Israeli soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza

I take it that was tongue in cheek. And if it wasn't, someone's views on 911 shouldn't make any difference to this Gaza-IDF story
It shows he is a fool or a tool. If he is either in one place, I assume he is the same in others. Does not didprove the stories and the stories, some or all may be true. That would alter my belief in those people - the US has people who don't deserve to be called soldiers either. But we and Israel do a damn sight better that the Hamas and Hezbollah and AlQuaeda defilers of their mother's wombs.
 
It doesn't necessarily follow from these soldiers' actions in Gaza that Israel's plan is to have the whole of Palestine.
does it then follow from this?

"The Jewish communities in Judea, Samaria and Gaza are the realization of Zionist values. Settlement of the land is a clear expression of the unassailable right of the Jewish people to the Land of Israel and constitutes an important asset in the defense of the vital interests of the State of Israel. The Likud will continue to strengthen and develop these communities and will prevent their uprooting."

and

"The Palestinians can run their lives freely in the framework of self-rule, but not as an independent and sovereign state. Thus, for example, in matters of foreign affairs, security, immigration and ecology, their activity shall be limited in accordance with imperatives of Israel's existence, security and national needs."

and

"The Jordan Valley and the territories that dominate it shall be under Israeli sovereignty. The Jordan river will be the permanent eastern border of the State of Israel.

and

"Based on the Likud-led government's proposal, the 10th Knesset passed the law to extend Israeli law, jurisdiction and administration over the Golan Heights, thus establishing Israeli sovereignty over the area. The government will continue to strengthen Jewish settlement on the Golan."

so whats left? everything west of the Jordan shall be under Israeli sovereignty, the golan will continue to be strengthened....whats left?

Gaza is left....but as I read it this will remain under Israeli control with no time limit...

Of the original mandate...whats left that is not claimed under these statements?

This is not the rantings of some extremist minority....It is the platform of the Likud party.

http://www.knesset.gov.il/elections/knesset15/elikud_m.htm

The statement that "Israel wants it all" is an opinion. It may not happen in the end.....but can the platform of the Likud Party be seen as anything other than an expression of a desire to do just that?
 
Last edited:
I picked many examples, I could debate the merits of that one, but he ignores the rest. I take it he concedes them.

You picked THREE examples. I pointed out that even given your nearly microscopic sample size of anecdotal evidence, it still didn't say what you wanted it to.
 
You picked THREE examples. I pointed out that even given your nearly microscopic sample size of anecdotal evidence, it still didn't say what you wanted it to.

There were several examples listed in one of them. Captain R was never disputed to have filled the girls body with bullets. The recording of the event was taken. He just fired defensively and by a coincidence, the bullets wound up in her body.

There was another case I have referred to here, that is getting harder to find now because it happened several years ago. An officer training a new batch of IDF recruits took them through a Palestinian village, and ordered them to use 'defensive fire'. A teenage boy was killed. The officer was promoted.

Curiously, a boy being allowed to drive IDF property is taken seriously.
 
It's the same thing as in Deir Yassin. Did Deir Yassin happen? Sure. But it was the exception, not the rule. On the other hand, every single place where the Arabs won in the war in 1948 was razed to the ground or "evacuated" of every single Jew.

Or take the Abu Gharib case. Did it happen? Sure. Was it typical of US forces? No. Did it remotely resemble what went Saddam's Abu Gharib prison? No. Did it make the USA the moral equivalent of that vicious dictator, let alone of the Jihadist who are fighting it in Iraq? Of course not.

Same here. Some soldiers behaved badly? Sure. Did the IDF as a whole so behave? No. Does this mean there's the remotest moral equivelancy between Hamas and PLO, whose goal is a second holocaust through terrorism, rockets, and fanatic brainwashing, and Israel? No.
 
There were several examples listed in one of them. Captain R was never disputed to have filled the girls body with bullets. The recording of the event was taken. He just fired defensively and by a coincidence, the bullets wound up in her body.

There was another case I have referred to here, that is getting harder to find now because it happened several years ago. An officer training a new batch of IDF recruits took them through a Palestinian village, and ordered them to use 'defensive fire'. A teenage boy was killed. The officer was promoted.

Curiously, a boy being allowed to drive IDF property is taken seriously.

Your claim, if I am understanding you correctly, is that deliberate and premeditated war crimes and atrocities are common, systemic and openly encouraged in the IDF.

Your anecdotal evidence is insufficient to prove such a claim. Not only that, the anecdotes you provided didn't back your claim.

I cannot concede a point when no point has been made.
 
There were several examples listed in one of them. Captain R was never disputed to have filled the girls body with bullets. The recording of the event was taken. He just fired defensively and by a coincidence, the bullets wound up in her body.

There was another case I have referred to here, that is getting harder to find now because it happened several years ago. An officer training a new batch of IDF recruits took them through a Palestinian village, and ordered them to use 'defensive fire'. A teenage boy was killed. The officer was promoted.

Curiously, a boy being allowed to drive IDF property is taken seriously.

Obviously the 'defensive' in defensive fire means the same as 'defensive' in Israeli Defense Force

We all know the polarities are changed when it comes to Israeli policy. The defence, sorry offense minister says Israel's army ti the most moral, sorry immoral, in the world. It must be true!!

The IDF should be called the IOF
 
Your claim, if I am understanding you correctly, is that deliberate and premeditated war crimes and atrocities are common, systemic and openly encouraged in the IDF.

Your anecdotal evidence is insufficient to prove such a claim. Not only that, the anecdotes you provided didn't back your claim.

I cannot concede a point when no point has been made.

I don't think a_u_p's claim is that atrocities are openly encouraged in the IDF. But the record shows a discrepancy between the facts of each case and the subsequent verdict. This HRW report gives an overview of the problems with. A major problem with all IDF investigations is that hardly ever Palestinian witnesses are even heard, but that investigations (nearly) solely rely on the testimony of other soldiers. This is also what saved Captain R.: in the end, the case revolved mainly about the strife between him and his soldiers, and that some of their testimony was false, than about his actions; after all, there can be no doubt that he indeed emptied his magazine at point-blank range into the girl while she already laid on the ground.

But this track record of investigations and hardly serious punishments does send a clear message to IDF soldiers: no matter what you do, you can get away with it.
 
Your claim, if I am understanding you correctly, is that deliberate and premeditated war crimes and atrocities are common, systemic and openly encouraged in the IDF.

Your anecdotal evidence is insufficient to prove such a claim. Not only that, the anecdotes you provided didn't back your claim.

I cannot concede a point when no point has been made.

I have no idea if it's a policy, it's certainly not a stated policy, but the evidence is that apparently criminal acts are not punished. As that Haaretz arcticle says, they IDF is more concerned about misuse of a company vehicle.
 
But this track record of investigations and hardly serious punishments does send a clear message to IDF soldiers: no matter what you do, you can get away with it.
Military investigations are rarely ever public record, so this assumption is baseless.

Regardless, I'll await a proper investigation into this matter rather than run with 2nd hand statements.
 
Military investigations are rarely ever public record, so this assumption is baseless.
so are you saying that there are a larger group of investigations that are kept secret within the IDF that are soundly executed that more than balance out the ones the rest of the world actually hears about?

what happens to the people that are found guilty and receive a prison term from these investigations we don't hear about. How is there absence explained to their family?
 
so are you saying that there are a larger group of investigations that are kept secret within the IDF that are soundly executed that more than balance out the ones the rest of the world actually hears about?
Nope. This is regular military procedure, from the US to NATO nations. Military court, as a common practice, do not disclose their procedures to the public, unless the case itself has been highly publicized, in which case, some information has to be released to quell public interest with limited disclosure.

So this is common practice and no need to isolate the IDF from the rest of Western/Westernized nations' military practices.

what happens to the people that are found guilty and receive a prison term from these investigations we don't hear about. How is there absence explained to their family?
There's a difference between disclosing the military court proceedings to the family and full disclosure to the public. I hope this simple concept doesn't elude you.

Those who have found guilty of offenses serve in military prisons, as is also a common practice worldwide.
 
I On the other hand, every single place where the Arabs won in the war in 1948 was razed to the ground or "evacuated" of every single Jew. .

So the Arabs ridded themselves of all Jews...and Israel ridded itself of 2/3 of its Arabs.

Its still pretty close.
 
Nope. This is regular military procedure, from the US to NATO nations. Military court, as a common practice, do not disclose their procedures to the public, unless the case itself has been highly publicized, in which case, some information has to be released to quell public interest with limited disclosure.

So this is common practice and no need to isolate the IDF from the rest of Western/Westernized nations' military practices.


There's a difference between disclosing the military court proceedings to the family and full disclosure to the public. I hope this simple concept doesn't elude you.

Those who have found guilty of offenses serve in military prisons, as is also a common practice worldwide.
ok...there are lots of investigations that are done properly that we never hear about. take your word for it, look the other way and whistle a happy tune.

secret evidence supports your case and its just a damn pity it can't be produced. fair enough....
 
ok...there are lots of investigations that are done properly that we never hear about. take your word for it, look the other way and whistle a happy tune.

secret evidence supports your case and its just a damn pity it can't be produced. fair enough....
So secret that even you seem to know about it. These testimonies are unverified and continue to be so until there's an investigation. These investigations, however, rarely ever are as explosive as the initial allegations. So sorry for the big let down before hand...
 
So secret that even you seem to know about it. These testimonies are unverified and continue to be so until there's an investigation. These investigations, however, rarely ever are as explosive as the initial allegations. So sorry for the big let down before hand...

A girl is shot, in cold blood, and a magazine of bullets is emptied into her. The troops there are horrified, but it turns out it was all just a case of a lack of brotherly love. The bullets in the body were some defensive fire that, somehow, all wound up in her body.
 
On the contrary, if you are STUPID enough to actually consider believing that the 19 hijackers did not do 9-11, then your brain does not function correctly, and your ability to make sound judgements and observations, especially when it comes to politically sensitive issues that you CLEARLY have strong opinions over, is seriously in question.

A couple of comments. First, I would not condemn someone based solely on what it says in wikipedia, which is subject to biases of its own. Second, I do not see the Falk's quoted statements by themselves challenging whether 9/11 was perpetrated by 19 hijackers. One can challenge some of the official statements and actions around 9/11 without rejecting the core events.

I would agree that this particular gentleman, despite a long and distinguished career, appears to be more of an advocate than an objective observer, and as such is not the best choice for such a sensitive position.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom