Merged Jian Ghomeshi fired by CBC / Jian Ghomeshi Acquitted On All Charges

That's what I said! The only evidence that a crime occured is the claims by the accusers. The judge said it too.

Ghomeshi's defence didn't show a crime didn't occur, it couldn't, there was no evidence of the actual crime. Their evidence showed the accusers were completely unreliable. If they had not had that evidence, the accusers would have been believable and he could easily have been convicted.

That couldn't happen with a murder or attempted murder, assault, etc. There would have to be evidence that a crime took place and that he was the perpetrator.

The major difference is that the crux of these types of cases is not whether the acts occurred, but whether they were consensual.

From the beginning, when Jian tried to get ahead of the story, it became public knowledge that he had engaged in S+M practices.

The only thing that differentiates some of these practices from assault is consent. And generally, when two adults do something behind closed doors, the only evidence for that consent will be the word of the accuser.

If we go by your metric, then whatever Jian did, he could not be convicted, since the key fact, whether or not there was consent creates no physical evidence. I hope you see the problem with that.
 
If we go by your metric, then whatever Jian did, he could not be convicted, since the key fact, whether or not there was consent creates no physical evidence. I hope you see the problem with that.

If the victims had abstained from emailing him love letters afterwards, if two had not colluded after being told not to...

Sorry, but it seems there is, in this case, positive evidence of a deliberate deception on the part of the accusers.
 
If the victims had abstained from emailing him love letters afterwards, if two had not colluded after being told not to...

Sorry, but it seems there is, in this case, positive evidence of a deliberate deception on the part of the accusers.

I'm addressing the generalizable sentiments Quayak expressed about evidence in sexual assault cases. that's independent of the specifics of this case.

However, I don't think that emailing him love letters is particularly good evidence against the charges. I could introduce you to a lot of battered women who said sweet things to their abusive partners afterwards.

I do think the accusers have been deceptive, and I think the outcome was appropriate for the evidence presented. I'll talk about why I think they were deceptive if you'd like and why I still think he committed assault.
 
I'm addressing the generalizable sentiments Quayak expressed about evidence in sexual assault cases. that's independent of the specifics of this case.

Fair enough.

However, I don't think that emailing him love letters is particularly good evidence against the charges. I could introduce you to a lot of battered women who said sweet things to their abusive partners afterwards.

That is problematic, I agree.

I do think the accusers have been deceptive, and I think the outcome was appropriate for the evidence presented. I'll talk about why I think they were deceptive if you'd like and why I still think he committed assault.

Given your core assumptions here, I think that conclusion is pretty much inevitable, isn't it?
 
Exactly right! And there are many SWJs who insist that his not deleting the emails is clear evidence of his guilt. "What innocent man would save old emails?"

Given that most email serviced these days offer accouts with unlimited storage space, the better question would be: "Why would an innocent person delete any emails?"


I've got various assorted files that are over ten years old. But then, I'm something of a pack rat.

As to Ghomeshi saving stuff, my theory is that, as someone who was, even ten years ago, a public figure, he is at some risk of being falsely accused of some untoward action. Thus by saving all correspondence, it serves as a hedge against any false allegations. (And in any event saving files is easy; it's just some bytes on a hard drive.)
 
Last edited:
Two things, perhaps. It's a continuation of the government's--and, by extension, the Canadian people's--attitude toward the First Nation peoples.


Only if the rate at which Aboriginal women have disappeared is higher than the rate for non-Aboriginal women, it seems to me.


Between assimilation policies, theft of reserve lands, residential schools designed to "take the Indian out of the Indian," and the Sixties scoop, Canada has had a very poor relationship with its indigenous people. Those policies raised several broken generations; is it any wonder they're struggling now to raise their own children and grandchildren?


I'll accept all of that. But I would add every community does bear some responsibility for its own actions in regards to events. Other minorities have suffered poor treatment in the past, and have managed to overcome that past.
 
I don't think that's true, I don't know why you would think I do.

I've probably misunderstood you, then. My apologies.

Given the following sequence of events:

a) A man and woman have a sexual encounter
b) the woman sends him an email signifying it was consensual
c) the woman reports to the police it was not consensual

did a crime occur? If so, how would the man have known?
 
However, I don't think that emailing him love letters is particularly good evidence against the charges. I could introduce you to a lot of battered women who said sweet things to their abusive partners afterwards.

You misunderstood the ruling if this is your interpretation on events.

According to the judge, there was nothing wrong with their behaviour toward Ghomeshi after the fact. The problem was with their behaviour toward tge police, prosecutors, and the court. They stated in sworn statements that they had no contact with Ghomeshi when in fact they had repeated contact over long periods which they initiated.

It's their lies to the court, exposed by the defence, that led to the verdict. The police and prosecution made a grievous error in taking them at their word and not checking out their claims.
 
Last edited:
I've probably misunderstood you, then. My apologies.

Given the following sequence of events:

a) A man and woman have a sexual encounter
b) the woman sends him an email signifying it was consensual
c) the woman reports to the police it was not consensual

did a crime occur? If so, how would the man have known?

So there's a question here of when the consent happened and what constituted it.

I hope you'll agree with me that consent needs to happen before an act. Otherwise, from a legal standpoint, there's no hope of mens rea. Any legally pertinent information should be known before the act. Legally, consent must be established by what someone knows before they act. Just as consent can't be rescinded after the fact, I don't think it can be created after the fact.


If you don't agree that meaningful legal consent is obtained before action, then we can get more into that.

Now let's look at what the specific allegations were. Choking, hitting, things that outside of a consensual BDSM relationship or an MMA match, constitute battery.

How is consent, before the fact, meaningfully achieved? I think affirmative consent is a great way to go about that, it sure sweeps away the mystery, but I don't really want to argue about affirmative consent here. Let's talk about a reasonable person standard.

To kiss someone? Most reasonable people will agree on context, say the end of a date, lounging on the couch over drinks, body language can show clear consent to a kiss. Again, most reasonable people will agree that body language while kissing can indicate the consent for some groping.

I think that within the reasonable person standard, we can get through vanilla sex without someone having a conversation.

What about choking? Do you think that within a reasonable person standard, there's a bit of body language that says "I consent to you choking me?" or slapping across the face, hard, multiple times?

I agree with most of the BDSM community, who say that these acts that would otherwise qualify as assault, must be specifically discussed first.

Yes, choking is different from kissing. I think one has a duty to make damn well sure one's partner consents to choking before it happens.

I think someone who chokes another person without discussing it first has done so without consent. It may be that the choker lucks out and the chokee happens to like it, but given it was not an exchange of information BEFORE the act, it's still not meaningfully consent.

So as to your final questions

did a crime occur? If so, how would the man have known?

If you choke another human being without clear indications they consent to choking before you do it, you are acting without consent and you should be aware of that. I'm not well versed enough in Canadian law to say whether a crime occured, even in the US BDSM is in a lot of legal gray areas. There are some places where you can't legally consent to certain BDSM acts even if you wanted to.
 
You misunderstood the ruling if this is your interpretation on events.

According to the judge, there was nothing wrong with their behaviour toward Ghomeshi after the fact. The problem was with their behaviour toward tge police, prosecutors, and the court. They stated in sworn statements that they had no contact with Ghomeshi when in fact they had repeated contact over long periods which they initiated.

It's their lies to the court, exposed by the defence, that led to the verdict. The police and prosecution made a grievous error in taking them at their word and not checking out their claims.

I wasn't commenting on the judges decision, but on certain poster's interpretations of the events of the trial. I may in fact have read those interpretations wrong though.
 
So there's a question here of when the consent happened and what constituted it.

I hope you'll agree with me that consent needs to happen before an act. Otherwise, from a legal standpoint, there's no hope of mens rea. Any legally pertinent information should be known before the act. Legally, consent must be established by what someone knows before they act. Just as consent can't be rescinded after the fact, I don't think it can be created after the fact.


If you don't agree that meaningful legal consent is obtained before action, then we can get more into that.

Now let's look at what the specific allegations were. Choking, hitting, things that outside of a consensual BDSM relationship or an MMA match, constitute battery.

How is consent, before the fact, meaningfully achieved? I think affirmative consent is a great way to go about that, it sure sweeps away the mystery, but I don't really want to argue about affirmative consent here. Let's talk about a reasonable person standard.

To kiss someone? Most reasonable people will agree on context, say the end of a date, lounging on the couch over drinks, body language can show clear consent to a kiss. Again, most reasonable people will agree that body language while kissing can indicate the consent for some groping.

I think that within the reasonable person standard, we can get through vanilla sex without someone having a conversation.

What about choking? Do you think that within a reasonable person standard, there's a bit of body language that says "I consent to you choking me?" or slapping across the face, hard, multiple times?

I agree with most of the BDSM community, who say that these acts that would otherwise qualify as assault, must be specifically discussed first.

Yes, choking is different from kissing. I think one has a duty to make damn well sure one's partner consents to choking before it happens.

I think someone who chokes another person without discussing it first has done so without consent. It may be that the choker lucks out and the chokee happens to like it, but given it was not an exchange of information BEFORE the act, it's still not meaningfully consent.

So as to your final questions



If you choke another human being without clear indications they consent to choking before you do it, you are acting without consent and you should be aware of that. I'm not well versed enough in Canadian law to say whether a crime occured, even in the US BDSM is in a lot of legal gray areas. There are some places where you can't legally consent to certain BDSM acts even if you wanted to.
The thing is, Ghomeshi never commented on these cases, he was commenting on the videos he showed to CBC prior to his firing. He never said whether or not he ever had sex, or sexual contact, with these women. The judgement was based on the stories told by the accusers, period.

The interesting thing is tgat Ghomeshi has another trial pending. In that case his lawyer waived the right to a preliminary hearing. According to defence lawyers, a lawyer only does that if they have a slam dunk. With his habit of saving documents I suspect they have a document, written by the accuser, that completely nullifies her claim to events. With the woman being a co-worker of his at the CBC I think it is even more likely.
 
So there's a question here of when the consent happened and what constituted it.
I hope you'll agree with me that consent needs to happen before an act.

That's reasonable enough.

Now let's look at what the specific allegations were. Choking, hitting, things that outside of a consensual BDSM relationship or an MMA match, constitute battery.

How is consent, before the fact, meaningfully achieved?

My understanding is that typically a safeword is negotiated. Not that I would know.

I think affirmative consent is a great way to go about that, it sure sweeps away the mystery, but I don't really want to argue about affirmative consent here.

I suspect that affirmative consent will become more popular.

What about choking? Do you think that within a reasonable person standard, there's a bit of body language that says "I consent to you choking me?" or slapping across the face, hard, multiple times?

Having agreed to use a safeword in advance, surely it becomes an issue of whether or not the safeword's respected.
 
My understanding is that typically a safeword is negotiated. Not that I would know.

Having agreed to use a safeword in advance, surely it becomes an issue of whether or not the safeword's respected.

It tends to be a bit more complicated than that.

BDSM is a very broad category that includes everything from tying hand together with a silk scarf, to hanging someone from their piercings from the ceiling and a whole lot inbetween.

Just because two people are having kinky sex together, doesn't mean they can do anything in that spectrum and it's the burden of the other to say "stop". Some of these practices can be dangerous. In safe, sane and consensual BDSM, there is a thorough discussion ahead of time about interests and limits.

Breathplay, for instance, choking, is a particularly dangerous area. To choke someone who isn't expecting it is frowned upon by the BDSM world and by the law.

Agai, consent comes before the act. Being kinky doesn't mean one consents to all kinky acts until one withdraws it with a safe word.

Above and beyond that, in the Ghomeshi charges, and the other accusations that were not on trial, neither the accusers nor Ghomeshi are saying that these negotiations or a safe word existed. (Unless I'm missing something, didn't follow the trial with laser focus, so feel free to correct me)

For a meaningful claim that these actions were consensual, Ghomeshi only has two routes. Either these actions did not happen, or they were preceded by a clear conversation about them particularly.

For the sake of the hypothetical, you and I are pursuing, that these happened, but were consensual, that clear discussion would need to have happened. But I don't see the defense even claiming that explicitly(Again, if that's in error, please correct me).
 
As I see it, it currently looks as if someone made a very serious criminal accusation against someone else. The court system determined that the accuser had not demonstrated that a crime had actually occurred and ruled the defendant innocent,

Technically, Canadian criminal courts cannot "rule the defendant innocent." Their main options are guilty and not guilty. I know I sound a bit pedantic to some, but in terms of legal and practical distinctions, there is a difference.

I am not saying Jian is not innocent, I am just saying that the court is not saying he is innocent, or more precisely, the court is not saying he was ruled or otherwise proven innocent.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom