Of course, so long as we don't sacrifice core principles on the alter of PC. Freedom of speech, the right to decent and other basic human rights are paramount and we should not back down in our defense of them for fear of offending.
Seriously, this whole anti-political-correctness stuff just smells like a certain-colored aquatic animal as far as the actual topic is concerned. "I'm not PC" is about as pop-culture as the "I'm nerdy" type of self-designation with people, usually as a tool to sound more desirable in some rhetorical sense.
You see, voicing a concern that you believe the fundamentalist beliefs of some groups in Islam might bring back the bronze age, but making a statement from the perspective that you believe all of Islam (you said "Islam" not "some Islam" or "fundamentalist Islam") to be stuck in the bronze age is a whole different tone altogether. Hopefully you understand that it's the tone I'm having trouble with, not the concern that fundamentalist beliefs are going to drag society down.
I understand your concern. There is no single magic bullet in the fight against ignorance, intolerance and fanaticism. I think strength in ones convictions as it concerns core values is paramount. When it comes to basic human rights we should draw a line in the sand. Prohibition of the criticism of religion is a line we shouldn't cross.
My only addendum to the effects of fundie religion on society is that I think Islam is one side of that coin that holds this risk, and on the other side of that is the strong politically-fueled fundamentalism in the US, each side of which consistently uses the other as its justification for its fundamentalist views.
A valid concern but of less significance for me as the US is a Democracy and there are counter voices.
Additionally, what I'm seeing as indictments against a religion don't seem to make sense, in that it feels to me like more of an attacking a symptom rather than a cause.
It's not that you don't have a point, you do. The problem I have with this is it is overly simplistic and while religion can be seen as a symptom it is overwhelmingly, IMO, a cause and not merely a symptom.
I wish I remember the names of the authors or had the links handy to some of the articles I've read, but I've read elsewhere that the nations containing some of the worst human rights violations in the 20th and 21st centuries have tended to be oil-producing, and the worst cases have tended to be oil-producing as their main source of income. Basically, the thesis was that these single-resource nations have an environment that is suited to oligarchies and that the ones in power tend to get there through the most use of violence. Since the most damning indictments against Islam tend to have to do with human rights violations in Mid-Eastern and North African nations, I'd say there is a similarity to the locations of discontent but a difference in where the possible (or probable) sources of the behavior lie. You mention an enlightenment, but the Muslim world actually experienced such an enlightenment but had it diminished through the effects of the Crusades (and the demonization by the Holy Roman Empire) as well as the later centuries of Ottoman rule (which broke up social structure under its heavy-handed oligarchy). Transitioning from those conditions (which hampered the enlightenment) to the Western colonialism (after the fall of the Ottoman empire) to the development where the only political carrot they had was oil (most of the 20th century), and I would argue that it's more than religion that's at play here, and making the indictment against Islam alone is throwing out the baby with the bathwater in actually addressing the problem. I'd say that the moves by the UN in disregarding the role fundamentalist religion plays in the violations also throws out the baby with the bathwater, but then the argument becomes about which method of throwing out the baby is worse.
I sympathize with your concerns but I can't agree completely with your analysis. We've already discussed the enlightenment of Muslims in this thread. Sadly it ended for whatever reason and now intellectualism is largely looked down on in many if not most Muslim nations. Yes, there is an assault on intellectualism in America but the answer to that is to stand up to it.
I used to come to the forum and argue and beg for patience and understanding toward religion. I at one time had an email debate with James Randi and I took your stance. I want you to know that I've carefully considered the arguments and I have become convinced that we need to stand up to the tyranny of religious fanaticism. We need to criticize religion. We need to expose it because we care for the adherents.
I think it is patronizing to adherents to think that they are too sensitive or fragile to tell them the truth because it might offend them.
Seriously, this whole anti-political-correctness stuff just smells like a certain-colored aquatic animal as far as the actual topic is concerned. "I'm not PC" is about as pop-culture as the "I'm nerdy" type of self-designation with people, usually as a tool to sound more desirable in some rhetorical sense.
I don't agree with you. I'm not interested in a rhetorical sense. I look at what is going on and the people who in the past would stand up for freedom who now fight it and the only conclusion I have for them forsaking core values is fear of offending.
If the UN or any political body said that we couldn't criticize George Bush because it would offend Republicans we would all be outraged as well we should.
That people are offended is not a reason to forgo the strength of your convictions. Basic human rights are more important than offending religious sensibilities, and make no mistake, that is what this thread is about.
I understand your concern. There is no single magic bullet in the fight against ignorance, intolerance and fanaticism. I think strength in ones convictions as it concerns core values is paramount. When it comes to basic human rights we should draw a line in the sand. Prohibition of the criticism of religion is a line we shouldn't cross.
It's not that you don't have a point, you do. The problem I have with this is it is overly simplistic and while religion can be seen as a symptom it is overwhelmingly, IMO, a cause and not merely a symptom.
I just don't see it, then. I see it used as a tool, I see it as being involved in spreading certain ideas, but as you yourself have pointed out it isn't like the same types of institutional atrocities can't be attained through dogmatic following of leaders holding a more secular bent. Religion has certainly been a primary domain of dogma for a long time, but it doesn't have a monopoly.
I sympathize with your concerns but I can't agree completely with your analysis. We've already discussed the enlightenment of Muslims in this thread. Sadly it ended for whatever reason and now intellectualism is largely looked down on in many if not most Muslim nations. Yes, there is an assault on intellectualism in America but the answer to that is to stand up to it.
I used to come to the forum and argue and beg for patience and understanding toward religion. I at one time had an email debate with James Randi and I took your stance. I want you to know that I've carefully considered the arguments and I have become convinced that we need to stand up to the tyranny of religious fanaticism. We need to criticize religion. We need to expose it because we care for the adherents.
I think it is patronizing to adherents to think that they are too sensitive or fragile to tell them the truth because it might offend them.
If all your comments focused on the extremism and the fundamentalists, that I would agree with you 100%. However, even though I'm not a follower of any religion I am getting the impression in both your language and the language of others in the thread that the focus is on Islam as a whole and not fundamentalists and extremists. I realize that you've stated otherwise, as have others, but then the language goes right back to the general and the sweeping statements.
I don't agree with you. I'm not interested in a rhetorical sense. I look at what is going on and the people who in the past would stand up for freedom who now fight it and the only conclusion I have for them forsaking core values is fear of offending.
If the UN or any political body said that we couldn't criticize George Bush because it would offend Republicans we would all be outraged as well we should.
That people are offended is not a reason to forgo the strength of your convictions. Basic human rights are more important than offending religious sensibilities, and make no mistake, that is what this thread is about.
But if you refer to all Republicans as if they were like George Bush, even if you might be focusing most intently on George Bush, don't you see how your choice in framing the argument has a flaw that hampers actually communicating and addressing the problem?
I think we're still talking about two different things here GrenMe. I understand your point but there's a big difference between islamic countries which use Sharia and Bush's United States. Christian religion may influence this administration's decisions, but it doesn't dictate the laws of the country, it doesn't tell people how to behave. Sharia is both law and religion. If we want to criticize the abuses in countries which uses Sharia as their law, then we have to criticize Islam at the same time. That's the whole problem at the UN HRC. Everytime someone raises a concern about abuses under Sharia, Egypt, Pakistan and Iran are going stop the discussion and ask for Sharia not to be discussed, and pretend they are being offended in their rights for religious freedom.
You don't see that in the US. Evangelists and Christian groups may get offended and yell all they want, if abuses are being done under some religious pretext the courts are not going to stop there. Just look at the latest polygamous sect scandal.
Religion's interference and growing influence on politicians in the US is a concern, but Sharia is already a problem.
I'm not saying we have to criticize religion just for the sake of criticizing religion, I'm saying religion shouldn't have immunity. If there are human rights abuses, religion shouldn't be a pretext to avoid confronting those abuses, and if religion is the main cause for these abuses, then let's criticize this religion head-on, without fear of being labeled "intolerant", which of course is ridiculous since it's that very same religion which is causing intolerance to begin with.
I just don't see it, then. I see it used as a tool, I see it as being involved in spreading certain ideas, but as you yourself have pointed out it isn't like the same types of institutional atrocities can't be attained through dogmatic following of leaders holding a more secular bent. Religion has certainly been a primary domain of dogma for a long time, but it doesn't have a monopoly.
Religion is a meme. Evolutionary fit memes have defense mechanism to protect them. No, there is certainly no monopoly. I don't hold that religion is unique. I can only refer you to sources better than I. If you've not read them I recommend the God Delusion and Dennett's Breaking the Spell.
Again, you're implying that there aren't Muslims who stand up to such assaults within Islam.
I'm confused by this. I'm tempted to apologize for not being clear but I'm not certain the fault is mine. If it is then I apologize. I intend no such implications.
If all your comments focused on the extremism and the fundamentalists, that I would agree with you 100%. However, even though I'm not a follower of any religion I am getting the impression in both your language and the language of others in the thread that the focus is on Islam as a whole and not fundamentalists and extremists. I realize that you've stated otherwise, as have others, but then the language goes right back to the general and the sweeping statements.
It's not a simple problem. Moderates, to some degree, give cover to the fanatics. It's hard to see the attack as simply being one coming from fanatics when moderates demand that their beliefs not be criticized. But I'm willing to work on the rhetoric. I confess that this isn't the first time I've been taken to task for the self same thing. I'm not sure exactly how to broach the subjects but I will think seriously about it.
GreNME, Pardalis, RandFan-thank you for your thoughtful arguments on this very real problem. I am, by reading your points and counterpoints, slowly(!) learning to reign in my hot-headed 'Tscherman' temperament.
I think it's probably best that I gracefully back out of the conversation. I really only meant to voice my opinion about the examples of language used that could be taken for intolerance in this thread, and considering the rest of the subject matter I'm not inclined to get too invested. As you've both (and I've) pointed out it's a complex and multi-layered issue. Also, we seem to agree that the UN was wrong in its decision to exclude the references to religion in this case.
In all honesty, the use of the 700 Club video on the first page really threw me through a loop. I just wanted to point out that not all examples of criticism toward Islam is motivated by the same goals and desires as I would assume most people here have, and that there is a real benefit to avoiding using similar language to those who have different goals in mind.
I think it's probably best that I gracefully back out of the conversation. I really only meant to voice my opinion about the examples of language used that could be taken for intolerance in this thread, and considering the rest of the subject matter I'm not inclined to get too invested. As you've both (and I've) pointed out it's a complex and multi-layered issue. Also, we seem to agree that the UN was wrong in its decision to exclude the references to religion in this case.
In all honesty, the use of the 700 Club video on the first page really threw me through a loop. I just wanted to point out that not all examples of criticism toward Islam is motivated by the same goals and desires as I would assume most people here have, and that there is a real benefit to avoiding using similar language to those who have different goals in mind.
It was a fair concern. I'm not a big fan of the 700 Club either and while I would avoid an ad hominem against them I would view anything they had to say with a great deal of skepticism.
Clearly it's an emotional issue and there are valid concerns by Muslims that they are being unfairly tarnished by the actions of extremists. I keep getting reminded of that. I suppose I have no excuse for the thread title given that I've apologized for being polemic regarding Islam in the past.
It was a fair concern. I'm not a big fan of the 700 Club either and while I would avoid an ad hominem against them I would view anything they had to say with a great deal of skepticism.
Clearly it's an emotional issue and there are valid concerns by Muslims that they are being unfairly tarnished by the actions of extremists. I keep getting reminded of that. I suppose I have no excuse for the thread title given that I've apologized for being polemic regarding Islam in the past.
I don't think it's ad hominem to point out the 700 Club's hostility toward Islam. It's pretty open about it in general, just as it's generally open about its aggression toward Christian denominations with whose doctrines it disagrees. I pointed that out in my example because using it (the video) as a data point is about as useful rhetorically as using campaign advertisements as an honest assessment of domestic economic policy.
I agree the issue is definitely emotional, and I think the concerns apply to more than Muslims. If the goal is to reduce extremism, in most cases with religions the best place to start with the eschewing of the extremism is promotion of resistance to it from inside the religion-- carrots and sticks, heavy on the carrots, if you will. The Soviet Union fell not because they were wrong or because ideological opposition stamped it out, but instead because enough people in the USSR decided "hey, this isn't working." I think a similar methodology can be used to drive extremism back into the margins and nutball niches.
Yes, but their hostility doesn't invalidate their arguments.
It's pretty open about it in general, just as it's generally open about its aggression toward Christian denominations with whose doctrines it disagrees. I pointed that out in my example because using it (the video) as a data point is about as useful rhetorically as using campaign advertisements as an honest assessment of domestic economic policy.
It's difficult I agree however it's possible for the 700 club to tell the truth and to make valid arguments. I don't dismiss what they say because they are the 700 Club I just am more careful when considering what they say.
I agree the issue is definitely emotional, and I think the concerns apply to more than Muslims. If the goal is to reduce extremism, in most cases with religions the best place to start with the eschewing of the extremism is promotion of resistance to it from inside the religion-- carrots and sticks, heavy on the carrots, if you will. The Soviet Union fell not because they were wrong or because ideological opposition stamped it out, but instead because enough people in the USSR decided "hey, this isn't working." I think a similar methodology can be used to drive extremism back into the margins and nutball niches.
Fair question given the ambiguity of the statement. I guess it's speaking out in a strong voice when you see that something is wrong. Like when the Human Rights Commission stops discussion and debate regarding human rights abuses under the pretext that it might offend religious sensibilities. I think that's wrong and I think we should speak out against it using strong rhetoric.
When Abu Ghraib came to light many people spoke out against it in strong terms denouncing Bush and his administration. When extraordinary rendition came to light people spoke out strongly condemning the actions of Bush and the administration.
It's that kind of reaction that I feel is necessary.
It's difficult I agree however it's possible for the 700 club to tell the truth and to make valid arguments. I don't dismiss what they say because they are the 700 Club I just am more careful when considering what they say.
I don't dismiss what they say, but I tend to hear a lot of confirmation bias in the information they use even in passing. And when it comes to a religious program making an assessment of another religion, well, let's just say I'm inclined to require a more reputable second opinion.
When Abu Ghraib came to light many people spoke out against it in strong terms denouncing Bush and his administration. When extraordinary rendition came to light people spoke out strongly condemning the actions of Bush and the administration.
It's that kind of reaction that I feel is necessary.
Bush and his Admin deserved to get criticized.
but not the American people. it was not them.
that was my point i tryed to point out.
and when religion comes into play you have to be even more carefull and direct the critique very precise.
and indeed there need to be a firm aproach in the meaning i understood you.
but best this aproach comes from the inside, from moslems that do oppose Sharia punishment etc. we have to support those people as good as we can.
i think it is impossible for outstanders of said religion to change anything, it has to come from inside. and this is a long process.
and indeed when we start to forbid criticism against such things in generally we are sure moving into a wrong direction.
and who is this in Islam?
and do Christians follow the pope? for example about condoms?
btw, why did the US president not folow the religious leader, the Pope?
the Pope did say NO WAR, and Bush didnt listen to him.
how come God gave direct commands to Bush without informing the Pope? or is Bush a more respected religious leader than the Pope?
You cant be this thick!
The pope is catholic sir!
President Bush is not!
Only catholics follow the pope!
Non catholic Christians do not!
Is that plain enough for you to understand?
Oh I dont know..............how about stopping all violence against jews and I bet the same thing happens!
It really is that easy to make peace....but no all they want to do is push the evil jews into the sea!
You cant be this thick!
The pope is catholic sir!
President Bush is not!
Only catholics follow the pope!
Non catholic Christians do not!
Is that plain enough for you to understand?
ah we geting closer, soon you will understand it , i hope.
lucky enough not even all Catholics follow the pope anymore
see among Christians there are Diffrences, in rules and who they follow and such.
And also in Islam there are diffrences, there are woman in Islam that do not wear Burkas, some groups do not even wear a headscarfe, for example.
Some countrys have implemented full Sharia laws others have "only" partial Sharia laws.
and some people try to put them all together as a monolithic religion. just like i did it with christian's, there you knew the diffrences and pointed them out.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.