Is there a doctor in the house?

Where are these examples published?
In my posts above. I can't imagine why you are being so ridiculous. Try the experiments I suggested; it's called Home Science and will teach you a lot.
What do you mean by "absorbed," and where is this published?
Heavens above, I really cannot believe you are being so silly.
Concentrated nitric acid reacts with human skin and underlying tissue. The reaction forms compounds; each reaction uses up a part of the original nitric acid till none is left, if the dose was small, which is why a drop of concentrated nitric acid on your hand will cause you some anguish but not kill you. if you want literature on this, look up PubMed or MEDLINE or any good description on treatment for acid burns.
Tell me, why are you being so ridiculous?
Gurdur said:
Maybe you and JJM should be asking just why that is so arranged -- why the nitro is delivered, transdermally, inside the tip of a condom, rather than say systematically as pills.
I already explained that transderm drugs are applied near the affected site for the psychological benefit. I can't rule out some specific effect here; but innuendo is not persuasive. Do you have some data?
And now I am saying you are being willfully ignorant. Quite apart from the one citation I gave you, the fact that you implicitly claim here that nitro use on the penis would work the same way with the same dosis given say orally merely reflects your lack of knowledge.
Which part of this do you not understand? A small dose of nitro on the right place on the penis will cause local blood vessel dilation, helping an erection.
The same dosis given orally or in a patch on the chest is likely to have zero effects on the penis, which is why people being treated for angina pectoris do not walk around in a constantly priapic condition, that is, their patches used normally won't give them a hard-on.
Tell me just what part of this do you refuse to address and understand?

The emerging multifaceted roles of nitric oxide.
Kuo PC, Schroeder RA.
Ann Surg. 1995 Mar; 221(3): 220-235.

Gramkow J, Lendorf A, Zhu J, Meyhoff HH.
Transcutaneous nitroglycerine in the treatment of erectile dysfunction: a placebo controlled clinical trial.
Int J Impot Res. 1999 Feb;11(1):35-9.

Renganathan R, Suranjan B, Kurien T.
Comparison of transdermal nitroglycerin and intracavernous injection of papaverine in the treatment of erectile dysfunction in patients with spinal cord lesions.
Spinal Cord. 1997 Feb;35(2):99-103.

Meyhoff HH, Rosenkilde P, Bodker A.
Non-invasive management of impotence with transcutaneous nitroglycerin.
Br J Urol. 1992 Jan;69(1):88-90.

Heaton JP, Morales A, Owen J, Saunders FW, Fenemore J.
Topical glyceryltrinitrate causes measurable penile arterial dilation in impotent men.
J Urol. 1990 Apr;143(4):729-31.

Now be a good lad, JJM, run off and read all those, off you go then.

Gurdur said:
You can also take a bit of nitroglycerine, rub it around your leg.
Take half a day to observe any effects. Then run nitrogylcerine around your scalp. You will very certainly feel a big difference. This, BTW, is a favourite nasty trick in quarries and mines; rubbing a bit of nitro around inside the lining of a guy's hardhat. It gives the Mother Of All Headaches. Try it on your leg? Not a thing. ...
Literature citation?
You are really being ridiculous. But you could at least be coherent, and you're not even trying. You're simply playing pointless games.

What exactly do you want? A literature cite for the fact that nitro can cause bad headaches? :boggled: I mean, the bloody literature is full of that. Look for yourself. Oh and back up your claims with lit cites. Ha ha. :D

Or do you want a lit cite for the fact that it is a nasty trick often done in quarries and other shotblasting sites to take a bit of nitro and rub it around the lining of someone's hardhat?

Do try, for heaven's sakes.
:rolleyes:
 
Addendum
In case anyone wants to try playing pedantic games, I will add this addendum.

In the case of fast-acting, topically applied chemicals like nitro compounds or sulfuric acid, the greatest effect will be felt locally at the point of application unless the area is:
  • very well-vascularized
  • and also has fast circulation at the point of application
  • and the chemical is easily absorbed into and carried by the bloodstream
  • and of course depending on what exactly the chemical does, i.e. how choosey it is about receptors.
    (I'm going in for maximal preemptive pedantry overkill here ;) )
This is why to help get an erection, you apply the small dose of nitro topically to the penis and not to your ear.

Some nitro will be absorbed into the bloodstream and be carried away, and be metabolized at other points in the body, but that with low doses is usually negligable or only small in effect, which is why only a few patients using nitro applied to the penis will get headaches.

This is also why patients taking nitro for the heart with usual patch placement do not usually walk around encumbered by hard-on's.

Please note all precise qualified statements. This is in direct contradiction to the claim of JJM and others that such topically-applied agents have no significant local effect and only have a systematic effect; a claim so ludicrous I still can't believe it has to be argued out and explained so much.
 
Last edited:
My entire point -- backed up with a few examples -- was that it does (to a degree) matter where you place it. To give the examples in summary again:

  • placing the patch (leastaways back in the old days when the doses where bigger and less time-delay managed) on your willy will give you a very different reaction than placing it on your arm or abdomen.
    .
  • placing the patch (leastaways back in the old days when the doses where bigger and less time-delay managed) on your upper head (in a hair-free part of the forehead for example) will give you a very different reaction than placing it on your arm or abdomen.

So I hope you now see just how the differences work.

A crucial point here, which I did not mention before since I though it was self-evident and well-known, is just how active the chemical is that you are applying, or how active it is in terms of the area you are applying it too, and whether it is direct or in time-delay managed holding mechanisms (such as capsules or in time-delay-giving compound form).

Applying a highly active chemical such as nitrates locally can result in strong local effects simply because the chemical is basically mostly used up at the point of delivery. That is the whole point of shoving it into the tip of a condom, the example I gave in my last post, an example so far ignored.

To give you another, simpler example: dropping some concentrated nitric acid on your hand will give you a strong local reaction, but the concentrated nitric acid (as long as it's in a small dose), while it is absorbed directly, will not act systematically simply because it is used up in reactions at the immediate point of delivery.
No Gurder, for angina (the main use of nitroglycerin) there is no additional benefit in putting the patch over the heart. You do want it on part of the body with sufficient circulation so you don't place it very distally on a limb.

Standard patient instructions: Apply the patch to clean, dry skin that is relatively free of hair (above your knee) or upper arm (above your elbow). Avoid irritated, scarred, broken, and calloused skin. Select a different area each day to avoid skin irritation. Be sure to remove the patch before you apply another one.

There are many topicals one uses for local effect. Lidocaine for example is used as a topical ointment prior to some procedures. Nitroglycerin for angina is not applied for its local effects.

In the case of nitroglycerin, it exerts an effect similar to nitric oxide. Nitric oxide is involved in the erection process. In that case local action of the drug does have an effect.

But the assumption you are making in error here is that the mechanism by which nitroglycerin affects erections is the same mechanism when it works for angina. However, it isn't.

Nitrates, arterial function, wave reflections and coronary heart disease
By increasing the distensibility of muscular arteries, nitroglycerin slows pulse wave velocity, reduces wave reflections and alters the shape of the aortic pulse. This alteration reduces the systolic blood pressure and left ventricular after load and helps to explain the usefulness of nitroglycerin in angina pectoris, congestive heart failure and isolated systolic hypertension.

Nitric oxide in the penis: physiology and pathology.
Nitric oxide is perceived to exert a host of functional roles by binding with specific molecular targets. Its synthesis and action in the penis are influenced by many different regulatory factors. CONCLUSIONS: Nitric oxide exerts a significant role in the physiology of the penis, operating chiefly as the principal mediator of erectile function. Alterations in the biology of nitric oxide likely account for various forms of erectile dysfunction. The diverse physiological roles of nitric oxide suggest that it may also directly contribute to or cause pathological consequences involving the penis.

In neither case is simple blood vessel dilation the mechanism of action.

Edited to add, the coronary arteries fill during diastole, on the back pulse of the cardiac contraction. When the heart contracts, blood moves in a wave called systole. As the aortic valve closes behind the wave and the aorta contracts back into its resting state, there is enough back pressure to then fill the coronary arteries. Nitroglycerin has to act systemically in the case of angina. And if you think about it, imagine if it acted locally. Could you use nitro then if the constricted arteries were on the back side of the heart? Just as JJM said, by that time the drug would be carried away by the blood stream. It would be like trying to cross a bunch of rivers. The drug wouldn't penetrate very deeply and certainly it wouldn't have any specific concentration in more than the superficial layers of the chest.
 
Last edited:
...

Now be a good lad, JJM, run off and read all those, off you go then....
One might suggest you take a more current physiology course. But I won't risk putting my foot in my mouth. The complexity the human body's physiology is quite mind boggling. And there is always the chance someone knows something you don't. ;)
 
That wasn't what I was advocating (at all). What exactly did you think I described that a skeptic should avoid?
You have a very good understanding of the scientific method I refer to.

And I think it illustrates part of the reason why believers dismiss what skeptics have to say....our everyday experience tells us that most of the time "after this, therefore because of this" is true....it really seemed that her experience was consistent with other causal experiences; her headache went away because she used Head-On. And an explanation that takes that into account will be more satisfying than one that simply dismisses the connection as "not evidence".
This is exactly what happens when believers dismiss skeptics and science.


So why then would this interpertation:
... The exercise isn't about evidence that the product is effective. It's about explaining something in a way that makes sense to the person asking the question.
be a useful exercise?


...That's what I was referring to (part of it anyway).
...Can you articulate what the "step" is that is the problem?
...Yes. That was what I was getting at. And that explaining why we get the impression of causality can help us frame the events in a way that allows the possibility of non-causality to make sense to non-skeptics.
What I was getting at was we don't want to analyze Headon the same way a woo believer would analyze it just because there might be a possible connection to an ingredient.

Think of this as the impression I got and not what Remie had in mind. Because I think she clarified that.

But here's the impression:

I know homeopathy is woo. I believe the skeptical science or evidence based explanations are valid. But I used Headon and my headache went away. So maybe it wasn't coincidence.

A skeptical science approach would then be to form an hypothesis that the product worked but not because of homeopathy, but rather because of an active ingredient.

And that is almost where Remie went. But....she seemed to fall a little into the trap of those personal experiences that tend to tempt us into those unscientific beliefs. By doing so, instead of following the scientific approach (which she almost followed) she was lured into speculating instead of hypothesizing.

My impression before hearing more about it was of Remie not being quite as objective because the personal experience was more persuasive than Remie wanted to admit. (I no longer have that impression.)

The difference in this case was subtle. I pointed out you must first show the product actually works. N=1 is not sufficient. JJM pointed out it was haphazard methodology to look for effects of chemicals without sufficient information about dose and means of absorption.

And you seemed to be saying it was OK to take the less than systematic approach and just look for an explanation since the explanation seemed logical.

Now bringing that impression up to date: I wasn't the only one who got the impression Remie was a tad leaning toward the possibility her N of 1 had some significance. But when replies addressed that leaning, it frustrated her. We can assume she wasn't leaning that way now that she has repeated that fact numerous times.


...Yes. The same kind of evidence that gives the impression that using Head-On relieved the headache.

Linda
No it isn't. When one throws a ball and has past experiences from which causality has been established the cause and effect conclusion is valid. When you wear your hat backward at the ball game and your team wins, we either know it isn't logically connected, or we start believing woo superstitions. Taking Headon and having your headache go away is somewhere in between.

What I believe skeptics should do is to stick to scientific principles. We have to be careful to not fall into the same trap as woo believers when those Headon experiences happen to us as opposed to happening to others where we tend to be more objective.

Personal anecdotes are legitimate for establishing hypotheses that can then be properly investigated. I think that's what Remie might have had in mind. First see if there is even a reason to investigate the ingredients by exploring if they have any known effects. You could either see if the ingredients are worth investigating or if the product worked as a first step.

I prefer to discuss why wearing your hat backward and having your team win is equal to taking Headon and having your headache go away. When we rationalize instead of hypothesize we get into the same trap as believers. We start thinking maybe it was an ingredient when we haven't even established a relationship beyond coincidence.
 
No Gurder, for angina (the main use of nitroglycerin) there is no additional benefit in putting the patch over the heart. You do want it on part of the body with sufficient circulation so you don't place it very distally on a limb.
You are simply ignoring what I said about getting effective dose to the point of need, and by the way, also ignoring that I replied quite correctly to you as you put your own question. That is only playing games; read back on everything I said. Points taken as to the rest, however since I was tackling the denying of local effect in regard to topical aplication along with JJM, then it really looks like we're meeting in the middle, doesn't it?
There are many topicals one uses for local effect.
Bingo. And that was the issue at hand, and my point.
One might suggest you take a more current physiology course. But I won't risk putting my foot in my mouth. The complexity the human body's physiology is quite mind boggling. And there is always the chance someone knows something you don't. ;)
Since you chose to add that in response to my reply to JJM showing local effect, then you could be a bit more honest and acknowledge that my point has been made, and that in abundance --- however much you want to get pedantic. One might suggest that instead of giving Remie such an unnecessarily hard time, you simply reply to point and not try the overly judgmental sermonising or over-interpreteting.
 
Last edited:
This is exactly what happens when believers dismiss skeptics and science.

I do think we should be sensitive (depending upon our goals) to why people dismiss what we have to say, and why we dismiss what other people have to say.

So why then would this interpertation:be a useful exercise?

I was thinking that if something makes sense, it is more likely to be persuasive.

What I was getting at was we don't want to analyze Headon the same way a woo believer would analyze it just because there might be a possible connection to an ingredient.

What I was getting at was that I was not suggesting that we should.

I know homeopathy is woo. I believe the skeptical science or evidence based explanations are valid. But I used Headon and my headache went away. So maybe it wasn't coincidence.

A skeptical science approach would then be to form an hypothesis that the product worked but not because of homeopathy, but rather because of an active ingredient.

And that is almost where Remie went. But....she seemed to fall a little into the trap of those personal experiences that tend to tempt us into those unscientific beliefs. By doing so, instead of following the scientific approach (which she almost followed) she was lured into speculating instead of hypothesizing.

So basically, your complaint is that we did not follow this approach to the point of performing experiments.

The difference in this case was subtle. I pointed out you must first show the product actually works. N=1 is not sufficient. JJM pointed out it was haphazard methodology to look for effects of chemicals without sufficient information about dose and means of absorption.

And you seemed to be saying it was OK to take the less than systematic approach and just look for an explanation since the explanation seemed logical.

I still think you are missing the point. It is not a question of "how does this work?" (in which case, you would be correct to ask for evidence that it does work, first), but rather, "are there any known ways this could work?" One does not need to think that it does work in order to speculate about ways that it could work.

How systemic you want to be when looking for alternate explanations depends upon the person and the situation. I think Remie was just looking for something that was plausible, not something that would serve as proof. If one was trying to persuade someone who was inclined to think it was homeopathic, then I think that a more detailed analysis of the ingredients and explanations about pain mechanisms would be required.

And this goes back to my original point. If you wish to persuade by presenting alternate explanations, then the alternate explanations need to be seen as at least as plausible as the woo explanation. Since a skeptic is inclined to think the woo explanation is very implausible, any plausible explanation would do. Since a woo finds the woo explanation very plausible and is inclined to dismiss information coming from skeptics, the process needs to be more systematic. And it needs to be presented in a way that allows the woo to reasonably compare the plausibility. Which means taking into consideration methods by which they, and people in general, evaluate plausibility.

No it isn't. When one throws a ball and has past experiences from which causality has been established the cause and effect conclusion is valid. When you wear your hat backward at the ball game and your team wins, we either know it isn't logically connected, or we start believing woo superstitions. Taking Headon and having your headache go away is somewhere in between.

You are saying that they are different because they are at different points on a spectrum. I am saying that they are the same because they are on the same spectrum.

What I believe skeptics should do is to stick to scientific principles. We have to be careful to not fall into the same trap as woo believers when those Headon experiences happen to us as opposed to happening to others where we tend to be more objective.

I was thinking that instead of avoiding the trap, it could help us to gain insight into why people believe things. If skeptics, who have lots of practice being objective, have to be warned about being objective with respect to personal experiences, then surely it must be more difficult for non-skeptics. Personal experience is compelling. It doesn't hurt for us to learn that.

Personal anecdotes are legitimate for establishing hypotheses that can then be properly investigated. I think that's what Remie might have had in mind. First see if there is even a reason to investigate the ingredients by exploring if they have any known effects. You could either see if the ingredients are worth investigating or if the product worked as a first step.

Will you stop complaining if we whip up an experiment for you. :)

I prefer to discuss why wearing your hat backward and having your team win is equal to taking Headon and having your headache go away. When we rationalize instead of hypothesize we get into the same trap as believers. We start thinking maybe it was an ingredient when we haven't even established a relationship beyond coincidence.

Do you honestly think we don't know that already? Did you honestly think that Remie wasn't already taking that into account?

It looked like this is what Remie was asking...."I put Head-On on my head and my headache went away. I already know that chance and psychological effects may account for this, but are there any other alternate explanations, such as an effect from the ingredients, that would serve as a plausible explanation for a compelling personal experience."

Linda
 
Last edited:
I'd also ask why you have spent all this time criticizing an N of 1 error that she might be trying to make, but ignoring an N of 1 error that she did make.

I got back home, perhaps ten minutes later, and applied the gunk directly to my forehead. It burned strangely. I kind of laughed internally, already beginning to phrase the stinging article I'd write about the worthlessness of "Head-On".

An N of 1 is not evidence of worthlessness, either.

Linda
 
Linda wrote "I still think you are missing the point. It is not a question of "how does this work?" (in which case, you would be correct to ask for evidence that it does work, first), but rather, "are there any known ways this could work?" One does not need to think that it does work in order to speculate about ways that it could work."

Okay- so, we have reason to to doubt homeopathy, we have insufficient data to conclude it was pharmacology, we do have reason to think it was a coincidence or a placebo. To speculate further- if a headache drug were known and if it could be rapidly absorbed through the skin to achieve therapeutic levels in seconds, that could explain it. However, I think that was implicit in the question.

Suppose there is a readily absorbed drug that is highly effective, as described. There is another possibilty to consider, the stick may secretly contain that drug. Homeopaths have been caught doping their products before.
 
Originally Posted by Gurdur
You can also take a bit of nitroglycerine, rub it around your leg.
Take half a day to observe any effects. Then run nitrogylcerine around your scalp. You will very certainly feel a big difference. This, BTW, is a favourite nasty trick in quarries and mines; rubbing a bit of nitro around inside the lining of a guy's hardhat. It gives the Mother Of All Headaches. Try it on your leg? Not a thing. ...

Originally Posted by JJM
Literature citation?

Gurdur then wrote "You are really being ridiculous."

Sorry- where did you read that sufficient nitro applied to the leg does not cause headache? You certainly haven't tried it.
 
Linda wrote "I still think you are missing the point. It is not a question of "how does this work?" (in which case, you would be correct to ask for evidence that it does work, first), but rather, "are there any known ways this could work?" One does not need to think that it does work in order to speculate about ways that it could work."

Okay- so, we have reason to to doubt homeopathy, we have insufficient data to conclude it was pharmacology, we do have reason to think it was a coincidence or a placebo.

In an effort to make these possibilities comparable.....

The possibility of homeopathy is almost non-existant.

The possibility of pharmacology....
A drug could have an effect by acting locally - skin cooling through evaporation or skin warming through heat released by a chemical reaction, leading to the physiologic response of increased or decreased blood flow (response varies depending upon site and other circumstances), stimulation of sensory nerves (pain, temperature), action on tissue through local absorption - or acting systemically - drug is carried into the systemic circulation through local absorption or inhalation. Would any of this fit with what we know about the pathophysiology of headache and pain? None of the ingredients would be likely to have a systemic effect - they have a weak effect systemically (if at all) and the amount that would get absorbed is tiny. Some local effects could help headache. Changes in circulatory pattern in the head can lead to headache relief, so if heat/cold effects were actually changing blood flow, this is a possibility. However, the amount of product used makes it unlikely that the actual temperature change would be sufficient to change blood flow. Local tissue effects are only plausible if the target tissue is within a few millimetres of the substance. Diffusion is generally difficult (a few solvents that make it easier have been mentioned), and you don't get very far before you hit capillaries, venioles, and veins that carry the drug away. Effects on the local circulation, before the drug is carried away, are not likely unless you have an unusual situation (such as the corpus cavernosa in the penis), but I'd give that more of a possibility than the other stuff I've mentioned so far. The target tissue for headache (i.e. the tissue where the pain arises) is not the subcutaneous tissue of the forehead. So a local tissue effect is not likely. Now we're down to a local effect on the nerves. And we do know that stimulation of the sensory nerves can counteract some types of pain including headaches. It is possible for there to be enough of the substances in the product to stimulate local sensory nerves (including the sensation of cool or heat from skin cooling or warming as it takes only a small change in temperature to get that effect) and Remie also specifically stated that she felt a burning sensation when she applied the product, which is reasonable evidence that the product was stimulating the local sensory nerves.

The probability of placebo.....
Placebo is not an effect, so we need to break this down. One component of placebo is that of chance or coincidence. What is the possibility of co-incidence? What is the possibility that a headache disappears immediately after a skeptic who likes to write about useless treatments applies the "useless" treatment, due to chance? Out of all the possible times during the day and night that the headache may be reasonably expected to go away, the possibility that it just so happened during that particular minute is very low. Another component is psychological. Even though she didn't believe the remedy was going to work, one must still admit to the possibility of a psychological effect. She may not have been inclined to downplay her symptoms afterward, but other cognitive biases could come into play (a definite point in time to tag her experiences to, for example). And we have to consider the possibility of relaxation and distraction. So a psychological effect has some possibility. Regression (which is a combination of chance and bias) has a small possibility. She did apply the remedy at a time when her headache was unusually bad, so there was a good chance that it would be less bad at a later time. But she probably wasn't biased towards calling "less bad" a cure, or misremembering it as co-incident to the Head-On aplication.

So we have a number of possible explanations that range from almost impossible to probable. (I may have forgotten some, as I'm just doing this off the top of my head.) And of course, as you brought up earlier, there are billions of opportunities for the almost impossible to happen, so listing things in terms of probabilities does not serve to tell you exactly what happened. I realize that I'm not telling you stuff that you don't know, I just think it may make it clearer to use a somewhat systematic framework. So in this context, when people are asking for explanations, what they are really asking for is suggestions for probable or reasonably possible explanations. It is easier to be satisfied with a possible explanation, even though, as skeptics, we know that we should also be satisfied with improbable (but natural/known) explanations.

To speculate further- if a headache drug were known and if it could be rapidly absorbed through the skin to achieve therapeutic levels in seconds, that could explain it. However, I think that was implicit in the question.

Suppose there is a readily absorbed drug that is highly effective, as described. There is another possibilty to consider, the stick may secretly contain that drug. Homeopaths have been caught doping their products before.

I agree that that is another good possibility that should be added to the list.

Linda
 
Last edited:
The target tissue for headache (i.e. the tissue where the pain arises) is not the subcutaneous tissue of the forehead.
I am just wondering if this has been established. I believe that one of the potential causes of headaches is vasodilation of the subcutaneous vessels in the scalp. Am I wrong?
 
Last edited:
I am just wondering if this has been established. I believe that one of the potential causes of headaches is vasodilation of the subcutaneous vessels in the scalp. Am I wrong?

Nope (with qualifications). Just that it is the tiniest vessels, in the area of application, that are accessible to absorption. Even if some of the small subcutaneous veins were also affected in the area of application, the effect is likely to be too weak to make a difference, since the vasodilation is general.

Linda
 
You are simply ignoring what I said about getting effective dose to the point of need,
No, it is you who are ignoring how nitroglycerin works treating angina.

Nitroglycerin topical for angina acts systemically. There is no therapeutic or physiological difference in its effect on cardiac pathology whether the drug is absorbed via the chest or the thigh or abdomen or back or upper arm. NONE! From your post quoted here, you still seem to think the drug reaches the heart directly through the chest wall. ALL of the drug reaches the heart via the bloodstream. The reason for using the skin is when given orally or sublingually, you cannot maintain therapeutic blood levels. Whereas via the skin, the drug is absorbed slowly. In fact, you wouldn't want a local effect. If it occurred, you'd need to actually avoid using the chest. You want an even blood level and a local effect would give you therapeutic peaks and valleys that defeat the purpose of giving the drug topically.

and by the way, also ignoring that I replied quite correctly to you as you put your own question. That is only playing games; read back on everything I said. Points taken as to the rest, however since I was tackling the denying of local effect in regard to topical aplication along with JJM, then it really looks like we're meeting in the middle, doesn't it?
I noted repeatedly some drugs are used topically for local effects, including your willy wagging (though not recommended because of all the additional effects). I've been acknowledging the topical use of meds for local effects from my first post re the issue.

You were wrong about the use of topical nitroglycerin for angina and JJM was wrong about the lack of local effects of nitroglycerin in other areas of the body.

I don't see anywhere that I said anything different. And you needn't have gotten defensive. You could have just said what I do when I'm wrong, "Oh, I didn't know that. I learned something new."

I learned something new about the nitric oxide effect on erections. I read about your claims before responding. Anytime someone makes a statement I think may be wrong or don't really know anything about (as in this case), I try to check before commenting.

Since you chose to add that in response to my reply to JJM showing local effect, then you could be a bit more honest and acknowledge that my point has been made, and that in abundance --- however much you want to get pedantic. One might suggest that instead of giving Remie such an unnecessarily hard time, you simply reply to point and not try the overly judgmental sermonising or over-interpreteting.

Calm yourself, Gur and re-read my posts. How is my honesty even involved here? What judgmental sermon, what interpretation, what unnecessary hard time?

I made an observation about a message conveyed with and without an anecdote.

That observation was confirmed when fls actually stated (without noticing what I said about it) that she interpreted the message with the use of the anecdote as I observed people would.

You made an incorrect claim about topical nitroglycerin for angina. You sarcastically told JJM he should read a slew of citations (which by the way are useless to list without links, no one has the time for a simple discussion such as this to hunt those down). So I merely commented you might not want to be calling the kettle black.

And as far as I can see, I made correct statements about topical meds and in particular, nitroglycerin, as well as supported the statements with linked citations.

So where is it you have a specific issue?
 
Couple points, vasodilation is not how NTG affects Gur's willy. It may not be what causes the headache either. I'll look into it later and follow up if no one has by then.

And, I don't disagree with the majority of your post, fls. After the thread progressed, a lot of those issues were resolved. For whatever reason, as I try to discuss my initial reaction, readers are forgetting it isn't my current reaction. You're talking about all the things we know from asking Remie questions. My observation was earlier on and I tried to point that out.

And I'm not asking for a clinical trial. Merely that we not fall into the same trap woo believers fall into, that of thinking personal experience has more weight than it does*, and thinking some logical connections have more weight than they do**.

*It isn't N of 1 that is the issue. I merely refer to that to remind people that the issue isn't whether something is an anecdote. The issue is one's personal experience shouldn't by itself, carry more evidential weight than any other N of 1.

**For example, it makes sense to people when they learn germs make one ill, not cold weather, that perhaps cold weather weakens one's resistance to germs. So they change from one wrong belief to another wrong belief without using the scientific principle of testing that hypothesis before accepting it is true. They learn one belief is wrong but see it as if we just have new data. What they don't see is what was the fallacy that gave people the wrong belief in the first place.

People get ill more in winter.

False belief: Therefore illness is caused by the weather.

New data, infectious organisms cause winter illnesses.

New false belief: Weather must affect our susceptibility to germs.

How should a skeptic approach the problem? Start by brainstorming all the possibilities and then test them.

Turns out no study has found bad weather affects your immune system. But studies do confirm we share more germs in winter because we are inside with doors and windows shut, and, many viruses survive on surfaces longer in winter.
 
Nope (with qualifications). Just that it is the tiniest vessels, in the area of application, that are accessible to absorption. Even if some of the small subcutaneous veins were also affected in the area of application, the effect is likely to be too weak to make a difference, since the vasodilation is general.

Linda
The effect is likely to be weak...ok.... however we could just do away with all of this speculation and say the product is likely to not work. The amount that is absorbed and how far it will diffuse through tissue is unknown as far as I know so it still leaves a possible scenario for an effect. Not likely but a minuscule possibility and I think that is what Remie wanted to know.
 
I just paid a bit more attention to a Headon ad.

"Apply directly to the pain"
"It works"

You can get away with complete fraud as long as you only imply the thing does something.

Here's more unspoken messages. Notice they never say just what Headon does. No claim is actually made it even relieves headaches. So back to my earlier statement. No sense speculating about the ingredients unless there is some evidence the stuff actually affects a headache in the first place. Clearly they weren't able to even make the most modest claim in that regard.

These are common false advertising tactics and an example of a hidden message. In this case, it is an intended hidden message rather than an inadvertent one.
 
There are a lot of replies; but you can distill some ideas from them. Nobody, not even a doctor, can tell you more because almost ALL of the speculation about the pharmacology of the inactive ingredients is unwarranted; especially absent realistic (analytical) data concerning concentrations.

Switchtech got some of it right by finding the purpose of some of the ingredients (the preservatives, triethanolamine and steareth-21).

I will say this another way- I made topical pharmaceutical products for ten years, before I went to graduate school. I know the uses of all the ingredients, depending on concentration (which I cannot get from our data; which is suspect). What is "suspect" is the order in which the ingredients are listed by the manufacturer.

Remie, I don't see how you can write an article concerning a product about which so little is known. If you can't cite clinical trials or facts about ingredients- what can you say? Will you consider the popularity of an unproven remedy and the effect that has on the pocketbook? This is not an attack- I would really like to know.

Sorry, I have a tendency to wander off from the forums for a few days and totally forget I'm involved in something.

On the SAPS site, there is a products section in which we test out products that have some paranormal aspect and talk about the experience. It isn't supposed to be scientific. It is pure anecdote.

I know, that probably seems like it has no purpose. The purpose is this: Many people want to buy something just to "see". Much of the support for it comes from testimonials, and it all sounds quite impressive. Well, we're buying it so other people don't have to.

What I can't believe is that, with only one product listed so far, we've gotten a response. As it stands, the section only has a "Colour Bath" in it. Which is a long, complicated procedure involving chakras, pendulums, dye, and a bathtub. Anyway, apparently if you google color bath, the SAPS site comes up. And people have e-mailed saying they were on the verge of trying it, but read the site and changed their minds.

People have also written and said "THIS ISN'T SCIENTIFIC." So, it's really just directed at the first type.

Anyway, on the site, we list the manufacturer, the price, where you can get the product, what the experience was like, what's in it, what's comparable. All that sort of thing.

I have a voodoo memory charm right here, actually, that I really need to get to work on.

Hope that explains it.
 
By the way, Linda, I always love your posts. You're just amazing. :D

And Vampire, thanks for speaking up and everything... I can't believe I wandered off at such a critical time :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom