Israeli soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza

Last edited:
Or "compensated".

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/697464.html

The judges who acquitted Captain R accepted his version of event, in which he stated that the shots that he fired were not aimed directly at the girl's body. Captain R told the court he opened fire in order to create a deterrence, and that he believed that the young girl posed a serious threat.

They weren't aimed directly at the body, but somehow most of them wound up in it.
 
It's a matter of getting your priorities right.

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1007105.html

Brigadier General Moshe "Chico" Tamir is a devoted and loving father who let his 14-year-old son drive a military all-terrain vehicle. Being the law-abiding organization that it is, the Israel Defense Forces probed the incident, calling it "serious." As a result, Tamir's promotion may be put on hold and he may be indicted. Certainly, a brigade commander who tried to cover up his son's accident by lying deserves to be punished. But the commander of the Gaza Brigade deserves much more for acts considerably more serious - acts that the world defines as war crimes and for which no one has been held accountable.

I would like Tamir, the dedicated father, to meet a girl the same age as his beloved son whose world fell apart when she was 14 years old. I saw her in mourning in November 2006, in the courtyard of her destroyed house in Beit Hanun. Islam Athamneh lost eight family members: Her mother, grandmother, grandfather, aunts, uncles and cousins. They fled their house when it was struck by a shell and were killed by another onslaught. The legs of Abdullah, her three-year-old brother, were blown off. Islam, whose father had died years earlier, became an orphan.

The soldiers who fired the 11 shells at houses in Beit Hanun were under the command of Tamir, the dedicated dad who let his son take a Tomcar for a joyride. Some 22 people were killed in the shelling and another 40 were hurt. Most lost limbs or sustained head wounds.
0.gif
Advertisement
It was the Gaza Brigade commander, Tamir, who was responsible for that atrocity, but the IDF quickly absolved him of blame. Instead, they placed it on a faulty electronic component in the gun barrel. It was the chip, not Chico, who was to blame. In the seven days before the heinous shelling, which violates international law, Tamir's troops managed to kill 80 Palestinians, 40 of whom were innocent civilians, as part of Operation Autumn Clouds. Their blood was let and their deaths pale in significance to the Tomcar affair as far as the army is concerned. After all, what's some unlawful killing en masse next to illegally driving an ATV?
 
Another investigation.
http://www.counterpunch.com/levy09292007.html
[SIZE=-1]Abir Aramin was even younger; she was just 11. The daughter of an activist in the Combatants for Peace organization, in January she left her school in Anata and was on the way to buy candy in a little shop. She was fired upon from a Border Police vehicle. Bassam, her father, told us back then with bloodshot eyes and in a strangled voice: "I told myself that I don't want to take revenge. Revenge will be for this 'hero,' who was so 'threatened' by my daughter that he shot and killed her, to stand trial for it." But just a few days ago the authorities announced that the case was being closed: The Border Police apparently acted appropriately.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=-1]"I'm not going to exploit my daughter's blood for political purposes. This is a human outcry. I'm not going to lose my mind just because I lost my heart," the grieving father, who has many Israeli friends, also told us.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=-1]

[/SIZE]
 
It was the chip, not Chico, who was to blame. In the seven days before the heinous shelling, which violates international law, Tamir's troops managed to kill 80 Palestinians, 40 of whom were innocent civilians, as part of Operation Autumn Clouds.

Only 40 of them were "innocent civillians"?

If you want the people responsible for the civilian deaths punished, you should consider going after Hamas for their use of fellow palestinians as human shields.

140049689c77b24b2.jpg
 
In other words, you have nothing to say.

Can you not read?

I just pointed out that only HALF the people Tamir killed were civilians. And this is against an enemy notorious for using human shields.

And Hamas and Hezbollah don't use uniforms either... I wouldn't be suprised if some of those 40 civilians were also Hamas/Hezbollah/Fatah/whateverah.

Maybe you can explain to us your foolproof method for discerning combatants from civvies in the Gaza Strip and West Bank.
 
Can you not read?

I just pointed out that only HALF the people Tamir killed were civilians. And this is against an enemy notorious for using human shields.

And Hamas and Hezbollah don't use uniforms either... I wouldn't be suprised if some of those 40 civilians were also Hamas/Hezbollah/Fatah/whateverah.

Maybe you can explain to us your foolproof method for discerning combatants from civvies in the Gaza Strip and West Bank.

There were many examples, you cherry pick one.
 
Only 40 of them were "innocent civillians"?

If you want the people responsible for the civilian deaths punished, you should consider going after Hamas for their use of fellow palestinians as human shields.

[qimg]http://i30.photobucket.com/albums/c345/Kilstryke/140049689c77b24b2.jpg[/qimg]

LOL
And this in a thread about the IDF taking over civilian homes, chucking out the furniture but keeping the people for a couple of days and then not properly escorting the civilians to a place of safety.

I'm invading New York. Anyone who wishes to defend New Yorkers can go fight me in the middle of the Atlantic -- or some place else I won't be. After all... They wouldn't want to use New Yorkers as Human shields, would they?

What? A sniper in a skyscraper? Let me call in an airstrike... I'll blame the sniper for the collatoral damage.
 
Very disturbing indeed, but it does correlate to the obvious and undeniable long term Zionist Agenda to take the lot.

Although I agree that these acts were reprehensible and the guilty soldiers and their commanding officers trialed, you are committing a logical fallacy, I would say a form of non-sequitur.

It doesn't necessarily follow from these soldiers' actions in Gaza that Israel's plan is to have the whole of Palestine.

You're trying once again to spin this story and have the same discussion about your hatred of what you call the "Zionist agenda".
 
Last edited:
While of course not everyone in the IDF is a racist murderer,and indeed it's great that these soldiers are speaking out, it's obvious that the endemic climate in the IDF is one of racist murderous thuggery.

What makes you come to this conclusion?

Even the mainstream media are having to report the atrocities of Israel.
No, they are reporting the atrocities of a few IDF soldiers, you are the one spinning this and accusing the entire state of Israel.

The IDF is a vile murderous terrorist organization. made even worse that the Israeli Establishment makes it compulsory to participate in.

Compulsory military service exists in other countries, it is actually not uncommon. It doesn't make a state a terrorist state, again, you are making a logical fallacy.
 
Last edited:
Israeli Every nation's soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza every goddamn war in human history.


Fixed it for you.
 
Only 40 of them were "innocent civillians"?

If you want the people responsible for the civilian deaths punished, you should consider going after Hamas for their use of fellow palestinians as human shields.

Oh yes - when the Arabs/Palestinians/... do something, Israel is allowed to do like things?

What happened to the meme that Israel is the only western state with democratic values in the region?

Epic fail.
 
Oh yes - when the Arabs/Palestinians/... do something, Israel is allowed to do like things?
That's a nice straw man you constructed! Who has ever claimed Israel should do "like" things?

What happened to the meme that Israel is the only western state with democratic values in the region?
What that has to do with this issue I don't have the slightest idea. I note that the ruling party in Israel hasn't rounded up and summarily executed the soldiers who are speaking out. Can't say I'd expect the same from any other players in the region.

Epic fail.
A straw man followed by a non sequitur followed by a taunting cry of victory, "epic fail" indeed.
 
Last edited:
Israeli Every nation's soldiers admit to murder, useless vandalism, in Gaza every goddamn war in human history.
Fixed it for you.

Ahh the old "Two wrongs Make a Right" dilution. Thankfully most people have had the sense to see how weak and tired that old argument is.

IOW "Don't pick on Israel, everyone does it" :rolleyes:

YAWN!!!

And what if everyone deflected criticism on the grounds that they aren't the only one committing atrocities.

Sorry Buddy. Israel is committing atrocities and Israel is getting criticized for it.

Israel Atrocity Deniers can throw as many toys out of their crib as they like.
 
Fixed it for you.

Which is why you don't have wars to fix your problems if they can be avoided. Israel's who strategy from the start, when it knew there would be a resistance to it's colonial style creation, was the "Iron Wall". It's an inherent problem with the existence of Israel until a peaceful resolution to the problem is found.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom