Israeli soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza

The above postings are an excellent example of attacking a source rather than disputing the information. >.<
 
Last edited:
The above postings are an excellent example of attacking a source rather than disputing the information.

Ah a chance to educate <cracks fingers>

When you say "Israel is bad as demonstrated by this source," you refer to the source's credibility to support your argument. Should the source be discredited, then relying on them to provide accurate facts and analysis undercuts the argument.

In these cases attacking the source is disputing the information. We don't trust the source so we cannot trust that the information is accurate, in context, and not misleading.

Should you actually have a debatable point, you should be able to find non-whackjob citations. If you cannot, that should tell you something.
 
Last edited:
Show some reliable sources which dispute the lines drawn on that map at the time intervals shown? You can't, they are accurate.

Instead you attack the reliablity of the source in general, rather than make any attempt to dispute this specific information.
 
Show some reliable sources which dispute the lines drawn on that map at the time intervals shown? You can't, they are accurate.

Instead you attack the reliablity of the source in general, rather than make any attempt to dispute this specific information.

Until you find a non CT-Whackjob site to support your arguments, I will make the reasonable assumption that your arguments are those advanced by CT-whackjobs.
 
Again, assumptions and ad hominems. Dispute the information with something more accurate, and I will take you seriously.
 
Again, assumptions and ad hominems. Dispute the information with something more accurate, and I will take you seriously.
You might want to look up what an ad-hominem is.

Also, nobody is going to take you seriously when you link to CT sites, especially when you already dabble in Holocaust Denial. In fact, it probably doesn't matter either way; nobody will take you seriously, ever, except for perhaps your fellow Holocaust Denial buddies.
 
You might want to look up what an ad-hominem is.

And an assumption for that matter, given it made no sense in context since I explicitly said I was making an assumption and why.

I get that it was some form of criticism but "You're saying what you said you were saying" doesn't pack much sting.
 
Last edited:
An ad hominem argument, also known as argumentum ad hominem (Latin: "argument to the man", "argument against the man") consists of replying to an argument or factual claim by attacking or appealing to a characteristic or belief of the source making the argument or claim, rather than by addressing the substance of the argument or producing evidence against the claim.

The process of proving or disproving the claim is thereby subverted, and the argumentum ad hominem works to change the subject.

Comparing me to "CT-whackjobs", derision of the source as a "CT-whackjob site"
not a single shred of evidence disputing the actual information provided. A series of following posts designed to do nothing but divert the course of the argument.

Sounds like a perfect example of ad hominem to me.

I repeat, show some reliable sources which dispute the map I provided, or stfu.
 
Comparing me to "CT-whackjobs", derision of the source as a "CT-whackjob site"
not a single shred of evidence disputing the actual information provided. A series of following posts designed to do nothing but divert the course of the argument.

Sounds like a perfect example of ad hominem to me.

I repeat, show some reliable sources which dispute the map I provided, or stfu.
So you didn't look up what an ad hominem is, apparently.
 
Comparing me to "CT-whackjobs", derision of the source as a "CT-whackjob site"

Sounds like a perfect example of ad hominem to me.

Since the first only happened in your imagination and the second does not refer to you as a person/individual/poster in any way, you appear to be mistaken either as to the definition of an ad hominem or as to its application. Since you found a dictionary definition, I assume you are confused as to its application.

I repeat, show some reliable sources which dispute the map I provided, or stfu.
I believe I've told you this once already. Perhaps it will sink in this time:

Verily, if you locate my domicile of residence and lay a wet smacker upon my posterior, I shall begin to consider a concession to your demands on my behavior.
 
So you didn't look up what an ad hominem is, apparently.

If your intention is to just draw out this stupidity to the next page, I'll just repost the image on the next page. I'm assuming that's what you are trying to do, to stop as many people as possible from seeing the maps by filling the thread up with useless bickering.
 
Last edited:
If your intention is to just draw out this stupidity to the next page, I'll just repost the image on the next page. I'm assuming that's what you are trying to do, to stop as many people as possible from seeing the maps by filling the thread up with useless bickering.
No, I'm trying to educate you, as you seem to have no clue as to what an ad hominem is. You'll thank me some day.
 
No, I'm trying to educate you, as you seem to have no clue as to what an ad hominem is. You'll thank me some day.

To further elaborate:

You are a CT-Wackjob and therefore wrong. -> Ad hominem

Your sources are CT-Wackjob sites so information drawn from them will not be presumed to be accurate, honest, or factual given their history of posting inaccurate, dishonest and non-factual information. -> Not ad hominem
 
Last edited:
So refute it with facts from a more reliable source.

I won't hold my breath waiting for you to do anything other than obfuscate and continue to make baseless ad hominem attacks on myself and the information I provided.

You guys are really digging your own graves by attacking me and not making any attempt to actually disprove the information.
 
So refute it with facts from a more reliable source.

I won't hold my breath waiting for you to do anything other than obfuscate and continue to make baseless ad hominem attacks on myself and the information I provided.

You guys are really digging your own graves by attacking me and not making any attempt to actually disprove the information.
Still haven't figured out what an ad hominem is, eh?
 
So refute it with facts from a more reliable source.

No need.

If you cited David Icke and claimed that the Queen of England was really a lizard person, would I try and find records from her last doctor's physcial to debunk you?

No.

I would say, "Dude, you just cited David Icke."

So then.

"Dude, you just cited whatreallyhappened."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom