that story and, assuming the kid wasn't abused, tortured, threatened, or mistreated*, I couldn't work up any outrage about it.

He did write "terrorist", and I would hope someone would at least start asking questions when something like that happened.

*Like, say, being taken away in handcuffs and interrogated, alone, for a few hours.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom