Merged Jian Ghomeshi fired by CBC / Jian Ghomeshi Acquitted On All Charges

By "defense" I mean the lawyer for the defense.

The "defense (or lawyer for the defense)" was not claiming any position. Since Jian did not have to take the stand, the claims examined were those of the accusers. The defense simply discredited the accusers as unreliable as they withheld details and misrepresented the events of their relationship with Jian.
 
The "defense (or lawyer for the defense)" was not claiming any position. Since Jian did not have to take the stand, the claims examined were those of the accusers. The defense simply discredited the accusers as unreliable as they withheld details and misrepresented the events of their relationship with Jian.

So my statement that I didn't see them making a particular claim is correct. Thank you.
 
Exactly right! And there are many SWJs who insist that his not deleting the emails is clear evidence of his guilt. "What innocent man would save old emails?"

Given that most email serviced these days offer accouts with unlimited storage space, the better question would be: "Why would an innocent person delete any emails?"


Anyone indulging in sexual practice that, to the casual observer, may appear abusive or non-consensual is wise to keep some sort of evidence of consent, surely?
 
Anyone indulging in sexual practice that, to the casual observer, may appear abusive or non-consensual is wise to keep some sort of evidence of consent, surely?

Definitely a good idea. There is no evidence that he engage in any sexual activity of that type with any of these women, though.
 
I would think that this trial is direct evidence against the SJW perpetuated myth of victims not being believed. When a case this weak makes it all the way through the trial stage, one would think people would hsve to admit the system is bending over bavkwards for victims of sexual abuse.
 
I would think that this trial is direct evidence against the SJW perpetuated myth of victims not being believed. When a case this weak makes it all the way through the trial stage, one would think people would hsve to admit the system is bending over bavkwards for victims of sexual abuse.

In many ways I see the trial and its results as a strong setback for justice for rape victims. The accusers in this case do not appear to have been severely traumatized either physically or emotionally. To call them brave, to support their courage for coming forward and to raise their status to high victim hood as a result of their exposure by the court as less than truthful does a great disservice to the fourteen year old abducted from the street, raped repeatedly by her pimp and then tossed out to nearly bleed death in an alley. She is the one who needs support. She is the one who needs the full force of the justice system not some adult who has her hair pulled and, when she objects, is sent home in a cab.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps before you responded to my post, you could have read the conversation it was part of.

Careful with that sort of thing; it can be deceptive.

"John Nowak has never commented on his involvement with the Japanese Mafia" is a true statement.

Of course, I've never had any involvement nor has anyone been silly enough to ask me, but that's not the impression the sentence gives.
 
Careful with that sort of thing; it can be deceptive.

"John Nowak has never commented on his involvement with the Japanese Mafia" is a true statement.

Of course, I've never had any involvement nor has anyone been silly enough to ask me, but that's not the impression the sentence gives.

Is there an impression my sentence gives that you object to? If so, I'm happy to reword what I'm trying to communicate for clarity.
 
In many ways I see the trial and its results as a strong setback for justice for rape victims. The accusers in this case do not appear to have been severely traumatized either physically or emotionally. To call them brave, to support their courage for coming forward and to raise their status to high victim hood as a result of their exposure by the court as less than truthful does a great disservice to the fourteen year old abducted from the street, raped repeatedly by her pimp and then tossed out to nearly bleed death in an alley. She is the one who needs support. She is the one who needs the full force of the justice system not some adult who has her hair pulled and, when she objects, is sent home in a cab.

That I agree with whole heartedly!
 
In many ways I see the trial and its results as a strong setback for justice for rape victims. The accusers in this case do not appear to have been severely traumatized either physically or emotionally. To call them brave, to support their courage for coming forward and to raise their status to high victim hood as a result of their exposure by the court as less than truthful does a great disservice to the fourteen year old abducted from the street, raped repeatedly by her pimp and then tossed out to nearly bleed death in an alley. She is the one who needs support. She is the one who needs the full force of the justice system not some adult who has her hair pulled and, when she objects, is sent home in a cab.


I'd say it's not just this case. You could add the Gregory Alan Elliott case, the Rolling Stone UVA rape story, Emma Sulkowicz (a.k.a. 'mattress girl'), and several instances of men being expelled from U.S. universities/colleges due to sexual assault allegations that were were very weak.

And, of course, there is plenty of press coverage in the aftermath of the Ghomesi case verdict granted to DeCoutere and the others that is, to say the least, very favourable.

Diana Davison on YouTube has put together several videos on the Ghomeshi trial that are actually better researched and more hard-hitting than many of the articles written by supposedly professional journalists. Here is the latest one that looks at the post-trial news coverage given to the accusers.

ETA: The aforementioned video is thirty minutes long, and well worth a watch. The last five minutes in particular are interesting due to certain revelations involving DeCoutere.
 
Last edited:
I'd say it's not just this case. You could add the Gregory Alan Elliott case, the Rolling Stone UVA rape story, Emma Sulkowicz (a.k.a. 'mattress girl'), and several instances of men being expelled from U.S. universities/colleges due to sexual assault allegations that were were very weak.

And, of course, there is plenty of press coverage in the aftermath of the Ghomesi case verdict granted to DeCoutere and the others that is, to say the least, very favourable.

Diana Davison on YouTube has put together several videos on the Ghomeshi trial that are actually better researched and more hard-hitting than many of the articles written by supposedly professional journalists. Here is the latest one that looks at the post-trial news coverage given to the accusers.

ETA: The aforementioned video is thirty minutes long, and well worth a watch. The last five minutes in particular are interesting due to certain revelations involving DeCoutere.

Good analysis.

Marie Henein (Jian's Lawyer) is being interviewed by Peter Mansbridge on CBC's The National at this very minute. I'm PVRing it for later viewing.
 
You didn't read deeply enough. The lies are not their actions after the assault. They didn't come clean on many of the facts until after the trial had started, blindsiding the prosecution and completely contradicting earlier testimony, statements, and versions of events they gave to the media. They didn't come clean until they realized Ghomeshi had copies of their emails that painted a completely different picture. All of a sudden they had more information they had "forgotten" to tell the prosecutors.

You should go read reports of what actually happened in the courtroom. It wasn't about what they did after the assaults, it was that they gave several completely contradictory stories about what happened.

Also, after being told not to talk to other witnesses, which is standard in Canadian justice, two of the witnesses sent 5000 emails between them where they discussed bring Ghomeshi down and how they would do it. That's collusion and it seriously undermines their honesty and credibility.

The judge's verdict was the only possible one under the circumstances. This was not the trial SJW should have rallied behind and as a result they have seriously undermined any credibility they may have had.

Ha, you're right, I didn't see those details. Sigh. I still have an inclination to believe them, but can now see where the ruling came from. Stupid people.
 
So a trailer park boys actor got charged for roughing up a woman in an LA bar last night. Lucy D. resigns from the show because she stands with survivors.
 
So a trailer park boys actor got charged for roughing up a woman in an LA bar last night. Lucy D. resigns from the show because she stands with survivors.

I got sorta slammed in this thread when I suggested a "rush to judgment" in the initial reporting of the charges against Ghomeshi. In this case:

http://www.torontosun.com/2016/04/0...-park-boys-after-star-denies-assaulting-woman

Mike Smith, known for playing Bubbles on the cult comedy show, was charged with a misdemeanour in Los Angeles on Friday.

"misdemeanour" not "sexual assault".

The statement also included quotes from the alleged victim saying police were called by others not present in the room who mistakenly perceived the argument to be "something other than what it was," and there was no real issue.

So this time I'll say nothing.
 
I got sorta slammed in this thread when I suggested a "rush to judgment" in the initial reporting of the charges against Ghomeshi. In this case:

http://www.torontosun.com/2016/04/0...-park-boys-after-star-denies-assaulting-woman



"misdemeanour" not "sexual assault".



So this time I'll say nothing.

As a Haligonian., I'm surprised this is the first time he's made the news for a criminal matter. His local business "investments" involved people that could charitably be described as questionable characters. That being said, it has nothing to do with current allegations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom