As I read through the exchange to try to sum it up, it's difficult to get past all the crap. I tried and continue to try to have a discussion here about the topic, the science, and my observations. The thread is now completely cluttered with a number of people being offended by comments that were not intended to be offensive. Can you not have a discussion without taking offense to everything a person says?
I tried to point out an observation that when you claim to not believe a product worked while inquiring if maybe it did work, regardless of how intelligent, informed, or skeptical you may be, you have just implied you are considering the possibility it did work.
That isn't an insult. It doesn't mean anything bad. It's an observation about unintended meaning in the way we communicate.
You can take the following comment two ways:
I think if you and/or Remie had more of a clue what I've been talking about, you'd recognize there's been no malice here except in your imaginations.
One way, the way you have apparently taken it, is I'm calling you clueless. That is not the case. Much of what I've said here has been taken wrong. The wording was harsher than it could have been because I was replying to Vamp who has posted much of the crap.
The way my comment was intended is you've taken what I've said in the thread wrong because you missed the point I was making.
Your answer was to defend your position, but that wasn't the point. I wasn't saying you believed anything. I was pointing out your anecdote had unintended implications. Why should that call for a defensive reply? It was just an observation.
I am going to continue to ignore the crap in this thread. I am tempted to rant back but I see no benefit in doing so. Regardless if someone didn't like the tone of something I said, or even the content, I haven't insulted anyone intentionally. I may be frank but I'm not malicious. And I will post what I think is worthwhile saying whether there are replies from people who continue to take what I'm saying wrong or not. I would be happy to clarify anything someone thinks is an insult. But claiming I'm lying about the clarification? That is uncalled for and deserves to be ignored.
Is this a discussion or a popularity contest? Do you want feedback or just comments that make everyone feel good? When a comment is misunderstood, people normally explain and that is that. But when someone like Vamp goes on and on about my explanation is a lie or not sufficient or whatever, instead of a conversation going back to a civil one, more and more comments are taken wrong. And that has occurred here.
If you don't like my posts, don't read them. There is an ignore feature. But if you quit thinking everything I have to say is just to insult everyone, you may find I do have a little knowledge to share and no reason to insult anyone.