Merged Jian Ghomeshi fired by CBC / Jian Ghomeshi Acquitted On All Charges

I think the most disturbing part is this . . .

If even one of the accusers had been "believable" Ghomeshi would have been found guilty. Unless the judge is psychic that's as accurate at getting at the truth as a coin would be toss but a whole lot more expensive.
 
Last edited:
While it's good to see that Ghomeshi was acquitted due to the evidence in this case, in my opinion the SJWs have a point: there has been an unfortunate history of poor prosecution of sexual offences against women.


I've bolded the critical word in your post. Is that history still occurring today? That is the key question. Policing has changed greatly over the last twenty years; I would ask if you can cite cases from within the last twenty years which are deserving of the kind of criticism mentioned in your comment. (There is also the flip side to the legal system: women tend to get considerably lighter sentences as compared to men for the same crime.)


At one time a husband could not be convicted of raping his wife.


I've again bolded the critical component of your post. Is what you describe still the case in Canada? Does law enforcement still disregard such allegations? Does the Crown refuse or otherwise avoid prosecuting such cases?


Often times important men can get out of a rape charge by pulling the right strings or putting money into the correct pockets.


That's true for pretty much every type of crime, not just sexual assault charges. Money, if nothing else, will grant one access to superior legal counsel, which can make a big difference in itself.


On the other hand, the SJWs seem to be saying all men accused of sexual assault of any kind, from unwanted touching up to rape, are guilty until proven innocent, and a woman's word on such matters is not to be questioned. That's just wrong.


Something else that happens is the conflation of the terms 'sexual assault' and 'rape'.
 
Last edited:
I've bolded the critical word in your post. Is that history still occurring today? That is the key question. Policing has changed greatly over the last twenty years; I would ask if you can cite cases from within the last twenty years which are deserving of the kind of criticism mentioned in your comment. (There is also the flip side to the legal system: women tend to get considerably lighter sentences as compared to men for the same crime.)
Two items come to mind: Robert William Pickton and and missing and murdered aboriginal women (MMIW.) There are allegations the police didn't investigate the disappearances in a timely fashion because the victims were poor and/or aboriginal. Now that we're getting an inquiry into MMIW, we'll see how true the allegations are.

I've again bolded the critical component of your post. Is what you describe still the case in Canada? Does law enforcement still disregard such allegations? Does the Crown refuse or otherwise avoid prosecuting such cases?
Good point. I can't show any evidence for my statement, so it falls.

That's true for pretty much every type of crime, not just sexual assault charges. Money, if nothing else, will grant one access to superior legal counsel, which can make a big difference in itself.
Yes. Access to legal counsel is, unfortunately, where access to heath care was about eighty years ago. Yet there is no serious attempt to put together a universal legal aid system. That's a whole other discussion.
 
Last edited:
Do you think so? If I walked into a police station and said, "I have no evidence, and no witnesses, but 20 years ago Shemp tried to murder me and I want you to prosecute him" do you think they would do anything beyond asking Shemp if it were true?

I think the investigation would end when Shemp said "No I didn't."
That's strange, because when hockey players, residential school students, and orphans from Mount Cashel went to the police with allegations of assault from many years in the past, they were listened to and men now in their sixties and seventies went to trial.
 
That's strange, because when hockey players, residential school students, and orphans from Mount Cashel went to the police with allegations of assault from many years in the past, they were listened to and men now in their sixties and seventies went to trial.

Graham James plead guilty (twice) which skips the whole trial part.
 
I think the most disturbing part is this . . .

If even one of the accusers had been "believable" Ghomeshi would have been found guilty. Unless the judge is psychic that's as accurate at getting at the truth as a coin would be toss but a whole lot more expensive.

No.

From the judge's decision I quoted earlier:

He noted that “one of the challenges for the prosecution in this case is that the allegations against Mr. Ghomeshi are supported by nothing in addition to the complainants’ word. There is no evidence to look to determine the truth. There is no tangible evidence. There is no DNA. There is no ‘smoking gun.’ There is only the sworn evidence of each complainant, standing on its own, to be measured against a very exacting standard of proof. This highlights the importance of the assessment of the credibility and the reliability and the overall quality of the evidence.”

That is what is missing. It's at least partially, "He said. She said." The judge himself says that was part of his decision making process.
 
Two items come to mind: Robert William Pickton and and missing and murdered aboriginal women (MMIW.) There are allegations the police didn't investigate the disappearances in a timely fashion because the victims were poor and/or aboriginal. Now that we're getting an inquiry into MMIW, we'll see how true the allegations are.


So, by your own admission, it's allegations only.

(Also, interesting item I've heard: there are more missing aboriginal men than there are women, yet for some reason the missing women claim the headlines. If this is indeed the case, what does that say about our society?)


Good point. I can't show any evidence for my statement, so it falls.


Do understand what it is I'm really trying to get at: many of the things you mentioned I can easily see being fairly common occurrences back in the 1970s and 1980s. But it isn't the 1980s anymore, it's the second half of the 2010s, and things have changed a lot over the last thirty-plus years. But the way some folks talk, one would think we're still back in the 1980s in terms of attitudes.
 
No.

From the judge's decision I quoted earlier:



That is what is missing. It's at least partially, "He said. She said." The judge himself says that was part of his decision making process.

You missed this part:
This highlights the importance of the assessment of the credibility and the reliability and the overall quality of the evidence.

He then goes on to explain the unreliability of the witnesses and why that allows Ghomeshi to go free. That means if the "evidence," sworn statements of the complainants, had been more reliable the verdict would have been different.
 
That's strange, because when hockey players, residential school students, and orphans from Mount Cashel went to the police with allegations of assault from many years in the past, they were listened to and men now in their sixties and seventies went to trial.


And that example works against the suggestion that police forces and prosecutors as a rule ignore or otherwise disregard sexual assault claims. (Obviously there can be individual instances of disinterested or recalcitrant officials.)
 
I believe that questions of the statute of limitations for a crime differ from issues of evidence. As I understand it, murder has no statute of limitations in the USA. If evidence is uncovered 50 years after the murder that implicates someone, they can be brought to trial and, if the jury agrees, convicted. I have no problem with this concept for the most serious crimes. I can see a number of valid reasons to also apply it to crimes like child molestation, and perhaps rape. I base this on an evaluation of the seriousness of the crime, not whether it was sexual in nature or not. I could see the same lack of a statute of limitations for severe physical child abuse with no sexual component.

This is different, of course, from a lack of evidence. In fact, a lacking of evidence should (and usually does) prevent charging someone with any crime, even a recent crime.
 
So, by your own admission, it's allegations only.

(Also, interesting item I've heard: there are more missing aboriginal men than there are women, yet for some reason the missing women claim the headlines. If this is indeed the case, what does that say about our society?)

It says our society is nothing but male privilege and patriarchy. Duh.
 
Graham James plead guilty (twice) which skips the whole trial part.

And that example works against the suggestion that police forces and prosecutors as a rule ignore or otherwise disregard sexual assault claims. (Obviously there can be individual instances of disinterested or recalcitrant officials.)
I was responding specifically to qayak's contention that the police would not investigate a complaint from twenty years in the past. His initial claim was the police would laugh at a simple assault charge (which they could well do), but he further claimed they would not investigate even an attempted murder charge. I showed how they investigated and eventually prosecuted sexual assault charges from many years in the past.
 
So, by your own admission, it's allegations only.
Currently it's allegations. But Stephen Harper stonewalled attempts over the past decade to investigate those allegations to see if there was substance to them. For sure he wasn't a friend of our First Nations people, and his failure to follow-up on the allegations reeks of an attitude that says "I don't believe it, therefore it's not true." As soon as we got a new government with a Prime Minister much more friendly to indigenous peoples, we got an inquiry going.

Also, interesting item I've heard: there are more missing aboriginal men than there are women, yet for some reason the missing women claim the headlines. If this is indeed the case, what does that say about our society?
Two things, perhaps. It's a continuation of the government's--and, by extension, the Canadian people's--attitude toward the First Nation peoples. Between assimilation policies, theft of reserve lands, residential schools designed to "take the Indian out of the Indian," and the Sixties scoop, Canada has had a very poor relationship with its indigenous people. Those policies raised several broken generations; is it any wonder they're struggling now to raise their own children and grandchildren?

Second, perhaps the aboriginal women are better at organizing and advocating for their cause than the men.

Do understand what it is I'm really trying to get at: many of the things you mentioned I can easily see being fairly common occurrences back in the 1970s and 1980s. But it isn't the 1980s anymore, it's the second half of the 2010s, and things have changed a lot over the last thirty-plus years. But the way some folks talk, one would think we're still back in the 1980s in terms of attitudes.
Good point. One useful aspect of social justice is to ensure the gains of the last thirty years aren't forgotten and lost. But the SJWs seem to be missing the forest for the trees.
 
I was responding specifically to qayak's contention that the police would not investigate a complaint from twenty years in the past. His initial claim was the police would laugh at a simple assault charge (which they could well do), but he further claimed they would not investigate even an attempted murder charge. I showed how they investigated and eventually prosecuted sexual assault charges from many years in the past.

No. My point was that the only crime that does not need evidence to convict is long ago sexual abuse. Murders, attempted murders, physical assaults, thefts, etc., that happened decades ago all require physical evidence but sexual assaults just require a "believable" accuser.

What could possibly go wrong with that?
 
You missed this part:


He then goes on to explain the unreliability of the witnesses and why that allows Ghomeshi to go free. That means if the "evidence," sworn statements of the complainants, had been more reliable the verdict would have been different.

No. He says,
I have no hesitation in concluding that the quality of the evidence in this case is incapable of displacing the presumption of innocence. The evidence fails to prove the allegations beyond a reasonable doubt.

That is the totality of the evidence. There was no independent evidence brought forward to substantiate the accusations.
 
That's strange, because when hockey players, residential school students, and orphans from Mount Cashel went to the police with allegations of assault from many years in the past, they were listened to and men now in their sixties and seventies went to trial.

Since I had never heard of this, I did a quick Google search. It brings up a timeline showing that accusations were made to the police and social services at the time. Some investigations were done (when the cops weren't ignoring things), and some evidence was gathered.

That's very different than qayak's scenario of somebody years later making an accusation of a crime for the first time and there being no evidence available beyond their word. If there is evidence beyond their word, like in the example you cite, then the conditions of qayak's scenario are broken.
 
I think the most disturbing part is this . . .

If even one of the accusers had been "believable" Ghomeshi would have been found guilty. Unless the judge is psychic that's as accurate at getting at the truth as a coin would be toss but a whole lot more expensive.

Or if there had been only one, and Ghomeshi had deleted his emails.
 
Or if there had been only one, and Ghomeshi had deleted his emails.

Exactly right! And there are many SWJs who insist that his not deleting the emails is clear evidence of his guilt. "What innocent man would save old emails?"

Given that most email serviced these days offer accouts with unlimited storage space, the better question would be: "Why would an innocent person delete any emails?"
 
No. He says,

That is the totality of the evidence. There was no independent evidence brought forward to substantiate the accusations.

That's what I said! The only evidence that a crime occured is the claims by the accusers. The judge said it too.

Ghomeshi's defence didn't show a crime didn't occur, it couldn't, there was no evidence of the actual crime. Their evidence showed the accusers were completely unreliable. If they had not had that evidence, the accusers would have been believable and he could easily have been convicted.

That couldn't happen with a murder or attempted murder, assault, etc. There would have to be evidence that a crime took place and that he was the perpetrator.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom