Merged Jian Ghomeshi fired by CBC / Jian Ghomeshi Acquitted On All Charges

Social Justice Warrior is a real thing, a terminology that is used by the very people who you call SJWs? Perhaps they even have a social club by that name, or a group of like-minded posse-members who utilize that particular terminology? That must have slipped my attention.


It's a term, like many other terms for other things, that has become a recognized moniker for a certain type of mindset, ideology, and behaviour.


My use of the term "self-invented boogey-men" is that the term (1) was invented by conservatives not by the people who are themselves the target of this terminology ...


This is false. The term "social justice warrior" dates back to at least 2001, when it was used in an academic paper,. Moreover, in said paper the term was used in a glowing, positive light.

The term has moved from a positive to a negative connotation as a result of the types of behavious of some of its adherents. You can argue that it unfairly targets those who don't truly share that mindset, but tough luck there - the exact same thing has happened with terms such as 'MRA', 'feminism'. and 'MGTOW'.


... and (2) is clearly used to lump a wide range of people together, thus allowing all of them to be easily demeaned by the glib process of ridiculing the most extreme of this group.


See above.


But then why not just identify the specific people and offenses involved rather than use the term "SJWs?" Clearly SJW is used to employ the broadest brush possible, thus allowing the mud to attach not just to the crazies and extremists who deserve condemnation, but also to splash more widely on the much larger group of people with liberal goals for society but who are not guilty of this kind of reprehensible behavior.


See first and second replies.


Obviously the term was invented solely to be sarcastic and demeaning.


That is incorrect. See second reply.


In fact, advocating that the false accusers in this case be prosecuted and sent to jail is indeed seeking social justice. Yet I don't think that you would identify such advocates as SJWs.


You could. But the term has come to mean something else. Rightly or wrongly that other meaning and association is what it now has. See also first and second replies.
 
Last edited:
It's a term, like many other terms for other things, that has become a recognized moniker for a certain type of mindset, ideology, and behaviour.





This is false. The term "social justice warrior" dates back to at least 2001, when it was used in an academic paper,. Moreover, in said paper the term was used in a glowing, positive light.

The term has moved from a positive to a negative connotation as a result of the types of behavious of some of its adherents. You can argue that it unfairly targets those who don't truly share that mindset, but tough luck there - the exact same thing has happened with terms such as 'MRA', 'feminism'. and 'MGTOW'.





See above.





See first and second replies.





That is incorrect. See second reply.





You could. But the term has come to mean something else. Rightly or wrongly that other meaning and association is what it now has. See also first and second replies.

I fully accept that you are correct as to the original definition of SJW (although I would have liked a reference to the 2001 academic paper to which you refer, just to indulge my curiosity- my own quick search suggests a 2009 derivation)- I improperly employed the word invented when I really meant re-invented and currently used by conservatives for the purposes I stated in my original post. "SJW" as it is currently typically used by conservatives is not considered a complement by the very people it is meant to describe, and it is instead used in this context as a pejorative by those of one political ideology directed against those of another political ideology. Acquisition of a legitimate term and its conversion into an sarcastic insult used by an out group to demean not only the original group but others intentionally lumped with them by an inaccurate extension of the same term, is quite common. "Cretan" was once a formal medical term, but nonetheless it became an and childish schoolyard insult rather than a clinical diagnosis. Liberals barely to the left of Eisenhower in the USA in the 1950s became "communists."

Many KKK members are to the right of center. Would it be appropriate if I therefore tried to adapt the term KKK to refer to all conservatives? Or would you instead suspect that I was trying to unfairly demean and belittle all conservatives by deliberately misapplying a narrow terminology and thereby intentionally lump those with a wide spectrum of political views together in the same group as those who profess the most deplorable, and therefore easiest to criticize, extreme?
 
Last edited:
The CBC management made a preemptive strike on an expectation of the issue being "tried" by the popular press.



No, the CBC management looks silly because nothing has been proven.



No, I "passed judgement" on the CBC management based on its actions.


Do continue. :cool:


:thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup:ftw
 
I fully accept that you are correct as to the original definition of SJW (although I would have liked a reference to the 2001 academic paper to which you refer, just to indulge my curiosity- my own quick search suggests a 2009 derivation)

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...a-gamergate-insult-is-now-a-dictionary-entry/

This article cites a 1991 use of the term as a positive descriptor, and I doubt that this was the first use of it that way. It is, after all, a fairly natural extension of the term "social justice", which is over a century old.

I improperly employed the word invented when I really meant re-invented and currently used by conservatives for the purposes I stated in my original post.

Here's the thing about this re-invention: in both cases, it applies to basically the same people. It's only the speaker's opinion of the subject which is different. So it's really not much of a re-invention.

Acquisition of a legitimate term and its conversion into an sarcastic insult used by an out group to demean not only the original group but others intentionally lumped with them by an inaccurate extension of the same term, is quite common.

What makes you think the extension is largely inaccurate? Seems to me most of the subjects of the term do in fact subscribe to "social justice" theory. And "warrior" was obviously metaphorical from the start.
 
I fully accept that you are correct as to the original definition of SJW (although I would have liked a reference to the 2001 academic paper to which you refer ...


I would have done so, but at the moment I'm not on my regular computer. When I get back to that machine I can post up the link.


"SJW" as it is currently typically used by conservatives is not considered a complement by the very people it is meant to describe, and it is instead used in this context as a pejorative by those of one political ideology directed against those of another political ideology.


It isn't just being used by 'conservatives'; it is also being used by those on the left who do not agree with the ideological bent and preferred tactics of 'SJWs'. (A related item is the term 'social regressive', coined by Dave Rubin, who is most assuredly not a conservative.)
 
Back to the main topic of the thread. And it continues: from The Guardian: Canada urged to rethink approach to sexual assault after Ghomeshi acquittal.

I would like to know why the crime of sexual assault should be held to a different standard and tried in a different manner than all other types of crimes, e.g. robbery, assault, fraud, arson, homicide, etc. Why does it deserve its own special class?
 
Last edited:
it involves naughty bits


I find the concept of incorporating the laws of sexual assault into the broader category of assault an attractive proposal. The sexual part seems to drive people into crazy ideas both on the left and right.

If someone touches you genitals against your will, it is an assault and should be tried with the same legal requirements and punishment as an "equivalent" assault. This doesn't mean ignoring that someone convicted of intentionally touching your genitals against your will should have the same penalty as if they touched your arm: clearly the impact of the two actions on the victim are quite different. Perhaps touching one's genitals should be considered the same as punching your face? Rape the same as hitting someone repeatedly over the head ith a lead pipe? I haven't decided on the equivalency of the punishments. But the requirements of proof, the questions that can be asked bby both attorneys, and the goal of seeking logical rather than emotional proceedings, should be the same for all kinds of assault.
 
I find the concept of incorporating the laws of sexual assault into the broader category of assault an attractive proposal. The sexual part seems to drive people into crazy ideas both on the left and right.

If someone touches you genitals against your will, it is an assault and should be tried with the same legal requirements and punishment as an "equivalent" assault. This doesn't mean ignoring that someone convicted of intentionally touching your genitals against your will should have the same penalty as if they touched your arm: clearly the impact of the two actions on the victim are quite different. Perhaps touching one's genitals should be considered the same as punching your face? Rape the same as hitting someone repeatedly over the head ith a lead pipe? I haven't decided on the equivalency of the punishments. But the requirements of proof, the questions that can be asked bby both attorneys, and the goal of seeking logical rather than emotional proceedings, should be the same for all kinds of assault.

I agree! To put the absurdity of these cases into perspective: What would the result if you walked into a police station and told them someone punched you 20 years ago, there is no evidence whatsoever, and you want the person prosecuted.

How long do you think it would take for the cops to stop laughing?
 
I agree! To put the absurdity of these cases into perspective: What would the result if you walked into a police station and told them someone punched you 20 years ago, there is no evidence whatsoever, and you want the person prosecuted.

How long do you think it would take for the cops to stop laughing?
However, if you tell them someone attempted to murder you twenty years ago or sexually assaulted you as a youth, they'd probably open an investigation.

Certain crimes are held to be more damaging to a person than others. Rape and murder pretty much top the list.

While it's good to see that Ghomeshi was acquitted due to the evidence in this case, in my opinion the SJWs have a point: there has been an unfortunate history of poor prosecution of sexual offences against women. At one time a husband could not be convicted of raping his wife. Often times important men can get out of a rape charge by pulling the right strings or putting money into the correct pockets.

On the other hand, the SJWs seem to be saying all men accused of sexual assault of any kind, from unwanted touching up to rape, are guilty until proven innocent, and a woman's word on such matters is not to be questioned. That's just wrong.
 
Last edited:
However, if you tell them someone attempted to murder you twenty years ago . . .

Do you think so? If I walked into a police station and said, "I have no evidence, and no witnesses, but 20 years ago Shemp tried to murder me and I want you to prosecute him" do you think they would do anything beyond asking Shemp if it were true?

I think the investigation would end when Shemp said "No I didn't."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom