Israeli soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza

Stop with the stupid, will you?

"Never happens again" is idiot speak. People do not pass all and complete knowledge along, and turnover in military services is endemic. No matter how you try, some folks don't learn from the book and the experience of others. They have to screw up on their own.

DR


Maybe "never happens again" was too strong, but surely there is something that can be done here.

I'm not condemning the Israeli soldiers. The sniper was told not to allow anyone into that area and that woman was instructed to go a different direction.
 
how can someone shoot an unarmed woman...or an unarmed child???

or an unarmed elderly person?

these folks must go to trial.
 
how can someone shoot an unarmed woman...or an unarmed child???
Sight alignment, trigger control, and adjustment for wind.
or an unarmed elderly person?
Same way.
these folks must go to trial.
If you can show me the targets were not part and parcel to the fight, and were indeed non combatants, I am with you 100%. Your assumption, however, might be worth looking into. I don't pretend to know one way or another.
Israeli soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza
Whereas the IAF engaged in vandalism with a purpose. Those modern, guided bombs sure do mess things up. The street gangs of our cities are green with envy.

DR
 
An IDF internal investigation and an "independent" investigation by Falk would be equally worthless, IMO.

I 100% agree. I think the Quartet should send a team of investigators to look into IDF and Hamas crimes in Gaza and southern Israel.
 
Actually it's not true.

This is a lie.

But if you really think 9/11 deniers aren't the biggest bunch of liars in the universe, you are welcome to make your case in the appropriate forum.

Until then, Mr. Falk's opinion on pretty much anything is null and void.
 
Last edited:
To be a Truther, you have to cherry-pick data and ignore information that doesn't conform to your preconceived conclusion. This does not make for a good investigation or investigator.

There's a difference between ignoring information and distrusting it/disbelieving it.

The problem comes is that it's nigh on impossible to find out if evidence provided by the government is true or not. I don't take the government's word on anything to be honest. Contrary to teh silly assertions by some in this forum I'm not a truther as I don't claim 911 was an inside job. However I don't discount the possibility. Anyway that's for another sub-forum.

An IDF internal investigation and an "independent" investigation by Falk would be equally worthless, IMO.

Agreed.
 
This is a lie.

Grow up. I know many people who don't dislike people who claim 911 was an inside job. Of course it's not a lie.


But if you really think 9/11 deniers aren't the biggest bunch of liars in the universe, you are welcome to make your case in the appropriate forum.

More nonsense. Why should a truther be a liar? Why can't they genuinely believe something to be true?

Until then, Mr. Falk's opinion on pretty much anything is null and void.

I take things on a case by case basis. Just because someone has some views on one subject it doesn't mean everything they say is wrong.

It's both illogical and narrow minded IMO to assume X is wrong just because Y is wrong or might be wrong.

By your standards I should ignore everything *you* say based upon your ridiculous arguments above, but I'll take what you say on a case by case basis
 
An IDF internal investigation and an "independent" investigation by Falk would be equally worthless, IMO.

An unfortunate attitude as an IDF internal investigation is likely all you are going to get.

If the Israelis determine that allowing outsiders to poke around their armed forces would be harmful to their national security, then the only way around that would be to have an army and air force bigger than theirs.
 
I take things on a case by case basis. Just because someone has some views on one subject it doesn't mean everything they say is wrong.

It's both illogical and narrow minded IMO to assume X is wrong just because Y is wrong or might be wrong.

By your standards I should ignore everything *you* say based upon your ridiculous arguments above, but I'll take what you say on a case by case basis

TFT- this guy has contributed to several 9-11 books.

If he doesn't have the mental capacity to understand that the 9-11 conspiracy theories are utter BS, then his capacity to make sound judgements regarding controversial and political issues is in serious jeapordy.

Would you have problems believing the investigative findings of someone who believed that the Earth was 6,000 years old? Or that Jews are really Lizard People?

How about someone who believed that the Earth was flat..would that bother you?

If Obama came out in support of 9-11 conspiracy theories, I would NOT have voted for him.

If Clinton believed that the Earth was flat and was 6,000 years old, I would NOT have voted for the man.

Sue me. I guess I'm just judgemental.
 
Last edited:
If the Israelis determine that allowing outsiders to poke around their armed forces would be harmful to their national security, then the only way around that would be to have an army and air force bigger than theirs.

The Israelis believe that anything that says that they did something wrong is against their national security interests.

I expect a long Israeli investigation that will find "tragic...but all legal actions".
 
More nonsense. Why should a truther be a liar? Why can't they genuinely believe something to be true?

This is the last I am going to address this particular issue in this thread and subforum.

I have not yet met a 9/11 denier who has not lied in order to convince people of his lunacy.

Here is a typical example:

9/11 Denier: "WTC7 collapsed in 6.6 seconds, free fall speed!"

Rationalist: "No, it collapsed in 16+ seconds, you are way off"

9/11 Denier: (An hour, a day or a week later) "WTC7 collapsed in 6.6 seconds, free fall speed!"

Every... last... one... of... them...
has done this. They make a false statement, get corrected on it then repeat the false statement at a later point already knowing it is bloody well not true.

All 9/11 deniers are liars.

But as I said, with respect to our long-suffering, overworked and underpaid mods, this is not the forum for this discussion. Take it where it belongs if you wish to discuss it further (assuming the mods haven't split and moved this already).
 
The Israelis believe that anything that says that they did something wrong is against their national security interests.

I expect a long Israeli investigation that will find "tragic...but all legal actions".

This doesn't apply to just Israel alone.

Do you really believe that having "independent investigators" poke around your military hierarchy is going to be completely benign to their ability to do their jobs?

The Bush administration refused to sign onto the International Criminal Court for exactly these reasons.

As a Canadian I wouldn't want anyone but my fellow canadians policing our armed farces... and even then we still managed to screw that up. Having foreigners who do not have my countries best interests at heart do it is just begging for an even worse disaster.
 
Yep. It's the equivalent of an accused murderer conducting his own investigation and finding himself innocent.

i.e., worthless.

The innocent PPCLI snipers drummed out of the Canadian Armed Forces would disagree.
 
This doesn't apply to just Israel alone.

Do you really believe that having "independent investigators" poke around your military hierarchy is going to be completely benign to their ability to do their jobs?

The Bush administration refused to sign onto the International Criminal Court for exactly these reasons.

As a Canadian I wouldn't want anyone but my fellow canadians policing our armed farces... and even then we still managed to screw that up. Having foreigners who do not have my countries best interests at heart do it is just begging for an even worse disaster.

I can't imagine non israelis being allowed to investigate the IDF....the Israeli Judiciary would do....as would just about anyone but the IDF themselves.
 
I can't imagine non israelis being allowed to investigate the IDF....the Israeli Judiciary would do....as would just about anyone but the IDF themselves.

Doesn't the IDF have its own military justice system like most western nations do?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom