Oy vey this thread moves fast.
Yes. There is a real problem as I've documented throughout this thread.
...
Islam has not revealed itself, in large part, conducive to enlightenment. To the extent that that offends people I'm sorry. However I think the criticism isn't without merit and I think the actions of the UN take us away from enlightenment and not toward it. I think religion is the greatest threat to the enlightenment and Islam is of particular concern.
Religion isn't based in empirical knowledge and in fact it is often anti-empiricism. I think there is a valid fear that Islam can leads us back toward bronze age beliefs and not toward modernity.
I stand by that and my hope is a sincere one. If Islam can survive and embrace modernity then I'm fine with that. But let's move away from superstition and barbarism.
You see, voicing a concern that you believe the fundamentalist beliefs of some groups in Islam might bring back the bronze age, but making a statement from the perspective that you believe all of Islam (you said "Islam" not "some Islam" or "fundamentalist Islam") to be stuck in the bronze age is a whole different tone altogether. Hopefully you understand that it's the tone I'm having trouble with, not the concern that fundamentalist beliefs are going to drag society down. My only addendum to the effects of fundie religion on society is that I think Islam is one side of that coin that holds this risk, and on the other side of that is the strong politically-fueled fundamentalism in the US, each side of which consistently uses the other as its justification for its fundamentalist views. That's what concerns me, because it feels like a not-so-cold-war between two extreme ideologies, and I have no desire to be stuck in the middle of that.
Additionally, what I'm seeing as indictments against a religion don't seem to make sense, in that it feels to me like more of an attacking a symptom rather than a cause. I wish I remember the names of the authors or had the links handy to some of the articles I've read, but I've read elsewhere that the nations containing some of the worst human rights violations in the 20
th and 21
st centuries have tended to be oil-producing, and the worst cases have tended to be oil-producing as their main source of income. Basically, the thesis was that these single-resource nations have an environment that is suited to oligarchies and that the ones in power tend to get there through the most use of violence. Since the most damning indictments against Islam tend to have to do with human rights violations in Mid-Eastern and North African nations, I'd say there is a similarity to the locations of discontent but a difference in where the possible (or probable) sources of the behavior lie. You mention an enlightenment, but the Muslim world actually experienced such an enlightenment but had it diminished through the effects of the Crusades (and the demonization by the Holy Roman Empire) as well as the later centuries of Ottoman rule (which broke up social structure under its heavy-handed oligarchy). Transitioning from those conditions (which hampered the enlightenment) to the Western colonialism (after the fall of the Ottoman empire) to the development where the only political carrot they had was oil (most of the 20
th century), and I would argue that it's more than religion that's at play here, and making the indictment against Islam alone is throwing out the baby with the bathwater in actually addressing the problem. I'd say that the moves by the UN in disregarding the role fundamentalist religion plays in the violations also throws out the baby with the bathwater, but then the argument becomes about which method of throwing out the baby is worse.
-----
No need to get on the offensive.
My apologies.
I'll take a look at these, at least it's far better than what Google got me.
Honestly, I thought Google would have better results. Basically, I would start by taking a look at his administration's appointments, especially those in the areas of education, medicine, and law. Many of the Bush appointments, especially those who followed him from Texas, follow a similar pattern in the language they use and the associations they have, mostly of a highly-evangelical and in some cases reconstructionist nature. I'd have listed Ashcroft in there as well, but honestly a lot of the Bush top appointments and cabinet have their own lists of dubious evangelical associations. The Christian Coalition and other right-wing religious lobbies are too close for my comfort.
To balance that, though: I don't think it's a problem with just Bush or the right. Honestly, Carter was the one to bring the heavy use of religion in campaign rhetoric to the fore, and the right has simply been doing it more efficiently. What concerns me, though, is when high-ranking appointments are made to people who publicly espouse biblical literalism in their views, most especially those views directly pertaining to their job. The last ten years in particular have seen a decline in the separation of church and state, and the current administration has a lot to do with that.
I apologize if I did that, I didn't mean to be dismissive, I didn't address the rest of your post because I thought it spoke for itself, and didn't have anything to add to it, since it was your opinion.
Well, I was attempting to phrase in a more reasonable manner what I think Oliver may have been hinting at, though to be honest I am aware his views on subjects like that tend to go far beyond what I would consider reasonable. I wouldn't agree with his assertion that there's been bigotry in this thread, but there's been a lot of language that can be seen as intolerant and open to be observed as bigoted.
Good point. And Christianity and Islam shouldn't be immune to any criticism. But these days you got to admit that people tend to be more afraid to criticize Islam.
It's not the religions that I think need to be criticized-- criticizing a religion just causes the followers to circle the figurative wagons. Instead, criticizing leaders and groups (and practices) seems to be more efficient, and on top of that leaves room for followers of that same religion to join in the voices of those criticizing. There are Muslims all over who criticize fundamentalist behavior in their religion, especially the political regimes that allow it to flourish. I'd be willing to bet that most EU Muslims would be just as disappointed as non-Muslims with the UN HRC behavior ignoring the use of fundamentalism in perpetrating human rights violations. The reasons may differ-- such things tend to de-legitimize their own religious presence and allows Islam as a whole to be looked upon as inherently barbaric (with the implicit comparison to whatever religion du jour)-- but the hope for improved human rights, more civilized international relations, and an overall reduction of suffering is probably not much different than yours or mine. Moreover, like I mention in my response to RandFan, one could very well argue it's the existence of oil as the top or the single largest resource in these nations that are the problem-- the UAE, for example, tends to be far less problematic with regard to human rights violations than does Saudi Arabia, the former of which has begun moving out of oil as its primary source of national income. Libya, Iran, and honestly even Iraq-- all nations with a high dependency on oil for their national income and all nations with consistent histories of political turmoil and an oligarchical tendency.
Just something I suggest be considered. The whole "<religion x> is the problem" line of thinking just tends to cause a bit of dissonance to me when the discussion becomes heated.