Israeli soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza

As I thought, you know the maps are correct and continue to divert the subject with baseless, contorted arguments about the credibility of a source.
 
Nor does it mean calling someone a CT-Whackjob.

Well I'd argue that one. In many cases it could be.

It could just be an insult and not technically an ad-hom, but I'm pretty unsympathetic to that distinction. Simply by posting in the discussion forum you are addressing the argument and if your only contribution is insult, I'd consider that an ad-hom.

Now, if someone was making a claim based on their own credibility and you said they were a CT-Whackjob because they were a holocaust-denying, no-planing, anti-vaxxer and so would not take their word for it, that would be different.
 
Last edited:
As I thought, you know the maps are correct and continue to divert the subject with baseless, contorted arguments about the credibility of a source.

Is there an argument about the credibility of a source? I thought it was conceded that you could only find nutjob CT sites to back you up.

If not, google is thataway ->
 
As I thought, you know the maps are correct and continue to divert the subject with baseless, contorted arguments about the credibility of a source.
There's nothing baseless or contorted about it. whatreallyhappened is a CT Whackjob site.
 
For those without the stomach to reread the previous half page of bile ridden idiocy, here's the image I used to provide a visual examination of the effects of Israel's insatiable drive for land conquest in palestine over the last 60-odd years. Fairly suggestive, I thought.
 
And here is the image used to provide a visual examination of the quality of sourcing used in the above post. Fairly suggestive, I thought.



thum_1026149dbb9a589833.jpg


from http://whatreallyhappened.com/RANCHO/POLITICS/FOSTER_COVERUP/
 
Funny, when I clicked your link I didn't see the page you showed a pic of, all I got was the following text.

OUR AD POLICY
ADV: Drunken Israeli Settler Threatens Film Crew - In a drunken racial tirade, an Israeli settler threatens a British film crew. The wild exchange has the settler cursing Jesus, threatening to kill the film crew and Palestinians.

ADV: Precious Metals & Financial Market News: Protect Yourself By Staying Informed
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ADV: "Warning The NAU & Amero Are Coming, Are You Protected?"
Our National currency,financial markets and economy are headed into an abiss not seen since that great depression. The Elite Bankers and Goverment Cartels have been plotting the largest transfer of wealth our nation has ever seen. The only question is ARE YOU PROTECTED?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ADV: DON'T PAY FOR ELECTRICITY ANY LONGER: HOW TO BUILD SOLAR PANELS and WIND POWER GENERATORS for Your Own Back Yard for $100!
The Easiest, Cheapest Way To Generate Free Renewable Energy for Home and Save 1000's on electricity bills
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ADV: Counting on Washington to Save Your Retirement? DON’T BE NAIVE!
Inside your special report, find out why the bailouts are a sham and how you could rescue your retirement No Matter What Washington Does. Save your retirement with up to 78 personal "bailout" checks, paid direct to your account over the next 24 months… Read the Full report:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ADV: Six Stocks Will Be Doubling Today!
Six stocks will double within 8 min of the next market opening! Easy profit trades

Interestingly, the first link is a really telling little video about the realities facing some of the people living in the area.

http://www.evtv1.com/player.aspx?itemnum=6595

I actually have had a copy of this video and a bunch of similar and worse ones for several months.
 
Last edited:
Funny, when I clicked your link I didn't see the pagge you showed a pic of, all I got was the following text

Yep, link got cut off. If you had clicked the "Vince Foster" link, you would have found it. Research skills.

http://whatreallyhappened.com/RANCHO/POLITICS/FOSTER_COVERUP/foster.html


I'd go into the many things wrong with your link, including lack of context, lack of attribution, lack of connection to your overall argument, etc. However, since you're still trying to support your position through appeals to CT-Whackjob sites, I will simply note that you are still supporting your position through appeals to CT-Whackjob sites.

eta: I suppose I should be charitable and qualify that by saying "through appeals to videos found through ads on CT-Whackjob sites" which is slightly better.
 
Last edited:
And I'll note that you insist upon making no reference to any information that refutes it.

I'm advancing no argument, I simply provided a map to give some context to other's arguments here.
 
Last edited:
And I'll note that you insist upon making no reference to any information that refutes it.

No need.

If you cited David Icke and claimed that the Queen of England was really a lizard person, would I try and find records from her last doctor's physcial to debunk you?

No.

I would say, "Dude, you just cited David Icke."

So then.

"Dude, you just cited whatreallyhappened."

I'm advancing no argument. I simply provided a map to give some context to other's arguments here.
Ah, well if you're advancing no argument you surely can't expect anyone to refute the argument you're not advancing, now can you?
 
Last edited:
So, Malkuth, let's assume for argument's sake that your CT Whackjob website's map is accurate. What do you suggest be done about it?
 
Why is Gaza illustrated in Green? If the Jews truly had an insatiable appetite, that little morsel would have long ago been enthically-cleansed and taken over as a nice beach-resort vacation property.
 
Why is Gaza illustrated in Green? If the Jews truly had an insatiable appetite, that little morsel would have long ago been enthically-cleansed and taken over as a nice beach-resort vacation property.

Looks like they're well on their way. I guess they're just taking a little longer to do the last million or so than you had hoped? Just add another 5 or 10 years to that map trend and see how small the green bits can get.

Or maybe they IDF is actually being careful not to kill too many of them at any one time. Maybe they want to drag it out 30 or 40 more years and have their grandchildren the ones forced to finally finish the palestinians off?

Will you throw a party when it's all white, no green? Will there be fireworks and cakes and a band?
 
Last edited:
Looks like they're well on their way. I guess they're just taking a little longer to do the last million or so than you had hoped? Just add another 5 or 10 years to that map trend and see how small the green bits can get.

Or maybe they IDF is actually being careful not to kill too many of them at any one time. Maybe they want to drag it out 30 or 40 more years and have their grandchildren the ones forced to finally finish the palestinians off?

Will you throw a party when it's all white, no green? Will there be fireworks and cakes and a band?
So, Malkuth, let's assume for argument's sake that your CT Whackjob website's map is accurate. What do you suggest be done about it?
 
mortimer said:
So, Malkuth, let's assume for argument's sake that your CT Whackjob website's map is accurate. What do you suggest be done about it?

If there is ever going to be a viable independent Palestinian state it must allow for freedom of movement through the whole of the state. That basically means no cantonization like today. It would also mean no splitting the West Bank into three detached colonies like proposed by Israel in 2000 (Final Status Map).

What is to be done? Well, it doesn't take a genius to figure that out: The settlements are currently a hindrance to a viable Palestinian state. Furthermore, restrictions of movement that currently follow this disturbed policy, which seem to center a great degree around the colonization activities – around settlements and outposts which shouldn't be there in the first place – are detrimental to Palestinians and the Palestinian economy.

Reuters:
Reuters said:
JERUSALEM, May 9 (Reuters) - Israeli restrictions have divided the occupied West Bank into 10 economically isolated enclaves, severing financial links and denying Palestinians access to some 50 percent of the land, the World Bank said.

The Washington-based international lending agency, in a report released on Wednesday in Jerusalem, said Israeli security concerns were "undeniable and must be addressed".

But the World Bank said Israel's West Bank barrier and system of road and zoning restrictions were aimed at "protecting and enhancing the free movement of settlers and the physical and economic expansion of the settlements at the expense of the Palestinian population".
 
Looks like they're well on their way. I guess they're just taking a little longer to do the last million or so than you had hoped? Just add another 5 or 10 years to that map trend and see how small the green bits can get.

Or maybe they IDF is actually being careful not to kill too many of them at any one time. Maybe they want to drag it out 30 or 40 more years and have their grandchildren the ones forced to finally finish the palestinians off?

Will you throw a party when it's all white, no green? Will there be fireworks and cakes and a band?

The map will eventually be all white. That is the most obvious extrapolation.
Herzl recognized back in the late 1800s that it would take 50 years before the creation of a Jewish state. Ben Gurion and his buddies recognized the declaration of independence was only a stepping stone to 'greater things'.

They can't get the IDF to kill too many at once as the world is watching,so ity has to be be done systematically and within what they can get away with under the excuse of the hideous propaganda of certain elements of the Palestinians resistance being 'terrorists'. - IOW Hamas are 'useful idiots' to Israel

Another 50 years ain't gonna make much difference in the grand scheme of things.
 
The map will eventually be all white. That is the most obvious extrapolation.
Herzl recognized back in the late 1800s that it would take 50 years before the creation of a Jewish state. Ben Gurion and his buddies recognized the declaration of independence was only a stepping stone to 'greater things'.

They can't get the IDF to kill too many at once as the world is watching,so ity has to be be done systematically and within what they can get away with under the excuse of the hideous propaganda of certain elements of the Palestinians resistance being 'terrorists'. - IOW Hamas are 'useful idiots' to Israel

Another 50 years ain't gonna make much difference in the grand scheme of things.

Please do the math for me.

Let's assume that the IDF really does go out and indiscriminately kill Palestinians every day. Since you think the recent events in Gaza were so heinous, let's also use that as a measuring stick.

So, the IDF killed 1300 Gazans in about 4 weeks. We are not going to separate combatants from innocents, since it appears that in your mind, the IDF doesn't make a distinction. So with that total, we can do some math. That works out to roughly 325 killed a week.

So....325 killed a week. How long would it take Israel to..."make the map white" so to speak?

As a means of comparison:

The Russian army, back in 1994-1995 attacked the city of Grozny for 5 weeks. In that period, they killed 30,000 innocents. We are going to ignore the fighters killed, as it would tick the number up a few more thousand.

So, that's 30,000 killed in 5 weeks. That works out to 6,000 killed a week.

Assuming the Russian army was doing this, how long would it take THEM to "make the map white"?
 
I'm advancing no argument

You are a rotten liar.

Israel's insatiable drive for land conquest in palestine over the last 60-odd years.

It seems to me that you are advancing an argument that Israel has had an "insatiable drive for land conquest in palestine over the last 60-odd years".

Why do you always do this, Malkuth? Who do you think you are fooling when you go all "...but I'm not making any argument!" immediately after making some idiotic comment? The whole "I'm not making any argument!" line is just an excuse to try to prevent people from debunking your ********, because after all, you're not "advancing an argument", you're just providing some helpful evidence...that JUST HAPPENS to be severely biased to one side. But you're not making an argument! Right?


Oh, and by the way, I'm not making any argument. I'm simply providing information about your posting behavior to other posters on this forum. I'm not actually making an argument so there's nothing you can say to refute me.
 
Still not a single post going even close to attempting to refute the maps? I'll take this to mean that nobody takes seriously any assertion that the trend illustrated by that series of maps is not actually occuring.

Thanks to lupus in fabula for this link http://www.poica.org/maps/index.php confirming the 2000 map.

You guys trying to paint a negative picture of me to try to divert the discussion points of the thread can go back to playing hungry hungry hippos now.
 
Still not a single post going even close to attempting to refute the maps? I'll take this to mean that nobody takes seriously any assertion that the trend illustrated by that series of maps is not actually occuring.

Thanks to lupus in fabula for this link http://www.poica.org/maps/index.php confirming the 2000 map.

You guys trying to paint a negative picture of me to try to divert the discussion points of the thread can go back to playing hungry hungry hippos now.

What do you mean by refuting the maps? Can you even tells us what the maps you have put here refer to. And by that I mean the exact details. A hint, the different maps, for different years, do not use the same criteria.

As for the 2000 map. As far as I know no maps were presented during the Camp David negotiations. The sides never got to the stage where presenting maps would have been useful. I happen to have Dennis Ross' book at home and can check this again sometime during the weekend.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom