Israeli soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza

In keeping with not starting too many threads ...

U.N. reports say Israel targeted civilians in Gaza

http://www.reuters.com/article/middleeastCrisis/idUSLN537222

Extract:

The Sri Lankan human rights lawyer visited the region in early February. She cited a long series of incidents to back her charges.

In one, she said, Israeli soldiers shot a father after ordering him out of his house and then opened fire into the room where the rest of the family was sheltering, wounding the mother and three brothers and killing a fourth.

In another, on January 15, at Tal al Hawa south-west of Gaza City, Israeli soldiers forced an 11-year-old boy to walk in front of them for several hours as they moved through the town, even after they had been shot at.



Of course, apart from Israel Atrocity Deniers, we all know that a wanton slaughter of Palestinians ha taken place in Gaza recently, but the repotrs and evidence keep coming and coming.
 
If Rumsfeld was involved in ordering what happened at Abu Ghraib, then yes: sending scapegoats to prison was worthless.
If he was. Do you have evidence. I have a suspicion, and that is all. And no, please clue up. Not worthless even is somewhat tainted. Some heads did roll, though in my view the leadership at the star level was not held accountable enough, nor the secretariat and undersecretariat level leadership.
What's the point in punishing a dog for being obedient?
You rather miss the point. The chain of command was, as I have said time and again, not held accountable, but the larger problem was that there were too many fingers into the operation, too many stovepipes. It was not, not matter how it was spun in the press, a purely military operation. That is partly a function of Rummy contracting things out, and once again, he didn't have to do that.
But who will conduct an investigation into the chain of command that led to those abuses?
Our Congress or nobody.

I do not recognize the authority of any of "rhymes with hunts" of "the international community" to be remotely objective. Sorry, loaded with political baggage, and all are politely invited to go fish.
How can we be sure that Rumsfeld's DoD really looked objectively at the evidence of who ordered what?
Who is this we, Fire? I suggest you go back to the breaking news on the topic, before the photos arose, from November 03 to March 04.
Surely an international investigation, independent of the accused, is what is needed.
Surely you are full of crap. A politically loaded "investigation" cum 'witch hunt' is as farcical a body as can be found.

Fire, see as example alpha the scumbags who get put on the HR committee in the UN, like Syria. Your appeal to "world governmental authority" is an appeal to madness, the lynch mob, and pitchfork, and the torch.

DR
 
Last edited:
If he was. Do you have evidence. I have a suspicion, and that is all. And no, please clue up. Not worthless even is somewhat tainted. Some heads did roll, though in my view the leadership at the star level was not held accountable enough, nor the secretariat and undersecretariat level leadership.

So we both suspect some whitewash was used. Says a lot for the accused being involved in running the investigation.

You rather miss the point. The chain of command was, as I have said time and again, not held accountable, but the larger problem was that there were too many fingers into the operation, too many stovepipes.

You miss the point. It's simply about who runs an investigation. We all know something went wrong. Many related accusations needed to be investigated. But "Our Congress or nobody", means that Iraqis have to rely on America's good nature to fairly investigate itself. That's not how justice is done and seen to be done.

The idea that only America can be trusted to run a fair investigation is either arrogance or paranoia.
 
In another, on January 15, at Tal al Hawa south-west of Gaza City, Israeli soldiers forced an 11-year-old boy to walk in front of them for several hours as they moved through the town, even after they had been shot at.

Now the IDF can no longer claim moral high ground as far as Hamas using human shields go.
 
While I am at it, Cleon, with your out of focus scorn of investigations, Rumsfeld's DoD should never have investigated and charged soldiers at Abu Ghraib for their misconduct. Ya know, the investigation that began in the fall of 2003.

These internal investigations are all worthless, ya see ...

DR

There is also, of course, the unanswerable question of whether these investigations would have taken place at all were it not for the photos that became public that forced the issue. Once that happened someone's head was going to roll. The probability that the whole thing would have been swept under the rug otherwise is pretty high.
 
Double post in other thread, sorry:

The Honestreporting article regarding the OP, as well as other media outlet's response to this issue, is quite an interesting read:

"War Crimes" and Shoddy Journalism
Excerpts:
There are precisely two charges of gratuitous killing of Palestinian civilians under allegedly explicit orders to do so. One is what even Ha'aretz made clear was an accidental killing, when two women misunderstood the evacuation route the Israeli soldiers had given them and walked into a sniper's gunsights as a result. Moreover, the soldier who said this has subsequently admitted he didn’t see this incident - he wasn’t even in Gaza at the time - and had merely reported rumour and hearsay.

The second charge is based on a supposedly real incident in which, when an elderly woman came close to an IDF unit, an officer ordered that they shoot her because she was approaching the line and might have been a suicide bomber. The soldier relating this story did not say whether or not the woman in this story actually was shot. Indeed, since he says 'from the description of what happened' it would appear this was merely hearsay once again.

It is important to note that none of the testimony was about what the soldiers did themselves, but rather of what they heard or saw other soldiers do. It is also important that what was reported seems to fall within the realm of aberrations by individuals during war against a cruel enemy hiding behind civilians, not a systematic loss by the army of its moral compass.

The second piece of context is Dani Zamir, the head of the program, who had the soldiers' words transcribed and published. A story in Haaretz on Thursday said that in 1990 Zamir, then a parachute company commander in the reserves, was tried and sentenced to prison for refusing to guard a ceremony where "right-wingers" brought Torah scrolls to Joseph's tomb in Nablus.

A Paratroopers Brigade soldier who also participated in the war called the claims "nonsense". Speaking on condition of anonymity, he said, "It is true that in war morality can be interpreted in many different ways, and there are always a few idiots who act inappropriately, but most of the soldiers represented Israel honorably and with a high degree of morality.

"For instance, on three separate occasions my company commander checked soldiers' bags for stolen goods. Those who stole the smallest things, like candy, were severely punished," he said.

"We were forbidden from sleeping in Palestinians' beds even when we had no alternate accommodations, and we didn’t touch any of their food even after we hadn't had enough to eat for two days."

Just to put these allegations into perspective.
 
What a UN report. Love it when it states at the end

Report also cites Hamas violations

These incidents aren't verified and the statement:

"If you want to know whether I think that in doing so we killed innocents, the answer is, unequivocally, yes,"

Doesn't imply intentional targeting of civilians. So another baseless puff piece.
 
Internal army investigation finds that the mother and her kids were not shot:
Two central incidents that came up in the testimony, which Danny Zamir, the head of the Rabin pre-military academy presented to Chief of Staff Gaby Ashkenazi, focus on one infantry brigade. The brigade’s commander today will present to Brigadier General Eyal Eisenberg, commander of the Gaza division, the findings of his personal investigation about the matter which he undertook in the last few days, and after approval, he will present his findings to the head of the Southern Command, Major General Yoav Gallant.
Regarding the incident in which it was claimed that a sniper fired at a Palestinian woman and her two daughters, the brigade commander’s investigation cites the sniper: “I saw the woman and her daughters and I shot warning shots. The section commander came up to the roof and shouted at me, ?Why did you shoot at them.’ I explained that I did not shoot at them, but I fired warning shots.”
Officers from the brigade surmise that fighters that stayed in the bottom floor of the Palestinian house thought that he hit them, and from here the rumor that a sniper killed a mother and her two daughters spread.
​

Note, this is from an investigation initiated by the commander of the unit involved.
 
Unfortunately, the damage has already been done. As with most of these cases, the actual investigations that take place after all the finger pointing and colorful stories are worthless.
 
Internal army investigation finds that the mother and her kids were not shot:


Note, this is from an investigation initiated by the commander of the unit involved.

so as I read this the entire "personal investigation" was this one commanding officer asking the sniper if he shot them and the snipers denial. Then some talk that soldiers had "Thought" he shot them and this "surmised" to have started a rumor.

ummm....talk to the people that "thought" he shot them and ask them why they thought this? But anyway, a denial would probably be enough.

So one officer goes and asks a question and accepts a denial. This is an "Investigation"?
 
Here are the facts as I understand them so far:

1. Israeli newspaper publish an article based on stories from soldiers. One of the incidents reported is about a woman and two kids who where shot and killed due to a ****up.

This seemed credible at the time, as one is lead to understand that the soldier reporting the incident was a witness to it.

2. After a day or two, other Israeli journalists contact the soldier which have reported the incident. (One of these journalists is Ronny Daniel, from Israel's channel two. I have not seen his report.) They discover he was not in Gaza during the war, and was not a witness to the incident. He merely repeated
a story he heard.

3. Internal IDF investigation, which I have linked to above, find that there was an incident, but it only involved warning shots, and no one was killed. This incident is claimed to start some rumors, leading to the story in the paper.

This is all the information we have at this point. I have been asked whether it is possible that the army investigation is either covering up something, or is just not a proper investigation. This is always possible.

However, the evidence that the original story is true is very weak, based on rumors reported by someone not present at the scene. Until further evidence is presented I find the IDF version to be more likely to be true. (Further evidence would be, for instance, establishing the mother and kids identity, and that they were in fact killed on that day.)
 
Here are the facts as I understand them so far:

1. Israeli newspaper publish an article based on stories from soldiers. One of the incidents reported is about a woman and two kids who where shot and killed due to a ****up.

This seemed credible at the time, as one is lead to understand that the soldier reporting the incident was a witness to it.

2. After a day or two, other Israeli journalists contact the soldier which have reported the incident. (One of these journalists is Ronny Daniel, from Israel's channel two. I have not seen his report.) They discover he was not in Gaza during the war, and was not a witness to the incident. He merely repeated
a story he heard.

3. Internal IDF investigation, which I have linked to above, find that there was an incident, but it only involved warning shots, and no one was killed. This incident is claimed to start some rumors, leading to the story in the paper.

This is all the information we have at this point. I have been asked whether it is possible that the army investigation is either covering up something, or is just not a proper investigation. This is always possible.

However, the evidence that the original story is true is very weak, based on rumors reported by someone not present at the scene. Until further evidence is presented I find the IDF version to be more likely to be true. (Further evidence would be, for instance, establishing the mother and kids identity, and that they were in fact killed on that day.)
well, you are persistant.

you still describe one officer posing one question to the accused and accepting a denial as an "internal IDF Investigation".

I expect that this will be the end of this...."investigated" and forgotten. All the people that are happy to accept the IDF "investigations" can get on with ignoring stuff.
 
All the people that are happy to accept the IDF "investigations" can get on with ignoring stuff.

Everyone else however will want these vile atrocities investigated and punished properly.

The story and the citations from soldiers were even on the ABC news today.

I nearly threw up when an IDF general said "We are the most humane army in the world!"

The lies are incredulous!!! But I guess it's hardly surprising as the Zionist Movement and it's tools like the IDF work on lies and propaganda.

Good that this evidence is on mainstream US news networks
 
Not surprising that these admissions by IDF soldiers, who weren't witnesses to begin with, are used as absolute evidence that these incidents took place as initially reported, if at all.

And what I've read above, this is just as ridiculous as the statements of Ahmadinejad that the 'myth of the Holocaust must be investigated'. That statement itself indicates that there has been a decision has already been made on the matter. As with these two incidents reported on.

So let's wait and see until these investigations come to a close, both internal and external, before making definitive conclusions.
 
It was as if the media were altogether so eager to find reason to criticize the IDF that they pounced on one discussion by nine soldiers who met after returning from the battlefield to share their experiences and subjective feelings with each other, using that one episode to draw conclusions that felt more like an indictment. Dogma replaced balance and led to a dangerous misunderstanding of the depth and complexity of Israeli reality. The individual accounts were never intended to serve as a basis for broad generalizations and summary conclusions by the media; they were published internally, intended for program graduates and their parents as a tool to be used in the process of educating and guiding the next generation.

The author is Danny Zamir, who submitted the original accounts to the IDF. He is not happy with the way the media covered this story. See this, and this.
 
Everyone else however will want these vile atrocities investigated and punished properly.
The story and the citations from soldiers were even on the ABC news today.
I nearly threw up when an IDF general said "We are the most humane army in the world!"
The lies are incredulous!!! But I guess it's hardly surprising as the Zionist Movement and it's tools like the IDF work on lies and propaganda.
Good that this evidence is on mainstream US news networks


There is a Special Investigatory Team headed by Richard Goldstone.
Let's wait for the results of their efforts before making rash assumptions and accusations that may or may not be true.

As noted by Doctor Evil, Danny Zamir is pretty pissed off at the way this has been misrepresented.
Also, General Galant has some choice words:
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/129587
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom